Investigating the origin of subtelomeric and centromeric AT-rich elements in Aspergillus flavus.

An in silico study of Aspergillus flavus genome stability uncovered significant variations in both coding and non-coding regions. The non-coding insertions uniformly consisted of AT-rich sequences that are evolutionarily maintained, albeit distributed at widely different sites in an array of A. flavus strains. A survey of ≥ 2kb AT-rich elements (AT ≥ 70%; ATEs) in non-centromeric regions uncovered two major categories of ATEs. The first category is composed of homologous insertions at ectopic, non-allelic sites that contain homology to transposable elements (TEs; Classes B, C, D, and E). Strains differed significantly in frequency, position, and TE type, but displayed a common enrichment in subtelomeric regions. The TEs were heavily mutated, with patterns consistent with the ancestral activity of repeat-induced point mutations (RIP). The second category consists of a conserved set of novel subtelomeric ATE repeats (Classes A, G, G, H, I and J) which lack discernible TEs and, unlike TEs, display a constant polarity relative to the telomere. Members of one of these classes are derivatives of a progenitor ATE that is predicted to have undergone extensive homologous recombination during evolution. A third category of ATEs consists of ~100 kb regions at each centromere. Centromeric ATEs and TE clusters within these centromeres display a high level of sequence identity between strains. These studies suggest that transposition and RIP are forces in the evolution of subtelomeric and centromeric structure and function.

Towards the Mechanism of Yeast Telomere Dynamics.

A mechanistic understanding of the yeast telomere requires an integrated understanding of telomere chromatin structure (telosomes), telomeric origins of replications, telomere length homeostasis, and telosome epigenetics. Recent molecular and genetic studies of the yeast telosomal components Rap1, Rif1, and Rif2, the Mre11 complex, and Tel1ATM promise to increase our insight into the coordination between these processes. Here, an intricate relationship is proposed between these multiple components that has resulted in increased appreciation of the multiple levels of telomere length control and their differentiation from double-strand repair. The mre11A470 motif (A470-A482) alleles have also opened new avenues to the exploration of telosome structure and function.

The mre11A470T mutation and homeologous interactions increase error-prone BIR.

In the absence of the RNA-templated reverse transcriptase, telomerase, the predominant means of terminal addition, arises from break-induced replication (BIR) at multiple homologous subtelomeric Y' loci and among internal homeologous (imperfect) (polyG1-3T) tracts. These last tracts are interspersed between subtelomeric Y' direct repeats. One major survivor class contains very short (~50 bp) terminal telomere repeats. This size is sufficient for slow growth and partial telomere functionality and cell viability. However, in cells carrying the mre11A470T allele, adjacent to the predicted Rad50/Mre11 junction, cells thrive at wild-type rates, with small, but reproducible, increases in telomere length. We have proposed that the increase in telomere size and growth rate are causally linked. To understand the BIR process at the telomere, we initiated studies of large-tract (RAD51-sensitive) homologous BIR in MRE11 and mre11A470T cells in a model color assay coupled with CHEF gel analysis and marker retention. Wild-type and mutant homologous BIR rates are maintained at the same level as the rates between wild-type and mutant homeologous BIR. However, the fidelity of BIR products was severely altered in mre11A470T cells. We find that 95% of homologous BIR in MRE11 cells gives rise to the expected product size, while 25% of BIR products in mre11A470T cells were of unpredicted size (error-prone), most of which initiated at an aberrant site. However, ~25% of homeologous MRE11 cells and 1/7 of homeologous mre11A470T cells underwent error-prone BIR. This class is initiated erroneously, followed by secondary events that elongate or truncate the telomere. We conclude that error-prone BIRs are increased in homeologous recombination in wild-type and in mre11A470T cells. This finding may explain the bypass of senescence in telomerase-negative cells.

