Disease modifying treatment trials in Parkinson's disease: how to balance expectations and interests of patients, physicians and industry partners?

BACKGROUND: The advent of therapeutic strategies designed to modify the disease course in Parkinson's disease has raised great expectations in the currently conducted clinical trials. However, we see ethical challenges in the cooperation of industry and clinical partners, specifically evident in the way recruitment is performed.We here discuss the different positions and challenges of all involved to set the stage for a study and recruitment culture taking into account the expectations of all: (i) patients and their caregivers, ready to take the considerable burden of clinical trials in hope for the development of disease-modifying treatments; (ii) physicians and study nurses, obligated to the patients' well-being and benefit who accompany and supervise patients closely as basis for the performance of elaborate clinical trials (iii) industrial partners, investing years of efforts and finances to develop new treatments. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that the current competitive race for enrollment in clinical studies in PD is challenging the primary goal to ensure patients' benefit and formulate requests to the industrial partners to encounter these concerns.

[Clinical and cognitive aspects of functional (psychogenic) tremor]. / Klinische und kognitive Neurologie des funktionellen (psychogenen) Tremors.

Functional (psychogenic) tremor is the most common functional movement disorder. Characteristic clinical features, so called red flags, can help to make the clinical distinction of this type from other tremor disorders. The most common features include the variability of frequency and amplitude. Clinical examination should include different types of distraction including motor or cognitive tasks or testing the influence of suggestibility on tremor amplitude, frequency or direction. Patients often report sudden onset and remissions that may last for months or even years. In some cases, the tremor is only present in highly specific situations. Although functional tremor shares characteristics with voluntary actions, patients experience their abnormal movements as involuntary. Recent experimental approaches have revealed an impairment in sense of agency. The diagnosis can be supported by neurophysiological measurements including accelerometry, which achieved a sensitivity of 89.5% and a specificity of 95.9% in a validated test battery, thus providing a useful additional diagnostic tool. Psychotherapeutic treatment is indicated in patients with and without evident psychological symptoms. A specific physiotherapeutic approach for functional tremor is re-trainment.

The olfactory bulb volume in patients with idiopathic Parkinson's disease.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: This study addresses the question of whether the neuropathological findings on the olfactory bulb (OB) in idiopathic Parkinson's disease (IPD) correspond to a detectable change in volume of the OB. Additionally, the relationship between OB volume and residual olfactory function, clinical disease characteristics and age are investigated. METHODS: Fifty-two IPD patients were investigated and compared to 31 healthy age-matched controls. All participants were scanned using a 3 T magnetic resonance imaging MRI scanner including a T2 DRIVE sequence in coronal slices through the OB. The OB volumes were measured via manual segmentation of the OB. Olfactory testing was carried out using the Sniffin' Sticks test battery. RESULTS: The OB volume in the IPD group was 42.1 mm³ (SD ± 11.6) for the right and 41.5 mm³ (SD ± 11.7) for the left OB and showed no difference from the controls. Additionally, there were no significant correlations between OB volume and disease characteristics such as disease duration or Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale motor score. Likewise, patients' residual smell function did not correlate with their OB volume. In contrast, controls indicated a correlation between smell function and OB volume. CONCLUSION: The study shows that high resolution MRI does not show a detectable volume loss of the OB in PD patients. It is concluded that OB measurement using in vivo high resolution MRI at 3 T is not helpful to identify IPD.

Slow pre-movement cortical potentials do not reflect individual response to therapy in writer's cramp.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether movement-related cortical potentials (MRCP) provide a physiological correlate that indicates the response to treatment in patients with writer's cramp. METHODS: In 21 patients with writer's cramp, who underwent 4 weeks of limb immobilization followed by re-training for 8 weeks, we recorded MRCPs preceding a self-initiated brisk finger abduction movement. MRCP measurements of pre-movement activity were performed at baseline, after the end of immobilization and four and 8 weeks of re-training. We examined 12 controls, who received no intervention, twice 4 weeks apart. RESULTS: Patients benefited from the therapeutical intervention (Zeuner et al., 2008). They showed no abnormalities of the MRCPs at baseline. In controls, MRCPs did not significantly change after 4 weeks. In patients, immobilization and re-training had no effect on MRCPs. There was no correlation between the severity of dystonic symptoms or the individual treatment response and MRCPs. CONCLUSION: MRCPs are stable measures for interventional studies. However, they do not reflect clinical severity of dystonic symptoms or improvement after therapeutic interventions. SIGNIFICANCE: This is the first study to investigate MRCPs in a large cohort of patients with writer's cramp compared to a control group at different time points. These potentials do not reflect the motor control disorder in patients with writer's cramp.

Abnormal reorganization in focal hand dystonia--sensory and motor training programs to retrain cortical function.

