Ribosome-inactivating proteins: progress and problems.

Ribosome-inactivating proteins (RIPs), mostly from plants, are enzymes which depurinate rRNA, thus inhibiting protein synthesis. They also depurinate other polynucleotide substrates. The biological activity of RIPs is not completely clarified, and sometimes independent of the inhibition of protein synthesis. There are differences in the cytotoxicity of RIPs and, consequently, in their toxicity to animals. Some RIPs are potent toxins, the best known being ricin, a potential biological weapon. New toxins have recently been identified. RIPs cause apoptotic and necrotic lesions, and induce production of cytokines causing inflammation. RIPs are potentially useful in agriculture and medicine because (i) they have antiviral activity and (ii) they are used for the preparation of conjugates with antibodies ('immunotoxins') or other carriers, rendering them specifically toxic to the cell target of the carrier, which may be helpful in therapy. The distribution, mechanism of action and role in nature of RIPs are not completely understood, and we can expect several future developments in their practical application.

Occupational sensitization to ribosome-inactivating proteins in researchers.

BACKGROUND: Ribosome-inactivating proteins (RIPs) are expressed in many plants. Because of their anti-infectious and anti-proliferative effects, intensive research is going on for applying these toxins in therapy against viral infections or malignancies. Recently, we demonstrated that type I allergy against RIPs from elderberry can occur. OBJECTIVE: Stimulated by our study, a group of RIP researchers reported that some of the employees had suspected allergy to RIPs. METHODS AND RESULTS: We tested their sera in ELISA on natural RIPs. Specific IgE in four subjects were found against dianthin30, gelonin, momordin, PAP-S, saporin, ricin and volkensin. In contrast, asparin and lychnin did not show any IgE binding. When separating extracts of plants containing the toxins in SDS-PAGE, RIPs appeared to be the predominant constituents. Interestingly, among the other plant proteins, they were exclusively recognized by IgE in immunoblot. RIPs derived from close botanical families share high sequence homologies. Nevertheless, in IgE inhibition experiments with human sera, cross-reactivity between RIPs also derived from non-related plants could be demonstrated. CONCLUSION: We conclude that sensitization and IgE induction to RIPs may occur upon exposure. This has to be considered when applying them in therapy against malignancies or viral infections.

Toxicity of xanthine oxidoreductase to malignant B lymphocytes.

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) generated by xanthine oxidoreductase (XOR) were toxic to B lymphoma-derived Raji cells (positive for 8A monoclonal antibody, mAb). The sensitivity of these malignant cells to the hypoxanthine/XOR system was higher than that observed in peripheral human lymphocytes. The understanding of the mechanisms of cytotoxicity induced by XOR-produced ROS is essential in view of a possible clinical application. Cell death mostly had the feature of apoptosis and post-apoptotic necrosis and depended on the activity of XOR. Catalase, but not superoxide dismutase, protected cells from the toxicity of XOR, thus indicating that cell damage depended on the production of hydrogen peroxide. The toxicity of ROS was selectively targeted to malignant Raji cells by antibody-XOR conjugation, either directly, with an 8A-XOR conjugate, or indirectly, with an 8A mAb plus an anti-mouse IgG-XOR. Both direct and indirect immunotoxins induced apoptotic death to target cells in a dose-dependent manner. These conjugates showed no aspecific cytotoxicity in conditions very similar to the ex vivo treatment of cell suspension for bone marrow transplantation. Moreover, the prevalence of apoptotic death over necrosis may reduce the in vivo inflammatory response and its local and systemic consequences, thus becoming relevant in the construction of immunotoxins with therapeutic potential.

CD38 as a target of IB4 mAb carrying saporin-S6: design of an immunotoxin for ex vivo depletion of hematological CD38+ neoplasia.

