[Towards a generalization of non-invasive prenatal diagnosis of single-gene disorders? Assesment and outlook]. / Vers une généralisation du diagnostic prénatal non-invasif des maladies monogéniques ? État des lieux et perspectives.

OBJECTIVES: The screening of fetal aneuploidies and non-invasive prenatal diagnosis of monogenic diseases (NIPD-MD) both rely on the study of free fetal DNA in maternal circulation, but their respective rise was unequal. Development of NIPD-MD has taken longer as it represents a less attractive commercial dynamic for industry, but also because it usually involves the development of tailored tests specific to each pathogenic variant. METHODS: We have carried out a review of the literature on the various indications and technologies involved in the use of NIPD-MM. We present its current implementation and its development in France. RESULTS: To date, NIPD-MD has been routinely offered in France for several years by the laboratories of the French NIPD-MD network but remains mostly limited to the exclusion of paternal or de novo variants, the exclusion DPNI-MD. Indeed, it is still difficult to study the transmission of maternal variants from circulating free DNA analysis, due to its biological complexity: coexistence and predominance of similar DNA sequences of maternal origin. Different strategies, either direct or indirect, are being evaluated to establish fetal status regardless of the parental origin of the disease or its transmission mode. The emergence of commercial screening solutions for monogenic diseases complements the arsenal of prenatal exploration tools for these diseases. CONCLUSION: The multitude of existing technologies and protocols may complicate the information provided during antenatal consultations, but mastery of know-how and knowledge of ethical issues of NIPD-MD will ensure optimal service and better management of pregnancies at risk of transmitting monogenic disease.

RFC1 nonsense and frameshift variants cause CANVAS: clues for an unsolved pathophysiology.

Cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy and vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS) is an inherited late-onset neurological disease caused by bi-allelic AAGGG pentanucleotide expansions within intron 2 of RFC1. Despite extensive studies, the pathophysiological mechanism of these intronic expansions remains elusive. We screened by clinical exome sequencing two unrelated patients presenting with late-onset ataxia. A repeat-primer polymerase chain reaction was used for RFC1 AAGGG intronic expansion identification. RFC1 mRNA expression was assessed by quantitative reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction. We identified the first two CANVAS affected patients who are compound heterozygous for RFC1 truncating variants (p.Arg388* and c.575delA, respectively) and a pathological AAGGG expansion. RFC1 expression studies in whole blood showed a significant reduction of RFC1 mRNA for both patients compared to three patients with bi-allelic RFC1 expansions. In conclusion, this observation provides clues that suggest bi-allelic RFC1 conditional loss-of-function as the cause of the disease.

Biallelic RFC1-expansion in a French multicentric sporadic ataxia cohort.

OBJECTIVE: Cerebellar ataxia with neuropathy and vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS) is a recessively inherited multisystem ataxia compromising cerebellar, vestibular, and sensory nerves, which has been associated to a pathogenic AAGGG(n) biallelic expansion repeat in the RFC1 gene. Our objective was to assess its prevalence in a French cohort of patients with idiopathic sporadic late-onset ataxia (ILOA), idiopathic early-onset ataxia (IEOA), or Multiple System Atrophy of Cerebellar type (MSA-C). METHODS: 163 patients were recruited in 3 French tertiary centers: 100 ILOA, 21 IEOA, and 42 patients with possible or probable MSA-C. RESULTS: A pathogenic biallelic RFC1 AAGGG(n) repeat expansion was found in 15 patients: 15/100 in the ILOA group, but none in the IEOA and MSA-C subgroups. 14/15 patients had a CANVAS phenotype. Only 1/15 had isolated cerebellar ataxia, but also shorter biallelic expansions. Two RFC1 AAGGG(n) alleles were found in 78% of patients with a CANVAS phenotype. In one post-mortem case, the pathophysiological involvement of cerebellum and medullar posterior columns was found. CONCLUSION: Our study confirms the genetic heterogeneity of the CANVAS and that RFC1 repeat expansions should be searched for preferentially in case of unexplained ILOA associated with a sensory neuronopathy, but not particularly in patients classified as MSA-C.