Dystonia is a disabling movement disorder, which is characterized by an abnormal pattern of muscle activity with co-contraction of agonist and antagonist muscles. In the case of focal hand dystonia (FHD), these abnormal movements affect muscles of the forearm and hand while performing a specific task. Patients may initially present with dystonic symptoms occurring with a selective task (simple writer's cramp or musician's cramp), and may progress to develop symptoms with multiple tasks (dystonic writer's cramp). The underlying cause of this disabling condition remains unclear. This review examines recent studies designed to further elucidate the underlying pathophysiological processes in focal dystonia. Animal research work, and neurophysiological and neuroimaging studies in humans, have identified several possible mechanisms that may contribute to the underlying pathophysiology, including impaired sensorimotor integration, motor cortex activation and surround inhibition. Pharmacological treatment for dystonia is currently suboptimal. Based on these recent pathophysiological findings, several promising and novel non-pharmacological treatment modalities have recently been developed. Attempts at modulating impaired sensorimotor integration and cortical inhibition using sensorimotor retraining, and the range of sensory training techniques recently described, are further discussed in this review.

The basal ganglia are hyperactive during the discrimination of tactile stimuli in writer's cramp.

Writer's cramp is a focal hand dystonia that specifically affects handwriting. Though writer's cramp has been attributed to a dysfunction of the basal ganglia, the role of the basal ganglia in the pathogenesis of writer's cramp remains to be determined. Seventeen patients with writer's cramp (nine females; age range: 24-71 years) and 17 healthy individuals (six females; age range: 27-68 years) underwent functional MRI (fMRI) while they discriminated the orientation of gratings delivered to the tip of the right index finger. Statistical parametric mapping was used to analyse the fMRI data. The significance level was set at a corrected P-value of 0.05. Relative to healthy controls, patients with writer's cramp showed a widespread bilateral increase in task-related activity in the putamen, caudate nucleus, internal globus pallidus and lateral thalamus. In these areas, hyperactivity was more pronounced in patients who had recently developed writer's cramp. The enhanced response of the basal ganglia to tactile input from the affected hand is compatible with the concept of impaired centre-surround inhibition within the basal ganglia-thalamic circuit and may lead to an excessive activation of sensorimotor cortical areas during skilled movements affected by dystonia. Outside the basal ganglia, dystonic patients showed task-related overactivity in visual cortical areas, left anterior insula and right intraparietal sulcus, but not in the primary or secondary sensory cortex. In addition, task-related activity in the cerebellar nuclei, posterior vermis, right paramedian cerebellar hemisphere and dorsal pons was inversely related with the severity of hand dystonia. Regional activity in these areas may reflect secondary adaptive reorganization at the systems level to compensate for the dysfunction in the basal ganglia-thalamic loop.

Accelerometry to distinguish psychogenic from essential or parkinsonian tremor.

The authors measured postural wrist tremor with accelerometry in patients with psychogenic (n = 6), essential (n = 11), and parkinsonian (n = 12) tremor. Tremor was measured in one hand, while the other hand either rested or tapped to an auditory stimulus at 3 and 4 or 5 Hz. Psychogenic tremors showed larger tremor frequency changes and higher intraindividual variability while tapping. Accelerometry may differentiate psychogenic from essential and parkinsonian tremor.

Abnormalities of spatial discrimination in focal and generalized dystonia.

Sensory processing is impaired in focal hand dystonia (FHD), with most previous studies having evaluated only the symptomatic limb. The purpose of this study was to establish whether the sensory system is affected in other types of dystonias and whether the contralateral hand is also involved in FHD. We used a spatial acuity measure (Johnson-Van Boven-Phillips domes) to evaluate sensory spatial discrimination in both hands of patients with different forms of dystonias including primary generalized DYT1 dystonia (associated with a unique deletion in the DYT1 gene) (n = 13), FHD (n = 15), benign essential blepharospasm (n = 9), cervical dystonia (n = 10) and in age-matched controls. Clinical evaluation included the Fahn dystonia scale for the focal dystonia groups and the Marsden-Burke-Fahn scale for the generalized dystonia group. Spatial discrimination was normal in patients with DYT1 dystonia, despite all of these patients having hand dystonia. However, spatial discrimination thresholds were significantly increased in both hands in the focal dystonia groups (thresholds were similar for each group) and did not correlate significantly with either severity or duration of dystonic symptoms. Thresholds were significantly increased in the dominant hand compared with the non-dominant hand only within the FHD group. Our observations demonstrate involvement of both the dominant and non-dominant somatosensory cortices, and suggest that abnormal sensory processing is a fundamental disturbance in patients with focal dystonia. These findings of altered sensory processing in idiopathic focal but not generalized DYT1 dystonia suggest both a primary pathophysiological role for the phenomenon in focal dystonia and divergent pathophysiological processes in the two conditions.