Avidity maturation of anti-citrullinated protein antibodies in rheumatoid arthritis.

OBJECTIVE: Anti-citrullinated protein antibodies (ACPAs) are highly specific for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and are present years before the onset of symptoms. The avidity of autoantibodies can have a strong impact on their effector potency. This study was undertaken to analyze the avidity of ACPAs in serum samples obtained from ACPA-positive healthy individuals (predisease), patients with early disease, and patients with established RA as well as the avidity maturation over time in samples from healthy subjects who later developed RA. METHODS: We measured ACPA avidity in serum samples from ACPA-positive healthy individuals, symptomatic individuals, and patients with established RA in 5 collections from The Netherlands, Canada, and Austria. We determined the dynamics of avidity maturation of ACPAs from the predisease stage to established disease in 1 case from the native North American population and in 10 cases from a Dutch blood donor cohort. RESULTS: The overall ACPA response was characterized by low-avidity antibodies. Higher-avidity ACPAs were observed in symptomatic patients only, while low-avidity ACPAs were observed in both healthy subjects and patients. In longitudinal samples obtained from subjects prior to disease onset, ACPA avidity increased over time until disease onset. No further avidity maturation was observed after disease onset. CONCLUSION: Our findings indicate that avidity maturation of the ACPA response takes place prior to disease onset.

Anti-citrullinated protein antibodies have a low avidity compared with antibodies against recall antigens.

OBJECTIVES: Anti-citrullinated protein antibodies (ACPA) are highly specific for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and have been implicated in disease pathogenesis. Recent ongoing evidence indicates that the ACPA response broadens before precipitation of full-blown RA, as indicated by a more extensive isotype usage and an increased citrullinated epitope recognition profile. Nonetheless, the evolution of the ACPA response is still poorly understood and might intrinsically differ from the protective responses against pathogens. METHODS: The avidity and the avidity maturation of ACPA in relation to the avidity of antibodies against recall antigens were analysed. RESULTS: The avidity of ACPA was significantly lower than the avidity of antibodies to the recall antigens tetanus toxoid and diptheria toxoid. Moreover, ACPA did not show avidity maturation during longitudinal follow-up and ACPA avidity was also relatively low in patients who displayed extensive isotype switching. CONCLUSIONS: These observations indicate that the natural evolution of ACPA differs from the development of antibodies against recall antigens. These data also indicate that ACPA avidity maturation and isotype switching are disconnected, whereby extensive isotype switching occurs in the setting of restricted avidity maturation. Intrinsic differences between the RA-specific autoantibody system and protective antibody responses against pathogens could be of relevance for designing novel B cell-targeted therapies for RA.