Stable expression of antisense RNAs targeted to the 5' non-coding region confers heterotypic inhibition to foot-and-mouth disease virus infection.

The antiviral potential of transcripts targeted to the non-coding regions (NCRs) of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) RNA have been studied during transient and constitutive expression in susceptible BHK-21 cells. Transient expression of antisense transcripts corresponding to the 5' and 3'NCRs, alone or in combination, confers specific inhibition of homologous (serotype C) virus infection in BHK-21 cells. Constitutive expression of antisense 5'NCR transcripts (5'AS) exerted higher levels of inhibition to homologous and heterologous (serotypes O, A, Asia, SAT 1, SAT 2 and SAT 3) FMDV infection, as estimated by a 10-fold reduction in virus titre in the supernatants from infected clones and by a plaque reduction assay. These inhibitions were also observed, albeit to a lesser extent, in clones stably expressing antisense 3'NCR transcripts. The antiviral response was specific for FMDV, as the picornavirus encephalomyocarditis virus was not inhibited in any of the transformed cell lines. In all cases, a correlation was found between the level of transcript expression and the extent of virus inhibition. The potential to efficiently inhibit FMDV, including isolates representing the seven serotypes, by expressing interfering 5'AS transcripts opens the possibility of developing transgenic animals with a reduced susceptibility to FMDV.

IRES interaction with translation initiation factors: functional characterization of novel RNA contacts with eIF3, eIF4B, and eIF4GII.

Translation initiation promoted by picornavirus internal ribosome entry site (IRES) elements is dependent on the association of specific IRES sequences to the initiation factor eIF4G. However the RNA determinants interacting with other components of the translational machinery are still unknown. In this study, we have identified novel RNA-protein interactions between the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) IRES and three translation initiation factors. A doublet of 116/110 kDa that crosslinked to the FMDV IRES is a component of eIF3. We show here that domain 5 holds the preferential binding site for eIF3, although this complex initiation factor can establish multiple contacts with the IRES structure. We have also identified the phylogenetically conserved hairpin of domain 5 as the RNA motif responsible for eIF4B interaction. Mutation of this stem-loop structure abrogated eIF4B, but not eIF3, binding to the IRES. Remarkably, IRES mutants severely affected in their interaction with eIF4B showed a mild reduction in IRES activity when tested in the context of a bicistronic expression vector in transfected cells. Finally, we provide evidence of the interaction of eIF4GII with FMDV IRES, the RNA determinants for this interaction being shared with its functional homolog eIF4GI. The FMDV Lb protease generated a C-terminal fragment of eIF4GII that binds to the IRES as efficiently as the intact protein. Competition experiments showed that titration of eIF4B or p110/116 interaction with the FMDV IRES required a large excess of competitor relative to eIF4G, strongly suggesting that eIF4G-IRES interaction is a limiting factor to titrate the IRES. Comparative analysis of the activity of IRES mutants affected in domains 4 and 5 regarding their pattern of RNA-protein complex formation demonstrates that while binding of eIF4B with the FMDV IRES is dispensable, interaction of eIF4G is a central feature of the activity of this element.

Deletion or substitution of the aphthovirus 3' NCR abrogates infectivity and virus replication.

The 3' noncoding region (NCR) of the genomic picornaviral RNA is believed to contain major cis-acting signals required for negative-strand RNA synthesis. The 3' NCR of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) was studied in the context of a full-length infectious clone in which the genetic element was deleted or exchanged for the equivalent region of a distantly related swine picornavirus, swine vesicular disease virus (SVDV). Deletion of the 3' NCR, while maintaining the intact poly(A) tail as well as its replacement for the SVDV counterpart, abrogated virus replication in susceptible cells as determined by infectivity and Northern blot assays. Nevertheless, the presence of the SVDV sequence allowed the synthesis of low amounts of chimeric viral RNA at extended times post-transfection as compared to RNAs harbouring the 3' NCR deletion. The failure to recover viable viruses or revertants after several passages on susceptible cells suggests that the presence of specific sequences contained within the FMDV 3' NCR is essential to complete a full replication cycle and that FMDV and SVDV 3' NCRs are not functionally interchangeable.

