Achieving international targets for tuberculosis treatment success among HIV-positive patients in New York City.

OBJECTIVE: To review outcomes of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) positive tuberculosis (TB) patients in New York City (NYC) to determine if the World Health Organization treatment success target of 85% was met in a setting with ready access to treatment for HIV and TB. DESIGN: Retrospective review of new TB patients diagnosed from 1995 to 2004, excluding patients with rifampin (RMP) resistance. RESULTS: Of 9198 eligible TB patients, 83% had achieved treatment success, 8% died during treatment, 4% failed, 3% defaulted and 2% were transferred from NYC. Among 6374 HIV-negative individuals, treatment success was consistently over 85%; 5% died during treatment. Among 2824 HIV-positive individuals, treatment success was 72% overall and 66% in sputum acid-fast bacilli smear-positive patients. Mortality among the HIV-positive decreased from 26% in 1995 to 14% in 2004. HIV-positive patients achieved higher treatment success if 1) they received treatment by directly observed therapy (DOT) (82% vs. 74%, OR(adj) = 1.80, 95%CI 1.44-2.26), or 2) were administered rifabutin (RFB) in the regimen, a proxy for receiving antiretroviral therapy (ART) (84% vs. 78%, OR(adj) = 1.49, 95%CI 1.20-1.85). Treatment success of 85% was achieved in HIV-positive patients who received RFB and DOT. CONCLUSION: High mortality precluded achieving 85% treatment success among HIV-positive TB patients. DOT and ART remain essential for improving success among co-infected patients everywhere.

Congenital tuberculosis and management of exposure in three neonatal intensive care units.

Congenital tuberculosis (TB) is uncommon, and diagnosis may be delayed. We report a case of congenital TB and the management of exposure in three different neonatal intensive care units. This case demonstrates the need for a high index of suspicion, active communication among maternal and neonatal medical providers, and timely provider reporting of maternal disease, and emphasizes the relatively greater risk of transmission to health care workers versus infants in this setting.

Evaluation of case management in tuberculosis control: a three-year effort to improve case management practices in New York City.

OBJECTIVE: To describe a 3-year effort to identify factors associated with lapses in case management (CM) and to improve CM practices by New York City Bureau of Tuberculosis Control (BTBC) staff. DESIGN: Evaluation of the CM of TB cases reported in the second quarter of 2003 and comparison of results with the findings of a similar review conducted in 2002. Implementation of strategies to target areas in need of improvement and identification of interventions that contribute to improved work practices. RESULTS: From 2002 to 2003, significant improvements were found in some CM indicators, such as patient education about the importance of directly observed therapy (32% vs. 74%), importance of monthly follow-up (24% vs. 51%) and potential for development of drug resistance (36% vs. 61%). Informing patients about the availability of services provided by the BTBC also improved (16% vs. 59%); however, timeliness and documentation of CM activities and implementation of supervisory activities remained poor. Supervisors largely attributed this lack of improvement to poor documentation of work actually performed. CONCLUSIONS: These evaluations identified lapses in CM practices and program supervision. The findings were used to adjust protocols, target interventions, and focus education and training to improve work practices.

Molecular epidemiology of tuberculosis after declining incidence, New York City, 2001-2003.

Tuberculosis incidence in New York City (NYC) declined between 1992 and 2000 from 51.1 to 16.6 cases per 100,000 population. In January 2001, universal real-time genotyping of TB cases was implemented in NYC. Isolates from culture-confirmed tuberculosis cases from 2001 to 2003 were genotyped using IS6110 and spoligotype to describe the extent and factors associated with genotype clustering after declining TB incidence. Of 2408 (91.8%) genotyped case isolates, 873 (36.2%) had a pattern indistinguishable from that of another study period case, forming 212 clusters; 248 (28.4%) of the clustered cases had strains believed to have been widely transmitted during the epidemic years in the early 1990s in NYC. An estimated 27.4% (873 minus 212) of the 2408 cases were due to recent infection that progressed to active disease during the study period. Younger age, birth in the United States, homelessness, substance abuse and presence of TB symptoms were independently associated with greater odds of clustering.

Ensuring accountability: the contribution of the cohort review method to tuberculosis control in New York City.

SETTING: In 1993, the New York City (NYC) Bureau of Tuberculosis Control developed the cohort review process as a quality assurance method to track and improve patient outcomes. METHODS: The Bureau Director reviews every tuberculosis (TB) case quarterly in a multi-disciplinary staff meeting. In 2004 we also began collecting details on issues identified at cohort review to quantify how this process directly impacts TB control efforts. RESULTS: From 1992 to 2004, NYC TB cases decreased by 72.7% and treatment success rates significantly increased by 26.7%. Implementing the cohort review was key to improving case management, thus leading to these results. For the 1039 patients in 2004, 596 issues were identified among 424 patients; 55.0% were incorrect, unclear or unknown patient information, 13.8% were treatment issues, 12.4% were case management issues and 10.6% were incomplete contact investigations. Most (76.5%) issues were addressed within 30 days of the cohort reviews. CONCLUSION: A systematic review of every TB case improves the quality of patient information, enhances patient treatment and ensures accountability at all levels of the TB control program.