Single Circulating Fetal Trophoblastic Cells Eligible for Non Invasive Prenatal Diagnosis: the Exception Rather than the Rule.

Non-Invasive Prenatal Diagnosis (NIPD), based on the analysis of circulating cell-free fetal DNA (cff-DNA), is successfully implemented for an increasing number of monogenic diseases. However, technical issues related to cff-DNA characteristics remain, and not all mutations can be screened with this method, particularly triplet expansion mutations that frequently concern prenatal diagnosis requests. The objective of this study was to develop an approach to isolate and analyze Circulating Trophoblastic Fetal Cells (CFTCs) for NIPD of monogenic diseases caused by triplet repeat expansion or point mutations. We developed a method for CFTC isolation based on DEPArray sorting and used Huntington's disease as the clinical model for CFTC-based NIPD. Then, we investigated whether CFTC isolation and Whole Genome Amplification (WGA) could be used for NIPD in couples at risk of transmitting different monogenic diseases. Our data show that the allele drop-out rate was 3-fold higher in CFTCs than in maternal cells processed in the same way. Moreover, we give new insights into CFTCs by compiling data obtained by extensive molecular testing by microsatellite multiplex PCR genotyping and by WGA followed by mini-exome sequencing. CFTCs appear to be often characterized by a random state of genomic degradation.

A Broad Test Based on Fluorescent-Multiplex PCR for Noninvasive Prenatal Diagnosis of Cystic Fibrosis.

BACKGROUND: Analysis of cell-free fetal DNA in maternal plasma is very promising for early diagnosis of monogenic diseases. However, it has been limited by the need to set up patient- or disease-specific custom-made approaches. Here we propose a universal test based on fluorescent multiplex PCR and size fragment analysis for an indirect diagnosis of cystic fibrosis (CF). METHODS: The test, based on haplotyping, includes nine intra- and extragenic short tandem repeats of the CFTR locus, the coamplification of p.Phe508del (the most frequent mutation in CF patients worldwide), and a specific SRY sequence. The assay is able to determine the inherited paternal allele. RESULTS: Our simple approach was successfully applied to 30 couples and provided clear results from the maternal plasma. The mean rate of informative markers was sufficient to propose it for use in indirect diagnosis. CONCLUSIONS: This noninvasive prenatal diagnosis test, focused on indirect diagnosis of CF, offers many advantages over current methods: it is simple, rapid, and cost-effective. It allows for the testing of a large number of couples with high risk of CF, whatever the familial mutation of the CFTR gene. It provides an alternative method to reduce the number of invasive tests.

Non-invasive prenatal diagnosis of monogenic disorders: an optimized protocol using MEMO qPCR with miniSTR as internal control.

BACKGROUND: Analysis of circulating cell-free fetal DNA (cffDNA) in maternal plasma is very promising for early diagnosis of monogenic diseases. However, this approach is not yet available for routine use and remains technically challenging because of the low concentration of cffDNA, which is swamped by the overwhelming maternal DNA. METHODS: To make clinical applications more readily accessible, we propose a new approach based on mutant enrichment with 3'-modified oligonucleotides (MEMO) PCR along with real-time PCR to selectively amplify from the maternal blood the paternally inherited fetal allele that is not present in the maternal genome. RESULTS: The first proof of concept of this strategy was displayed for cystic fibrosis by the accuracy of our detection of the p.Gly542* mutation used as the initial developmental model. Subsequently, a retrospective study of plasmas originating from two pregnant women carrying a fetus with private mutation confirmed the effectiveness of our method. We confirmed the presence of cffDNA in the studied samples by the identification of a tri-allelic DNA profile using a miniSTR kit. CONCLUSIONS: This new non-invasive prenatal diagnosis test offers numerous advantages over current methods: it is simple, cost effective, time efficient and does not require complex equipment or bioinformatics settings. Moreover, our assays for different private mutations demonstrate the viability of this approach in clinical settings for monogenic disorders.

Dissecting the structure and mechanism of a complex duplication-triplication rearrangement in the DMD gene.

