Loss of B1 and marginal zone B cells during ovarian cancer.

Recent advances in immunotherapy have not addressed the challenge presented by ovarian cancer. Although the peritoneum is an "accessible" locus for this disease there has been limited characterization of the immunobiology therein. We investigated the ID8-C57BL/6J ovarian cancer model and found marked depletion of B1 cells from the ascites of the peritoneal cavity. There was also selective loss of the B1 and marginal zone B cell subsets from the spleen. Immunity to antigens that activate these subsets validated their loss rather than relocation. A marked influx of myeloid-derived suppressor cells correlated with B cell subset depletion. These observations are discussed in the context of the housekeeping burden placed on innate B cells during ovarian cancer and to foster consideration of B cell biology in therapeutic strategies to address this challenge.

IgD ligation allows peritoneal cavity B cell proliferation.

Atypical cytokine production and immune cell subset ratios, particularly those that include high proportions of macrophages, characterize tumor microenvironments (TMEs). TMEs can be modeled by culturing peritoneal cavity (PerC) cells which have a high macrophage to lymphocyte ratio. With TCR or BCR ligation, PerC lymphocyte proliferation is tempered by macrophages. However, PHA (T cells) and anti-CD40 (B cells) are activators that induce proliferation. Herein, we report that ligating IgD, in contrast to IgM, triggers PerC B cell proliferation. IL-4 addition enhanced the IgD response for BALB/c PerC B cells but suppressed that of C57BL/6 mice. Intriguingly, concurrent ligation of IgD and CD3ε rescued a PerC T cell proliferative response. These results serve to expand the list of targets for promoting cellular and humoral immunity in conditions that model macrophage-rich TMEs.

PHA eludes macrophage suppression to activate CD8+ T cells.

Tumors may include a high proportion of immune modulatory cells and molecules that restrain the anti-cancer response. Activation of T cells to eliminate cancer cells within the immune-suppressive tumor microenvironment remains a challenge. We have shown that C57BL/6 J peritoneal cell culture models features of macrophage-dense tumors as TCR ligation fails to activate T cells unless IFNγ is neutralized or iNOS is inhibited. We tested other forms of T cell activation and found phytohemagglutinin (PHA) distinctive in the ability to markedly expand CD8 T cells in this model. IFNγ or iNOS inhibition was not necessary for this response. PHA triggered less IFNγ production and inhibitory PD-L1 expression than TCR ligation. Macrophages and CD44hi T cells bound PHA. Spleen T cell responses to PHA were markedly enhanced by the addition of peritoneal cells revealing that macrophages enhance T cell expansion. That PHA increases CD8 T cell responses within macrophage-dense culture suggests this mitogen might enhance anti-tumor immunity.

High macrophage PD-L1 expression not responsible for T cell suppression.

Tumors are often comprised of microenvironments (TMEs) with a high proportion of cells and molecules that regulate immunity. Peritoneal cavity (PerC) cell culture reproduces key features of TMEs as lymphocyte proliferation is suppressed by PerC macrophages (Mϕs). We monitored the expression of T cell stimulatory (Class II MHC, B7) and inhibitory (PD-L1) molecules by PerC APCs before and after culture and report here that IFNγ-driven PD-L1 expression increased markedly on PerC Mϕs after TCR ligation, even more so than seen with direct APC activation by LPS. Considering the high APC composition of and pronounced PD-L1 expression by PerC cells, it was surprising that blocking PD-1/PD-L1 interaction by mAb neutralization or genetic ablation did not relieve suppression. This result parallels TME challenges observed in the clinic and validates the need for further study of this culture model to inform strategies to promote anti-tumor immunity.

Macrophage regulation of B cell proliferation.

Unlike organized lymphoid tissue, the tumor microenvironment (TME) often includes a high proportion of immunosuppressive macrophages. We model the TME by culturing peritoneal cavity (PerC) cells that naturally have a high macrophage to lymphocyte ratio. Prior studies revealed that, following TCR ligation, PerC T cell proliferation is suppressed due to IFNγ-triggered inducible nitric oxide synthase expression. In this study we assessed the ability of PerC B cells to respond to surrogate activating signals in the presence of high numbers of macrophages. Surface IgM (BCR) ligation led to cyclooxygenase-mediated, and TLR-4 ligation to IL10-mediated, suppression of PerC B cell proliferation. In contrast, PerC B cells had a robust response to CD40 ligation, which could overcome the suppression generated by the BCR or TLR-4 response. However, the CD40 response was suppressed by concurrent TCR ligation. These results reveal the challenges of promoting B and T cell responses in macrophage-rich conditions that model the TME.

Erythropoietin increases macrophage-mediated T cell suppression.

