Uncovering DUB Selectivity through an Ion Mobility-Based Assessment of Ubiquitin Chain Isomers.

Ubiquitination is a reversible post-translational modification that maintains cellular homeostasis and regulates protein turnover. Deubiquitinases (DUBs) are a large family of proteases that catalyze the removal of ubiquitin (Ub) along with the dismantling and editing of Ub chains. Assessing the activity and selectivity of DUBs is critical for defining physiological functions. Despite numerous methods for evaluating DUB activity, none are capable of assessing activity and selectivity in the context of multicomponent mixtures of native unlabeled Ub conjugates. Here, we report an ion mobility (IM)-based approach for measuring DUB selectivity in the context of unlabeled mixtures of Ub chains. We show that IM-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) can be used to assess the selectivity of DUBs in a time-dependent manner. Moreover, using the branched Ub chain selective DUB UCH37/UCHL5 along with a mixture of Ub trimers, a strong preference for branched Ub trimers bearing K6 and K48 linkages is revealed. Our results demonstrate that IM-MS is a powerful method for evaluating DUB selectivity under conditions more physiologically relevant than single-component mixtures.

Uncovering DUB Selectivity Through Ion-Mobility-Based Assessment of Ubiquitin Chain Isomers.

Ubiquitination is a reversible posttranslational modification that maintains cellular homeostasis and regulates protein turnover. Deubiquitinases (DUBs) are a large family of proteases that catalyze the removal of ubiquitin (Ub) along with the dismantling and editing of Ub chains. Assessing the activity and selectivity of DUBs is critical for defining physiological function. Despite numerous methods for evaluating DUB activity, none are capable of assessing activity and selectivity in the context of multicomponent mixtures of native, unlabeled ubiquitin conjugates. Here we report on an ion mobility (IM)-based approach for measuring DUB selectivity in the context of unlabeled mixtures of Ub chains. We show that IM-MS can be used to assess the selectivity of DUBs in a time-dependent manner. Moreover, using the branched Ub chain selective DUB UCH37/UCHL5 along with a mixture of Ub trimers, a strong preference for branched Ub trimers bearing K6 and K48 linkages is revealed. Our results demonstrate that IM coupled with mass spectrometry (IM-MS) is a powerful method for evaluating DUB selectivity under conditions more physiologically relevant than single component mixtures.

Quantitative Analysis of Diubiquitin Isomers Using Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry.

The diversity of ubiquitin modifications calls for methods to better characterize ubiquitin chain linkage, length, and morphology. Here, we use multiple linear regression analysis coupled with ion mobility mass spectrometry (IM-MS) to quantify the relative abundance of different ubiquitin dimer isomers. We demonstrate the utility and robustness of this approach by quantifying the relative abundance of different ubiquitin dimers in complex mixtures and comparing the results to the standard, bottom-up ubiquitin AQUA method. Our results provide a foundation for using multiple linear regression analysis and IM-MS to characterize more complex ubiquitin chain architectures.

A Strategy for Accessing Nanobody-Based Electrochemical Sensors for Analyte Detection in Complex Media.

Nanobodies are single variable domain antibodies isolated from camelids and are rapidly distinguishing themselves as ideal recognition elements in biosensors due to their comparative stability, ease of production and isolation, and high binding affinities. However, transducing analyte binding by nanobodies in real time is challenging, as most nanobodies do not directly produce an optical or electrical signal upon target recognition. Here, we report a general strategy to fabricate sensitive and selective electrochemical sensors incorporating nanobodies for detecting target analytes in heterogeneous media, such as cell lysate. Graphite felt can be covalently functionalized with recombinant HaloTag-modified nanobodies. Subsequent encapsulation with a thin layer of a hydrogel using a vapor deposition process affords encapsulated electrodes that directly display a decrease in current upon antigen binding, without added redox mediators. Differential pulse voltammetry affords clear and consistent decreases in electrode current across multiple electrode samples for specific antigen concentrations. The change in observed current vs increasing antigen concentration follows Langmuir binding characteristics, as expected. Importantly, selective and repeatable target binding in unpurified cell lysate is only demonstrated by the encapsulated electrode, with an antigen detection limit of ca. 30 pmol, whereas bare electrodes lacking encapsulation produce numerous false positive signals in control experiments.

