A review of environmental odor quantification and qualification methods: The question of objectivity in sensory analysis.

For several years, various issues have up surged linked to odor nuisances with impacts on health and economic concerns. As awareness grew, recent development in instrumental techniques and sensorial analysis have emerged offering efficient and complementary approaches regarding environmental odor monitoring and control. While chemical analysis faces several obstacles, the sensory approach can help overcome them. Therefore, this latter may be considered as subjective, putting the reliability of the studies at risk. This paper is a review of the most commonly sensory methodology used for quantitative and qualitative environmental assessment of odor intensity (OI), odor concentration (OC), odor nature (ON) and hedonic tone (HT). For each of these odor dimensions, the assessment techniques are presented and compared: panel characteristics are discussed; laboratory and field studies are considered and the objectivity of the results is debated. For odor quantification, the use of a reference scale for OI assessment offers less subjectivity than other techniques but at the expense of ease-of-use. For OC assessment, the use of dynamic olfactometry was shown to be the least biased. For odor qualification, the ON description was less subjective when a reference-based lexicon was used but at the expense of simplicity, cost, and lesser panel-training requirements. Only when assessing HT was subjectivity an accepted feature because it reflects the impacted communities' acceptance of odorous emissions. For all discussed dimensions, field studies were shown to be the least biased due to the absence of air sampling, except for OC, where the dispersion modeling approach also showed great potential. In conclusion, this paper offers the reader a guide for environmental odor sensory analysis with the capacity to choose among different methods depending on the study nature, expectations, and capacities.

Objective odor analysis of incidentally emitted compounds using the Langage des Nez® method: application to the industrial zone of Le Havre.

Environmental odor studies are usually done using two approaches: nuisance impact assessment and source identification. The latter may be done using chemical analysis or sensory analysis. While sensory analyses offer many advantages, they also face the main obstacle: odor nature description still uses conventional methods based on subjective evocations as odor descriptors. This makes the sensory method ineffective especially when the expected outcome is the source identification in the context of an industrial accident. This work wants to fulfill this gap proposing to build an objective database including the odor nature description of selected potentially emitted compounds using a promising approach: the Langage des Nez® (LdN). Using definite odorous compounds as odor referents, this work provides the odor nature description of 44 compounds, reported as potential incidentally released chemical compounds in the industrial zone of Le Havre. The city of Le Havre, France, was chosen as a model due to a history of odorous emissions of industrial origins. A trained panel described the odor of each compound using up to three referents of the LdN referents collection and attributed a score to each referent. A data analysis method was developed based on the frequency of citation of the referents and the attributed scores allowing the categorization of each compound in three types of consensus categories. The data analysis results showed that around 80% of compounds were described with a good consensus, showing the LdN as a well-adapted lexicon. This study does not point to any correlation between the chemical structures of the compounds of interest and their relative referents. When compared to conventional methods, LdN revealed a more objective and precise approach. The proposed experimental method and the results provided in this work offer the first insight for time-efficient approaches to objectively describe environmental odors, especially potentially emitted odors during incidents. This work may be supplemented by abatement and mixture effect investigations for a complete understanding of odor dispersion.

Comparison of the chemical composition of aerosols from heated tobacco products, electronic cigarettes and tobacco cigarettes and their toxic impacts on the human bronchial epithelial BEAS-2B cells.

The electronic cigarettes (e-cigs) and more recently the heated tobacco products (HTP) provide alternatives for smokers as they are generally perceived to be less harmful than conventional cigarettes. However, it is crucial to compare the health risks of these different emergent devices, in order to determine which product should be preferred to substitute cigarette. The present study aimed to compare the composition of emissions from HTP, e-cigs and conventional cigarettes, regarding selected harmful or potentially harmful compounds, and their toxic impacts on the human bronchial epithelial BEAS-2B cells. The HTP emitted less polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and carbonyls than the conventional cigarette. However, amounts of these compounds in HTP aerosols were still higher than in e-cig vapours. Concordantly, HTP aerosol showed reduced cytotoxicity compared to cigarette smoke but higher than e-cig vapours. HTP and e-cig had the potential to increase oxidative stress and inflammatory response, in a manner similar to that of cigarette smoke, but after more intensive exposures. In addition, increasing e-cig power impacted levels of certain toxic compounds and related oxidative stress. This study provides important data necessary for risk assessment by demonstrating that HTP might be less harmful than tobacco cigarette but considerably more harmful than e-cig.

Method development and validation for the determination of sulfites and sulfates on the surface of mineral atmospheric samples using reverse-phase liquid chromatography.