Erythropoietin (EPO), used to treat anemia in cancer patients, has been reported to accelerate tumor progression and increase mortality. Research of the mechanism for this effect has focused upon EPOR expression by tumor cells. We model the high macrophage to lymphocyte ratio found in tumor microenvironments (TMEs) by culturing peritoneal cavity (PerC) cells that naturally have a high macrophage to T cell ratio. Following TCR ligation, C57BL/6J PerC T cell proliferation is suppressed due to IFNγ-triggered inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) expression. EPO was tested in the PerC culture model and found to increase T cell suppression. This effect could be abrogated by inhibiting iNOS by enzyme inhibition, genetic ablation, or blocking IFNγ signaling. Flow cytometry revealed the EPOR on CD11b(+)F4/80(+) macrophages. These results suggest that EPO could increase T cell suppression in the TME by acting directly on macrophages.

Porphyromonas gingivalis: keeping the pathos out of the biont.

The primary goal of the human microbiome initiative has been to increase our understanding of the structure and function of our indigenous microbiota and their effects on human health and predisposition to disease. Because of its clinical importance and accessibility for in vivo study, the oral biofilm is one of the best-understood microbial communities associated with the human body. Studies have shown that there is a succession of select microbial interactions that directs the maturation of a defined community structure, generating the formation of dental plaque. Although the initiating factors that lead to disease development are not clearly defined, in many individuals there is a fundamental shift from a health-associated biofilm community to one that is pathogenic in nature and a central player in the pathogenic potential of this community is the presence of Porphyromonas gingivalis. This anaerobic bacterium is a natural member of the oral microbiome, yet it can become highly destructive (termed pathobiont) and proliferate to high cell numbers in periodontal lesions, which is attributed to its arsenal of specialized virulence factors. Hence, this organism is regarded as a primary etiologic agent of periodontal disease progression. In this review, we summarize some of the latest information regarding what is known about its role in periodontitis, including pathogenic potential as well as ecological and nutritional parameters that may shift this commensal to a virulent state. We also discuss parallels between the development of pathogenic biofilms and the human cellular communities that lead to cancer, specifically we frame our viewpoint in the context of 'wounds that fail to heal'.

CD28 ligation increases macrophage suppression of T-cell proliferation.

When compared to spleen or lymph node cells, resident peritoneal cavity cells respond poorly to T-cell activation in vitro. The greater proportional representation of macrophages in this cell source has been shown to actively suppress the T-cell response. Peritoneal macrophages exhibit an immature phenotype (MHC class II(lo), B7(lo)) that reduces their efficacy as antigen-presenting cells. Furthermore, these cells readily express inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS), an enzyme that promotes T-cell tolerance by catabolism of the limiting amino acid arginine. Here, we investigate the ability of exogenous T-cell costimulation to recover the peritoneal T-cell response. We show that CD28 ligation failed to recover the peritoneal T-cell response and actually suppressed responses that had been recovered by inhibiting iNOS. As indicated by cytokine ELISpot and neutralizing monoclonal antibody (mAb) treatment, this 'cosuppression' response was due to CD28 ligation increasing the number of interferon (IFN)-γ-secreting cells. Our results illustrate that cellular composition and cytokine milieu influence T-cell costimulation biology.Cellular & Molecular Immunology advance online publication, 23 April 2012; doi:10.1038/cmi.2012.13.

Age-dependent loss of naïve T cells in TCR transgenic bone marrow chimeras.

Study of immune senescence is complicated by low numbers of antigen-specific lymphocytes, particularly naïve T (Tn)cells which disappear with aging. Although T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic mice facilitate aging research, their large number of Ag-specific T cells renders their T cell pool abnormal, precluding normal in vivo immunity. To create a physiologically relevant model with measurable numbers of TCR transgenic CD4+ T cells in the context of normal lymphocytes, mixed (DO11.10+BALB/c) bone marrow (BM) chimeras were constructed. As found in normal mice, the total number of transgenic T cells and the Tn:memory T cell ratio declined with the aging of the BM chimeras. Although these shifts in T cell subsets were evident in both the lymph nodes and the spleen (SP), they were more pronounced in the SP. Unlike DO11.10 mice, transgenic T cells in the chimera acquired an effector/memory phenotype upon antigen challenge. These results reveal a pliable model to study the impact of the constriction of the Tn cell repertoire upon optimal vaccine responses in the elderly.

Differential effects of CD28 costimulation upon cytokine production by CD4+ and CD8+ T cells.

The impact of CD28 ligation upon CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocyte proliferation and cytokine production was assessed. Although costimulation increased the proliferative response of both T cell subsets, cytokine production was most markedly increased in the CD4+ subset, as evidenced by a 40-fold increase in interleukin-2 (IL-2), a 14-fold increase in interleukin-3 (IL-3) and 5-fold increases in interferon gamma and GM-colony-stimulating factor (CSF) production. The CD8+ T cell response to CD28 ligation was less marked, maxima being a 5-fold increase in IL-2 production and 2-fold increases in IL-3 and GM-CSF production. Resolution of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells into their CD44lo (naïve) and CD44hi (memory/effector) subsets revealed that naive CD4+ T cells were the most CD28-responsive subsets. CD28-mediated costimulation promotes distinct differentiation programs in CD4+ versus CD8+ T cells.

