Heterogeneity in immune cell composition is associated with Mycobacterium tuberculosis replication at the granuloma level.

The control of bacterial growth is key to the prevention and treatment of tuberculosis (TB). Granulomas represent independent foci of the host immune response that present heterogeneous capacity for control of bacterial growth. At the whole tissue level, B cells and CD4 or CD8 T cells have an established role in immune protection against TB. Immune cells interact within each granuloma response, but the impact of granuloma immune composition on bacterial replication remains unknown. Here we investigate the associations between immune cell composition, including B cell, CD4, and CD8 T cells, and the state of replicating Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) within the granuloma. A measure of ribosomal RNA synthesis, the RS ratio®, represents a proxy measure of Mtb replication at the whole tissue level. We adapted the RS ratio through use of in situ hybridization, to identify replicating and non-replicating Mtb within each designated granuloma. We applied a regression model to characterize the associations between immune cell populations and the state of Mtb replication within each respective granuloma. In the evaluation of nearly 200 granulomas, we identified heterogeneity in both immune cell composition and proportion of replicating bacteria. We found clear evidence of directional associations between immune cell composition and replicating Mtb. Controlling for vaccination status and endpoint post-infection, granulomas with lower CD4 or higher CD8 cell counts are associated with a higher percent of replicating Mtb. Conversely, changes in B cell proportions were associated with little change in Mtb replication. This study establishes heterogeneity across granulomas, demonstrating that certain immune cell types are differentially associated with control of Mtb replication. These data suggest that evaluation at the granuloma level may be imperative to identifying correlates of immune protection.

A preclinical model of TB meningitis to determine drug penetration and activity at the sites of disease.

Tuberculosis meningitis (TBM) is essentially treated with the first-line regimen used against pulmonary tuberculosis, with a prolonged continuation phase. However, clinical outcomes are poor in comparison, for reasons that are only partially understood, highlighting the need for improved preclinical tools to measure drug distribution and activity at the site of disease. A predictive animal model of TBM would also be of great value to prioritize promising drug regimens to be tested in clinical trials, given the healthy state of the development pipeline for the first time in decades. Here, we report the optimization of a rabbit model of TBM disease induced via inoculation of Mycobacterium tuberculosis into the cisterna magna, recapitulating features typical of clinical TBM: neurological deterioration within months post-infection, acid-fast bacilli in necrotic lesions in the brain and spinal cord, and elevated lactate levels in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). None of the infected rabbits recovered or controlled the disease. We used young adult rabbits, the size of which allows for spatial drug quantitation in critical compartments of the central nervous system that cannot be collected in clinical studies. To illustrate the translational value of the model, we report the penetration of linezolid from plasma into the CSF, meninges, anatomically distinct brain areas, cervical spine, and lumbar spine. Across animals, we measured the bacterial burden concomitant with neurological deterioration, offering a useful readout for drug efficacy studies. The model thus forms the basis for building a preclinical platform to identify improved regimens and inform clinical trial design.

Spore-FP1 tuberculosis mucosal vaccine candidate is highly protective in guinea pigs but fails to improve on BCG-conferred protection in non-human primates.

Tuberculosis remains a major health threat globally and a more effective vaccine than the current Bacillus Calmette Guerin (BCG) is required, either to replace or boost it. The Spore-FP1 mucosal vaccine candidate is based on the fusion protein of Ag85B-Acr-HBHA/heparin-binding domain, adsorbed on the surface of inactivated Bacillus subtilis spores. The candidate conferred significant protection against Mycobacterium. tuberculosis challenge in naïve guinea pigs and markedly improved protection in the lungs and spleens of animals primed with BCG. We then immunized rhesus macaques with BCG intradermally, and subsequently boosted with one intradermal and one aerosol dose of Spore-FP1, prior to challenge with low dose aerosolized M. tuberculosis Erdman strain. Following vaccination, animals did not show any adverse reactions and displayed higher antigen specific cellular and antibody immune responses compared to BCG alone but this did not translate into significant improvement in disease pathology or bacterial burden in the organs.