An anti-CD38 mAb (IB4) coupled to saporin-S6, a type 1 ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP), was designed for ex vivo or loco-regional therapeutical applications in myeloma and lymphoma. The ability of this immunotoxin to eliminate CD38+ cells was studied in vitro on selected CD38+ human cell lines (Raji, HBL6, L540 and CEM) and on CD38+ neoplastic cells from a Non Hodgkin Lymphoma (NHL) patient. HBL6, Raji and L540 cells resulted very sensitive to the IB4/saporin-S6 conjugate, concentrations as low as 100 pM of the immunotoxin completely inhibited protein synthesis. CD38+ neoplastic cells from the NHL patient were completely eliminated after treatment with immunotoxin at 10 nM concentration. CFU-c rescue by bone marrow precursors was maintained after exposure to the immunotoxin. These results indicate that IB4/saporin-S6 is endowed with strong and specific cytotoxic effects on selected CD38+ tumor cells lineages. Consequently, it is reasonable to propose a clinical use of the IB4/saporin-S6 for ex vivo purging of unwanted cells (e.g. depletion of contaminating neoplastic cells in aphereses obtained from G-CSF-treated patients) or for loco-regional therapies of CD38+ tumors.

Interaction of volkensin with HeLa cells: binding, uptake, intracellular localization, degradation and exocytosis.

Among two-chain ribosome-inactivating proteins (RIPs), volkensin is the most toxic to cells and animals, and is retrogradely axonally transported in the rat central nervous system, being an effective suicide transport agent. Here we studied the binding, endocytosis, intracellular routeing, degradation and exocytosis of this RIP. The interaction of volkensin with HeLa cells was compared to that of nigrin b, as an example of a type 2 RIP with low toxicity, and of ricin, as a reference toxin. Nigrin b and volkensin bound to cells with comparable affinity (approx. 10(-10) M) and had a similar number of binding sites (2 x 10(5)/cell), two-log lower than that reported for ricin. The cellular uptake of volkensin was lower than that reported for nigrin b and ricin. Confocal microscopy showed the rapid localization of volkensin in the Golgi stacks with a perinuclear localization similar to that of ricin, while nigrin b was distributed between cytoplasmic dots and the Golgi compartment. Consistently, brefeldin A, which disrupts the Golgi apparatus, protected cells from the inhibition of protein synthesis by volkensin or ricin, whereas it was ineffective in the case of nigrin b. Of the cell-released RIPs, 57% of volkensin and only 5% of ricin were active, whilst exocytosed nigrin b was totally inactive. Despite the low binding to, and uptake by, cells, the high cytotoxicity of volkensin may depend on (i) routeing to the Golgi apparatus, (ii) the low level of degradation, (iii) rapid recycling and (iv) the high percentage of active toxin remaining after exocytosis.

The conjugate Rituximab/saporin-S6 completely inhibits clonogenic growth of CD20-expressing cells and produces a synergistic toxic effect with Fludarabine.

Immunotoxins are chimeric proteins consisting of a toxin coupled to an antibody. To date, several clinical trials have been conducted, and some are still ongoing, to evaluate their anti-tumor efficacy. In this view, we chemically constructed an anti-CD20 immunotoxin with the mAb Rituximab and the type 1 ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP) saporin-S6, designed for B cells non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) therapy. This immunotoxin showed a specific cytotoxicity for the CD20+ cell lines Raji and D430B, evidenced by inhibition of protein synthesis, evaluation of apoptosis and clonogenic assay. Upon conjugation, saporin-S6 increased its toxicity on target cells by at least 2 logs, with IC(50) values of 0.1-0.3 nM. The percentage of AnnexinV+ cells was over 95% in both cell lines treated with 10 nM immunotoxin. A complete elimination of Raji clones was reached with the 10 nM immunotoxin, whereas a mixture of free RIP and mAb gave about 90% of clonogenic growth. Rituximab/saporin-S6, at 10 nM concentration, also induced apoptosis in 80% of lymphoma cells from NHL patients. Moreover, sensitivity of Raji to Rituximab/saporin-S6 was augmented when cells were coincubated with Fludarabine. The synergistic toxic effect of the two drugs led to a total elimination of the neoplastic population.