Ubiquitination drives COPI priming and Golgi SNARE localization.

Deciphering mechanisms controlling SNARE localization within the Golgi complex is crucial to understanding protein trafficking patterns within the secretory pathway. SNAREs are also thought to prime coatomer protein I (COPI) assembly to ensure incorporation of these essential cargoes into vesicles, but the regulation of these events is poorly understood. Here, we report roles for ubiquitin recognition by COPI in SNARE trafficking and in stabilizing interactions between Arf, COPI, and Golgi SNAREs in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The ability of COPI to bind ubiquitin, but not the dilysine motif, through its N-terminal WD repeat domain of ß'-COP or through an unrelated ubiquitin-binding domain is essential for the proper localization of Golgi SNAREs Bet1 and Gos1. We find that COPI, the ArfGAP Glo3, and multiple Golgi SNAREs are ubiquitinated. Notably, the binding of Arf and COPI to Gos1 is markedly enhanced by ubiquitination of these components. Glo3 is proposed to prime COPI-SNARE interactions; however, Glo3 is not enriched in the ubiquitin-stabilized SNARE-Arf-COPI complex but is instead enriched with COPI complexes that lack SNAREs. These results support a new model for how posttranslational modifications drive COPI priming events crucial for Golgi SNARE localization.

Immobilization of Nanobodies with Vapor-Deposited Polymer Encapsulation for Robust Biosensors.

To produce next-generation, shelf-stable biosensors for point-of-care diagnostics, a combination of rugged biomolecular recognition elements, efficient encapsulants, and innocuous deposition approaches is needed. Furthermore, to ensure that the sensitivity and specificity that are inherent to biological recognition elements are maintained in solid-state biosensing systems, site-specific immobilization chemistries must be invoked such that the function of the biomolecule remains unperturbed. In this work, we present a widely applicable strategy to develop robust solid-state biosensors using emergent nanobody (Nb) recognition elements coupled with a vapor-deposited polymer encapsulation layer. As compared to conventional immunoglobulin G antibodies, Nbs are smaller (12-15 kDa as opposed to ~150 kDa), have higher thermal stability and pH tolerance, boast greater ease of recombinant production, and are capable of binding antigens with high affinity and specificity. Photoinitiated chemical vapor deposition affords thin, protective polymer barrier layers over immobilized Nb arrays that allow for retention of Nb activity and specificity after both storage under ambient conditions and complete desiccation. Most importantly, we also demonstrate that vapor-deposited polymer encapsulation of Nb arrays enables specific detection of target proteins in complex heterogeneous samples, such as unpurified cell lysate, which is otherwise challenging to achieve with bare Nb arrays.

Real-Time and Label-Free Measurement of Deubiquitinase Activity with a MspA Nanopore.

Covalently attaching ubiquitin (Ub) to cellular proteins as a post-translational modification can result in altered function of modified proteins. Enzymes regulating Ub as a post-translational modification, such as ligases and deubiquitinases, are challenging to characterize in part due to the low throughput of in-vitro assays. Single-molecule nanopore based assays have the advantage of detecting proteins with high specificity and resolution, and in a label-free, real-time fashion. Here we demonstrate the use of a MspA nanopore for discriminating and quantifying Ub proteins. We further applied the MspA pore to measure the Ub-chain disassembly activity of UCH37, a proteasome associated deubiquitinase. The implementation of this MspA system into nanopore arrays could enable high throughput characterizations of unknown deubiquitinases as well as drug screening against disease related enzymes.

The ubiquitin proteoform problem.

The diversity of ubiquitin modifications is immense. A protein can be monoubiquitylated, multi-monoubiquitylated, and polyubiquitylated with chains varying in size and shape. Ubiquitin itself can be adorned with other ubiquitin-like proteins and smaller functional groups. Considering different combinations of post-translational modifications can give rise to distinct biological outcomes, characterizing ubiquitylated proteoforms of a given protein is paramount. In this Opinion, we review recent advances in detecting and quantifying various ubiquitin proteoforms using mass spectrometry.

Proteasome-Bound UCH37/UCHL5 Debranches Ubiquitin Chains to Promote Degradation.

