RESUMO
INTRODUCTION: Traumatic injuries of the shoulder or chest wall are commonly treated in the Emergency Department (ED). A complementary treatment is kinesiotaping, an elastic tape often used to treat musculoskeletal dysfunction and pain. However, the added pain-reducing effect of kinesiotape in comparison to standard conservative treatment is unknown. The aim of this study was to determine the effect of kinesiotaping on pain relief compared to standard treatment with pain medication and immobilization in patients with uncomplicated traumatic injury of the shoulder or chest wall in the ED. METHOD: A pilot randomized controlled trial (RCT) was conducted in the ED of a teaching hospital in the Netherlands from January 2021 until the end of March 2021. Patients diagnosed with uncomplicated isolated rib fractures, rib contusions, clavicle fracture, disruption of the AC joint and fracture of the proximal humerus were assigned to two treatment groups. The control group received the standard treatment with oral analgesics (acetaminophen q6h 1000 mg and NSAID (according to prescription) and if shoulder injury also a sling. The intervention group received kinesiotaping in addition to the same standard treatment. Pain intensity was measured with 0-10 Numeric Rating Scale (NRS) just before treatment (T1) and after 15 min (T2). On day 4 both groups were assessed with NRS in a follow up phone call (T3). RESULTS: A total of 251 patients presented with traumatic injury of the shoulder or chest wall in the study period, 85 patients were approached to participate and 2 of them were excluded. The remaining 83 were randomly allocated to kinesiotaping (n = 40) or control group (n = 43), 57 of them completed the study and had sufficient data for complete analysis In both groups, pain intensity after 15 min and 4 days significantly reduced compared with baseline. Regarding the reduction of pain intensity on day 4, kinesiotaping was significantly superior compared to the control group with a difference in pain reduction of 2.45 compared with 0.88 in control group (p = 0.018). CONCLUSION: Compared to standard treatment alone, kinesiotaping combined with standard care appears to be more effective in terms of acute pain reduction in patients with uncomplicated traumatic injury of the shoulder or chest wall. Further research is recommended.
Assuntos
Dor Aguda , Fita Atlética , Fraturas das Costelas , Parede Torácica , Humanos , Fraturas das Costelas/complicações , Fraturas das Costelas/terapia , OmbroRESUMO
INTRODUCTION: Currently, it is common practice in the emergency department (ED) for pain relief in hip-fracture patients to administer pain medication, commonly systemic opioids. However, with these pain medications come a high risk of side effects, especially in elderly patients. This study investigated the safety profile and success rate of fascia iliaca compartment block (FICB) in a busy ED. This ED was staffed with emergency physicians (EPs) and residents of varying levels of experience. This study followed patients' pain levels at various hourly intervals up to eight hours post procedure. METHODS: Between September 2012 and July 2013, we performed a prospective pilot study on hip-fracture patients who were admitted to the ED of a teaching hospital in the Netherlands. These patients were followed and evaluated post FICB for pain relief. Secondary outcome was the use of opioids as rescue medication. RESULTS: Of the 43 patients in this study, patients overall experienced less pain after the FICB (p=0.04). This reduction in pain was studied in conjunction with the use and non-use of opioids. A clinically meaningful decrease in pain was achieved after 30 minutes in 62% of patients (54% with the use of opioids, 8% without opioids); after 240 minutes in 82% of patients (18% with opioids, 64% without opioids); after 480 minutes in 88% of patients (16% with opioids, 72% without opioids). No adverse events were reported. CONCLUSION: In a busy Dutch ED with rotating residents of varying levels of experience, FICB seems to be an efficient, safe and practical method for pain reduction in patients with a hip fracture. Even without the use of opioids, pain reduction was achieved in 64% of patients after four hours and in 72% of patients after eight hours.