Sensory evaluation of whey and sweet cream buttermilk.

The objective of this work was to characterize the sensory attributes of sweet cream buttermilk (CBM) and a nontraditional product, whey buttermilk (WBM). Whey buttermilk results from processing whey cream into butter. The products were evaluated as fresh liquid buttermilk obtained directly from the butter churn, and as reconstituted buttermilk or whey buttermilk powders. Sweet cream buttermilk and WBM were produced either at the Dairy Products Technology Center (experimental samples, n = 2) or provided by the industry (n = 2 from 2 different commercial sources). Nine panelists were trained for twenty-four 1-h sessions; they then rated samples on a 15-cm line scale in triplicate using descriptive analysis. Data obtained were analyzed using SAS statistical software. Results indicated that WBM had similar sensory characteristics as regular CBM; however, there was a marked color difference between them. Liquid buttermilk was not significantly different from reconstituted buttermilk powder on many attributes. However, WBM was significantly more yellow, more sour, and more astringent than the CBM samples, and it had more cardboard flavor than the commercially produced CBM. Liquid buttermilk was not significantly different from reconstituted buttermilk powder on many attributes. However, some buttermilk types had more cardboard aroma and flavor in their powdered form than in liquid form. Most attributes showed no significant differences across replicates, indicating consistency of rating. Principal component analysis showed that attributes were separated on the 2 principal components based on production site and processing form (fresh vs. reconstituted).

Compositional and functional properties of buttermilk: a comparison between sweet, sour, and whey buttermilk.

Buttermilk is a dairy ingredient widely used in the food industry because of its emulsifying capacity and its positive impact on flavor. Commercial buttermilk is sweet buttermilk, a by-product from churning sweet cream into butter. However, other sources of buttermilk exist, including cultured and whey buttermilk obtained from churning of cultured cream and whey cream, respectively. The compositional and functional properties (protein solubility, viscosity, emulsifying and foaming properties) of sweet, sour, and whey buttermilk were determined at different pH levels and compared with those of skim milk and whey. Composition of sweet and cultured buttermilk was similar to skim milk, and composition of whey buttermilk was similar to whey, with the exception of fat content, which was higher in buttermilk than in skim milk or whey (6 to 20% vs. 0.3 to 0.4%). Functional properties of whey buttermilk were independent of pH, whereas sweet and cultured buttermilk exhibited lower protein solubility and emulsifying properties as well as a higher viscosity at low pH (pH

Effect of milk base and starter culture on acidification, texture, and probiotic cell counts in fermented milk processing.

In the present work, the compared effect of milk base and starter culture on acidification, texture, growth, and stability of probiotic bacteria in fermented milk processing, was studied. Two strains of probiotic bacteria were used, Lactobacillus acidophilus LA5 and L. rhamnosus LR35, with two starter cultures. One starter culture consisted only of Streptococcus thermophilus ST7 (single starter culture); the other was a yogurt mixed culture with S. thermophilus ST7 and L. bulgaricus LB12 (mixed starter culture). For the milk base preparation, four commercial dairy ingredients were tested (two milk protein concentrates and two casein hydrolysates). The resulting fermented milks were compared to those obtained with control milk (without enrichment) and milk added with skim milk powder. The performance of the two probiotic strains were opposite. L. acidophilus LA5 grew well on milk but showed a poor stability during storage. L. rhamnosus LR35 grew weakly on milk but was remarkably stable during storage. With the strains tested in this study, the use of the single starter culture and the addition of casein hydrolysate gave the best probiotic cell counts. The fermentation time was of about 11 h, and the probiotic level after five weeks of storage was greater than 106 cfu/ml for L. acidophilus LA5 and 10(7) cfu/ml for L. rhamnosus LR35. However, an optimization of the level of casein hydrolysate added to milk base has to be done, in order to improve texture and flavor when using this dairy ingredient.

Effect of inoculum composition and low KCl supplementation on the biological and rheological stability of an immobilized-cell system for mixed mesophilic lactic starter production.

Two strains of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis (L. lactis KB and KBP) and one of L. lactis subsp. lactis biovar. diacetylactis (L. diacetylactis MD) were immobilized separately in kappa-carrageenan-locust bean gum gel beads. Continuous fermentations were carried out in supplemented whey permeate in a 1-L pH-controlled stirred tank reactor inoculated with a 30% (v/v) bead inoculum and a bead ratio of 55:30:15 for KB, KBP, and MD, respectively. The process demonstrated a high productivity and microbial stability during the 7-week continuous culture. Compared with previous experiments carried out with an inoculum bead ratio of 33:33:33 for KB, KBP, and MD beads, respectively, the modification of the inoculum bead ratio had apparently little effect on free and immobilized, total and specific populations. A dominant behavior of L. diacetylactis MD over the other strains of the mixed culture was observed both with free-cell populations in the effluent and with immobilized-cell populations. Additional experiments were carried out with other strain combinations for continuous inoculation-prefermentation of milk. The data also confirmed the dominance of L. diacetylactis during long-term continuous immobilized-cell fermentations. This dominance may be tentatively explained by the local competition involved in the development of the bead cross-contamination and in citrate utilization by L. diacetylactis strains. The gel beads demonstrated a high rheological stability during the 7-week continuous fermentation even at low KCl supplementation of the broth medium (25 mM KCl).