The linkage, length, and architecture of ubiquitin (Ub) chains are all important variables in providing tight control over many biological paradigms. There are clear roles for branched architectures in regulating proteasome-mediated degradation, but the proteins that selectively recognize and process these atypical chains are unknown. Here, using synthetic and enzyme-derived ubiquitin chains along with intact mass spectrometry, we report that UCH37/UCHL5, a proteasome-associated deubiquitinase, cleaves K48 branched chains. The activity and selectivity toward branched chains is markedly enhanced by the proteasomal Ub receptor RPN13/ADRM1. Using reconstituted proteasome complexes, we find that chain debranching promotes degradation of substrates modified with branched chains under multi-turnover conditions. These results are further supported by proteome-wide pulse-chase experiments, which show that the loss of UCH37 activity impairs global protein turnover. Our work therefore defines UCH37 as a debranching deubiquitinase important for promoting proteasomal degradation.

Quantitative Middle-Down MS Analysis of Parkin-Mediated Ubiquitin Chain Assembly.

Misregulation of the E3 ubiquitin ligase Parkin and the kinase PINK1 underlie both inherited and idiopathic Parkinson's disease-associated neurodegeneration. Parkin and PINK1 work together to catalyze the assembly of ubiquitin chains on substrates located on the outer mitochondrial membrane to facilitate autophagic removal of damaged mitochondria through a process termed mitophagy. Quantitative measurements of Parkin-mediated chain assembly, both in vitro and on mitochondria, have revealed that chains are composed of Lys6, Lys11, Lys48, and Lys63 linkages. The combinatorial nature of these chains is further expanded by the ability of PINK1 to phosphorylate individual subunits. The precise architecture of chains produced by the coordinated action of PINK1 and Parkin, however, are unknown. Here, we demonstrate that quantitative middle-down mass spectrometry using uniformly 15N-labeled ubiquitin variants as internal standards informs on the extent of chain branching. We find that Parkin is a prolific branching enzyme in vitro. Quantitative middle-down mass spectrometry also reveals that phospho-Ser65-ubiquitin (pSer65-Ub)-a key activator of Parkin-is not incorporated into chains to a significant extent. Our results suggest that Parkin-mediated chain branching is "on-pathway", and branch points are the principal targets of the deubiquitinase USP30.

Synthesis of Branched Triubiquitin Active-Site Directed Probes.

Active-site directed probes are powerful tools for studying the ubiquitin conjugation and deconjugation machinery. Branched ubiquitin chains have emerged as important proteasome-targeting signals for aggregation-prone proteins and cell cycle regulators. By implementing a new synthetic strategy for the electrophilic warhead, we herein report on the generation and reactivity of a series of branched triubiquitin active-site directed probes. These new tools can be used to dissect the molecular basis of branched chain assembly and disassembly.

Enzymatic Logic of Ubiquitin Chain Assembly.

Protein ubiquitination impacts virtually every biochemical pathway in eukaryotic cells. The fate of a ubiquitinated protein is largely dictated by the type of ubiquitin modification with which it is decorated, including a large variety of polymeric chains. As a result, there have been intense efforts over the last two decades to dissect the molecular details underlying the synthesis of ubiquitin chains by ubiquitin-conjugating (E2) enzymes and ubiquitin ligases (E3s). In this review, we highlight these advances. We discuss the evidence in support of the alternative models of transferring one ubiquitin at a time to a growing substrate-linked chain (sequential addition model) versus transferring a pre-assembled ubiquitin chain (en bloc model) to a substrate. Against this backdrop, we outline emerging principles of chain assembly: multisite interactions, distinct mechanisms of chain initiation and elongation, optimal positioning of ubiquitin molecules that are ultimately conjugated to each other, and substrate-assisted catalysis. Understanding the enzymatic logic of ubiquitin chain assembly has important biomedical implications, as the misregulation of many E2s and E3s and associated perturbations in ubiquitin chain formation contribute to human disease. The resurgent interest in bifunctional small molecules targeting pathogenic proteins to specific E3s for polyubiquitination and subsequent degradation provides an additional incentive to define the mechanisms responsible for efficient and specific chain synthesis and harness them for therapeutic benefit.

Reprogramming a Deubiquitinase into a Transamidase.