Expression of CTLA-4 in nonhuman primate lymphocytes and its use as a potential target for specific immunotoxin-mediated apoptosis: results of in vitro studies.

T-cell-mediated immunoregulation is one of the main mechanisms implicated in induction and maintenance of transplantation tolerance. In this regard, deletion or modulation of xeno/alloantigen-specific T cells, as well as blocking of their interactions with other cell populations, are currently being pursued for tolerance induction in humans as well as nonhuman primates. In order to investigate whether cytotoxic T-lymphocyte antigen-4 (CTLA-4) may represent a suitable target for a T cell depletion approach in nonhuman primate models, we analysed CTLA-4 expression in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from nonhuman primates and the potential role of two anti-CTLA-4 saporin-conjugated immunotoxins. The analysis was performed in PBMCs from 8 cynomolgus monkeys from Philippines and from Mauritius both at protein level by flow cytometry and at transcriptional level by RT-PCR. In addition, the apoptotic role of the immunotoxins was investigated. The results showed that CTLA-4 was expressed at variable levels depending on the origin of the cynomolgus monkeys and the resting or activated cell condition. CTLA-4 was not expressed on resting Mauritius PBMCs and showed a lower up-regulation upon PMA/PHA activation compared to the Philippines PBMCs that expressed CTLA-4 also before activation. Two CTLA-4 RNA transcripts (672 and 550 bp) were detected with levels variations after cell stimulation. Two anti-CTLA-4 immunotoxins induced in vitro apoptosis of activated PBMCs from both sources of cynomolgus monkeys. This is the first report that documents CTLA-4 expression both at protein and transcriptional level by nonhuman primate PBMCs and provides novel perspectives of xeno/allograft rejection immunotherapy based on CTLA-4 targeting.

Immunotoxins containing recombinant anti-CTLA-4 single-chain fragment variable antibodies and saporin: in vitro results and in vivo effects in an acute rejection model.

Immunotoxins containing recombinant human-derived single-chain fragment variable (scFv) reagents (83 and 40) against CTLA-4 (CD152) linked to saporin, a ribosome-inactivating protein, were prepared and tested on CD3/CD28-activated T lymphocytes, MLRs, CTLA-4-positive cell lines, and hemopoietic precursors. Immunotoxins induced apoptosis in activated T lymphocytes and were able to specifically inhibit MLR between T lymphocytes and dendritic cells. The 83-saporin immunotoxin also inhibited the T cell activation in an MLR between T lymphocytes and an EBV-positive lymphoblastoid B cell line. Toxicity tests on hemopoietic precursors showed little or no effects in inhibiting colonies' growth. As the 83 scFv Ab was reactive also with activated mouse T lymphocytes, 83-saporin was tested in a model of tumor rejection consisting of C57BL/6 mice bearing a murine H.end endothelioma cell line, derived from DBA/2 mice. The lymphoid infiltration due to the presence of the tumor was reduced to a high extent, demonstrating that the immunotoxin was actually available and active in vivo. Thus, taking the results altogether, this study might represent a new breakthrough for immunotherapy, showing the possibility of targeting CTLA-4 to kill activated T cells, using conjugates containing scFv Abs and type 1 ribosome-inactivating protein.

Ricin toxicity to microglial and monocytic cells.

