A superagonist variant of peptide MART1/Melan A27-35 elicits anti-melanoma CD8+ T cells with enhanced functional characteristics: implication for more effective immunotherapy.

In the present study, we show that a singly substituted peptide derived from the epitope MART1(27-35) and containing a Leu in position 1 (LAGIGILTV; 1L) behaves as a superagonist by in vitro inducing specific T cells with enhanced immunological functions. 1L-specific CTLs can be raised from peripheral blood of HLA-A2+ melanoma patients more efficiently than T cells specific for the cognate peptide. These T cells show a greater sensitivity to native MART1(27-35) when compared with CTL variable raised to parental peptide from the same patients. More importantly, anti-1L but not anti-native T cells display high levels of interferon gamma production at early time points, and readily secreted interleukin-2 in response to native epitope endogenously presented by melanoma cells. Additionally, anti-1L T cells are insensitive to the inhibitory effects of MART1(27-35) natural analogues that antagonize the lytic response of CTLs raised to the cognate peptide. Analysis of T-cell receptor variable beta usage suggests that the native and 1L peptides stimulate different components of the MART1(27-35)-reactive T cell population. These data provide rationale to the use of superagonist analogues of tumor antigens for inducing in vivo immunization potentially able to overcome tumor immune escape and mediate a more significant control of tumor growth.

Human melanoma-reactive CD4+ and CD8+ CTL clones resist Fas ligand-induced apoptosis and use Fas/Fas ligand-independent mechanisms for tumor killing.

Tumor cells have been shown recently to escape immune recognition by developing resistance to Fas-mediated apoptosis and acquiring expression of Fas ligand (FasL) molecule that they may use for eliminating activated Fas+ lymphocytes. In this study, we report that tumor-specific T lymphocytes isolated from tumor lesions by repeated in vitro TCR stimulation with relevant Ags (mostly represented by normal self proteins, such as MART-1/Melan A and gp100) can develop strategies for overcoming these escape mechanisms. Melanoma cells (and normal melanocytes) express heterogeneous levels of Fas molecule, but they result homogeneously resistant to Fas-induced apoptosis. However, CD4+ and CD8+ CTL clones kill melanoma cells through Fas/FasL-independent, granule-dependent lytic pathway. In these lymphocytes, Ag/MHC complex interaction with TCR does not lead to functional involvement of FasL, triggered, on the contrary, by T cell activation with nonspecific stimuli such as PMA/ionomycin. Additionally, melanoma cells express significant levels of FasL (detectable on the cell surface only after treatment with metalloprotease inhibitors), although to a lesser extent than professional immune cells such as Thl clones. Nevertheless, antimelanoma CTL clones resist apoptosis mediated by FasL either in soluble form or expressed by Thl lymphocytes or FasL+ melanoma cells. These results demonstrate that CD4+ and CD8+ antimelanoma T cell clones can be protected against Fas-dependent apoptosis, and thus be useful reagents of immunotherapeutic strategies aimed to potentiate tumor-specific T cell responses.

Peptides derived from self-proteins as partial agonists and antagonists of human CD8+ T-cell clones reactive to melanoma/melanocyte epitope MART1(27-35).

The self-peptide MART1(27-35) derives from the melanocyte/melanoma protein Melan A/MART1 and is a target epitope of CD8+ T cells, commonly recovered from tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes of HLA-A2.1+ melanoma patients. Despite their prevalence in such patients, these CTLs generally appear to be ineffective in mediating tumor regression in vivo. We have noted previously that numerous peptides from both endogenous and foreign proteins are similar to MART1(27-35) and, potentially, are capable of productively engaging the T-cell receptors of patient-derived CTLs. This observation raised the question of whether CTLs in vivo might encounter self-peptide analogues of MART1(27-35) that lack full agonist activity, perhaps to the detriment of the antitumor CTL response. This possibility was evaluated using cloned, patient-derived CTLs with a panel of self-derived natural analogues of MART1(27-35) in assays for cytolysis, cytokine release, and phosphorylation of T-cell receptor signaling constituents. Several peptides were identified as partial agonists, capable of eliciting cytolysis and/or release of cytokines tumor necrosis factor-alpha and IFN-gamma but not interleukin 2. Several other peptides showed antagonist behavior, effectively inhibiting cytolysis of MART1(27-35)-pulsed targets, but did not inhibit killing of cells prepulsed with a synthetic, heteroclitic variant of MART1(27-35). Some of these antagonists also had lasting effects on interleukin 2 secretion by CTLs under experimental conditions involving sequential exposure to ligands. Together, these observations suggest that encounters with self-peptide analogues of MART1(27-35) may contribute to the peripheral maintenance of these CTLs, while ultimately impairing the efficacy of this antitumor T-cell response.