Public-private collaboration for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis control in New York City.

SETTING: An urban tuberculosis control program where an enhanced multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) management plan coordinated care with multiple providers. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate treatment outcomes of primary MDR-TB patients treated by multiple providers. DESIGN: Retrospective cohort study of tuberculosis patients from 1992-1997 provided that 1) their Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates were resistant to at least isoniazid and rifampin, and 2) they had had < or = 30 days of anti-tuberculosis treatment prior to the collection of the first MDR-TB specimen. RESULTS: More than 100 facilities and providers reported 856 MDR-TB patients. Treatment completion reached 70% among non-HIV-infected and 30% among HIV-infected persons; 57.2% of the cohort died prior to treatment completion, 26.5% completed treatment, 16.0% transferred out, refused treatment or were lost to follow-up and 0.2% are still in care. Diagnosis in the later years of the study or cavitation on chest radiograph was independently associated with increased completion among HIV-infected patients. Eight of the 227 (3.5%) patients who completed treatment relapsed (relapse rate 1.01/100 person-years), two with drug-susceptible strains. CONCLUSION: A comprehensive MDR-TB control program improved the outcomes of both HIV-infected and non-infected individuals, despite management by multiple providers. Relapse was infrequent among patients who completed the recommended regimens.

Risk factors for drug-resistant tuberculosis among non-US-born persons in New York City.

SETTING: New York City (NYC). OBJECTIVES: To examine the extent to which prior tuberculosis (TB) treatment, length of residence in the United States and other factors are associated with the occurrence of drug resistance among non-US-born persons in NYC. DESIGN: Cases were non-US-born persons diagnosed with TB in NYC from 1998-1999 and from 2001-2002, with an initial Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolate resistant to any first-line anti-tuberculosis drug. Controls were randomly selected from non-US-born persons whose isolates were susceptible to all first-line anti-tuberculosis drugs. RESULTS: Overall, cases with multidrug-resistant (MDR) TB were more likely to have had prior TB treatment; other drug resistance was not associated with prior TB treatment. In a multivariate model, the relationship between MDR-TB and prior treatment remained significant for non-US-born persons regardless of length of time in the U.S. CONCLUSIONS: The findings underscore the utility of monitoring trends in drug resistance among the non-US-born by time in the US and prior treatment to determine where or when drug resistance may be occurring.

Finding contacts of homeless tuberculosis patients in New York City.

OBJECTIVE: To determine factors associated with no contacts identified for homeless patients in New York City. DESIGN: Culture-confirmed pulmonary tuberculosis cases in persons >18 years old diagnosed in 1997-1999 were included. Demographic and clinical characteristics of tuberculosis patients associated with the number of contacts identified according to homeless status were analyzed using unconditional logistic regression. RESULTS: Homeless patients (n = 152) had a significantly lower median number of contacts than non-homeless patients (n = 2836) (1 vs. 4, P < 0.001). Among homeless patients, having AFB smear-positive sputum with cavitary lesions reduced the likelihood of having no contacts identified. Homeless patients who lived on the street at the time of diagnosis were more likely to have no contacts identified compared to those with contacts identified (61.4% vs. 56.1%); however, the difference was not statistically significant (P = 0.506). Unlike non-homeless patients, being hospitalized at the time of tuberculosis diagnosis was not associated with having contacts identified in homeless patients. CONCLUSIONS: Homelessness independently predicted the likelihood of having no contacts identified. Strategies such as interviews that focus on location rather than persons may be more effective for identifying contacts. Furthermore, being homeless at the time of diagnosis should be used as an indicator for prioritizing prompt contact evaluation.

Contact investigations in congregate settings, New York City.

SETTING: Large urban tuberculosis control program. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate results of procedures implemented for systematic investigation of tuberculosis exposures in congregate settings. DESIGN: Between October 1995 and December 2000, a unit consisting of epidemiologists, health educators and tuberculin screening staff investigated exposures in sites with >15 persons. Transmission at the site was defined as likely, possible, unlikely or unknown. RESULTS: Among 100 investigations, 12 were tuberculosis case clusters, five were source case investigations, and 83 were exposures to single infectious cases. Transmission was likely in 24 (21%), possible in eight (8%), unlikely in 62 (62%), and could not be assessed in four (4%). Among the 83 exposures to single infectious cases, 2740 contacts were tested; 502 (18%) were infected. Among 1202 close contacts, 996 (82%) were tested, 197 (20%) were infected and started treatment of latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) and 102/197 (52%) completed treatment. Sites with likely transmission had index patients with longer duration of cough (13 vs. 6 weeks, P = 0.01) and cavitary lesions (84% vs. 44%, P = 0.01) compared to sites with unlikely transmission. CONCLUSION: A systematic approach for conducting contact investigations in congregate settings is useful for assessing transmission. As such investigations are resource intensive and transmission is not common, performing tuberculin skin testing after most persons would have converted should be considered in low-risk groups. Additional efforts are needed to increase completion of treatment for LTBI in contacts identified in these settings.

