The consistency of experts' evaluation of obstetric claims for compensation.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to investigate the consistency of experts' evaluation of different types of obstetric claims for compensation. DESIGN: Inter-rater reliability study of obstetric claims for compensation. SETTING: Medical experts' evaluation in The Norwegian System of Compensation to Patients, a no-blame system. SAMPLE: The 15 most frequently used medical experts were asked to evaluate 12 obstetric claims applied for compensation. METHODS: Inter-rater agreement was assessed by absolute agreement, Fleiss' kappa statistic and Gwet's AC1. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Consistency in the evaluation of negligence (carelessness without intention to harm) and causality (relation between care and injury) between negligence and patient injury. RESULTS: The experts demonstrated moderate consistency in their evaluation of negligence (Fleiss' kappa = 0.53/AC1 = 0.54) and causality (Fleiss' kappa = 0.41/AC1 = 0.54). There was a higher level of agreement in clinical scenarios with well-documented diagnostic criteria and guidelines, including shoulder dystocia and asphyxia with low Apgar score and metabolic acidosis. CONCLUSION: We found a moderate level of agreement in experts' evaluation of negligence and causality between the injury and provided health care, the two most important questions to be answered in obstetric claims for compensation.

Risk factors for obstetric anal sphincter injury after a successful multicentre interventional programme.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate and compare the risk profile of sustaining obstetric anal sphincter injuries (OASIS) and associated risks in five risk groups (low to high), after the OASIS rate was reduced from 4.6% to 2.0% following an interventional programme. The main focus of the intervention was on manual assistance during the final part of second stage of labour. DESIGN: A multicentre interventional cohort study with before and after comparison. SETTING: Four Norwegian obstetric departments. SAMPLE: A total of 40,154 vaginal deliveries in 2003-09. METHODS: Pre-intervention and postintervention analyses. The associations of OASIS with possible risk factors were estimated using odds ratios obtained by logistic regression. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Risk factors of OASIS. RESULTS: The risk of sustaining OASIS decreased by 59% (odds ratio [OR] 0.41; 95% confidence interval [95% CI] 0.36-0.46) after the intervention. Associations with obstetric risks for OASIS were largely unchanged after the intervention, including first vaginal delivery (OR 3.84; 95% CI 2.90-5.07), birthweight ≥ 4500 g (OR 4.42; 95% CI 2.68-7.27), forceps delivery (OR 3.54; 95% CI 1.99-6.29) and mediolateral episiotomy (OR 0.89; 95% CI 0.70-1.12). However, the highest reduction of OASIS, (65%), was observed in group 0 (low-risk) (OR 0.35; 95% CI 0.24-0.51), and a 57% (OR 0.43; 95% CI 0.35-0.52), 61% (OR 0.39; 95% CI 0.31-0.48), and 58% (OR 0.42; 95% CI 0.30-0.60) reduction in groups with one, two and three risk factors, respectively. No change was observed in the group with four risk factors. CONCLUSION: After the intervention the most significant decrease of OASIS was observed in low-risk births, although the main risk factors for OASIS remained unchanged.

Different labour outcomes in primiparous women that have been subjected to childhood sexual abuse or rape in adulthood: a case-control study in a clinical cohort.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the duration and outcome of the first labour in women who have been subjected to childhood sexual abuse (CSA) and women who have been raped in adulthood (RA). DESIGN: Case-control study in a clinical cohort. SETTING: University Hospital of North Norway. SAMPLE: In all, 373 primiparas: 185 subjected to CSA, 47 to RA and 141 controls without a history of abuse. METHODS: Data on birth outcomes were retrieved from the patient files. Information on sexual abuse was reported in consultation with specialised midwives in the mental health team. Birth outcomes were analysed by multinominal regression analysis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Vaginal births, delivery by caesarean section, operative vaginal delivery and duration of labour. RESULTS: As compared with controls, the RA group showed a significantly higher risk for caesarean section (adjusted OR 9.9, 95% CI 3.4-29.4) and operative vaginal delivery (adjusted OR 12.2, 95% CI 4.4-33.7). There were no significant differences between the CSA and the control group. The RA group displayed significantly longer duration of labour in all phases as compared with the control and CSA groups. CONCLUSIONS: There were major differences in the duration of labour and birth outcomes in the two abuse groups. Despite a higher proportion of obstetric risk factors at onset of labour in the CSA group, women subjected to CSA had shorter labours and less risk for caesarean section and operative vaginal deliveries than women subjected to RA. The best care for birthing women subjected to sexual abuse needs to be explored in further studies.