Recognition of melanoma-derived antigens by CTL: possible mechanisms involved in down-regulating anti-tumor T-cell reactivity.

Several T cell-recognized epitopes presented by melanoma cells have been identified recently. Despite the large array of epitopes potentially available for clinical use, it is still unclear which of these antigens could be effective in mediating anti-tumor responses when used as a vaccine. Preliminary studies showed that immunization of melanoma patients with epitopes derived from proteins of the MAGE family may result in significant clinical regressions. However, no sign of systemic immunization could be observed in peripheral blood of treated patients. Conversely, significant immunization (detected as increased antigen-specific CTL activity in peripheral blood) was obtained by vaccinating HLA-A2.1+ melanoma patients with the immunodominant epitope (residues 27-35) of the differentiation antigen MART-1, but this immunization was not accompanied by a significant clinical response. To implement immunotherapeuties capable of significantly impacting disease outcome, it is necessary to identify the potential mechanisms responsible for the failure of some antigens to mediate significant anti-tumor responses in vivo. In the case of the MART-1(27-35) epitope, we hypothesize that one of these mechanisms may be related to the existence of natural analogs of this peptide in other human normal proteins.

Identification of epitope mimics recognized by CTL reactive to the melanoma/melanocyte-derived peptide MART-1(27-35).

CTL reactivity to the epitope MART-1(27-35), of the melanoma (self) antigen MART-1/melan A is frequently observed in tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes and may be readily elicited from the peripheral blood of melanoma patients that express HLA-A*0201. Available data suggest that these observations contrast with those made for other HLA-A*0201-presented melanoma self antigens regarding the regularity of observed CTL responses. Based on preliminary findings, we hypothesized that the CTL response to MART-1 might be augmented in part by T cell encounters with peptides derived from sources other than MART-1, which show sequence similarity to MART-1(27-35). To test this idea, a protein database search for potential MART-1 epitope mimics was done using criteria developed from analyses of effector recognition of singly-substituted peptide analogues of MART-1(27-35). Synthetic peptides were made for a portion of the sequences retrieved; 12/40 peptides tested were able to sensitize target cells for lysis by one or more anti-MART-1 effectors. The peptides recognized correspond to sequences occurring in a variety of proteins of viral, bacterial, and human (self) origin. One peptide derives from glycoprotein C of the common pathogen HSV-1; cells infected with recombinant vaccinia virus encoding native glycoprotein C were lysed by anti-MART-1 effectors. Our results overall indicate that sequences conforming to the A2.1 binding motif and possessing features essential to recognition by anti-MART-1 CTL occur frequently in proteins. These findings further suggest that T cells might encounter a variety of such sequences in vivo, and that epitope mimicry may play a role in modulating the CTL response to MART-1(27-35).

Cytotoxic T cells directed to tumor antigens not expressed on normal melanocytes dominate HLA-A2.1-restricted immune repertoire to melanoma.

To determine whether HLA-A21 restricted melanoma Ags exist that are not expressed on normal melanocytes, a panel of 478 T cell clones from six HLA-A21+ patients was selected for HLA-A2 restricted lysis of autologous tumor and then tested for differential recognition of HLA-A2.1+ melanomas and normal melanocytes. Four subsets of clones were identified in the panel of 107 HLA-A2-restricted CTL clones. CTL clones from three of the four subsets did not lyse melanocytes, but recognized fresh HLA-A2.1+ melanomas and defined three classes of epitopes, including unique Ags, common melanoma Ags, and Ags shared with neoplastic cells of different histologic origin. These CTL clones did not recognize any of the 10 peptides selected for specific association to HLA-A2.1 and derived from Melan-A/Mart-1, tyrosinase, gp100, or MAGE-3 proteins. By contrast, the fourth subset of HLA-A2.1-restricted CTl clones recognized both melanoma and melanocytes. These CTL clones were directed to a peptide from either Melan-A/Mart-1, tyronise, or gp100. By a limiting dilution assay, designed to evaluate the frequency of HLA-A2-restricted CTL precursors (CTLp) directed to melanoma but not to melanocytes, such precursors were found in the peripheral blood or tumor site of five of six HLA-A2.1+ melanoma patients, and their frequency was much higher than the frequency of CTLp recognizing both tumor cells and the melanocytes. These results suggest that in melanoma patients most of the HLA-A2.1-restricted immune repertoire to melanoma is directly to epitopes expressed in the neoplastic but not in the normal cells of the melanocyte lineage.