Differential decline in tuberculosis incidence among US- and non-US-born persons in New York City.

SETTING: A large urban tuberculosis control program. OBJECTIVES: To examine changes in tuberculosis incidence and characteristics of cases in New York City (NYC), and assess the epidemiology of tuberculosis among non-US-born persons. DESIGN: Tuberculosis surveillance data (1995-1999) for NYC were analyzed. RESULTS: Tuberculosis incidence decreased by 56.6% in US-born and 19.6% in non-US-born persons (age-adjusted) over the study period. The decline in tuberculosis incidence among US-born persons was more substantial in the first half of the study period (23-24%) than in the second half (13-15%). The greatest decline in incidence was among US-born Hispanic or Black males aged 25-64. However, although there was an overall decline in incidence among non-US-born persons, there was no significant change in any sex or racial/ethnic subgroup. The percent of multidrug-resistant (MDR) cases among non-US-born patients remained stable, but recent arrivals accounted for 79% of non-US-born MDR-TB patients in 1999, a significant increase from 16% in 1997. CONCLUSIONS: Continuing current tuberculosis control efforts and treatment of immigrants with latent tuberculosis infection are of highest priority for reducing incident cases in NYC. Global collaboration towards earlier detection and treatment of active tuberculosis cases in high incidence countries is also essential.

Yield of continued monthly sputum evaluation among tuberculosis patients after culture conversion.

SETTING: New York City. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the yield of continued monthly sputum monitoring after culture conversion. DESIGN: A retrospective review of tuberculosis patients verified between 1 January 1995 and 31 December 1996 who had: 1) pulmonary tuberculosis with organisms susceptible to isoniazid and rifampin; 2) culture conversion; and 3) completed therapy. We assessed time to smear and culture conversion and number of persons who developed a positive culture after culture conversion (culture reversion). RESULTS: Of 1440 patients, 379 were cared for by tuberculosis control program providers and 1061 were cared for by other providers; 813 (56%) were initially smear-positive. After the fifth month, 44 (5.3%) were smear-positive; four of these were culture-positive. Eighteen (1.3%) had culture reversions; eight were smear-positive. Excluding one specimen per patient collected at treatment completion, 7967 sputum samples were collected after culture conversion. The minimum estimated cost per culture reversion detected was $26,557. CONCLUSION: Continued monthly monitoring of sputum after culture conversion identified a very small number of patients who had culture reversion. However, patients who cannot tolerate or adhere to a standard regimen may need continued monitoring to assess response to treatment. For all patients a specimen should be collected at the end of treatment to document cure.

Molecular identification of streptomycin monoresistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis related to multidrug-resistant W strain.

A distinct branch of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis W phylogenetic lineage (W14 group) has been identified and characterized by various genotyping techniques. The W14 group comprises three strain variants: W14, W23, and W26, which accounted for 26 clinical isolates from the New York City metropolitan area. The W14 group shares a unique IS6110 hybridizing banding motif as well as distinct polymorphic GC-rich repetitive sequence and variable number tandem repeat patterns. All W14 group members have high levels of streptomycin resistance. When the streptomycin resistance rpsL target gene was sequenced, all members of this strain family had an identical mutation in codon 43. Patients infected with the W14 group were primarily of non- Hispanic black origin (77%); all were US-born. Including HIV positivity, 84% of the patients had at least one known risk factor for tuberculosis.

Relapse in persons treated for drug-susceptible tuberculosis in a population with high coinfection with human immunodeficiency virus in New York City.

The optimal duration of tuberculosis treatment for persons infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) has been debated. A cohort of 4571 culture-positive drug-susceptible patients who received > or =24 weeks of standard 4-drug tuberculosis treatment were assessed to determine the incidence of tuberculosis relapse. Tuberculosis "recurrence" was defined as having a positive culture < 30 days after the last treatment date and "relapse" as having a positive culture > or =30 days after the last treatment. Patients infected with HIV were more likely than those who were uninfected to have recurrence or relapse (2.0 vs. 0.4 per 100 person-years, P< .001). Patients infected with HIV who received < or =36 weeks of treatment were more likely than those who received > 36 weeks to have a recurrence (7.9% vs. 1.4%, P< .001). Clinicians should be aware of the possibility of recurrence of tuberculosis 6-9 months after the start of treatment. Sputum evaluation to ensure cure or assessment 3 months after completion of treatment should be performed among persons infected with HIV who receive the shorter regimen.