Interaction of the eIF4G initiation factor with the aphthovirus IRES is essential for internal translation initiation in vivo.

The strategies developed by internal ribosome entry site (IRES) elements to recruit the translational machinery are poorly understood. In this study we show that protein-RNA interaction of the eIF4G translation initiation factor with sequences of the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) IRES is a key determinant of internal translation initiation in living cells. Moreover, we have identified the nucleotides required for eIF4G-RNA functional interaction, using native proteins from FMDV-susceptible cell extracts. Substitutions in the conserved internal AA loop of the base of domain 4 led to strong impairment of both eIF4G-RNA interaction in vitro and IRES-dependent translation initiation in vivo. Conversely, substitutions in the vicinity of the internal AA loop that did not impair IRES activity retained their ability to interact with eIF4G. Direct UV-crosslinking as well as competition assays indicated that domains 1-2, 3, and 5 of the IRES did not contribute to this interaction. In agreement with this, binding to domain 4 alone was as efficient as to the full-length IRES. The C-terminal fragment of eIF4G, proteolytically processed by the FMDV Lb protease, was sufficient to interact with the IRES or to its domain 4 alone. Additionally, we show here that binding of the eIF4B initiation factor to the IRES required domain 5 sequences. Moreover, eIF4G-IRES interaction was detected in the absence of eIF4B-IRES binding, suggesting that both initiation factors interact with the 3' region of the IRES but use different residues. The strong correlation found between eIF4G-RNA interaction and IRES activity in transfected cells suggests that eIF4G acts as a linker to recruit the translational machinery in IRES-dependent initiation.

Long-range RNA interactions between structural domains of the aphthovirus internal ribosome entry site (IRES).

Internal initiation of translation is promoted by internal ribosome entry site (IRES) cis-acting elements. Using transcripts that correspond to the structural domains of the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) IRES, we have identified RNA-RNA interactions between separated domains (1-2, 3, 4-5, or HH) of the IRES structure. All the assayed domains were able to interact with the full-length IRES as well as with domain 3, although to a different extent, with the most efficient interactions being those occurring between domains 3 and 4-5, and domains 3 and 1-2. RNA-RNA complexes were stable over 1 h of incubation at 37 degrees C, and depended on Mg2+ and RNA concentration. Neither the antisense domain 1-2 nor tRNA interacted with domain 3, providing experimental evidence of the specificity for the sense strand of the IRES sequence. Additionally, domain 1-2 did not interact with 4-5, leading to the suggestion that domain 3 acts as a scaffold structure where the other domains bind. The thermal disassociation profile of these complexes indicated different strength in these interactions. Whereas 50% of the complexes between domains 3 and 4-5 were destabilized at 45 degrees C, those formed by domain 1-2 and 3 required temperatures higher than 51 degrees C. Efficient self-dimerization of domains 3 and 4-5 was found in the absence of other transcripts. Formation of domain 3 homodimer competed with formation of heterocomplexes with other domains, and conversely, domain 3 homodimers were competed out by the presence of the other domains. RNA interactions were also observed at physiological concentrations of Mg2+ and K1+. The identification of the RNA-RNA complexes reported here provide direct experimental evidence of tertiary interactions within IRES elements.

Internal ribosome entry site biology and its use in expression vectors.

Internal ribosome entry sites (IRESs) are cis-acting elements that recruit the small ribosomal subunits to an internal initiator codon in the mRNA with the help of cellular trans-acting factors. The recent discovery of the IRES recognition site of the eIF4G initiation factor is beginning to shed some light into how IRES elements are recognized by the translational machinery. Additionally, the progress made in the understanding of the parameters that influence start codon selection will be instrumental in establishing the rational design of bicistronic expression vectors.

Response to retreatment with interferon-alpha plus ribavirin in chronic hepatitis C patients is independent of the NS5A gene nucleotide sequence.