Adaptation to the intracellular environment of primary human macrophages influences drug susceptibility of Mycobacterium tuberculosis.

As a facultative intracellular pathogen, M. tuberculosis (Mtb) is highly adapted to evading antibacterial mechanisms in phagocytic cells. Both the macrophage and pathogen experience transcriptional and metabolic changes from the onset of phagocytosis. To account for this interaction in the assessment of intracellular drug susceptibility, we allowed a 3-day preadaptation phase post-macrophage infection prior to drug treatment. We found that intracellular Mtb in human monocyte-derived macrophages (MDM) presents dramatic alterations in susceptibility to isoniazid, sutezolid, rifampicin and rifapentine when compared to axenic culture. Infected MDM gradually accumulate lipid bodies, adopting a characteristic appearance reminiscent of foamy macrophages in granulomas. Furthermore, TB granulomas in vivo develop hypoxic cores with decreasing oxygen tension gradients across their radii. Accordingly, we evaluated the effects of hypoxia on preadapted intracellular Mtb in our MDM model. We observed that hypoxia induced greater lipid body formation and no additional shifts in drug tolerance, suggesting that the adaptation of intracellular Mtb to baseline host cell conditions under normoxia dominates changes to intracellular drug susceptibility. Using unbound plasma concentrations in patients as surrogates for free drug concentrations in lung interstitial fluid, we estimate that intramacrophage Mtb in granulomas are exposed to bacteriostatic concentrations of most study drugs.

Determination of the Pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics of Isoniazid, Rifampicin, Pyrazinamide and Ethambutol in a Cross-Over Cynomolgus Macaque Model of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Infection.

Innovative cross-over study designs were explored in non-human primate (NHP) studies to determine the value of this approach for the evaluation of drug efficacy against tuberculosis (TB). Firstly, the pharmacokinetics (PK) of each of the drugs Isoniazid (H), Rifampicin (R), Pyrazinamide (Z) and Ethambutol (E), that are standardly used for the treatment of tuberculosis, was established in the blood of macaques after oral dosing as a monotherapy or in combination. Two studies were conducted to evaluate the pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of different drug combinations using cross-over designs. The first employed a balanced, three-period Pigeon design with an extra period; this ensured that treatment by period interactions and carry-over could be detected comparing the treatments HR, HZ and HRZ using H37Rv as the challenge strain of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tb). Although the design accounted for considerable variability between animals, the three regimens evaluated could not be distinguished using any of the alternative endpoints assessed. However, the degree of pathology achieved using H37Rv in the model during this study was less than expected. Based on these findings, a second experiment using a classical AB/BA design comparing HE with HRZ was conducted using the M. tb Erdman strain. More extensive pathology was observed, and differences in computerized tomography (CT) scores and bacteriology counts in the lungs were detected, although due to the small group sizes, clearer differences were not distinguished. Type 1 T helper (Th1) cell response profiles were characterized using the IFN-γ ELISPOT assay and revealed differences between drug treatments that corresponded to decreases in disease burden. Therefore, the studies performed support the utility of the NHP model for the determination of PK/PD of TB drugs, although further work is required to optimize the use of cross-over study designs.

A Rabbit Model to Study Antibiotic Penetration at the Site of Infection for Nontuberculous Mycobacterial Lung Disease: Macrolide Case Study.

Nontuberculous mycobacterial pulmonary disease (NTM-PD) is a potentially fatal infectious disease requiring long treatment duration with multiple antibiotics and against which there is no reliable cure. Among the factors that have hampered the development of adequate drug regimens is the lack of an animal model that reproduces the NTM lung pathology required for studying antibiotic penetration and efficacy. Given the documented similarities between tuberculosis and NTM immunopathology in patients, we first determined that the rabbit model of active tuberculosis reproduces key features of human NTM-PD and provides an acceptable surrogate model to study lesion penetration. We focused on clarithromycin, a macrolide and pillar of NTM-PD treatment, and explored the underlying causes of the disconnect between its favorable potency and pharmacokinetics and inconsistent clinical outcome. To quantify pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic target attainment at the site of disease, we developed a translational model describing clarithromycin distribution from plasma to lung lesions, including the spatial quantitation of clarithromycin and azithromycin in mycobacterial lesions of two patients on long-term macrolide therapy. Through clinical simulations, we visualized the coverage of clarithromycin in plasma and four disease compartments, revealing heterogeneous bacteriostatic and bactericidal target attainment depending on the compartment and the corresponding potency against nontuberculous mycobacteria in clinically relevant assays. Overall, clarithromycin's favorable tissue penetration and lack of bactericidal activity indicated that its clinical activity is limited by pharmacodynamic, rather than pharmacokinetic, factors. Our results pave the way toward the simulation of lesion pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic coverage by multidrug combinations to enable the prioritization of promising regimens for clinical trials.