Microglial cells, like macrophages, are very sensitive to ricin, a galactose-specific toxic lectin belonging to the family of ribosome-inactivating proteins. This toxin can be taken up by most cells through the binding of its B chain to galactose-containing molecules on the cell membrane. In macrophagic cell types it can be internalised also by mannose receptors which are present on the surface of these cells. Endocytosis of the toxin by either pathway was evaluated by ricin toxicity to primary cultures of rat microglial cells and to a microglial N11 cell line in the presence or absence of lactose and mannan, which compete for the endocytosis via the ricin lectin chain or cellular mannose receptors, respectively. Results were compared with those obtained in cultures of mouse macrophages, human monocytes, and a monocytic JM cell line. All cultures were protected from ricin toxicity more by lactose than by mannan, indicating that ricin endocytosis via its lectin B chain is prevalent over that mediated by cellular mannose receptors. However, a partial protection by mannan was observed in all cases but not-stimulated N11 cells, either in the form of direct protection or of significant additional protection over that afforded by lactose. Mannose receptor expression by N11 cells was negative before, and positive after, treatment with endotoxin, as assessed by the specific binding of 125I-mannose-bovine serum albumin. Moreover, a partial protection from ricin toxicity by mannan was induced in the N11 microglial line after stimulation, consistently with an inducible expression of the mannose receptor by activated cells switched towards a microglial phenotype.

Serum xanthine oxidase in human liver disease.

OBJECTIVES: High concentrations of serum xanthine oxidase (XO) have been reported during human liver disease and hepatocyte injury in experimental settings. However, it is unclear whether this elevation reflects hepatocyte necrosis or has a different meaning. METHODS: The serum level of XO in 64 patients with chronic liver disease (17 patients with cirrhosis, 30 with chronic hepatitis, and 17 with cholestatic disorders) and in 12 control subjects was determined by a competitive ELISA. Conventional serum markers of liver damage were assessed in all patients, and grading and staging were scored in the chronic hepatitis group according to Knodell. RESULTS: The XO serum levels were significantly higher in the patients than in the controls. The differences were also significant when controls were compared to patients with chronic hepatitis and cholestatic disorders separately, but not when compared to the cirrhosis group. Patients with cholestatic disorders had XO values higher than those of patients with cirrhosis or chronic hepatitis. XO levels did not correlate with stage and grade in chronic hepatitis group. We found a weak but significant positive correlation in patients between XO serum level and gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase (r = 0.37). This correlation was stronger when chronic hepatitis (r = 0.42) and, especially cholestatic disorders (r = 0.71), were separately tested, but was absent in the cirrhosis group. The XO values positively correlated with alkaline phosphatase in patients with cholestatic disorders. A level of serum XO >32 microg/ml specifically identified cholestatic disorders in our study population. CONCLUSIONS: A marked elevation of serum XO in patients with chronic liver disease seems to reflect the presence of cholestasis. No correlation between XO levels and histological or serum evidence of hepatocyte necrosis was found in these patients.

Reliable sequence determination of ribosome- inactivating proteins by combining electrospray mass spectrometry and Edman degradation.

The primary structure of saporin-S9 and MAP-S, two type-1 ribosome-inactivating proteins isolated from the seeds of Saponaria officinalis L. and Mirabilis jalapa, respectively, was determined using a combined approach based on Edman degradation and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESMS). Saporin-S9 has 253 amino acids with a calculated molecular mass of 28,492.99, which is in good agreement with that determined by ESMS (28 495 +/- 2 Da). Unlike other saporins with known primary structure, saporin-S9 contains four histidinyl residues (positions 111, 121, 216 and 248). By comparing the amino acid sequence of saporin-S9 with that of saporin-S6, we found 22 amino acid substitutions (8.7%), 13 of which are conservative and nine non-conservative. The residues known to be involved in the definition of the active site and with RNA base recognition are conserved. The four histidinyl residues and especially Lys for Gln203 contribute to the higher calculated pI value (10.17) of saporin-S9 compared with saporin-S6 (9.98). MAP-S contains 250 amino acid residues with a calculated molecular mass of 27,789.49, in good agreement with that determined by ESMS (27,789 +/- 2). Cys36 and Cys220 form a disulphide bridge and only four amino acid residues are different from the amino acid sequence of MAP, isolated from the roots of the same plant, i.e. Leu34 (Glu), Ile161 (Leu), Asp185 (Glu) and Asp191 (Glu) (in parentheses, the residues present in MAP). The reported approach can provide rapid and reliable sequence screening in the analysis of homologous proteins, including the presence of disulphide bridges.

