A comparative study of different tissue materials for bioprosthetic aortic valves using experimental assays and finite element analysis.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Extracting the mechanical behaviors of bioprosthetic aortic valve leaflets is necessary for the appropriate design and manufacture of the prosthetic valves. The goal of this study was to opt a proper tissue for the valve leaflets by comparing the mechanical properties of the equine, porcine, and donkey pericardia with those of the bovine pericardium and human aortic valve leaflets. METHODS: After tissue fixation in glutaraldehyde, the mechanical behaviors of the pericardial tissues were experimentally evaluated through computational methods. The relaxation tests were performed along the tissue fiber direction. The Mooney-Rivlin model was utilized to describe the hyperelastic behavior of the tissues at the ramp portion. The viscous behaviors at the hold portion were extracted using the Fung quasi-linear viscoelastic (QLV) model. Furthermore, the extracted parameters were used in the modeling of the bovine, equine, porcine, and donkey pericardia through finite element analysis (FEA). RESULTS: Based on the results, relaxation percentages of the equine, donkey, and bovine pericardia were greater than that of the porcine pericardium and similar to the native human aortic valve leaflets. Indeed, the equine and donkey pericardia were found more viscous and less elastic than the porcine pericardium. Compared with the porcine pericardium, the mechanical properties of the equine and donkey pericardia were rather closer to those of the native human leaflets and bovine pericardium. The computational analysis demonstrated that the donkey pericardium is preferable over other types of pericardium due to the low stress on the leaflets during the systolic and diastolic phases and the large geometric orifice area (GOA). CONCLUSION: The donkey pericardium might be a good candidate valve leaflet material for bioprosthetic aortic valves.

Comparison of tensile properties of xenopericardium from three animal species and finite element analysis for bioprosthetic heart valve tissue.

Bioprosthetic heart valves still have poor long-term durability due to calcification and mechanical failure. The function and performance of bioprostheses is known to depend on the collagen architecture and mechanical behavior of the target tissue. So it is necessary to select an appropriate tissue for such prostheses. In this study, porcine, equine, and bovine pericardia were compared histologically and mechanically. The specimens were analyzed under light microscopy. The planar biaxial tests were performed on the tissue samples by applying synchronic loads along the axial (fiber direction) and perpendicular directions. The measured biaxial data were then fitted into both the modified Mooney-Rivlin model and the anisotropic four parameter Fung-type model. The modified Mooney-Rivlin model was applied to the modeling of the bovine, equine, and porcine pericardia using finite element analysis. The equine pericardium illustrated a wavy collagen bundle architecture similar to bovine pericardium, whereas the collagen bundles in the porcine pericardium were thinner and structured. Wavy pericardia may be preferable candidates for transcutaneous aortic valves because they are less likely to be delaminated during crimping. Based on the biaxial tensile test, the specimens indicated some degree of anisotropy; the anisotropy rates of the equine specimens were almost identical, and higher than the other two specimens. In general, porcine pericardium appeared stiffer, based on the greater strain energy magnitude and the average slope of the stress-stretch curves. Moreover, it was less distensible (due to lower areal strain) than the other two pericardial tissues. Furthermore, the porcine model induced localized high stress regions during the systolic and diastolic phases of the cardiac cycle. However, increased mechanical stress on the bioprosthetic leaflets may cause tissue degeneration and reduce the long-term durability of the valve. Based on our observations, the pericardial specimens behaved as anisotropic and nonlinear tissues-well-characterized by both the modified Mooney-Rivlin and the Fung-type models. The results indicate that, compared to bovine pericardium, equine tissue is mechanically and histologically more appropriate for manufacturing heart valve prostheses. The results of this study can be used in the design and manufacture of bioprosthetic heart valves.

Donkey pericardium compares favorably with commercial xenopericardia used in the manufacture of transcatheter heart valves.

Transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI) has gained considerable acceptance in the past decade due to its lower risks than conventional open-heart surgery. However, the deformation and delamination of the leaflets during the crimping procedure have raised questions about the durability and long-term serviceability of the pericardium tissue from which the leaflets are made. The collagen architecture, wall thickness and mechanical properties of donkey pericardium were investigated to assess its suitability as an alternative material for the manufacture of heart valves. Coupons sampled from different locations of donkey pericardium were investigated. Bovine, equine, and porcine pericardium specimens served as controls. The donkey pericardium had a similar surface morphology to that of the control pericardia except for the wavy topology on both the fibrous and serous sides. The average thickness of donkey pericardium (ca. 120 µm) was significantly lower than that from bovine (375 µm) and equine (410 µm), but slightly higher than that from porcine (99 µm) specimens. The interlaced wavy collagen bundles in the pericardium were composed of collagen fibers about 100 nm in diameter. This unique structure ensures that the donkey pericardium has a comparable ultimate tensile strength (UTS) and a much higher failure strain than the commercial pericardia used for the manufacture of heart valves. The donkey pericardium has an organized wavy collagen bundle architecture similar to that of bovine pericardium and has a satisfactory UTS and high failure strain. The thin and strong donkey pericardium might be a good candidate valve leaflet material for TAVI.

Structural Model for Viscoelastic Properties of Pericardial Bioprosthetic Valves.

The benefit of bioprosthetic aortic valve over mechanical valve replacements is the release of thromboembolism and digression of long-term anticoagulation treatment. The function of bioprostheses and their efficiency is known to depend on the mechanical properties of the leaflet tissue. So it is necessary to select a suitable tissue for the bioprosthesis. The purpose of the present study is to clarify the viscoelastic behavior of bovine, equine, and porcine pericardium. In this study, pericardiums were compared mechanically from the viscoelastic aspect. After fixation of the tissues in glutaraldehyde, first uniaxial tests with different extension rates in the fiber direction were performed. Then, the stress relaxation tests in the fiber direction were done on these pericardial tissues by exerting 20, 30,40, and 50% strains. After evaluation of viscoelastic linearity, the Prony series, quasilinear viscoelastic (QLV) and modified superposition theory were applied to the stress relaxation data. Finally, the parameters of these constitutive models were extracted for each pericardium tissue. All three tissues exhibited a decrease in relaxation rate with elevating strain, indicating the nonlinear viscoelastic behavior of these tissues. The three-term Prony model was selected for describing the linear viscoelasticity. Among different models, the QLV model was best able to capture the relaxation behavior of the pericardium tissues. More stiffness of porcine pericardium was observed in comparison to the two other pericardium tissues. The relaxation percentage of porcine pericardium was less than the two others. It can be concluded that porcine pericardium behaves more as an elastic and less like a viscous tissue in comparison to the bovine and equine pericardium.

Biaxial mechanical properties of human ureter under tension.

PURPOSE: The Mechanical properties of the ureteral wall may be altered by certain diseases such as megaureter. Ureter compliance and wall tension alterations can occur, leading to some abnormalities such as reflex mechanisms. Familiarizing with the mechanical properties of the ureter can help us advance in the understanding of urinary tract diseases. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A constitutive model that can predict the mechanical response of ureteral tissue under complex mechanical loading is required. Parameters characterizing the mechanical behaviour of the material were estimated from planar biaxial test data, where human ureter specimens were simultaneously loaded along the longitudinal and circumferential directions. RESULTS: The biaxial stress-stretch curve was plotted and fitted to a hyperelastic four-parameter Fung type model and five-parameter Mooney-Rivlin model. The average strength in the longitudinal direction was 3.48 ± 0.47 MPa and 2.31 ± 0.46 MPa (P <.05) for the circumferential direction.In the Fung model the value of parameter a2 (0.699 ± 0.17) was higher than a1 (0.279 ± 0.07), which may be due to the collagen fiber orientation's preference along the longitudinal axis. CONCLUSION: According to this study, it seems that ureter tissue is stiffer in the longitudinal than in the circumferential direction and maybe the collagen fiber are along the axial axes. Also the specimens showed some degree of anisotropy.