Pathogenic complex genomic rearrangements are being increasingly characterized at the nucleotide level, providing unprecedented opportunities to evaluate the complexities of mutational mechanisms. Here, we report the molecular characterization of a complex duplication-triplication rearrangement involving exons 45-60 of the DMD gene. Inverted repeats facilitated this complex rearrangement, which shares common genomic organization with the recently described duplication-inverted triplication-duplication (DUP-TRP/INV-DUP) events; specifically, a 690-kb region comprising DMD exons from 45 to 60 was duplicated in tandem, and another 46-kb segment containing exon 51 was inserted inversely in between them. Taking into consideration (1) the presence of a predicted PRDM9 binding site in the near vicinity of the junction involving two inverted L1 elements and (2) the inherent properties of X-Y chromosome recombination during male meiosis, we proposed an alternative two-step model for the generation of this X-linked DMD DUP-TRP/INV-DUP event.

Targeted high-throughput sequencing for diagnosis of genetically heterogeneous diseases: efficient mutation detection in Bardet-Biedl and Alström syndromes.

BACKGROUND: Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS) is a pleiotropic recessive disorder that belongs to the rapidly growing family of ciliopathies. It shares phenotypic traits with other ciliopathies, such as Alström syndrome (ALMS), nephronophthisis (NPHP) or Joubert syndrome. BBS mutations have been detected in 16 different genes (BBS1-BBS16) without clear genotype-to-phenotype correlation. This extensive genetic heterogeneity is a major concern for molecular diagnosis and genetic counselling. While various strategies have been recently proposed to optimise mutation detection, they either fail to detect mutations in a majority of patients or are time consuming and costly. METHOD: We tested a targeted exon-capture strategy coupled with multiplexing and high-throughput sequencing on 52 patients: 14 with known mutations as proof-of-principle and 38 with no previously detected mutation. Thirty genes were targeted in total including the 16 BBS genes, the 12 known NPHP genes, the single ALMS gene ALMS1 and the proposed modifier CCDC28B. RESULTS: This strategy allowed the reliable detection of causative mutations (including homozygous/heterozygous exon deletions) in 68% of BBS patients without previous molecular diagnosis and in all proof-of-principle samples. Three probands carried homozygous truncating mutations in ALMS1 confirming the major phenotypic overlap between both disorders. The efficiency of detecting mutations in patients was positively correlated with their compliance with the classical BBS phenotype (mutations were identified in 81% of 'classical' BBS patients) suggesting that only a few true BBS genes remain to be identified. We illustrate some interpretation problems encountered due to the multiplicity of identified variants. CONCLUSION: This strategy is highly efficient and cost effective for diseases with high genetic heterogeneity, and guarantees a quality of coverage in coding sequences of target genes suited for diagnosis purposes.

Comprehensive oligonucleotide array-comparative genomic hybridization analysis: new insights into the molecular pathology of the DMD gene.

We report on the effectiveness of a custom-designed oligonucleotide-based comparative genomic hybridization microarray (array-CGH) to interrogate copy number across the entire 2.2-Mb genomic region of the DMD gene and its applicability in diagnosis. The high-resolution array-CGH, we developed, successfully detected a series of 42 previously characterized large rearrangements of various size, localization and type (simple or complex deletions, duplications, triplications) and known intronic CNVs/Indels. Moreover, the technique succeeded in identifying a small duplication of only 191 bp in one patient previously negative for DMD mutation. Accurate intronic breakpoints localization by the technique enabled subsequent junction fragments identification by sequencing in 86% of cases (all deletion cases and 62.5% of duplication cases). Sequence examination of the junctions supports a role of microhomology-mediated processes in the occurrence of DMD large rearrangements. In addition, the precise knowledge of the sequence context at the breakpoints and analysis of the resulting consequences on maturation of pre-mRNA contribute to elucidating the cause of discrepancies in phenotype/genotype correlations in some patients. Thereby, the array-CGH proved to be a highly efficient and reliable diagnostic tool, and the new data it provides will have many potential implications in both, clinics and research.

Only four genes (EDA1, EDAR, EDARADD, and WNT10A) account for 90% of hypohidrotic/anhidrotic ectodermal dysplasia cases.