Episiotomy characteristics and risks for obstetric anal sphincter injuries: a case-control study.

OBJECTIVES: To investigate the association between the geometrical properties of episiotomy and obstetric anal sphincter injuries (OASIS) because episiotomies angled at 40-60° are associated with fewer OASIS than episiotomies with more acute angles. DESIGN: Case-control study. SETTING: University Hospital of North Norway, Tromsø and Nordland Hospital, Bodø, Norway. SAMPLE: Seventy-four women who had one vaginal birth and episiotomy. Cases (n = 37) have sustained OASIS at birth, while controls (n = 37) had not. The groups were matched for instrumental delivery. METHODS: Two groups of women with history of only one vaginal birth were compared. Episiotomy scar was identified and photographed and relevant measures were taken. Data were analysed using conditional logistic analysis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Mean episiotomy angle, length, depth, incision point. RESULTS: The risk of sustaining OASIS decreased by 70% (odds ratio [OR] 0.30; 95% CI 0.14-0.66) for each 5.5-mm increase in episiotomy depth, decreased by 56% (OR 0.44; 95% CI 0.23-0.86) for each 4.5-mm increase in the distance from the midline to the incision point of the episiotomy, and decreased by 75% (OR 0.25; 95% CI 0.10-0.61) for each 5.5-mm increase in episiotomy length. Lastly, there was no difference in mean angle between groups but there was a "U-shaped" association between angle and OASIS (OR 2.09; 95% CI 1.02-4.28) with an increased risk (OR 9.00; 95% CI 1.1-71.0) of OASIS when the angle was either smaller than 15° or >60°. CONCLUSION: The present study showed that scarred episiotomies with depth > 16 mm, length > 17 mm, incision point > 9 mm lateral of midpoint and angle range 30-60° are significantly associated with less risk of OASIS. Shrinkage of tissue must be considered.

Is the operative delivery rate in low-risk women dependent on the level of birth care? A randomised controlled trial.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate possible differences in operative delivery rate among low-risk women, randomised to an alongside midwifery-led unit or to standard obstetric units within the same hospital. DESIGN: Randomised controlled trial. SETTING: Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Østfold Hospital Trust, Tromsø, Norway. POPULATION: A total of 1111 women assessed to be at low risk at onset of spontaneous labour. METHODS: Randomisation into one of three birth units: the special unit; the normal unit; or the midwife-led unit. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Total operative delivery rate, augmentation, pain relief, postpartum haemorrhage, sphincter injuries and intrapartum transfer, Apgar score <7 at 5 minutes, metabolic acidosis and transfer to neonatal intensive care unit. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in total operative deliveries between the three units: 16.3% in the midwife-led unit; 18.0% in the normal unit; and 18.8% in the special unit. There were no significant differences in postpartum haemorrhage, sphincter injuries or in neonatal outcomes. There were statistically significant differences in augmentation (midwife-led unit versus normal unit RR 0.73, 95% CI 0.59-0.89; midwife-led unit versus special unit RR 0.69, 95% CI 0.56-0.86), in epidural analgesia (midwife-led unit versus normal unit RR 0.68, 95% CI 0.52-0.90; midwife-led unit versus special unit RR 0.64, 95% CI 0.47-0.86) and in acupuncture (midwife-led unit versus normal unit RR 1.45, 95% CI 1.25-1.69; midwife-led unit versus special unit RR 1.45, 95% CI 1.22-1.73). CONCLUSIONS: The level of birth care does not significantly affect the rate of operative deliveries in low-risk women without any expressed preference for level of birth care.

Childhood abuse and caesarean section among primiparous women in the Norwegian Mother and Child Cohort Study.