OBJECTIVE: Interferon-alpha plus ribavirin is an effective treatment for chronic hepatitis C patients. We evaluated whether the response to this combined therapy correlated with the presence of mutations in a region of 372 nucleotides within the NS5A gene. METHODS: Sixty-two patients, 42 nonresponders and 20 relapsers to a previous course of interferon-alpha, received 3 million units thrice weekly of interferon-alpha-2b and 1-1.2 g daily of ribavirin for 12 months. Basal biochemical and virological (HCV RNA and genotype) parameters were determined. Clinical examinations were carried out at 1, 2, 3, 6, and 12 months. In addition, nucleotide sequencing of the NS5A gene was determined for viral samples obtained from 38 of these patients at the baseline of the combined therapy, as well as in 15 of them before initiating the previous course of interferon as monotherapy. RESULTS: On finishing the 12 months, 36 patients (58.1%) had normal aminotransferases and 25 (40.3%) cleared viremia. Nucleotide sequencing indicated the same level of genetic variability within the group of responder and nonresponder patients all along the 124 amino acid residues of the NS5A gene studied. Neither the type of amino acid substitution nor the number of them was significantly different in one group relative to the other. CONCLUSIONS: Therapy with interferon-alpha-2b plus ribavirin was well tolerated, achieving an end-of-treatment response in 25 (40.3%) patients. Response did not correlate with the presence of mutations in the NS5A gene analyzed, including the interferon sensitivity determining region (ISDR) and its flanking sequences.

Internal initiation of translation efficiency in different hepatitis C genotypes isolated from interferon treated patients.

Initiation of translation of hepatitis C viral RNA occurs internally and it is mediated by a segment of about 330 nucleotides termed Internal Ribosome Entry Site (IRES) located in the 5' end region. While being the most conserved part of the genome, this region also accumulates nucleotide substitutions which are often covariant. In this study we have examined the activity and sequence variation of IRES elements belonging to genotypes 1b, 2a/2c and 3a in patients that responded or not to interferon therapy. The substitutions found in the IRES region analyzed were predicted to maintain the secondary structure of the RNA. Comparison of their efficiency to promote internal initiation of translation in bicistronic constructs supported the conclusion that for both 1b and 3a genotypes, response to interferon therapy and IRES activity are unrelated, although sequence homology was not always found among isolates from patients with different type of response. IRES activity of the studied genotypes varied about 4-fold under the conditions used in our in vivo assays depending on the cell line used for transfection. Such differences were not evidenced in vitro suggesting that the differences observed depend on trans-acting factors present in the transfected cell.

Involvement of the aphthovirus RNA region located between the two functional AUGs in start codon selection.

Initiation of translation in picornavirus RNAs occurs internally, mediated by an element termed internal ribosome entry site (IRES). In the aphthovirus RNA, the IRES element directs translation initiation at two in-frame AUGs separated by 84 nucleotides. We have found that bicistronic constructs that contained the IRES element followed by the fragment including the aphthovirus start codons in front of the second gene mimicked the translation initiation pattern of viral RNA observed in infected cells. In those constructs, the frequency of initiation at the first AUG was increased by a sequence context that resembled the favorable consensus for cap-dependent translation, although initiation at the second site was always preferred. In addition, we have found that initiation at the second start codon was not diminished under conditions in which the first initiation codon was blocked by antisense oligonucleotide interference. Interestingly, mutations that positioned the second AUG out-of-frame with the first AUG did not interfere with the frequency of initiation at the second one. On the contrary, IRES-dependent translation initiation in bicistronic constructs lacking the sequences present between functional AUGs in the viral RNA was sensitive to the presence of out-of-frame initiator codons and hairpins in the spacer region. This remarkable difference in start codon recognition was due to the nucleotide composition of the RNA that separated the IRES from the initiator codon. Thus our results indicate that the region located in the aphthovirus RNA between functional AUGs is involved in start codon recognition, strongly favoring selection of the second start AUG as the main initiator codon.

Heterotypic inhibition of foot-and-mouth disease virus infection by combinations of RNA transcripts corresponding to the 5' and 3' regions.

