Food for thought: Opportunities to target carbon metabolism in antibacterial drug discovery.

Antimicrobial resistance is at an all-time high and new drugs are required to overcome this crisis. Traditional approaches to drug discovery have failed to produce novel classes of antibiotics, with only a few currently in development. It is thought that novel classes will come from antibacterial drug discovery efforts that focus on unconventional targets. One such collection of antibacterial targets are those that comprise central carbon metabolism. Targets of this kind have been largely overlooked because conventional antibacterial testing media are ill-suited for exploring carbon source utilization. Nevertheless, as a consequence of infection, bacteria must find a carbon source in order to survive. Here, we review what is known about the carbon sources available and used by bacteria in different host infection sites. We also look at discovery efforts targeting central carbon metabolism and evaluate how these processes can influence antibiotic efficacy.

Synthetic Genetic Interactions Reveal a Dense and Cryptic Regulatory Network of Small Noncoding RNAs in Escherichia coli.

Over the past 20 years, we have learned that bacterial small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs) can rapidly effect changes in gene expression in response to stress. However, the broader role and impact of sRNA-mediated regulation in promoting bacterial survival has remained elusive. Indeed, there are few examples where disruption of sRNA-mediated gene regulation results in a discernible change in bacterial growth or survival. The lack of phenotypes attributable to loss of sRNA function suggests that either sRNAs are wholly dispensable or functional redundancies mask the impact of deleting a single sRNA. We investigated synthetic genetic interactions among sRNA genes in Escherichia coli by constructing pairwise deletions in 54 genes, including 52 sRNAs. Some 1,373 double deletion strains were studied for growth defects under 32 different nutrient stress conditions and revealed 1,131 genetic interactions. In one example, we identified a profound synthetic lethal interaction between ArcZ and CsrC when E. coli was grown on pyruvate, lactate, oxaloacetate, or d-/l-alanine, and we provide evidence that the expression of ppsA is dysregulated in the double deletion background, causing the conditionally lethal phenotype. This work employs a unique platform for studying sRNA-mediated gene regulation and sheds new light on the genetic network of sRNAs that underpins bacterial growth. IMPORTANCE sRNAs have long been purported to be a critical mechanism by which bacteria respond to stress; however, uncovering growth phenotypes for sRNA deletion strains in E. coli and related bacteria has proven particularly challenging. In contrast, the deletion of hfq, a chaperone required for the activity of many sRNAs in E. coli, results in striking growth defects in E. coli under a variety of medium conditions and chemical stressors. Here, we examined the importance of hfq and sRNA deletion strains for E. coli growth in nutrient-limited medium supplemented with 30 different carbon sources. We then systematically combined sRNA deletion mutations, creating a library of 1,373 sRNA double deletion strains, which we screened for growth under the same conditions, yielding 43,936 individual growth measurements. Our data uncovered more than 1,000 growth phenotypes for sRNA double deletion strains, shedding light on complicated networks of sRNA regulation that underpin bacterial survival under nutrient stress.

Gene Dispensability in Escherichia coli Grown in Thirty Different Carbon Environments.

Central metabolism is a topic that has been studied for decades, and yet, this process is still not fully understood in Escherichia coli, perhaps the most amenable and well-studied model organism in biology. To further our understanding, we used a high-throughput method to measure the growth kinetics of each of 3,796 E. coli single-gene deletion mutants in 30 different carbon sources. In total, there were 342 genes (9.01%) encompassing a breadth of biological functions that showed a growth phenotype on at least 1 carbon source, demonstrating that carbon metabolism is closely linked to a large number of processes in the cell. We identified 74 genes that showed low growth in 90% of conditions, defining a set of genes which are essential in nutrient-limited media, regardless of the carbon source. The data are compiled into a Web application, Carbon Phenotype Explorer (CarPE), to facilitate easy visualization of growth curves for each mutant strain in each carbon source. Our experimental data matched closely with the predictions from the EcoCyc metabolic model which uses flux balance analysis to predict growth phenotypes. From our comparisons to the model, we found that, unexpectedly, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (ppc) was required for robust growth in most carbon sources other than most trichloroacetic acid (TCA) cycle intermediates. We also identified 51 poorly annotated genes that showed a low growth phenotype in at least 1 carbon source, which allowed us to form hypotheses about the functions of these genes. From this list, we further characterized the ydhC gene and demonstrated its role in adenosine efflux.IMPORTANCE While there has been much study of bacterial gene dispensability, there is a lack of comprehensive genome-scale examinations of the impact of gene deletion on growth in different carbon sources. In this context, a lot can be learned from such experiments in the model microbe Escherichia coli where much is already understood and there are existing tools for the investigation of carbon metabolism and physiology (1). Gene deletion studies have practical potential in the field of antibiotic drug discovery where there is emerging interest in bacterial central metabolism as a target for new antibiotics (2). Furthermore, some carbon utilization pathways have been shown to be critical for initiating and maintaining infection for certain pathogens and sites of infection (3-5). Here, with the use of high-throughput solid medium phenotyping methods, we have generated kinetic growth measurements for 3,796 genes under 30 different carbon source conditions. This data set provides a foundation for research that will improve our understanding of genes with unknown function, aid in predicting potential antibiotic targets, validate and advance metabolic models, and help to develop our understanding of E. coli metabolism.

Nutrient Stress Small-Molecule Screening Platform for Escherichia coli.

Clinically approved antibiotics target a narrow spectrum of cellular processes, namely cell wall synthesis, DNA replication, and protein synthesis. Numerous screens have been designed to identify inhibitors that target one of these cellular processes. Indeed, this narrow range of drug mechanisms and a reliance on chemical classes discovered many decades ago are thought to be principally responsible for the current crisis of antibiotic drug resistance. Seeking to expand the target base of antibacterial drug discovery, we developed a nutrient stress screening platform that identifies inhibitors of the growth of in Escherichia coli under nutrient limitation. Under nutrient stress, bacteria require an expanded biosynthetic capacity that includes the synthesis of amino acids, vitamins, and nucleobases. Growing evidence suggests that these processes may be indispensable to certain pathogens and at particular sites of infection. Indeed, more than 100 biosynthetic enzymes become indispensable to E. coli grown under nutrient stress in vitro. The screening platform described here puts a focus on these novel targets for new antibiotics and prioritizes growth inhibitory compounds that can be suppressed by individual nutrients and pools thereof.

Disruption of key NADH-binding pocket residues of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis InhA affects DD-CoA binding ability.

Tuberculosis (TB) is a global health problem that affects over 10 million people. There is an urgent need to develop novel antimicrobial therapies to combat TB. To achieve this, a thorough understanding of key validated drug targets is required. The enoyl reductase InhA, responsible for synthesis of essential mycolic acids in the mycobacterial cell wall, is the target for the frontline anti-TB drug isoniazid. To better understand the activity of this protein a series of mutants, targeted to the NADH co-factor binding pocket were created. Residues P193 and W222 comprise a series of hydrophobic residues surrounding the cofactor binding site and mutation of both residues negatively affect InhA function. Construction of an M155A mutant of InhA results in increased affinity for NADH and DD-CoA turnover but with a reduction in Vmax for DD-CoA, impairing overall activity. This suggests that NADH-binding geometry of InhA likely permits long-range interactions between residues in the NADH-binding pocket to facilitate substrate turnover in the DD-CoA binding region of the protein. Understanding the precise details of substrate binding and turnover in InhA and how this may affect protein-protein interactions may facilitate the development of improved inhibitors enabling the development of novel anti-TB drugs.