The mre11 A470 alleles influence the hereditability and the segregation of telosomes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Telomeres, the nucleoprotein complexes at the termini of linear chromosomes, are essential for the processes of end replication, end protection, and chromatin segregation. The Mre11 complex is involved in multiple cellular roles in DNA repair and structure in the regulation and function of telomere size homeostasis. In this study, we characterize yeast telomere chromatin structure, phenotypic heritability, and chromatin segregation in both wild-type [MRE11] and A470 motif alleles. MRE11 strains confer a telomere size of 300 base pairs of G+T irregular simple sequence repeats. This DNA and a portion of subtelomeric DNA is embedded in a telosome: a MNase-resistant non-nucleosomal particle. Chromatin immunoprecipitation shows a three to four-fold lower occupancy of Mre11A470T proteins than wild-type proteins in telosomes. Telosomes containing the Mre11A470T protein confer a greater resistance to MNase digestion than wild-type telosomes. The integration of a wild-type MRE11 allele into an ectopic locus in the genome of an mre11A470T mutant and the introduction of an mre11A470T allele at an ectopic site in a wild-type strain lead to unexpectedly differing results. In each case, the replicated sister chromatids inherit telosomes containing only the protein encoded by the genomic mre11 locus, even in the presence of protein encoded by the opposing ectopic allele. We hypothesize that the telosome segregates by a conservative mechanism. These data support a mechanism for the linkage between sister chromatid replication and maintenance of either identical mutant or identical wild-type telosomes after replication of sister chromatids. These data suggest the presence of an active mechanism for chromatin segregation in yeast.

Hypothesis: Paralog Formation from Progenitor Proteins and Paralog Mutagenesis Spur the Rapid Evolution of Telomere Binding Proteins.

Through elegant studies in fungal cells and complex organisms, we propose a unifying paradigm for the rapid evolution of telomere binding proteins (TBPs) that associate with either (or both) telomeric DNA and telomeric proteins. TBPs protect and regulate telomere structure and function. Four critical factors are involved. First, TBPs that commonly bind to telomeric DNA include the c-Myb binding proteins, OB-fold single-stranded binding proteins, and G-G base paired Hoogsteen structure (G4) binding proteins. Each contributes independently or, in some cases, cooperatively, to provide a minimum level of telomere function. As a result of these minimal requirements and the great abundance of homologs of these motifs in the proteome, DNA telomere-binding activity may be generated more easily than expected. Second, telomere dysfunction gives rise to genome instability, through the elevation of recombination rates, genome ploidy, and the frequency of gene mutations. The formation of paralogs that diverge from their progenitor proteins ultimately can form a high frequency of altered TBPs with altered functions. Third, TBPs that assemble into complexes (e.g., mammalian shelterin) derive benefits from the novel emergent functions. Fourth, a limiting factor in the evolution of TBP complexes is the formation of mutually compatible interaction surfaces amongst the TBPs. These factors may have different degrees of importance in the evolution of different phyla, illustrated by the apparently simpler telomeres in complex plants. Selective pressures that can utilize the mechanisms of paralog formation and mutagenesis to drive TBP evolution along routes dependent on the requisite physiologic changes.

Potential Risks in the Paradigm of Basic to Translational Research: A Critical Evaluation of qPCR Telomere Size Techniques.

Real time qPCR has become the method of choice for rapid large-scale telomere length measurements. Large samples sizes are critical for clinical trials, and epidemiological studies. QPCR has become such routine procedure that it is often used with little critical analysis. With proper controls, the mean telomere size can be derived from the data and even the size can be estimated. But there is a need for more consistent and reliable controls that will provide closer to the actual mean size can be obtained with uniform consensus controls. Although originating at the level of basic telomere research, many researchers less familiar with telomeres often misunderstand the source and significance of the qPCR metric. These include researchers and clinicians who are interested in having a rapid tool to produce exciting results in disease prognostics and diagnostics than in the multiple characteristics of telomeres that form the basis of the measurement. But other characteristics of the non-bimodal and heterogeneous telomeres as well as the complexities of telomere dynamics are not easily related to qPCR mean telomere values. The qPCR metric does not reveal the heterogeneity and dynamics of telomeres. This is a critical issue since mutations in multiple genes including telomerase can cause telomere dysfunction and a loss of repeats. The smallest cellular telomere has been shown to arrest growth of the cell carrying the dysfunction telomere. A goal for the future is a simple method that takes into account the heterogeneity by measuring the highest and lowest values as part of the scheme to compare. In the absence of this technique, Southern blots need to be performed in a subset of qPCR samples for both mean telomere size and the upper and lower extremes of the distribution. Most importantly, there is a need for greater transparency in discussing the limitations of the qPCR data. Given the potentially exciting qPCR telomere size results emerging from clinical studies that relate qPCR mean telomere size estimates to disease states, the current ambiguities have become urgent issues to validate the findings and to set the right course for future clinical investigations.