Access to well-defined ubiquitin conjugates has been key to elucidating the biochemical functions of proteins in the ubiquitin signaling network. Yet, we have a poor understanding of how deubiquitinases and ubiquitin-binding proteins respond to ubiquitin modifications when anchored to a protein other than ubiquitin or a ubiquitin-like protein. This is due to the difficulty of synthesizing ubiquitinated proteins comprised of native isopeptide bonds. Here we report on the evolution of a deubiquitinase capable of site-specifically modifying itself with defined ubiquitin chains. Following mutagenesis and yeast display screening, we identify a variant of the yeast ubiquitin C-terminal hydrolase Yuh1 that has a 28-fold improvement in the transamidation to hydrolysis ratio relative to the wild type enzyme. The switch in activity enables robust autoubiquitination of a lysine in the crossover loop to form an isopeptide bond. We demonstrate the utility of autoubiquitinating the evolved Yuh1 variant by investigating the consequences of ubiquitin chain anchoring on the activities of other deubiquitinases. Much to our surprise, we find that certain deubiquitinases are exquisitely sensitive to chain anchoring. These results highlight the importance of investigating the biochemical activities of deubiquitinases with both substrate-anchored and unanchored ubiquitin chains.

A fluorescence polarization-based competition assay for measuring interactions between unlabeled ubiquitin chains and UCH37•RPN13.

Ubiquitin chains regulate distinct signaling events through cooperative interactions with effector proteins and deubiquitinases. Measuring the strength of these interactions is often challenging; either large amounts of material are required or one of the binding partners must be labeled for detection. We sought to develop a label-free method for measuring binding of ubiquitin chains to the proteasome-associated deubiquitinase UCH37 and its binding partner RPN13. The method we describe here is based on a fluorescence polarization competition (FPcomp) assay in which fluorescent monoubiquitin is competed off the UCH37•RPN13 complex by the addition of unlabeled ubiquitin chains. We show that the UCH37•RPN13 complex displays higher affinity toward chains with more than two ubiquitin subunits. Removing the ubiquitin-binding PRU domain of RPN13 does not change affinities. These results suggest UCH37•RPN13 acts to selectively recruit proteins modified with long chains (>2 subunits) to the proteasome for degradation. We also demonstrate that the FPcomp assay is suitable for high-throughput screening, which is important considering both UCH37 and RPN13 are potential targets for cancer therapy.

Ubiquitin Chain Enrichment Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry (UbiChEM-MS) Reveals Cell-Cycle Dependent Formation of Lys11/Lys48 Branched Ubiquitin Chains.

The dynamics of cellular signaling events are tightly regulated by a diverse set of ubiquitin chains. Recent work has suggested that branched ubiquitin chains composed of Lys11 and Lys48 isopeptide linkages play a critical role in regulating cell cycle progression. Yet, endogenous Lys11/Lys48 branched chains could not be detected. By combining a Lys11 linkage specific antibody with high-resolution middle-down mass spectrometry (an approach termed UbiChEM-MS) we sought to identify endogenous Lys11/Lys48 branched ubiquitin chains in cells. Using asynchronous cells, we find that Lys11-linked branched chains can only be detected upon cotreatment with a proteasome and nonselective deubiquitinase inhibitor. Releasing cells from mitotic arrest results in a marked accumulation of Lys11/Lys48 branched chains in which branch points represent ∼3-4% of the total ubiquitin population. This report highlights the utility of UbiChEM-MS in characterizing the architecture of Lys11 Ub chains under various cellular conditions and corroborates the formation of Lys11/Lys48 branched chains during mitosis.

Determining Atomistic SAXS Models of Tri-Ubiquitin Chains from Bayesian Analysis of Accelerated Molecular Dynamics Simulations.

Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) has become an increasingly popular technique for characterizing the solution ensemble of flexible biomolecules. However, data resulting from SAXS is typically low-dimensional and is therefore difficult to interpret without additional structural knowledge. In theory, molecular dynamics (MD) trajectories can provide this information, but conventional simulations rarely sample the complete ensemble. Here, we demonstrate that accelerated MD simulations can be used to produce higher quality models in shorter time scales than standard simulations, and we present an iterative Bayesian Monte Carlo method that is able to identify multistate ensembles without overfitting. This methodology is applied to several ubiquitin trimers to demonstrate the effect of linkage type on the solution states of the signaling protein. We observe that the linkage site directly affects the solution flexibility of the trimer and theorize that this difference in plasticity contributes to their disparate roles in vivo.