Strategies to inhibit RNA virus multiplication based on the use of interfering nucleic acids have to consider the high genetic polymorphism exhibited by this group of viruses. Here, we report high levels of heterotypic inhibition of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) infective particle formation in cotransfection experiments of susceptible cell lines with infections viral RNA and combinations of viral transcripts. The interfering molecules used include the following regions on type C FMDV RNA: (i) sequences from the 5' region, spanning the proximal part of the internal ribosome entry site element and the two functional initiator AUGs; and (ii) the 3' terminal region including the 3' end of 3D gene and the complete 3' non-coding region. Combination of 5' antisense RNA molecules with either sense or antisense RNA molecules from the 3' region resulted in inhibition of up to 90% of the infectivity of homologous type C FMDV RNA. The inhibition was dose-dependent and specific, as no reduction was observed in the plaque-forming units recovered from RNA of swine vesicular disease virus, a related picornavirus. Interestingly, high levels-of intertypic inhibition, about 60% or higher, were observed when viral RNAs of serotypes O and A were analysed. These levels of inhibition are consistent with the levels of nucleotide homology exhibited by the viruses analysed in the target sequences. Inhibition of virus yield was also observed in FMDV-infected cells transiently expressing the interfering RNAs. Thus, transcripts of the FMDV RNA corresponding to the 5' and 3' regions specifically inhibit FMDV particle formation in a serotype-independent manner.

Parameters influencing translational efficiency in aphthovirus IRES-based bicistronic expression vectors.

Initiation of translation in picornavirus RNAs occurs internally, mediated by an internal ribosome entry site (IRES) element. This property has been exploited to coexpress proteins from a single bicistronic transcription unit in eukaryotic cells. The region that separates the IRES element from the authentic initiator codon of the second gene plays an important role in the translation efficiency of this cistron. In the present report, we have analyzed the effect of sequence modifications in this region on the translation efficiency directed by the foot-and-mouth disease (FMDV) IRES in bicistronic expression vectors. Insertion of various sequences, which contained additional start codons and/or the capacity to form hairpins immediately downstream of the 3' border of the IRES, strongly reduced the translation efficiency of the second gene in bicistronic RNAs. Interestingly, an increase of distance per se did not have a deleterious effect on translation efficiency. The bicistronic vector studied here tolerated 95 nucleotides between the 3' border of the IRES and the authentic start codon, provided that out-of-frame AUG codons or hairpins were not present in this RNA segment. These results indicate that FMDV-derived bicistronic constructs are extremely well suited for use in eukaryotic expression vectors.

Conserved structural motifs located in distal loops of aphthovirus internal ribosome entry site domain 3 are required for internal initiation of translation.

A comparison of picornavirus internal ribosome entry site (IRES) secondary structures revealed the existence of conserved motifs located on loops. We have carried out a mutational analysis to test their requirement for IRES-driven translation. The GUAA sequence, located in the aphthovirus 3A loop, did not tolerate substitutions that disrupt the GNRA motif. Interestingly, this motif was found at similar positions in all picornavirus IRESs, suggesting that it may form part of a tertiary-structure element. The RAAA tetranucleotide located in the 3B loop was conserved only in cardiovirus and aphthovirus. A mutational analysis of the RAAA motif revealed that activities of 3B loop mutants correlated with both the presence of a sequence close to CAAA at the new 3B loop and the absence of reorganization of the 3B and 3C stem-loops. In support of this conclusion, insertion of a large number of nucleotides close to the 3B loop, which was predicted to reorganize the 3B-3C stem-loop structure, led to defective IRES elements. We conclude that the aphthovirus IRES loops located at the most distal part of domain 3, which carries GNRA and RAAA motifs, are essential for IRES function.

Identification of an essential region for internal initiation of translation in the aphthovirus internal ribosome entry site and implications for viral evolution.

