Transplant Unit, Division of General Surgery, Department of Surgery, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Cape Town, South Africa.

Organ and tissue donation depends on non-transplant clinicians to identify and timeously refer potential donors and to counsel families compassionately about the prognosis at end of life. Organ donation referral is often felt to be beyond the capacity of district-level hospital services. In this case series, we report on four referrals from a geographically remote, public sector district-level hospital, and review the identification, referral and consent process of potential donors after brain death, and also donors after circulatory death. For the one successfully consented donor we report on the donor work-up and management, and the outcome of the organ recovery and organ allocation process.

A 10-year analysis of organ donor referrals to a South African tertiary public sector hospital.

BACKGROUND: South Africa (SA) has one of the lowest deceased organ donor rates in the world (1.4 donors per million population), with thousands of patients awaiting solid-organ transplantation. In order to improve access to transplantation we have to clearly define the reasons for the low deceased donation rate, specific to the population we serve. OBJECTIVES: Review of actual donor statistics highlights our successes, yet is not able to contextualise the factors responsible for the unsuccessful conversion of referred organ donors to actual organ donors. In an attempt to identify key factors preventing referred donors from becoming actual donors, we analysed the donor referral patterns at our institution over a 10-year period. METHODS: This was a retrospective descriptive study of consecutive deceased donor referrals at Groote Schuur Hospital, Cape Town, SA (from January 2007 to December 2016), utilising a regional donor referral registry. Qualitative and quantitative data were collected and presented as descriptive statistics and temporal trends. RESULTS: Over the 10-year study period, 861 possible organ donors were referred, with a steady increase in the number of referrals over time. Of the referrals, 514 (59.7%) were eligible for donation of at least one solid organ. Of the 508 families that were approached for consent to donation, 342 declined consent for a variety of reasons, resulting in a consent rate of 32.7%. Ultimately, at least one solid organ was obtained from 159 of the 166 consented donors. Despite the increasing number of possible and eligible donors, a statistically significant decline in consent rate was observed over time (ptrend=0.023). Furthermore, increasing trends in medical (as opposed to trauma) (ptrend<0.001) and extended criteria (as opposed to standard criteria) donor referrals (ptrend<0.001) were observed over the 10-year study period. CONCLUSIONS: Donor referral patterns have changed over time, with a notable increase in medical and extended criteria donors. Despite the increase in possible and eligible donors, the consent rate has declined. Further qualitative and quantitative research studies are required to understand and address this trend.

Factors influencing consent rates of deceased organ donation in Western Cape Province, South Africa.

BACKGROUND: South Africa (SA) has very low and unchanging organ donation rates. A key point in the pathway of organ donation is obtaining informed consent from the family, which is necessary before organ donation can proceed. There is no published SA research on the consent rate and factors that influence this. OBJECTIVES: To describe the number of requests for consent and factors influencing this process in the SA context. METHODS: A prospective descriptive study was performed of all requests to families for organ donation in Western Cape Province, SA, by Groote Schuur Hospital (state sector), Red Cross War Memorial Children's Hospital (state sector) and Netcare (private sector) transplant co-ordinators from 1 May 2017 to 1 May 2018 to describe factors influencing consent rates. RESULTS: The 6 co-ordinators (3 state sector and 3 private sector) recorded data of 83 consecutive families approached in 16 hospitals over the 1-year period. Consent to organ donation was granted for 23 family requests (n=18 (state sector); n=5 (private sector)). The number of families approached was greater in the state sector (n=74) than in the private sector (n=9). The overall consent rate was 27.7% (24.3% (state sector); 55.5% (private sector)). The majority of referrals came from trauma and emergency units (n=55; 66.3%) and very few from intensive care units (n=25; 30.1%). Immediate fluid resuscitation was required in 56 (67.5%) potential donors. The majority of families (n=74; 89.2%) were receptive to the organ donation request, independent of their ultimate decision regarding donation. The main reason given for refusing to consent was that it was against their religion (n=21) or culture (n=18). CONCLUSIONS: This study showed that the number of families approached for consent to organ donation were low in the Western Cape (lower in the private sector), with a low consent rate (lower in the state sector). Donor management by clinical teams needs to be ongoing and active during the consent process. Consent discussions (and public awareness initiatives) need to be sensitive to and deal with religious and cultural reservations about organ donation.

Deceased donor organ transplantation: A single center experience from Cape Town, South Africa.

Deceased donor kidney transplantation have been in place for more than ten years at Groote Schuur Hospital in Cape Town, South Africa. This retrospective review between 1995 and 2005 reports the experience with 824 deceased donor referrals. Race breakdown showed that 321 donors were black, 154 white, 318 mixed race and 30 unrecorded. Consent remains a major problem in South Africa and we were unable to obtain consent in 43% of our patients. Only 20% of donors had natural causes of death - the majority died because of trauma/unnatural circumstances. For this reason the average age of our donors are 26 years. A and O blood group donors were the most prevalent with A blood group patients making up 38% and O blood group 39% of the donor population.

Medical students' knowledge about organ transplantation: a South African perspective.