Identification of interacting mixed cultures of lactic acid bacteria by their exclusion from a model predicting the acidifying activity of non-interacting mixed cultures.

A model predicting the acidifying activity of mixed cultures of lactic acid bacteria and based on the lack of interaction between the strains has been investigated to identify interacting cultures. Three mixed cultures with Streptococcus thermophilus TH3 and ST7 and Lactobacillus delbrueckii ssp. bulgaricus LB10 were grown on milk. The acidifying activities of the two mixed cultures TH3/LB10 and TH3/ST7 were predicted accurately by the model, with mean prediction errors of 7.7% and 14.1%, respectively. However, the model underestimated the acidifying activity of the mixed culture ST7/LB10, with a mean prediction error of 43.5%, which provides evidence of positive interaction between the strains ST7 and LB10 during acidification.

Effect of citrate on growth of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis in milk.

The effect of citrate on the growth of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis var. diacetylactis in milk has been investigated. Five strains of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis var. diacetylactis were compared to their citrate-negative variants, which lack the plasmid coding for citrate permease. In most cases, acidification kinetics and the final bacterial concentration of pure cultures of parental and variant strains did not differ significantly. Co-cultures of parental and variant strains, however, systematically tended towards the predominance of parental strains. Citrate metabolism is responsible for this change, since the predominance of citrate-positive strains was not observed in the absence of citrate. Continuous culture in milk enabled the difference in growth rates between the parental strain Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis var. diacetylactis CDI1 and its citrate-negative variant to be quantified by following changes in the populations of the two co-cultured strains. At 26 degrees C, the growth rate of the parental strain was 7% higher than that of its citrate-negative variant. These results show that citrate metabolism slightly stimulates the growth of lactococci in milk.

Microbial dynamics of co- and separately entrapped mixed cultures of mesophilic lactic acid bacteria during the continuous prefermentation of milk.

Four strains of mesophilic lactic acid bacteria were separately or coentrapped in kappa-carrageenan/locust bean gum gel beads and used for continuous prefermentation of UHT skim milk in a stirred-tank bioreactor. Lactic acid and cell productivities of the immobilized cell bioreactor were particularly high and remarkably stable during eight weeks of continuous milk prefermentation (about 18 g h-1 l-1 of lactic acid and 4.9 x 10(12) CFU h-1 l-1, respectively, but important variations of the bacterial populations is prefermented milk and gel beads occurred in any case (co-or separate entrapment). The strain Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis biovar diacetylactis CDII became dominant, accounting for approx. 90% (released cells) and 78% (immobilized cells) of the total population. Microscopic observations of sections of gels beads showed a progressive destructing of the bead surface with rupture and release of entrapped viable cells from peripheral cavities of the gel. It is believed that these cavities close again after releasing all or part of their cell content, entrapping the different strains of the mixed culture and initiating a new colonization step and a cross-contamination of the beads. On the other hand, experimentations over seven-week periods with pasteurized milk showed the high resistance of the immobilized cell bioreactor to psychrotrophic contamination.

Use of an immobilized cell bioreactor for the continuous inoculation of milk in fresh cheese manufacturing.

A system was developed to continuously acidify and inoculate skim milk for the production of fresh cheese. Four strains of mesophilic lactic acid bacteria were entrapped separately in kappa-carrageenan/locust bean gum gel beads and used in a stirred bioreactor operated at 26 degrees C with a 25% (v/v) gel load. The pH in the reactor was controlled at 6.0 by adding fresh milk using proportional integrated derived regulation. The bioreactor was operated during 8-h daily cycles for up to 7 weeks with different milks (heat treatment, dry matter content) and differing starting procedures. The heat treatment of the milk was an important factor for process performance: a dilution rate increase of 57% and an inoculation level decrease of 63% were observed with sterilized UHT skim milk (142 degrees C - 7.5 s) compared with pasteurized skim milk (72 degrees C - 15 s). The dry matter content of the milk (8-13% w/w) had no detectable effect on these parameters. A convenient starting procedure of the system was tested; steady-state was reached in less than 40 min following an interruption period of 16-60 h. These results combined with our published data on process performance show the feasibility of using an integrated immobilized cell bioreactor for milk prefermentation in cheese manufacture.