Translation of aphthovirus RNA is initiated at an internal ribosome entry site (IRES) element, preceding the first functional AUG initiation codon. The effect of mutations at the base of domain 3 of the aphthovirus IRES on translation activity has been analyzed by site-directed mutagenesis and expression of bicistronic RNAs in transfected cells. The results have shown that the enhanced IRES activity associated with a single pyrimidine transition fixed in a persistent aphthovirus variant (E. Martínez-Salas, J. C. Sáiz, M. Dávila, G. J. Belsham, and E. Domingo, J. Virol. 67:3748-3755, 1993) is base specific. Mutations predicted to destabilize the base of domain 3 were detrimental to IRES function, but subsequent restoration of the RNA structure gave rise to fully competent IRES. In contrast, single or multiple mutations that did not affect predicted helical structures modified the relative efficiency of translation by at most 10-fold, suggesting that primary sequence also plays a role in IRES activity. A correlation between the energy of stabilization of the IRES structure and the efficiency of translation has been noted. None of the 15 mutations studied reached a level of initiation of translation comparable to that of the IRES from the persistent variant. The results indicate a critical participation of the base of domain 3 in the activity of the aphthovirus IRES, with a strong effect of secondary or higher-order structures and minor effects of primary structure.

Effect of expression of the aphthovirus protease 3C on viral infection and gene expression.

Cells transformed with specific regions of the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) genome have been constructed and analyzed with respect to viability and susceptibility to FMDV infection. Constitutive expression of an active protease 3C under the control of the tk promoter has been documented by the ability of transformed cells to catalyze the processing of a P1 capsid precursor. High-level, transient expression but not low-level, constitutive expression, of 3C caused a 10-fold reduction in the yield of FMDV and was detrimental to the expression of the cotransfected reporter luciferase gene. No such effect was observed in assays involving cells transfected with a deleted, inactive form of 3C. The negative effect of 3C was not observed when the same reporter gene was integrated and expressed in a constitutive fashion nor when its translation was directed by the internal ribosome entry site element of FMDV in transient expression assays. The results show that cells with a low level of expression of the aphthoviral 3C can be stably maintained and can provide a useful tool to study polyprotein processing.

Bent DNA in the large intergenic region of wheat dwarf geminivirus.

Wheat dwarf virus (WDV) is a member of the geminivirus group, unique plant DNA viruses which replicate exclusively via dsDNA replication intermediates. The large intergenic region (LIR), a nontranscribed regulatory region, contains an inverted repeat with the potential to form a stem-loop structure in which the initiation site for WDV (+)strand (virion-sense) DNA replication has been mapped. In this work, we have studied by two-dimensional electrophoresis and by electron microscopy the DNA structure of the WDV LIR and we have identified a DNA sequence which confers a static DNA curvature. This is the first report of the occurrence of DNA bending in the regulatory region of a geminivirus genome. The bending locus, defined by an 80-bp cluster of A(T) tracts, is located downstream from the potential stem-loop. The A(T) tract proximal to the stem-loop structure is separated by 14 bp from the inverted repeat, and deletion of distal A(T) tracts abolished the curvature of the new WDV deltaLIR. The bending center maps approximately 80 bp downstream from the putative initiation site for (+)strand DNA replication and approximately 70 bp upstream from the TATA box for virion-sense transcription. The possible implications of the DNA bending locus as a regulatory element of WDV DNA replication and/or virion-sense transcription are discussed.

Molecular evolution of aphthoviruses.

Aphthoviruses are an important group of animal pathogens. A combination of genetic and structural studies has revealed one of the main principles governing their evolution: severe limitations to variation imposed by functional and structural constraints, in conjunction with high mutation and recombination rates operating during genome replication. Evolution occurs by positive selection and random drift acting on complex quasispecies distributions. The mutant composition of a quasi-species (or mutant spectrum) is largely dictated by tolerance to nucleotide and amino acid substitutions in viral RNAs and proteins, which must remain functionally competent. We review recent evidence to support this proposal, and we suggest that similar concepts may apply to other RNA viruses as well.

Specific inhibition of aphthovirus infection by RNAs transcribed from both the 5' and the 3' noncoding regions.