BACKGROUND: Educating physicians about transplantation during undergraduate training can improve organ procurement rates. The aim of this study was to evaluate and analyze the knowledge of medical students regarding transplantation. METHODS: A previously validated self-administered anonymous questionnaire was distributed to all medical students. RESULTS: Of the 346 participants, 217 (63%) were preclinical students. Their mean age was 21 years (range, 18-33) and 62% were women. Twenty-nine (8%) students were registered as organ donors. One third of all study participants received formal transplantation teaching; a greater proportion of clinical students received teaching compared with the preclinical group (52% vs 22%, P < .05). Knowledge was frequently reported for kidney (88%), liver (81%), bone marrow (78%), and heart (76%) transplantation. Small Intestine (13%), pancreas (9%), and pancreatic islets (4%) were the least recognized organs/tissues. Ninety-six percent and 62% of respondents were aware of kidney and liver living-donor transplants, respectively; the 27% of students with an interest in a surgical career had better knowledge of living-donor transplantation (P < .05). Only 22 (6%) students knew which solid organ transplants were performed in South Africa. CONCLUSION: Medical students have limited knowledge about organ transplantation; there is a need for educational intervention early in the medical curriculum.

Overview of a paediatric renal transplant programme.

INTRODUCTION: Renal transplantation is the therapy of choice for children with end-stage renal failure. There are many challenges associated with a paediatric programme in a developing country where organs are limited. METHODS: A retrospective review was undertaken of 149 paediatric renal transplants performed between 1968 and 2006 with specific emphasis on transplants performed in the last 10 years. Survival of patients and grafts was analysed and specific problems related to drugs and infections were reviewed. RESULTS: On review of the total programme, 60% of the transplants have been performed in the last 10 years, with satisfactory overall patient and graft survival for the first 8 years post transplant. At this point, transfer to adult units with non-compliance becomes a significant problem. Rejection is less of a problem than previously but infection is now a bigger issue--specifically tuberculosis (TB), cytomegalovirus (CMV) and Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) infections with related complications. A wide variety of drugs are available for tailoring immunosuppression to minimise side-effects. CONCLUSION: It is possible to have a successful paediatric transplant programme in a developing country. However, to improve long-term outcomes certain issues need to be addressed, including reduction of nephrotoxic drugs and cardiovascular risk factors and providing successful adolescent to adult unit transition.

Liver transplantation at Red Cross War Memorial Children's Hospital.

UNLABELLED: The liver transplant programme for infants and children at Red Cross War Memorial Children's Hospital is the only established paediatric service in sub-Saharan Africa. Referrals for liver transplant assessment come from most provinces within South Africa as well as neighbouring countries. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Since 1987, 81 children (range 6 months-14 years) have had 84 liver transplants with biliary atresia being the most frequent diagnosis. The indications for transplantation include biliary atresia (48), metabolic (7), fulminant hepatic failure (10), redo transplants (3) and other (16). Four combined liver/kidney transplants have been performed. Fifty-three were reduced-size transplants with donor/recipient weight ratios ranging from 2:1 to 11:1 and 32 children weighed less than 10 kg. RESULTS: Sixty patients (74%) survived 3 months-14 years post-transplant. Overall cumulative 1- and 5-year patient survival figures are 79% and 70% respectively. However, with the introduction of prophylactic intravenous ganciclovir and the exclusion of hepatitis B virus (HBV) IgG core Ab-positive donors, the 1-year patient survival is 90% and the projected 5-year paediatric survival is > 80%. Early (< 1 month) post-liver-transplant mortality was low. Causes include primary malfunction (1), inferior vena cava thrombosis (1), bleeding oesophageal ulcer (1), sepsis (1) and cerebral oedema (1). Late morbidity and mortality was mainly due to infections: de novo hepatitis B (5 patients, 2 deaths), Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)- related post-transplantation lymphoproliferative disease (12 patients, 7 deaths) and cytomegalovirus (CMV) disease (10 patients, 5 deaths). Tuberculosis (TB) treatment in 3 patients was complicated by chronic rejection (1) and TB-drug-induced subfulminant liver failure (1). CONCLUSION: Despite limited resources, a successful paediatric programme has been established with good patient and graft survival figures and excellent quality of life. Shortage of donors because of infection with HBV and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) leads to significant waiting-list mortality and infrequent transplantation.

Prospective audit of deaths at a teaching hospital.

We undertook a prospective audit of all the deaths in the trauma unit, the emergency unit, and the intensive care units to estimate the number of potential organ donors in the hospital and identify the reasons for nonreferral of potential donors. The transplant coordinators undertook daily visits to the above units and documented all of the deaths occurring in the previous 24 hours. The patient records were reviewed, and the medical and nursing staff interviewed to determine the precise circumstances surrounding the death. Seven of the 14 deaths in the neurosurgical intensive care unit were related to the head injury, and five were certified brain dead and referred as an organ donor. Fifty-eight of 83 deaths in the trauma unit were head injury related; however, only eight were eventually certified brain dead and referred. In the emergency unit, only one of 76 patients who died was certified brain dead and referred as an organ donor. Although many of the deaths in the above units are related to a head injury or cerebral event, very few are actually certified brain dead. All potential donors who were certified brain dead were referred to the transplant team.

Outcome of assessment of potential donors for live donor kidney transplants.

The critical shortage of cadaver donor organs for renal transplantation has resulted in the increased use of living donors. We reviewed the outcomes of the assessments of potential living kidney donors. One hundred seventeen potential donors evaluated over a 39-month period were included in the study. The work-up of the potential donors consisted of a step-wise progression of clinical, blood, and radiological tests. Of the 117 potential donors, only 20 were ultimately used. Five percent of the donors were found to be unsuitable because of medical problems at the initial visit. A further 25% were blood group incompatible, 13% were excluded following the investigations, 9% had psychosocial problems, and in 4% there were recipient problems. Twenty-two percent of suitable donors were not used either because another live donor was used or because a cadaver donor kidney was available. In conclusion, although the assessment of potential donors requires much time and effort, only a small minority of donors assessed are ultimately used.