We examined the association between a history of childhood abuse and caesarean section in the population-based Norwegian Mother and Child Cohort Study (MoBa). Our sample consisted of 26 923 primiparous women with singleton pregnancies at term. Of all women, 18.8% (5060) had experienced any childhood abuse, 14.3% (3856) reported emotional abuse, 5.2% (1413) reported physical abuse and 6.4% (1730) reported sexual abuse. The proportion of caesarean sections before labour was not affected by any childhood abuse. Any childhood abuse was associated with a slightly increased risk of caesarean sections during labour (adjusted odds ratio 1.16; 95% CI 1.03-1.30).

Birth outcomes in primiparous women who were raped as adults: a matched controlled study.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the duration of labour and the birth outcome in a group of primiparous women who had been raped after the age of 16, with a control group from the same birth cohort. DESIGN: Cohort study. SETTING: University Hospital of North Norway. SAMPLE: Fifty women raped as adults and 150 controls. METHODS: Data about birth outcomes in the first pregnancy were collected from the patient files and data concerning the assault were obtained in a subsequent pregnancy through consultations with the women who had been raped. Birth outcomes in the group of women who had been raped were compared with matched controls using a multivariable logistic regression model. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Caesarean section, operative vaginal delivery and duration of labour. RESULTS: During their first delivery, the women who had been raped had an increased risk for caesarean section (adjusted odds ratio 15.7, 95% CI 5.0-49.1) and for assisted vaginal delivery (adjusted odds ratio 13.1, 95% CI 4.9-34.5) when compared with controls. The group of women who had been raped had a longer second stage of labour than the control group (120 versus 55 minutes, P < 0.01). They were more often single mothers, unemployed and smokers, and had a higher body mass index and more previous pregnancy terminations and miscarriages than the control group. CONCLUSIONS: The women who had been raped had a longer second stage of labour, and an increased risk of caesarean section and operative vaginal delivery compared with controls from the general birth cohort. These findings indicate that the consequences for delivery for women who had been raped as adults could be specific and may warrant particular attention. The birth experience of women who had been raped should also be illuminated in future studies.

Neonatal alloimmune thrombocytopenia in Norway: poor detection rate with nonscreening versus a general screening programme.

The implementation of an antenatal screening programme for neonatal alloimmune thrombocytopenia (NAIT) is currently under debate. We evaluated the detection rate for NAIT in a nonscreened population of 661,200 births where NAIT was diagnosed on clinical indication. We did a cross-sectional comparison with a population of 100,448 human platelet antigen 1a (HPA1a)-screened pregnancies from three of the five health regions in Norway. In a nonscreening situation, 7.5 cases of NAIT were detected per year compared with 53 cases when screening was applied. The detection rate of NAIT in Norway was therefore 14% of the expected rate.

Labor admission test: an assessment of the test's value as screening for fetal distress in labor.

BACKGROUND: To determine if the labor admission test (LAT) can predict fetal distress in a population of laboring women, and in subgroups of low- or high-risk women, who delivered within six hours or between six and 24 hours after LAT. METHODS: The data charts of all women who delivered at Hammerfest Hospital in 1996, 1997 and 1998 were retrospectively read. If the woman was admitted to the hospital because of onset of labor, was in the first stage of labor and delivered within 24 hours after admission, she was included. In the study period, 1639 gave birth and 932 were included in the study. A descriptive analysis of the population and assessment of LAT's sensitivity, positive predictive value, specificity and negative predictive value at different cut-off values was done. RESULTS: In the study population 5.8% had fetal distress, and 5.3% had an operative delivery because of fetal distress. LAT's sensitivity in the whole population was 0.15 and positive predictive value was 0.16. Specificity was 0.95 and positive predictive value was 0.95. In the subgroups of low- and high-risk women, who delivered within six hours or between six and 24 hours after LAT, sensitivity varied between 0 and 0.36, and positive predictive value varied between 0 and 0.27. Specificity varied between 0.92 and 0.96, and negative predictive value varied between 0.89 and 0.97. CONCLUSIONS: According to these results, LAT cannot be recommended as a screening test for fetal distress in labor in low-risk women. Sensitivity is too low, and there are too many false-positive tests. It is unclear if LAT has benefits among high-risk women.