The potential of microdialysis to estimate rifampicin concentrations in the lung of guinea pigs.

Optimised pre-clinical models are required for TB drug development to better predict the pharmacokinetics of anti-tuberculosis (anti-TB) drugs to shorten the time taken for novel drugs and combinations to be approved for clinical trial. Microdialysis can be used to measure unbound drug concentrations in awake freely moving animals in order to describe the pharmacokinetics of drugs in the organs as a continuous sampling technique. The aim of this work was to develop and optimise the microdialysis methodology in guinea pigs to better understand the pharmacokinetics of rifampicin in the lung. In vitro experiments were performed before progressing into in vivo studies because the recovery (concentration of the drug in the tissue fluid related to that in the collected dialysate) of rifampicin was dependent on a variety of experimental conditions. Mass spectrometry of the dialysate was used to determine the impact of flow rate, perfusion fluid and the molecular weight cut-off and membrane length of probes on the recovery of rifampicin at physiologically relevant concentrations. Following determination of probe efficiency and identification of a correlation between rifampicin concentrations in the lung and skeletal muscle, experiments were conducted to measure rifampicin in the sacrospinalis of guinea pigs using microdialysis. Lung concentrations of rifampicin were estimated from the rifampicin concentrations measured in the sacrospinalis. These studies suggest the potential usefulness of the microdialysis methodology to determine drug concentrations of selected anti-TB drugs to support new TB drug development.

Author Correction: Development of a diagnostic compatible BCG vaccine against Bovine tuberculosis.

An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via a link at the top of the paper.

Preclinical assessment of a new live attenuated Mycobacterium tuberculosis Beijing-based vaccine for tuberculosis.

Tuberculosis still claims more lives than any other pathogen, and a vaccine better than BCG is urgently needed. One of the challenges for novel TB vaccines is to protect against all Mycobacterium tuberculosis lineages, including the most virulent ones, such as the Beijing lineage. Here we developed a live attenuated M. tuberculosis mutant derived from GC1237, a Beijing strain responsible for tuberculosis outbreaks in the Canary Islands. The mutant strain is inactivated both in the Rv1503c gene, responsible for surface glycolipid synthesis, and in the two-component global regulator PhoPR. This double mutant is as safe as BCG in immunodeficient SCID mice. In immune-competent mice and guinea pigs, the mutant is as protective as BCG against M. tuberculosis strains of common lineage 4 (Euro-American). By contrast, in mice the vaccine is protective against a M. tuberculosis strain of lineage 2 (East-Asian, Beijing), while BCG is not. These results highlight differences in protection efficacy of live attenuated M. tuberculosis-derived vaccine candidates depending on their genetic background, and provide insights for the development of novel live vaccines against TB, especially in East-Asian countries where M. tuberculosis strains of the Beijing family are highly dominant.

Development of a diagnostic compatible BCG vaccine against Bovine tuberculosis.