The Ctf18RFC clamp loader is essential for telomere stability in telomerase-negative and mre11 mutant alleles.

The function of the replication clamp loaders in the semi-conservative telomere replication and their relationship to telomerase- and recombination mechanisms of telomere addition remains ambiguous. We have investigated the variant clamp loader Ctf18 RFC (Replication Factor C). To understand the role of Ctf18 at the telomere, we first investigated genetic interactions after loss of Ctf18 and TLC1 (the yeast telomerase RNA). We find that the tlc1Δ ctf18Δ double mutant confers a rapid >1000-fold decrease in viability. The rate of loss was similar to the kinetics of cell death in rad52Δ tlc1Δ cells. However, the Ctf18 pathway is distinct from Rad52, required for the repair of DSBs, as demonstrated by the synthetic lethality of rad52▵ tlc1Δ ctf18Δ triple mutants. These data suggest that each mutant elicits non-redundant defects acting on the same substrate. Second, interactions of the yeast hyper-recombinational mutant, mre11A470T, with ctf18▵ confer a synergistic cold sensitivity. The phenotype of these double mutants ultimately results in telomere loss and the generation of recombinational survivors. We observed a similar synergism between single mutants that led to hypersensitivity to the DNA alkylating agent, methane methyl sulphonate (MMS), the replication fork inhibitor hydroxyurea (HU), and to a failure to separate telomeres of sister chromatids. Hence, ctf18Δ and mre11A470T act in different pathways on telomere substrates for multiple phenotypes. The mre11A470T cells also displayed a DNA damage response (DDR) at 15°C but not at 30°C while ctf18Δ mutants conferred a constitutive DDR activity. Both the 15°C DDR pattern and growth rate were reversible at 30°C and displayed telomerase activity in vivo. We hypothesize that Ctf18 confers protection against stalling and/or breaks at the replication fork in cells that either lack, or are compromised for, telomerase activity. This Ctf18-based function is likely to contribute another level to telomere size homeostasis.

Telomerase as an important target of androgen signaling blockade for prostate cancer treatment.

As the mainstay treatment for advanced prostate cancer, androgen deprivation therapy (ADT) targets the action of androgen receptor (AR) by reducing androgen level and/or by using anti-androgen to compete with androgens for binding to AR. Albeit effective in extending survival, ADT is associated with dose-limiting toxicity and the development of castration-resistant prostate cancer (CRPC) after prolonged use. Because CRPC is lethal and incurable, developing effective strategies to enhance the efficacy of ADT and circumvent resistance becomes an urgent task. Continuous AR signaling constitutes one major mechanism underlying the development of CRPC. The present study showed that methylseleninic acid (MSA), an agent that effectively reduces AR abundance, could enhance the cancer-killing efficacy of the anti-androgen bicalutamide in androgen-dependent and CRPC cells. We found that the combination of MSA and bicalutamide produced a robust downregulation of prostate-specific antigen and a recently identified AR target, telomerase, and its catalytic subunit, human telomerase reverse transcriptase. The downregulation of hTERT occurs mainly at the transcriptional level, and reduced AR occupancy of the promoter contributes to downregulation. Furthermore, apoptosis induction by the two agents is significantly mitigated by the restoration of hTERT. Our findings thus indicate that MSA in combination with anti-androgen could represent a viable approach to improve the therapeutic outcome of ADT. Given the critical role of hTERT/telomerase downregulation in mediating the combination effect and the fact that hTERT/telomerase could be measured in blood and urine, hTERT/telomerase could serve as an ideal tumor-specific biomarker to monitor the efficacy of the combination therapy noninvasively.

An mre11 mutation that promotes telomere recombination and an efficient bypass of senescence.