Ubiquitin Chain Enrichment Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry Enables Characterization of Branched Ubiquitin Chains in Cellulo.

Ubiquitin (Ub) has a broad functional range that has been ascribed to the formation of an array of polymeric ubiquitin chains. Understanding the precise roles of ubiquitin chains, however, is difficult due to their complex chain topologies. Branched ubiquitin chains are particularly challenging, as multiple modifications on a single ubiquitin preclude the use of standard bottom-up proteomic approaches. Developing methods to overcome these challenges is crucial considering evidence suggesting branched chains regulate the stability of proteins. In this study, we employ Ubiquitin Chain Enrichment Middle-down Mass Spectrometry (UbiChEM-MS) to identify branched chains that cannot be detected using bottom-up proteomic methods. Specifically, we employ tandem ubiquitin binding entities (TUBEs) and the K29-selective Npl4 Zinc Finger 1 (NZF1) domain from the deubiquitinase TRABID to enrich for chains from human cells. Minimal trypsinolysis followed by high resolution mass spectrometric analysis reveals that Ub chain branching can indeed be detected using both Ub binding domains (UBDs) tested at endogenous levels. We find that ∼1% of chains isolated with TUBEs contain Ub branch points, with this value rising to ∼4% after proteasome inhibition. Electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) analysis indicates the presence of K48 in these branched chains. The use of the NZF1 domain reveals that ∼4% of the isolated chains contain branch points with no apparent dependence on proteasome inhibition. Our results demonstrate an effective strategy for detecting and characterizing the dynamics of branched conjugates under different cellular conditions.

Selenocysteine as a Latent Bioorthogonal Electrophilic Probe for Deubiquitylating Enzymes.

Deubiquitylating enzymes (DUBs) remove ubiquitin (Ub) from various cellular proteins and render eukaryotic ubiquitylation a dynamic process. The misregulation of protein ubiquitylation is associated with many human diseases, and there is an urgent need to identify specific DUBs associated with therapeutically relevant targets of Ub. We report the development of two facile selenocysteine-based strategies to generate the DUB probe dehydroalanine (Dha). Optimized oxidative or alkylative elimination of Se yielded Dha at the C-terminus of Ub. The high utility of alkylative elimination, which is compatible with multiple thiols in Ub targets, was demonstrated by generating a probe derived from the Ub ligase tripartite motif protein 25 (TRIM-25). Successful capture of the TRIM-25-associated DUB, ubiquitin-specific protease 15, demonstrated the versatility of our chemical strategy for identifying target-specific DUBs.

Subunit-Specific Labeling of Ubiquitin Chains by Using Sortase: Insights into the Selectivity of Deubiquitinases.

Information embedded in different ubiquitin chains is transduced by proteins with ubiquitin-binding domains (UBDs) and erased by a set of hydrolytic enzymes referred to as deubiquitinases (DUBs). Understanding the selectivity of UBDs and DUBs is necessary for decoding the functions of different ubiquitin chains. Critical to these efforts is the access to chemically defined ubiquitin chains bearing site-specific fluorescent labels. One approach toward constructing such molecules involves peptide ligation by sortase (SrtA), a bacterial transpeptidase responsible for covalently attaching cell surface proteins to the cell wall. Here, we demonstrate the utility of SrtA in modifying individual subunits of ubiquitin chains. Using ubiquitin derivatives in which an N-terminal glycine is unveiled after protease-mediated digestion, we synthesized ubiquitin dimers, trimers, and tetramers with different isopeptide linkages. SrtA was then used in combination with fluorescent depsipeptide substrates to effect the modification of each subunit in a chain. By constructing branched ubiquitin chains with individual subunits tagged with a fluorophore, we provide evidence that the ubiquitin-specific protease USP15 prefers ubiquitin trimers but has little preference for a particular isopeptide linkage. Our results emphasize the importance of subunit-specific labeling of ubiquitin chains when studying how DUBs process these chains.