[Modified midwife managed unit--an alternative for small birthing departments?]. / Modifisert fødestuedrift--et alternativ for små fødeavdelinger?

BACKGROUND: The Norwegian Board of Health has proposed to divide the delivery units into three categories. For several of today's smaller consultant managed units this could lead to a reclassification into midwife managed units. MATERIAL AND METHODS: During 1997 and 1998 the community hospital in Lofoten has tried out a modified type of midwife managed unit. By a continuous selection process a high risk and a low risk group of gravidas were identified. The high risk group was referred to the central hospital in Bodø, while the low risk group was offered to deliver locally. RESULTS: Previously more than 90% delivered at the community hospital in Lofoten, while approximately 70% still delivered locally during the trial period. There were no deliveries during transport and no serious complications for mother or child caused by the new system. The community hospital had facilities for performing emergency caesarean sections. In 1997 nine caesarean sections out of 211 deliveries and in 1998 four out of 224 were performed. The caesarean section rate for the total population was lower during the trial period than over the previous five years. INTERPRETATION: A modified midwife managed unit could be a good alternative for small consultant managed units if the Norwegian Board of Health's proposal is carried through.

Child births in a modified midwife managed unit: selection and transfer according to intended place of delivery.

BACKGROUND: As small obstetrical departments may not be able to give second-level perinatal care, the delivery unit at Lofoten hospital was for the years 1997-98 reorganized to a modified midwife managed unit. Women at low obstetrical risk were delivered at this unit and women at high risk were referred to the central hospital. We assessed the effectiveness of the risk selection. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The study was a prospective, pragmatic, population-based trial. Desired outcome was defined as a non-operative delivery at 35-42 weeks gestational age giving an infant not needing resuscitation. Intermediate outcomes: Operative deliveries, infants transferred to neonatal intensive care unit and infants diverging from normal. The intended place of delivery was ultimately decided at admittance to the midwife managed unit. RESULTS: Of the 628 women in study 435 (69.3%) gave birth at the midwife managed unit, 152 (24.2%) were selected to be delivered at the central hospital and 41 (6.5%) were transferred to the central hospital after admittance to the midwife managed unit. Desired outcome was recorded in 94% of the deliveries at the midwife managed unit as compared to 50.3% at the central hospital. Women who intended to be delivered at the midwife managed unit, needed fewer operative deliveries and relatively few infants were transferred to the neonatal intensive care unit or diverged from normal. CONCLUSIONS: As nearly 70% of the births occurred at the midwife managed unit and 94% of these deliveries had a desired outcome, this indicates an effective selection process. This model might be an alternative to centralization of births in sparsely population areas.

Antenatal, neonatal and post neonatal deaths evaluated by medical audit. A population-based study in northern Norway - 1976 to 1997.

BACKGROUND: Perinatal committees evaluate deaths by medical audit to improve antenatal and neonatal care. We report data from Troms County from 1976 to 1997. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Antenatal, neonatal and post neonatal deaths (n=472) at > or = 20 weeks of gestation have been evaluated. Data were collected from the Medical Birth Registry of Norway and from medical records. Pregnancy risk factors, mortality rates, causes of deaths, non-optimal care and avoidable deaths were recorded. RESULTS: The death rate (all deaths per thousand total births) declined from 13.8 (1976-80) to 7.7 (1992-97), (p<0.001), due to a reduced death rate in preterms > or = 24 weeks (p<0.001) and in those between 500 and 1995 g (p<0.001). Antenatal deaths decreased (p<0.001) due to reduced intrapartum deaths (p<0.001). Prelabor deaths, unexpected intrauterine pre-hospitalization deaths included, did not change. Postnatal deaths declined (p=0.01) due to reduced early neonatal mortality (p=0.002). Deaths from malformations (p<0.001), fetal and neonatal infections (p=0.03) and placental disorders (p<0.001) declined. Non-optimal care (22.5% of deaths, 2.3%o of total births), avoidable deaths (13.1% of deaths, 1.3% of total births), and maternal neglect (7.5% of cases with non-optimal care, 0.6% of total births) did not change. Death during transport was rare (n=5), and no deaths occurred at maternity homes. Non-cohabitance, smoking and undiagnosed SGA new borns declined, and the level of education increased in the study population. CONCLUSION: The improvement is due to a reduction in intrapartum deaths and early neonatal mortality in preterms. A constant high rate of unexpected intrauterine deaths in non-hospitalized patients is a challenge for antenatal health care providers.