Mls presentation by peritoneal cavity B cells.

DBA/2J spleen and peritoneal cells were compared for their ability to present the minor lymphocyte stimulatory superantigen Mls-1a. Although capable of Mls presentation in vivo, peritoneal cells were less effective than spleen cells in vitro. This difference was not due to cell concentration or culture duration. Flow cytometric comparison of spleen and peritoneal B cells revealed no significant differences in cell surface markers needed for cognate interaction with T cells. Resolution of peritoneal B cell subsets by cell sorting revealed that even though B-1 cells were capable of Mls presentation, they were less effective than B-2 cells. Mixing experiments showed that B-1 cells did not inhibit B-2 cell presentation of Mls. In contrast, total peritoneal cells inhibited T cell responses to Mls presented by spleen cells. The peritoneal cavity harbors B cells that can present Mls as well as other cells that can suppress this response.

Nonlymphoid peritoneal cells suppress the T cell response to Mls.

Comparative analyses of the ability of lymphoid tissue to present the minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) superantigen Mls-1a in vitro revealed that all tissues containing mature B cells, except peritoneal cavity (PerC) cells, induced Mls-1a-specific T cell activation. Irradiation and mitomycin C treatment, addition of IL-2 and IL-12, and neutralization of IL-10 and TGF-beta did not restore Mls-1a antigen presentation by PerC cells. Co-culture studies revealed that PerC cells actively suppress the T cell response to Mls-1a. PerC cells from severe-combined immune-defective (SCID) mice also suppressed this response indicating that nonlymphoid cells mediate this effect. These results suggest that in addition to antigen processing and presentation, resident peritoneal cavity cells may temper lymphocyte activation.

Impact of aging upon DBA/2J B cells.

The influence of age on B lymphocyte phenotype and function in DBA/2J mice was examined. The B cells of this strain express the endogenous minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) retroviral superantigen (SAg) Mls-1a permitting assessment of age-related changes in cognate B cell-T cell interaction. Relative to young DBA/2J mice (< 8 months), old mice (> 17 months) had greater numbers of B cells expressing high levels of IgM and low levels of the CD11b and CD5 antigens characteristic of B-1 B cells. As measured by the T cell proliferative response to Mls, the B cells from old DBA/2J mice had reduced ability to present SAg. Upon interaction with Mls-activated T cells, old B cells secreted more IgM while young B cells made more IgG1, IgG3, and IgG2a. DBA/2J BCL functioned poorly as Mls APCs and made considerably less serum Ig. T cells from old mice exhibited a lower response to SAg and were less capable of promoting B cell differentiation. These results indicate that aging influences the cellular collaboration necessary for humoral immunity.

Age-dependent increase of peritoneal B-1b B cells in SCID mice.

The impact of increasing age upon immunoglobulin production and B-lymphocyte generation in "leaky" severe combined immune-defective (SCID) mice was examined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and flow cytometry. By 1 year of age, the mice had normal numbers of B cells in their peritoneal cavity, while their spleen had very few immunoglobulin M-positive (IgM+) cells. The majority of B cells expressed the CD11b marker characteristic of the B-1b subset. B-1a (CD5+) cells were present at a lower frequency and B-2 cells were absent. The frequency of mice producing detectable immunoglobulin increased with age, and isotype diversity within individual mice was variable. IgM production was most frequently observed followed by IgG3 and IgG2a, then IgG1, and finally IgA. The selective persistence of the B-1 B-cell subset in the peritoneal cavity of aging SCID mice is a natural model for the study of those genetic and environmental influences that determine lymphocyte longevity.

Age-related changes in mature CD4+ T cells: cell cycle analysis.

T cell proliferative responses decrease with age, but the mechanisms responsible are unknown. We examined the impact of age on memory and naive CD4(+) T cell entry and progression through the cell cycle using acridine orange to identify cell cycle stage. For both subsets, fewer stimulated cells from old donors were able to enter and progress through the first cell cycle, with an increased number of cells arrested in G(0) and fewer cells in post G(0) phases. The number of dead cells as assessed by sub-G(0) DNA was also significantly greater in the old group. CD4(+) T cells from old mice also exhibited a significant reduction in clonal history as assessed by CFSE staining. This was associated with a significant decline in cyclin D2 mRNA and protein. We propose that decreases in cyclin D2 are at least partially responsible for the proliferative decline found in aged CD4(+) T cells.