Hypohidrotic and anhidrotic ectodermal dysplasia (HED/EDA) is a rare genodermatosis characterized by abnormal development of sweat glands, teeth, and hair. Three disease-causing genes have been hitherto identified, namely, (1) EDA1 accounting for X-linked forms, (2) EDAR, and (3) EDARADD, causing both autosomal dominant and recessive forms. Recently, WNT10A gene was identified as responsible for various autosomal recessive forms of ectodermal dysplasias, including onycho-odonto-dermal dysplasia (OODD) and Schöpf-Schulz-Passarge syndrome. We systematically studied EDA1, EDAR, EDARADD, and WNT10A genes in a large cohort of 65 unrelated patients, of which 61 presented with HED/EDA. A total of 50 mutations (including 32 novel mutations) accounted for 60/65 cases in our series. These four genes accounted for 92% (56/61 patients) of HED/EDA cases: (1) the EDA1 gene was the most common disease-causing gene (58% of cases), (2)WNT10A and EDAR were each responsible for 16% of cases. Moreover, a novel disease locus for dominant HED/EDA mapped to chromosome 14q12-q13.1. Although no clinical differences between patients carrying EDA1, EDAR, or EDARADD mutations could be identified, patients harboring WNT10A mutations displayed distinctive clinical features (marked dental phenotype, no facial dysmorphism), helping to decide which gene should be first investigated in HED/EDA.

Molecular diagnosis reveals genetic heterogeneity for the overlapping MKKS and BBS phenotypes.

Hydrometrocolpos and polydactyly diagnosed in the prenatal period or early childhood may raise diagnostic dilemmas especially in distinguishing McKusick-Kaufman syndrome (MKKS) and the Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS). These two conditions can initially overlap. With time, the additional features of BBS appearing in childhood, such as retinitis pigmentosa, obesity, learning disabilities and progressive renal dysfunction allow clear differentiation between BBS and MKKS. Genotype overlap also exists, as mutations in the MKKS-BBS6 gene are found in both syndromes. We report 7 patients diagnosed in the neonatal period with hydrometrocolpos and polydactyly who carry mutations in various BBS genes (BBS6, BBS2, BBS10, BBS8 and BBS12), stressing the importance of wide BBS genotyping in patients with this clinical association for diagnosis, prognosis and genetic counselling.

The clinical spectrum associated with a chromosome 17 short arm proximal duplication (dup 17p11.2) in three patients.

The p11.2-p12 region of human chromosome 17 is gene rich and composed of at least two genomically unstable domains: the Smith-Magenis syndrome region (17p11.2) and the Charcot-Marie-Tooth region (17p12), both of which are flanked by several low-copy repeat sequences. Homologous recombination between these flanking repeats results in either deletion- or duplication-associated phenotypes caused by a gene dosage effect. We report on the clinical phenotype of three patients presenting with either a 17p11.2 or 17p11.2p12 duplication, revealed by chromosome analysis and confirmed by fluorescent in situ hybridization analysis, high resolution genomic analysis of the 17p region using oligonucleotide array comparative genomic hybridization, and molecular studies with microsatellite markers. Two patients carry the 17p11.2 duplication, while the third one shows a larger duplication including the 17p12 region. The facial features observed in our patients include triangular face, full cheeks, smooth philtrum, thin upper lip, dental malocclusion, irregular eyebrows, and sparse hair, all of which are consistent with the pure proximal dup 17p phenotype. The patients' other clinical features are compared with previously published cases.

Monozygotic twins concordant for blood karyotype, but phenotypically discordant: a case of "mosaic chimerism".

We report on 23 years old discordant monozygotic (MZ) twins, one with minor anomalies and mental delay, the other one being normal. Both had 46,XX,dup(11)(p12p15)/46,XX mosaicism in blood, with a similar proportion of abnormal cells (respectively, 16% and 17%). However, interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis performed on buccal smear and urinary sediment using specific probes located at the duplicated region showed that mosaicism was only present in the abnormal twin, with 68% abnormal cells. We hypothesize that the postzygotic chromosomal rearrangement may have occurred early in one embryo after the twinning event, and the blood mosaicism observed in both twins would have resulted from blood exchanges via placental anastomoses. This hypothesis of chimerism is strongly supported by twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome observed during fetal life of our twins. This case and those previously reported lead us to suggest that blood is particularly unsuitable for cytogenetic investigations of twins.

