RESUMO
Background: While current preoperative and postoperative assessment of the fractured and surgically reconstructed calcaneus relies on computed tomography (CT)-imaging, there are no established methods to quantify calcaneus morphology on CT-images. This study aims to develop a semi-automated method for morphological measurements of the calcaneus on three-dimensional (3D) models derived from CT-imaging. Methods: Using CT data, 3D models were created from healthy, fractured, and surgically reconstructed calcanei. Böhler's angle (BA) and Critical angle of Gissane (CAG) were measured on conventional lateral radiographs and corresponding 3D CT reconstructions using a novel point-based method with semi-automatic landmark placement by three observers. Intraobserver and interobserver reliability scores were calculated using intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC). In addition, consensus among observers was calculated for a maximal allowable discrepancy of 5 and 10 degrees for both methods. Results: Imaging data from 119 feet were obtained (40 healthy, 39 fractured, 40 reconstructed). Semi-automated measurements on 3D models of BA and CAG showed excellent reliability (ICC: 0.87-1.00). The manual measurements on conventional radiographs had a poor-to-excellent reliability (ICC: 0.22-0.96). In addition, the percentage of consensus among observers was much higher for the 3D method when compared to conventional two-dimensional (2D) measurements. Conclusions: The proposed method enables reliable and reproducible quantification of calcaneus morphology in 3D models of healthy, fractured and reconstructed calcanei.
RESUMO
In 3D-analysis of the calcaneus, a consistent coordinate system aligned with the original anatomical directions is crucial for pre- and postoperative analysis. This importance stems from the calcaneus's key role in weight-bearing and biomechanical alignment. However, defining a reliable coordinate system based solely on fractured or surgically reconstructed calcanei presents significant challenges. Given its anatomical prominence and consistent orientation, the talus offers a potential solution to this challenge. Our work explores the feasibility of talus-derived coordinate systems for 3D-modeling of the calcaneus across its various conditions. Four methods were tested on nonfractured, fractured and surgically reconstructed calcanei, utilizing Principal Component Analysis, anatomical landmarks, bounding box, and an atlas-based approach. The methods were compared with a self-defined calcaneus reference coordinate system. Additionally, the impact of deviation of the coordinate system on morphological measurements was investigated. Among methods for constructing nonfractured calcanei coordinate systems, the atlas-based method displayed the lowest Root Mean Square value in comparison with the reference coordinate system. For morphological measures like Böhler's Angle and the Critical angle of Gissane, the atlas talus-based system closely aligned with ground truth, yielding differences of 0.6° and 1.2°, respectively, compared to larger deviations seen in other talus-based coordinate systems. In conclusion, all tested methods were feasible for creating a talus derived coordinate system. A talus derived coordinate system showed potential, offering benefits for morphological measurements and clinical scenarios involving fractured and surgically reconstructed calcanei. Further research is recommended to assess the impact of these coordinate systems on surgical planning and outcomes.