Preventing the formation of dysfunctional telomeres is essential for genomic stability. In most organisms, the ribo-nucleoprotein reverse transcriptase telomerase is responsible for telomere GT-strand elongation. However, in telomerase-negative cells, low-frequency recombination mechanisms can avert lethality by elongating critically short telomeres. This study focuses on the involvement of the budding yeast Mre11 in telomere recombination and homeostasis. We have identified a novel allele of MRE11, mre11-A470T, that, in telomerase-positive cells, confers a semidominant decrease in telomere size and a recessive defect in telomere healing. In addition, mutant cells lack normal telomere size homeostasis. Telomerase-negative mre11-A470T cells display a Rad51-dependent bypass of replicative senescence via induction of a highly efficient type I-related recombination pathway termed type IA. The type IA pathway involves an amplification of subtelomeric Y' elements, coupled with elongated and more heterogeneous telomere tracts relative to the short telomere size of type I survivors. The data have led us to propose the involvement of break-induced replication in telomere expansion. The differing phenotypes elicited by the mre11-A470T mutants in telomerase-positive and telomerase-negative cells have also led us to speculate that the telomere end structure may be modified differentially in mre11-A470T cells, directing the telomere into specific pathways.

Sir3 C-terminal domain involvement in the initiation and spreading of heterochromatin.

Heterochromatin is nucleated at a specific site and subsequently spreads into distal sequences through multiple interactions between modified histones and nonhistone proteins. In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, these nonhistone proteins include Sir2, Sir3, and Sir4. We have previously shown that loss of the C-terminal Rap1 domain containing Sir3 and Sir4 association sites can be overcome by tethering a 144-amino-acid C-terminal domain (CTD) of Sir3 adjacent to the telomere. Here, we explore the substructure and functions of the CTD. We demonstrate that the CTD is the minimum domain for Sir3 homodimerization, a function that is conserved in related yeasts. However, CTD heterodimers associate at only low efficiencies and correspondingly have low levels of tethered silencing, consistent with an essential role for dimerization in tethered silencing. Six missense alleles were generated, with ctd-Y964A producing the most extreme phenotypes when tethered to the LexA binding sites. Although ctd-Y964A is capable of dimerization, telomere silencing is abrogated, indicating that the CTD serves a second essential function in silencing. Chromatin immunoprecipitation analyses of wild-type and ctd-Y964A mutant cells indicate an association of the CTD with the deacetylated histone tails of H3 and H4 that is necessary for the recruitment of Sir3. The efficiency of spreading depends upon the apparent stoichiometry and stability during the initiation event. The predicted Cdc6 domain III winged-helix structure may well be responsible for dimerization.

Telomere dynamics in genome stability.

The past several years have seen an increasing interest in telomere recombinational interactions that provide many functions in telomere capping, in telomere size homeostasis and in overcoming the catastrophic effects of telomerase deficiency. Several key recombination mechanisms have emerged from recent investigations. In the yeasts, these mechanisms include exchange between subtelomeric regions and telomere sequences, rapid telomere expansion and telomere deletion. These processes proceed by pathways that use both the cellular recombination machinery and novel mechanisms such as rolling circle replication. The insights gained from recent studies extend our understanding of similar processes in higher eukaryotes and suggest that the recombinational dynamics of telomeres have additional roles that contribute to genomic stability and instability.

Mre 11 p nuclease activity is dispensable for telomeric rapid deletion.

Telomeric rapid deletion (TRD) is an intrachromatid recombination process that truncates over-elongated telomeres to the genetically determined average telomere length. We have proposed that TRD is initiated by invasion of the 3' G-rich overhang into centromere-proximal telomere sequence, forming an intermediate that leads to excision of the distal telomere tract. TRD efficiency is dependent on Mre 11p and Rad50p, two members of the widely conserved Mre 11p/Rad50p/Xrs2p (MRX) complex. To investigate the role of Mre 11p in TRD, we conducted a structure/function analysis by testing the TRD rate and precision of mutations within known functional domains. We analyzed 12 alleles that disrupt different Mre 11p activities. Surprisingly, mutations in essential residues of the nuclease domain do not inhibit TRD, effectively ruling out nuclease activity as the source of the Mre 11p requirement. Interestingly, loss of Exo1p alone or loss of Exo1p in an Mre 11 nuclease deficient background does not eliminate TRD, suggesting the presence of an additional nuclease. Second, deletion of DNA binding sites A (residues 410--420) and B (residues 644--692) actually enhances the TRD rate. Even deletion of both DNA binding domains does not abrogate TRD, although its kinetics and precision are variable. This suggests altered DNA binding or a conformational defect in the MRX complex may affect the rate of TRD product formation and indicates that the DNA binding sites formally act as repressors of TRD. Remarkably, the H213Y allele (nuclease motif IV) confers an extraordinarily rapid kinetics, with the vast majority of elongated telomeres deleted imprecisely in a single round of subculturing. In striking contrast, the P162S allele that confers dissolution of the complex also exhibits the null phenotype. These data suggest that Mre 11p can act as a positive and negative regulator of TRD in context of the MRX complex that is essential for TRD.