Subtelomeric 6p deletion: clinical, FISH, and array CGH characterization of two cases.

Thirty patients have been described with cytogenetically visible deletion of the short arm of chromosome 6. However, subtelomeric 6p deletion detected by subtelomeric specific probes has been reported only twice. We report two new patients with terminal 6p deletion detected by subtelomeric screening using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). The two patients exhibited mental retardation, ocular abnormalities, hearing loss, and a characteristic facial appearance. Detailed FISH analyses with probes covering the distal 6p25 region estimated the size of the terminal deletions to approximately 5.5 Mb and approximately 4.8 Mb. Array-based comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH) was used to confirm the cryptic deletions. Most patients with subtelomeric defects lack a characteristic phenotype. However, some of the subtelomeric deletions result in a specific phenotype, which can direct the clinician towards the diagnosis. Submicroscopic 6p deletion appears to be a recognizable clinical phenotype, and this region should be thoroughly investigated with FISH probes, including at least a subtelomeric 6p probe and a probe covering FOXC1, for patients presenting with a characteristic facial appearance, ocular abnormalities, predominantly anterior-chamber eye defects, hearing loss, and mental retardation.

Variable phenotype related to a novel PAX 6 mutation (IVS4+5G>C) in a family presenting congenital nystagmus and foveal hypoplasia.

PURPOSE: Several ocular defects have been identified as a consequence of the PAX6 gene mutations. With regard to the implication of this gene in unusual phenotypes, we report a family presenting with congenital nystagmus, foveal hypoplasia, and iris hypoplasia or atypical coloboma. DESIGN: Observational case report. METHODS: The entire transcribed region of the PAX6 gene was submitted to mutation search at the DNA and mRNA levels in five affected members of a French family in test with 82 normal subjects. RESULTS: A novel heterozygous PAX6 gene splice mutation (IVS4 + 5G>C) was identified. The mutation is located in IVS4 within the consensus donor splice site. A mutant mRNA lacking exon 4 as the sole defect was evidenced. The resultant protein was predicted to contain a cryptic ATG initiation codon in exon 3 and a slightly altered paired-domain in an open reading frame extended by 13 amino acids. CONCLUSIONS: The association of anterior segment anomalies and foveal hypoplasia with one of the slightest alterations of the PAX6 protein described to date confirms the association of variant phenotypes with hypomorphic alleles. Mutation screening of the PAX6 gene could be useful in elucidating the origin of complex ocular malformations.

Screening for PAX6 gene mutations is consistent with haploinsufficiency as the main mechanism leading to various ocular defects.

PAX6, a paired box transcriptional factor, is considered as the master control gene for morphogenesis of the eye. Human PAX6 mutations have been associated with a range of eye abnormalities, including aniridia, various anterior segment defects and foveal hypoplasia. We carried out a mutational analysis of the PAX6 gene in 54 unrelated patients with aniridia or related syndromes. A deleterious variation was evidenced in 17 sporadic cases (50%) and in 13 (72%) familial cases. Twenty-four different mutations, 17 of which are novel, were found. The spectrum of PAX6 mutations was highly homogeneous: 23 mutations (96%) leading to premature stop codons (eight nonsense and four splice site mutations, 11 insertions and deletions) and only one (4%) missense mutation. Twenty-two mutations were associated with aniridia phenotypes whereas two were associated with atypical phenotypes. These latter encompassed a missense mutation (R19P) in an individual with a microphthalmia-sclerocornea and a splice site mutation (IVS4+5G > C) in a family presenting with a congenital nystagmus. Both represented the most probably hypomorphic alleles. Aniridia cases were associated with nonsense or frameshifting mutations. A careful examination of the phenotypes did not make it possible to recognise significant differences whenever the predicted protein was deprived of one or another of its functional domains. This strongly suggested that most of the truncating mutations generated null alleles by nonsense mediated mRNA decay. Our observations support the concept of dosage effects of the PAX6 mutations as well as presenting evidence for variable expressivity.