Legionella in drinking water: the detection method matters.

Legionella concentrations in drinking water have been regulated for decades and are evaluated with regard to their concentrations in drinking water plumbing systems (DWPS). The respective action levels differ at the international level. In Germany, the Federal Environment Agency (UBA) specifies the application of ISO 11731 for the detection of legionella in drinking water and gives a binding recommendation for the methods to be used for culturing and evaluation. Effective from 01 March 2019, the UBA recommendation was revised. The utilized culture media in the culture approach were altered, consequently affecting the spectrum of legionella colonies detected in drinking water. Using data from a routine legionella monitoring of a large laboratory, over a period of 6 years and 17,270 individual drinking water samples, allowed us to assess the impact of the alteration on the assessment of DWPS. By comparing the amount of action level exceedances before and after the method change, it could be demonstrated that exceedances are reported significantly more often under the new method. Consequently, the corresponding action level for evaluation of legionella contamination and the resulting risk to human health needs to be revised to avoid the misleading impression of increased health risk.

Comparison of the Legiolert™/Quanti-Tray® MPN test for the enumeration of Legionella pneumophila from potable water samples with the German regulatory requirements methods ISO 11731-2 and ISO 11731.

Due to the promising results of a previous study of the performance of the novel MPN method (Legiolert™/Quanti-Tray®) compared to ISO 11731-2, this study was performed to compare Legiolert for Legionella pneumophila with the German regulatory requirements methods ISO 11731-2 (100 ml membrane filtration) and ISO 11731 (1 ml direct plating) for the enumeration of L. pneumophila and Legionella spp. from potable water. Data from a multi-laboratory study according to ISO 17994 showed that Legiolert yielded on average higher counts of L. pneumophila than the ISO 11731-2 method, but the comparison with ISO 11731 was inconclusive due to the number of samples needing to be tested. Likewise, comparisons of the MPN method for 100 ml to the highest result of either ISO 11731 or ISO 11731-2 according to Federal Environmental Agency recommendation (2012) yielded no conclusive difference, regardless of whether non-pneumophila species of Legionella were included in the evaluation. The MPN method has a high specificity for L. pneumophila of 97.9% which compares favourably to the specificity of 95.3% quoted for ISO 11731. The new method represents a significant improvement in the enumeration of L. pneumophila from drinking water and related samples.