Ndj1p-dependent epigenetic resetting of telomere size in yeast meiosis.

Telomeres are essential for the protection of chromosomes against nucleases and recombinases and for the addition of G+T-rich simple sequence by the ribonucleoprotein reverse transcriptase telomerase . Telomere size instability and loss of telomerase activity in somatic cells is strongly associated with both oncogenesis and aging . Yet, an understanding of the mechanisms that maintain telomere size and structure during meiosis is still in its infancy . We have investigated the stability of single elongated telomeres during yeast meiosis. We find that elongated telomeres undergo high rates of precise deletion to wild-type telomere size via an intrachromatid pathway that shares properties with mitotic telomere rapid deletion (TRD). Loss of Ndj1p, a telomeric protein necessary for meiotic bouquet structure formation , confers a severe reduction in deletion rates. Return-to-growth (RTG) experiments suggest that deletion occurs at or near the period of meiotic recombination in NDJ1/NDJ1, but not in ndj1Delta/ndj1Delta diploids . We propose that Ndj1p facilitates deletion by promoting telomeric interactions during meiosis, resulting in an effective increase in the concentration of limiting factors for deletion.

Telomerase RNA: a flexible RNA scaffold for telomerase biosynthesis.

Determination of the structure of the yeast telomerase RNA component TLC1 has been hampered by its large size and high rate of evolutionary divergence. But detailed phylogenetic comparisons have now revealed the unusually flexible and modular architecture of this important RNA molecule.

Clues to catastrophic telomere loss in mammals from yeast telomere rapid deletion.

Catastrophic losses of telomeric sequences have recently been described during apoptosis, senescence and tumorigenesis in murine and human cells, in ataxia telangiectasia patients and in immortalized cells in which telomerase is inactive. A mechanism that underlies a single-step non-reciprocal telomere deletion called telomere rapid deletion in Saccharomyces cerevisiae might provide clues for future studies of catastrophic telomere loss in higher eukaryotes.

The paradoxical relationship between NHEJ and telomeric fusion.

Recent results shed new light on the origin of fusion products observed in the destabilized chromosomes of cancer and related diseases. These findings define an unusual relationship between nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) and telomere "capping," with identical proteins playing opposing roles.

Multiple roles for Saccharomyces cerevisiae histone H2A in telomere position effect, Spt phenotypes and double-strand-break repair.

Telomere position effects on transcription (TPE, or telomeric silencing) are nucleated by association of nonhistone silencing factors with the telomere and propagated in subtelomeric regions through association of silencing factors with the specifically modified histones H3 and H4. However, the function of histone H2A in TPE is unknown. We found that deletion of either the amino or the carboxyltails of H2A substantially reduces TPE. We identified four H2A modification sites necessary for wild-type efficiency of TPE. These "hta1tpe" alleles also act as suppressors of a delta insertion allele of LYS2, suggesting shared elements of chromatin structure at both loci. Interestingly, we observed combinatorial effects of allele pairs, suggesting both interdependent acetylation and deacetylation events in the amino-terminal tail and a regulatory circuit between multiple phosphorylated residues in the carboxyl-terminal tail. Decreases in silencing and viability are observed in most hta1tpe alleles after treatment with low and high concentrations, respectively, of bleomycin, which forms double-strand breaks (DSBs). In the absence of the DSB and telomere-binding protein yKu70, the bleomycin sensitivity of hta1tpe alleles is further enhanced. We also provide data suggesting the presence of a yKu-dependent histone H2A function in TPE. These data indicate that the amino- and carboxyl-terminal tails of H2A are essential for wild-type levels of yKu-mediated TPE and DSB repair.