Skeletal muscle ultrastructure in normal pregnancy and preeclampsia.

The aim of this study was to assess by quantitative methods whether the assumed metabolic disturbance underlying preeclampsia would be reflected in muscle cell composition of lipid, mitochondria, or glycogen. We have reported mitochondrial dysfunction in preeclampsia, and since accumulation of lipid in skeletal muscle is a feature in mitochondrial disorders, our hypothesis was that preeclamptic women would have an increased content of triglyceride droplets. Quantitative investigation of the skeletal muscle ultrastructure was performed in 10 women with severe preeclampsia and in 6 normotensive pregnant women. Biopsy specimens from musculus rectus abdominis were taken during cesarean section and prepared for electron microscopy. Random pictures were taken by transmission electron microscopy, and point-counting stereology was performed. Preeclamptic women did not have a higher lipid volume fraction than normotensive pregnant women, and we had to reject our hypothesis. On the contrary, there was a tendency towards a lower triglyceride volume fraction in pre eclampsia. We did not detect differences in relative volumes of mitochondria or glycogen in skeletal muscle between the two groups.

Neonatal alloimmune thrombocytopenia due to anti-HPA 1a antibodies; the level of maternal antibodies predicts the severity of thrombocytopenia in the newborn.

Eleven thousand one hundred pregnant women were genotyped for human platelet antigen HPA 1, and 198 HPA 1bb women were followed in the pregnancy with quantitative assay for anti-HPA la antibodies. Antibodies were detected in 24 women, and nine children were born with severe thrombocytopenia (< 50x10(9)/L). All mothers with high levels of antibodies were delivered of children with severe thrombocytopenia. None of the newborn infants had clinical signs of intra-cranial haemorrhage. The level of maternal anti-HPA 1a antibodies is predictive for fetal thrombocytopenia and may be used in decisions related to time and mode of delivery.

Evidence of dysfunctional beta2-adrenoceptor signal system in pre-eclampsia.

OBJECTIVES: To determine how beta2-adrenoceptor binding and function differ between healthy women and those with pre-eclampsia. DESIGN: Case-control study. SETTING: Faculty of Medicine, University of Tromsø, Norway. PARTICIPANTS: Two groups of pregnant women: eight cases with pre-eclampsia, matched with eight healthy controls. METHODS: Venous blood was drawn from women in both groups after an overnight rest. The two groups were matched for gestational age which was (mean (SD)) 36 x 4 (3 x 8) and 36 x 5 (4 x 4) weeks for the pre-eclamptic and control groups, respectively. Six weeks after delivery a second blood sample was obtained. The binding and function of beta2-adrenoceptors were determined in isolated human mononuclear leukocytes. The levels of adrenaline and noradrenaline were determined in plasma from venous blood. RESULTS: An elevated density of functional beta2-adrenoceptors was observed in normal pregnancy [mean (SD) 390 (90) vs 270 (60) sites/cell postpartum], due to an increased fraction of receptors in high affinity state, with unaltered total receptor density. The number of functional beta2-adrenoceptors was reduced in pre-eclampsia [mean (SD) 80 (40) vs 240 (30) sites/cell postpartum], due to a reduction in the total receptor number with an unaltered fraction of high affinity receptors. In pregnancy, both unstimulated and isoprenaline-stimulated cAMP levels were reduced in the women with pre-eclampsia (0 x 5 (0 x 2) and 1 x 7 (0 x 9) pmol/10(6) cells, respectively) compared with the normal pregnant controls (mean (SD) 1 x 2 (0 x 3) and 4 x 7 (1 x 8) pmol/10(6) cells, respectively). Plasma catecholamine levels were not elevated in the women with pre-eclampsia. CONCLUSIONS: The increased number of functional beta2-adrenoceptors may contribute to the vasodilatation seen in normal pregnancy, while the reduced overall number of receptors may be one of several factors that account for increased peripheral vascular resistance in pre-eclampsia.