Earlier studies suggest that SO2 gas reacts at the surface of mineral dust and forms sulfites or bisulfites, which are then converted to sulfates. In order to monitor and quantify the amounts of both sulfites and sulfates formed on the surface of mineral dusts of volcanic and desert origins an accurate and precise reversed-phase liquid chromatography method was developed and validated to extract, stabilize and individually analyze sulfites and sulfates initially present on the surface of dusts exposed to SO2. The method was developed on a 25 mm Restek Ultra Column C18, Particle size: 5 µm, I.D. 4.60 mm column which was dynamically coated with 1.0 mM cetylpyridinium chloride in 7% acetonitrile solution to produce a charged surface as recommended in the literature. Mobile phase used: 1 mM Potassium Hydrogen Phthalate at pH 6.5 at a flow rate of 1.0 ml/min with negative UV-Vis detection at 255 nm in 15 min. The method was validated for specificity, linearity and range, injection repeatability, stability, robustness, limit of detection and limit of quantitation, and sample preparation and extraction reproducibility. The method was adapted for straight sulfite and sulfate quantification: (i) of environmental samples, and (ii) natural samples additionally exposed to SO2 gas in a dedicated laboratory setup. The method was then successfully applied to quantify sulfites and sulfates on natural volcanic and a desert dust samples both collected in the environment and additionally exposed to SO2 gas in the laboratory. The method can be efficiently used to identify sulfites and sulfates on fresh volcanic ash following an eruption, on aeolian desert dust exposed to industrial pollutants, as well as for laboratory investigations of sulfite and sulfate formation on the surface of minerals and natural dusts of different origins.

Does the ubiquitous use of essential oil-based products promote indoor air quality? A critical literature review.

Essential oils are frequently used as natural fragrances in housecleaning products and air fresheners marketed as green and healthy. However, these substances are volatile and reactive chemical species. This review focuses on the impact of essential oil-based household products on indoor air quality. First, housecleaning products containing essential oils are explored in terms of composition and existing regulations. Specific insight is provided regarding terpenes in fragranced housecleaning products, air fresheners, and pure essential oils. Second, experimental methodologies for terpene monitoring, from sampling to experimental chambers and analytical methods, are addressed, emphasizing the experimental issues in monitoring terpenes in indoor air. Third, the temporal dynamics of terpene emissions reported in the literature are discussed. Despite experimental discrepancies, essential oil-based products are significant sources of terpenes in indoor air, inducing a high exposure of occupants to terpenes. Finally, the fate of terpenes is explored from sorptive and reactive points of view. In addition to terpene deposition on surfaces, indoor oxidants may induce homogeneous and heterogeneous reactions, resulting in secondary pollutants, such as formaldehyde and secondary organic aerosols. Overall, essential oil-based products can negatively impact indoor air quality; therefore, standard protocols and real-scale approaches are needed to explore the indoor physics and chemistry of terpenes, from emissions to reactivity.

Influence of puffing conditions on the carbonyl composition of e-cigarette aerosols.

Owing to their harmful effects on human health, the presence of carbonyl compounds in e-cigarette aerosols raises concerns. To date, the reported concentration levels in e-vapors vary greatly between studies and several factors that markedly influence carbonyl emission during vaping have been highlighted including the heating temperature, the power supply, the device architecture, the filling level of the tank and the main e-liquid constituents. This study investigated the impact of puffing regimen parameters on the carbonyl composition of e-cigarette aerosols with the aim of: (1) better estimating the variability of carbonyl emissions depending on puffing conditions; (2) highlighting puffing profiles that increase the exposure to carbonyls; and (3) estimating to what extent puffing topography could be implied in the variability of carbonyl concentrations reported in the current literature. E-vapors from a single e-liquid were generated from two e-cigarette models with a smoking machine. A total of 7 different puffing regimens were used to individually study the influence of the puff volume, duration and frequency. Carbonyls were collected by DNPH cartridges and analysed by HPLC-UV. E-liquid consumption and e-vapor temperature were also monitored. E-vapor concentrations of formaldehyde, acetaldehyde, acetone, acrolein, propionaldehyde and methylglyoxal were affected, sometimes differently, by the modification of the puffing regimen, as well as by the e-cigarette model. For example, formaldehyde concentration ranged from 20 to 255 ng/puff depending on the puffing conditions. The results of principal component analyses, applied to the concentration data sets for the 6 carbonyls, suggest that the studied parameters interact and highlight some "carbonyl-emitting" combinations of concern (e-cigarette model/puffing regimen). However, the highest concentrations measured in the present study remain far lower than those observed in conventional cigarette mainstream smoke. This study confirms that the chosen puffing regimen contributes a part of the observed variability in the carbonyl levels reported in the scientific literature, hampering comparisons between studies and making interpretation difficult. Thus, harmonized and realistic protocols for the assessment of e-cigarette toxicity by physicochemical or experimental approaches are clearly needed.