Bovine tuberculosis (BTB) caused by Mycobacterium bovis remains a major problem in both the developed and developing countries. Control of BTB in the UK is carried out by test and slaughter of infected animals, based primarily on the tuberculin skin test (PPD). Vaccination with the attenuated strain of the M. bovis pathogen, BCG, is not used to control bovine tuberculosis in cattle at present, due to its variable efficacy and because it interferes with the PPD test. Diagnostic tests capable of Differentiating Infected from Vaccinated Animals (DIVA) have been developed that detect immune responses to M. bovis antigens absent in BCG; but these are too expensive and insufficiently sensitive to be used for BTB control worldwide. To address these problems we aimed to generate a synergistic vaccine and diagnostic approach that would permit the vaccination of cattle without interfering with the conventional PPD-based surveillance. The approach was to widen the pool of M. bovis antigens that could be used as DIVA targets, by identifying antigenic proteins that could be deleted from BCG without affecting the persistence and protective efficacy of the vaccine in cattle. Using transposon mutagenesis we identified genes that were essential and those that were non-essential for persistence in bovine lymph nodes. We then inactivated selected immunogenic, but non-essential genes in BCG Danish to create a diagnostic-compatible triple knock-out ΔBCG TK strain. The protective efficacy of the ΔBCG TK was tested in guinea pigs experimentally infected with M. bovis by aerosol and found to be equivalent to wild-type BCG. A complementary diagnostic skin test was developed with the antigenic proteins encoded by the deleted genes which did not cross-react in vaccinated or in uninfected guinea pigs. This study demonstrates the functionality of a new and improved BCG strain which retains its protective efficacy but is diagnostically compatible with a novel DIVA skin test that could be implemented in control programmes.

Comparison of pellicle and shake flask-grown BCG strains by quality control assays and protection studies.

A global BCG vaccine shortage began in 2013 which impacted availability for infant vaccinations, as well as preclinical studies and clinical trials of new TB vaccines. Stakeholders met in 2015 at McGill University in Montreal to discuss the shortage and potential mitigation strategies. Manufacturing BCG through a more tractable liquid fermentation process instead of the traditional pellicle growth method was considered a potentially viable strategy. This pilot program compared pellicle-grown and shake flask-grown BCG strains (as a first step towards modeling fermenter-produced BCG vaccine) in selected quality control assays, as well as mouse and guinea pig protection studies. Conventional pellicle-grown, lyophilized BCG WHO Reference Reagents (Danish, Moreau, Russian, Tokyo strains) were obtained from the National Institute for Biological Standards and Control (NIBSC), UK. Strains were grown in shake flasks and glycerol stocks prepared. Shake flask-grown BCG culture preparations generally met the requirements of quality control testing at NIBSC. In mouse and guinea pig protection studies there were no significant differences in lung colony forming units (CFUs) between shake flask-grown and pellicle-grown preparations, with the exception of BCG Russian, where the shake flask-grown preparation protected better in mice (P = 0.0042), but the pellicle-grown preparation protected better in guinea pigs (P = 0.0015). Producing BCG vaccines by a more tractable liquid growth process could be a viable solution to the global BCG shortage.

Revaccination of Guinea Pigs With the Live Attenuated Mycobacterium tuberculosis Vaccine MTBVAC Improves BCG's Protection Against Tuberculosis.

Background: The need for an effective vaccine against human tuberculosis has driven the development of different candidates and vaccination strategies. Novel live attenuated vaccines are being developed that promise greater safety and efficacy than BCG against tuberculosis. We combined BCG with the vaccine MTBVAC to evaluate whether the efficacy of either vaccine would be affected upon revaccination. Methods: In a well-established guinea pig model of aerosol infection with Mycobacterium tuberculosis, BCG and MTBVAC delivered via various prime-boost combinations or alone were compared. Efficacy was determined by a reduction in bacterial load 4 weeks after challenge. Results: Efficacy data suggests MTBVAC-associated immunity is longer lasting than that of BCG when given as a single dose. Long and short intervals between BCG prime and MTBVAC boost resulted in improved efficacy in lungs, compared with BCG given alone. A shorter interval between MTBVAC prime and BCG boost resulted in improved efficacy in lungs, compared with BCG given alone. A longer interval resulted in protection equivalent to that of BCG given alone. Conclusions: These data indicate that, rather than boosting the waning efficacy of BCG, a vaccination schedule involving a combination of the 2 vaccines yielded stronger immunity to M. tuberculosis infection. This work supports development of MTBVAC use as a revaccination strategy to improve on the effects of BCG in vaccinated people living in tuberculosis-endemic countries.