Melanoma cells and normal melanocytes share antigens recognized by HLA-A2-restricted cytotoxic T cell clones from melanoma patients.

HLA-A2-restricted, CD3+, CD8+, alpha/beta+ cytotoxic T cell (CTL) clones were isolated from peripheral blood (PBL) or tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) of two HLA-A2+ melanoma patients (9742 and 5810), to evaluate the possible recognition of autologous melanoma and of allogeneic HLA-A2-matched normal melanocytes. These CTL clones lysed not only fresh and cultured autologous melanoma cells, but also allogeneic HLA-A2+, but not HLA-A2-, normal melanocytes. The lysis of autologous neoplastic cells and of melanocytes could be inhibited by an anti-HLA-A2 monoclonal antibody (mAb). Lysis of the normal melanocytes was not dependent on the presence of human or fetal calf serum in the culture medium. HLA-A2-restricted CTL clones recognized not only proliferating melanocytes cultured in complete melanocyte medium, but also melanocytes made quiescent by culture for up to 6 d in a basal medium devoid of exogenous factors such as phorbol ester (O-tetradecanoyl phorbol 13-acetate [TPA]), epidermal growth factor, insulin, and pituitary extracts. Analysis of specificity of four CTL clones (A75, A83, A94, and 119) from patient 9742, performed on a panel of 39 targets, indicated that the three HLA-A2-restricted CTL (A75, A83, and A94) lysed all but one of nine allogeneic melanomas expressing the HLA-A2 molecule with no reactivity on nine HLA-A2- allogeneic melanomas. Only a few instances of borderline reactivity were seen by the same effectors on 21 targets of nonmelanocyte lineage, including 12 carcinomas of different histology, four Epstein-Barr virus-transformed B cells (lymphoblastoid cell lines [LCL]), including the autologous LCL, four lines of normal fibroblasts, and normal kidney cells. Lack of reactivity on allogeneic targets of nonmelanocyte lineage occurred in spite of expression of HLA-A2 on 14 of these targets as determined by conventional tissue typing and cytofluorimetric analysis with four different anti-HLA-A2 mAb. These data indicate that tissue-related antigens can be expressed on normal and neoplastic cells of the melanocyte lineage and can be recognized in association with HLA-A2 by CTL clones from melanoma patients.

Proliferative and/or cytotoxic activity of lymphocyte clones to autologous human melanoma.

Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of a patient with metastatic melanoma were cultured with autologous melanoma cells (Auto-Me) and recombinant interleukin 2 (IL-2) (MLTC-PBL). Thirty-five days later, when no cytotoxicity against Auto-Me or K562 was detectable, MLTC-PBL were cloned in the presence of Auto-Me, IL-2 (25 U/ml) and Daudi cells as feeder. Eighty-one growing clones were simultaneously screened for proliferative and cytotoxic activity to Auto-Me. Twenty-two clones proliferated in the presence of Auto-Me only, 29 in the presence of IL-2 only and 41 in the presence of Auto-Me plus IL-2; 12 clones showed cytotoxic activity against Auto-Me. Six clones expressed both cytotoxic and proliferative activity to Auto-Me. The phenotype of 6 proliferative clones tested was CD3+, CD4+, WT31+, CD8-, CD16-, Leu19-, whereas that of 2 cytotoxic-proliferative clones tested was CD3+, CD8+, Leu19+, WT31+, CD4-, CD16-. Specificity analysis of proliferative response of 6 clones and of cytotoxicity of 7 clones, tested on a panel of 14 different target cells, revealed a complex pattern of reactivity, each clone expressing a peculiar specificity. Our results suggest the possibility of isolating, from melanoma patients' PBL, T-cell clones with proliferative activity to Auto-Me and Auto-Me plus IL-2, and T-cell clones which apparently express both proliferative and cytotoxic activity to Auto-Me.