Oxidative stress to human lymphocytes by xanthine oxidoreductase activity.

The in vitro toxicity of the reactive oxygen species generating enzyme xanthine oxidoreductase (XOR) to human peripheral blood lymphocytes was studied after stimulation with phytohaemoagglutinin or anti-CD3/CD28 antibodies. Apoptosis and necrosis were induced by the XOR/hypoxanthine system in a time- and concentration-dependent manner. CD8+ lymphocytes showed a higher sensitivity than CD4+ cells to the XOR/hypoxanthine system. The occurrence of apoptosis was demonstrated by annexin-V binding to injured cell membrane, which was the most precocious alteration observed, followed by the increment of transglutaminase activity, which was significant at the lowest XOR concentration used. Nuclear damage was assessed by the increased hypodiploid nuclei and by DNA migration on gel electrophoresis, which turned to an apoptotic pattern before the occurrence of cell membrane necrotic lesions. Apoptosis was induced by XOR activity proportionally to substrate concentration and was prevented by the competitive enzyme inhibitor, allopurinol. The hydrogen peroxide scavenging enzyme, catalase, gave a higher protection than superoxide dismutase from the toxicity caused by the XOR/hypoxanthine system. Necrosis occurs in a variable percentage indicating that reactive oxygen species may trigger both apoptosis and necrosis in proliferating human lymphocytes, mostly depending on XOR concentration.

Polynucleotide:Adenosine glycosidase is the sole activity of ribosome-inactivating proteins on DNA.

Polynucleotide: adenosine glycosidases (PNAG) are a class of plant and bacterial enzymes commonly known as ribosome-inactivating proteins (RIP). They are presently classified as rRNA N-glycosidases in the enzyme nomenclature [EC 3.2.2.22]. Several activities on nucleic acids, other than depurination, have been attributed to PNAG: in particular modifications induced in circular plasmids, including linearisation and topological changes, and cleavage of guanidinic residues. Here we describe a chromatographic procedure to obtain nuclease-free PNAG by dye-chromatography onto Procion Red derivatized Sepharose((R)). Highly purified enzymes depurinate extensively pBR322 circular, supercoiled DNA at neutral pH and exhibit neither DNase nor DNA glycolyase activities, do not cause topological changes, and adenine is the only base released from DNA and rRNA, even at very high enzyme concentrations. A scanning force microscopy (SFM) study of pBR322 treated with saporin-S6 confirmed that (i) this PNAG binds extensively to the plasmid, (ii) the distribution of the bound saporin-S6 molecules along the DNA chain is markedly variable, (iii) plasmids already digested with saporin-S6 do not appear fragmented or topologically modified. The observations here described demonstrate that polynucleotide:adenosine glycosidase is the sole enzymatic activity of the four ribosome-inactivating proteins gelonin, momordin I, pokeweed antiviral protein from seeds and saporin-S6. These proteins belong to different families, suggesting that the findings here described may be generalized to all PNAG.

In vitro anti-tumour activity of anti-CD80 and anti-CD86 immunotoxins containing type 1 ribosome-inactivating proteins.

Immunotoxins specific for the CD80 and CD86 antigens were prepared by linking three type 1 ribosome-inactivating proteins (RIPs), namely bouganin, gelonin and saporin-S6, to the monoclonal antibodies M24 (anti-CD80) and 1G10 (anti-CD86). These immunotoxins showed a specific cytotoxicity for the CD80/CD86-expressing cell lines Raji and L428. The immunotoxins inhibited protein synthesis by target cells with IC50s (concentration causing 50% inhibition) ranging from 0.25 to 192 pmol/l as RIPs. The anti-CD80 immunotoxins appeared 1-2 log more toxic for target cells than the anti-CD86 ones. Immunotoxins containing saporin and bouganin induced apoptosis of target cells. The toxicity for bone marrow haemopoietic progenitors of these conjugates was also evaluated. Bouganin and related immunotoxins at concentrations up to 100 nmol/l did not significantly affect the recovery of committed progenitors or of more primitive cells. The saporin-containing immunotoxins at concentrations >/= 1 nmol/l showed some toxicity on colony-forming unit cells (CFU-C). The expression of the CD80 and CD86 molecules is prevalently restricted to antigen-presenting cells and is also strong on Hodgkin and Reed-Sternberg cells in Hodgkin's disease. Present results suggest that immunotoxins targeting type 1 ribosome-inactivating proteins to these antigens could be considered and further studied for the therapy of Hodgkin's disease or other CD80/CD86-expressing tumours.