Rising number of tuberculosis cases among Tibetans in New York City.

Tuberculosis among Tibetans increased in New York City between 1995 and 1999. We examined characteristics of 68 Tibetan patients compared to 702 non-Tibetan patients from Nepal, India, or China, diagnosed between January 1995 and December 1999. The number of Tibetan patients increased each year after 1995 whereas non-Tibetans remained stable during the same period. Tibetans were younger (27 vs. 44 years), more likely to be infectious (63% vs. 46%), have multidrug resistance (7% vs. 2%) and shorter time to diagnosis after arrival (9 vs. 79 months, p < 0.01). For Tibetan patients, 68% of identified contacts were evaluated. The prevalence of tuberculosis infection was 65%. In contrast, among non-Tibetan patients 88.8% of contacts were evaluated and 45.2% were infected. Outreach efforts with community leaders and educational presentations at community events have been implemented in an effort to ensure continuity of care and completion of treatment.

A prospective study of tuberculosis and HIV disease progression.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether active tuberculosis alters the rate of progression of HIV infection in dually infected patients. METHODS: HIV-seropositive patients at two Bronx, New York hospitals with tuberculosis confirmed by culture from July 1992 to February 1995, who survived the initial hospitalization for tuberculosis, were matched on gender, age, CD4+ percentage, and calendar time with HIV-seropositive patients without tuberculosis participating in a study of the natural history of HIV infection. Patients received follow-up observation prospectively until May 23, 1995 to determine survival rates and development of AIDS-defining opportunistic infections (OIs). RESULTS: 70 patients had tuberculosis; 120 did not. Mean CD4+ percentages were 12.4% and 12.5%, respectively. At study entry, 27% of those with tuberculosis had prior AIDS-defining OIs other than tuberculosis, compared with 10% of those without tuberculosis (p = .004). In multivariate survival analysis, controlling for CD4+ level, tuberculosis was not an independent predictor of increased other causes of AIDS-related mortality. However, in a logistic regression model, independent predictors of subsequent OIs included tuberculosis (hazard ratio, 4.1; 95% confidence intervals [CI], 1.9, 8.7), CD4+ count <100/mm3 (hazard ratio, 2.4; 95% CI, 1.1, 5.0) and prior OIs (hazard ration, 3.3; 95% CI, 1.3, 8.3). CONCLUSIONS: Tuberculosis was not an independent predictor of increased non-tuberculosis-related mortality in HIV-seropositive patients but was associated with increased risk of development of OIs.

A prospective study of tuberculosis and human immunodeficiency virus infection: clinical manifestations and factors associated with survival.

We prospectively studied the effect of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection on the presentation and outcome of tuberculosis. A total of 216 patients with tuberculosis were identified; 162 (75%) of these patients were tested for antibodies to HIV; 92 (57%) were seropositive. The patients who were seropositive for HIV were more likely to be male and Hispanic and to have been homeless or incarcerated. Eighty-one percent of these patients had CD4 lymphocyte counts of < or =200/mm3. The seropositive patients had extrapulmonary tuberculosis more often than did the seronegative patients (odds ratio [OR], 2.3; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.2-4.8). Smears for acid-fast bacilli were positive more often for non-HIV-infected patients with pulmonary tuberculosis (74.5%) than for HIV-infected patients (54.3%) [OR, 2.46; 95% CI, 1.01-6.02]-even those with focal or cavitary disease. A delay in initiating therapy was associated with in-hospital mortality: the median time from admission to the start of treatment was 4 days for patients who survived and 15 days for those who died (P = .02). The median survival was 22.7 months for HIV-infected patients who did not die during the initial hospitalization. Factors independently associated with reduced rates of survival included the severity of immunodeficiency, nonuse of directly observed therapy, infection due to drug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and a history of injection drug use.

Rifampin-monoresistant tuberculosis in New York City, 1993-1994.

All New York City patients whose cultures yielded Mycobacterium tuberculosis with isolated resistance to rifampin in 1993 and 1994 were included in this study. Of the 96 patients, 48 (50%) had primary resistance, 32 (33%) had acquired resistance, and 16 (17%) had unclassified resistance; 66% had histories of illicit drug use, and 79% were infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). The median time to emergence of resistance was 40 weeks among the 32 patients with acquired resistance. Each of the HIV-infected patients with acquired resistance (cases, n = 29) was matched to two HIV-infected patients who had disease due to fully susceptible M. tuberculosis (controls, n = 58). In multivariate analysis, factors associated with the emergence of rifampin resistance were as follows: a sputum smear positive for acid-fast bacilli, advanced immunosuppression, and nonadherence to therapy.