RNA molecules containing the 3' terminal region of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) RNA in both antisense and sense orientations were able to inhibit viral FMDV translation and infective particle formation in BHK-21 cells following comicroinjection or cotransfection with infectious viral RNA. Antisense, but not sense, transcripts from the 5' noncoding region including the proximal element of the internal ribosome entry site and the two functional initiation AUGs were also inhibitory, both in in vitro translation and in vivo in comicroinjected or cotransfected BHK-21 cells. This effect was not observed with nonrelated RNA transcripts from lambda phage. The inhibitions found were permanent, sequence specific, and dose dependent; an inverse correlation between the length of the transcript and the extent of the antiviral effect was seen. In all cases, the extent of inhibition increased when viral RNAs and transcripts were allowed to reanneal before transfection, concomitant with a decrease in the doses required. The antiviral effect was specific for FMDV, since transcripts failed to inhibit infective particle formation by other picornavirus, such as encephalomyocarditis virus. These results indicate that the ability of RNA transcripts to inhibit viral multiplication depends on their efficient hybridization with target regions on the viral genome. Furthermore, cells transfected with the 5'1as transcript, which is complementary to the 5' noncoding region, showed a significant reduction of plaque-forming ability during the course of a natural infection. RNA 5'1as was able to inhibit FMDV RNA translation in vitro, suggesting that the inhibitions observed are mediated by a blockage of the viral translation initiation. Conversely, hybridization of short sequences of both sense and antisense transcripts from the 3' end induces distortion of predicted highly ordered structural motifs, which could be required for the synthesis of negative-stranded viral RNA, and correlates with inhibition of viral propagation.

A single nucleotide substitution in the internal ribosome entry site of foot-and-mouth disease virus leads to enhanced cap-independent translation in vivo.

Mutants of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) with altered biological properties can be selected during the course of persistent infection of BHK-21 cells with FMDV C-S8c1 (J. C. de la Torre, E. Martínez-Salas, J. Díez, A. Villaverde, F. Gebauer, E. Rocha, M. Dávila, and E. Domingo, J. Virol. 62:2050-2058, 1988). Two nucleotide substitutions, U to C at position -376 and A to G at position -15, (counting as +1 the A of the first functional AUG), were fixed within the internal ribosome entry site (IRES) of R100, the virus rescued after 100 passages of the carrier BHK-21 cells. IRES-directed cap-independent protein synthesis was quantitated by using bicistronic constructs of the form chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene-IRES-luciferase gene. The IRES from R100 was 1.5- to 5-fold more active than that of C-S8c1 in directing cap-independent luciferase synthesis. This enhanced translational activity was observed when the RNAs were transcribed either in the nucleus or in the cytoplasm by a weak or a strong promoter, respectively. C-S8c1 and R100 IRES elements were functional in both FMDV-sensitive and FMDV-resistant cells (including persistently infected R cells), indicating that factors mediating cap-independent protein synthesis are not limited in any of the analyzed cell lines. Constructs in which each of the two mutations in the R100 IRES were analyzed separately indicate that the transition at position -376 is responsible for the enhanced activity of the R100 IRES. By estimating the effect that an increase in the initial translation efficiency may have on subsequent RNA replication steps, we suggest that the modifications in the IRES elements can account for the previously described hypervirulence of FMDV R100 for BHK-21 cells. The results show that a single point mutation in an IRES element of a picornavirus can cause an increase in translation efficiency.

Primer design for specific diagnosis by PCR of highly variable RNA viruses: typing of foot-and-mouth disease virus.

A PCR assay for the specific detection and identification of viral sequences that correlate with established serotypes of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) has been developed. A new analysis based on homology profiles among reported sequences was used for primer design. RNA replicase (3D) gene regions that showed high homology among FMDVs, and low homology to other picornaviruses, were used for PCR amplification. Specific and highly sensitive detection was achieved for RNA of FMDV types C, A, and O, either purified or extracted from vesicular fluids of infected animals, under reaction conditions permissive for the detection of variants present in the virus population. Similarly, serotype-specific primers were designed to amplify the carboxy-terminal end of VP1 gene of FMDV types either C, A, or O. The results of PCR amplification of 15 different FMDV RNAs using type-specific primers are in agreement with the serological typing of the corresponding viruses and show that the primer-selection procedure developed for FMDV constitutes a reliable method of viral diagnosis.