Polynucleotide:adenosine glycosidase activity of saporin-L1: effect on various forms of mammalian DNA.

Saporin-L1 from the leaves of Saponaria officinalis belongs to a group of plant polynucleotide:adenosine glycosidases, known as ribosome-inactivating proteins due to their property of depurinating the major rRNA. Previous experiments indicated that saporin-L1 and other ribosome-inactivating proteins depurinate also DNA [Barbieri et al. (1994) Nature 372, 324; and (1996) Biochem. J. 319, 507-513]. Here we describe the effects of highly purified nuclease-free saporin-L1 on mammalian nuclear and mitochondrial DNA. Saporin-L1 had less activity on mitochondrial DNA than on nuclear DNA. A low, although significant, depurination of both chromatin and whole nuclei was observed. Mitochondrial nucleic acids are heavily depurinated in intact mitochondria, although the contribute of mtDNA to the deadenylation events is not known. The kinetic constants for several substrates were determined.

Polynucleotide: adenosine glycosidase activity of immunotoxins containing ribosome-inactivating proteins.

Polynucleotide:adenosine glycosidases (rRNA N-glycosidases, EC 3.2.2.22, more commonly known as ribosome-inactivating proteins, RIP) are a numerous family of plant and bacterial enzymes, shown to release also adenine from DNA in vitro. They are well suited for the preparation of specifically toxic conjugates with several carriers, including monoclonal antibodies (immunotoxins). Here we show that (i) immunotoxins containing various PNAG (dianthin, gelonin, momordin I, PAP-S, PDS-2, ricin A-chain, saporin-L1, saporin-S6) all act on DNA; (ii) activity on DNA in vitro is less compromised by disulphide linkage to antibody than is inhibition of cell-free protein translation; and (iii) specific cytotoxicity of immunotoxin does not correlate with substrate specificity.

An Epstein-Barr virus-infected lymphoblastoid cell line (D430B) that grows in SCID-mice with the morphologic features of a CD30+ anaplastic large cell lymphoma, and is sensitive to anti-CD30 immunotoxins.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: In this study we describe a newly established CD30+ Epstein Barr virus (EBV)-infected B cell line derived from an EBV-infected B cell culture (utilized, once irradiated, as a feeder) which showed a B clonal rearrangement and strong CD30 antigen expression. DESIGN AND METHODS: The cells injected into SCID mice were able to grow giving rise to CD30+ solid tumors with the morphologic features of an anaplastic large cell lymphoma (ALCL). Thus we tried to establish a model to investigate the potency of immunoconjugates containing a CD30 monoclonal antibody (Ber-H2) and ribosome-inactivating proteins (saporin, momordin and ricin A-chain) as toxic moieties. RESULTS: We observed a strong cytotoxic activity of the anti-CD30 immunotoxins on the in vitro growth of D430B cells. High levels of anti-tumor activity were also observed in vivo, in the SCID mouse model. INTERPRETATION AND CONCLUSIONS: The antitumor immunotoxin therapy was sccessful in our chosen animal model, the effecacy seeming to be associated with strength of CD30 expression. Our data suggest that immunotoxins should be tested (before use) on the tumor cells of the subject to be treated and that immunotoxins should be directed to different tumor-associated antigens to avoid selection of cell populations with different antigenic mosaics.