Impact of material emissions and sorption of volatile organic compounds on indoor air quality in a low energy building: Field measurements and modeling.

The assessment of VOC emission rates and sorption coefficients was performed for ten surfaces present within a classroom, using field and laboratory emission cells (FLEC) coupled to online and off-line VOC quantification techniques. A total of 21 identified VOCs were emitted by the different surfaces. VOC emission rates measured using PTR-ToF-MS were compared to gas chromatographic measurements. The results showed that the two methods are complementary to one another. Sorption parameters were also successfully measured for a mixture of 14 VOCs within a few hours (<17 hours per surface). A study of the spatial and temporal variability of the measured parameters was also carried out on the two surfaces that presented the most potential for interaction with VOCs, accounting for the largest surface areas within the room. The dataset of emission rates and sorption parameters was used in the INCA-Indoor model to predict indoor air concentrations of VOCs that are compared to experimental values measured in the room. Modeling results showed that sorption processes had a limited effect on indoor concentrations of VOCs for these field campaigns. Modeled daily profiles show good agreement with the experimental observations for VOCs such as toluene (indoor source) and xylenes (outdoor source) but underestimate concentrations of methanol (both indoor and outdoor sources).

Data on comparison between FLEC and CLIMPAQ methods used for fast sorption measurements of VOCs on building materials.

A test emission chamber called CLIMPAQ has been coupled to a chromatography analyzer GC to measure volatile organic compounds (VOC) concentration during a sorption experiments (Fast sorption measurements of VOCs on building materials: Part 2 - Comparison between FLEC and CLIMPAQ methods, (Rizk et al., In press) [1]). The equations used to calculate the mass transfer coefficient and the thickness of the boundary layer developed on the surface of a material are presented. In addition, the experimental profiles obtained using the CLIMPAQ chamber is also presented in the presence and the absence of a building material. Finally, the impact of chamber size on the obtained concentration profile using different chambers is shown using 3 types of chambers having different volumes, 1 m(3), 30 m(3) and a micro chamber of 40 mL.

Improvement in 8h-sampling rate assessment considering meteorological parameters variability for biogas VOC passive measurements in the surroundings of a French landfill.

Passive sampling technology has been extensively used for long-term VOC atmospheric concentrations' monitoring. Its performances regarding the short-term measurements and related to VOC from biogas were evaluated in this work: laboratory scale experiments have been conducted in order to check the suitability of Radiello® diffusive samplers for the assessment of 8 h-VOC levels in highly changeable meteorological conditions; in a second step a short pilot field campaign was implemented in the vicinity of a West-French landfill. First of all, it was assessed that amongst a diversified list of 16 characteristic compounds from biogas, mercaptans, some halogenated, oxygenated compounds and terpenes could not be measured accurately by this passive technique either because they are not captured by the sorbent or they are not quantitatively desorbed in the chosen mediated analytical conditions. Moreover, it has been confirmed that sampling rates (SR) related to isopentane, THF, cyclohexane, toluene, p-xylene and n-decane are influenced by environmental factors: the main influence concerns the wind speed. From 2 m s(-1), when the velocity increases by 1 m s(-1), the SR increases from 12 to 32% depending on the COV (considering a linear dependence between 2 and 7 m s(-1)). Humidity has no effect on SR, and temperature influence is rather limited to less than 3% per degree. A comprehensive uncertainty estimation, including uncertainties linked to meteorological changes, has led to global relative uncertainties comprising between 18% and 54% from one VOC to another: a quite high value comparatively to those obtained without considering meteorological condition influences. To illustrate our results, targeted VOC were quantified in the field, on a single day: concentrations range between LD to 3 µg m(-3): relatively very low concentrations compared to those usually reported by literature.

Determination of 14 amines in air samples using midget impingers sampling followed by analysis with ion chromatography in tandem with mass spectrometry.

An Ion Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (IC-MS) method was developed for the simultaneous quantification of 14 volatile amines in air. The method includes collection of compounds into two midget impingers in a row filled with 15 ml of ultrapure water. The analytical performances with mass spectrometry detection were compared to those obtained with classical conductivity detection. The use of mass spectrometry detection (in SIM mode) overcomes most of the coelutions encountered with conductivity detection. Although the linearity domain of calibrations is reduced for the MS detection as compared with the CD detection, the detection limits in MS detection are highly lowered allowing the quantification of amines at the levels of µg m(-3) in air with a good accuracy for most compounds (RSD of less than 10%). This method was successfully applied to the analysis of amines released from polyurethane foams. Seven amines were identified and some in high concentrations, like dimethylaminoethanol, NIAX and TEDA.