Detection of cell-free fetal DNA in maternal plasma using two types of compound markers.

With the discovery of circulating cell-free fetal DNA (cffDNA) in maternal plasma, noninvasive prenatal testing became possible. However, analysis of low-level cffDNA against high background maternal DNA remains complicated and challenging. To circumvent this limitation, selective amplification of cffDNA was used in this study. Two kinds of compound markers (namely DIP-STR and SNP-STR), both based on selective amplification, were used here for targeting fetal DNA. By designing two allele-specific forward primers for DIP-STR and SNP-STR, DNA fragments with different DIP/SNP alleles can be selectively amplified. When analyzing maternal plasma DNA, these markers can selectively target paternally inherited fetal alleles whose DIP/SNP allele was not shared with the mother. In this study, 21 families were studied with six DIP-STRs and 11 SNP-STRs. Fetal DNA was successfully detected across plasma samples for at least one marker. Detection rate varied between DIP-STR and SNP-STR markers, and DIP-STR outperforms SNP-STR. Fetal alleles obtained from maternal plasma were double confirmed by genotyping paternal genomic DNA and fetal genomic DNA from amniocentesis. This study demonstrated that selective amplification strategy can be used to target cffDNA in maternal plasma, which will be a promising method for noninvasive prenatal paternity testing.

Forensic molecular biomarkers for mixture analysis.

The deconvolution of DNA mixtures has gathered the attention of forensic DNA scientists for over two decades. To enhance mixture deconvolution capabilities, a new generation of sensitive DNA-typing approaches has been recently proposed. In this review, we describe novel, forensically relevant multi-SNP loci (i.e., microhaplotypes or microhaps), compound markers (i.e., DIP-STRs, SNP-STRs and DIP-SNPs) and lineage markers (i.e., rapidly mutating Y chromosome STRs) that improve the deconvolution of two and more than two-person mixtures typed using conventional STR, binary and non-binary loci. We explore the features and applications of these emerging molecular biomarkers with respect to their ability to forensically detect same-or-opposite sex donors. Finally, we discuss the impact of initial massively parallel sequencing (MPS) investigations of STR, microhaplotype and SNP/indel assays for DNA mixture profiling.

Analysis of fetal DNA in maternal plasma with markers designed for forensic DNA mixture resolution.

PURPOSE: With the description of circulating fetal DNA in maternal blood, noninvasive prenatal diagnostics became theoretically possible. As the presence of background maternal DNA interferes with the detection of fetal DNA, analytical methods require genetic markers capable of distinguishing by quantitative or targeted approaches the minor population of DNA molecules of the fetus. Here we evaluate the feasibility of analyzing fetal DNA with novel DIP-STR genetic markers, designed for the investigation of forensic mixed biological evidence. METHODS: The DIP-STR molecular approach is based on sequence-specific analysis of paternally inherited fetal alleles. These sequences are biallelic deletion/insertion polymorphisms (DIPs) located very close to short tandem repeat (STR) markers, for combined analysis. In this study, 48 women were tested with 28 DIP-STRs during the first, second, and third trimester of pregnancy. RESULTS: Positive results were obtained across markers, including longer ones (386 base-pairs) and with blood samples collected during early pregnancy, such as 10 weeks of gestational age. CONCLUSION: These data show that DIP-STR markers can be used to amplify specific genomic regions of circulating fetal DNA to obtain targeted genetic information. This method may contribute to developments in noninvasive prenatal paternity testing and diagnosis of certain genetic diseases.

An investigation of a set of DIP-STR markers to detect unbalanced DNA mixtures among the southwest Chinese Han population.

The resolution of DNA mixtures is still a difficult problem that is worthy of further study. A common method applied for analysing mixtures is the use of autosomal STR markers as well as related calculation software based on genotypes; however, these markers have a limitation in detecting minor DNA in unbalanced mixtures if major DNA constitutes over 95% of the stain. Novel biomarkers, such as Y-STR, DIP-STR and SNP-STR, have been shown to perform well in distinguishing DNA donors in this type of mixture. DIP-STR can successfully target minor DNA in 1000-fold background DNA using two separate allele-specific primers. However, whether this method can successfully detect minor DNA primarily depends on the distribution of the DIPs in a population. Until now, only Swiss population data have been reported; therefore in this study, we selected 10 DIP-STR markers that performed well in the Swiss population and investigated whether these markers were also useful among the southwest Chinese Han population. The allele frequencies were estimated based on 152 samples, and six of the ten DIP-STR makers had a relatively high probability of informative markers (I value), which indicated their potential usefulness in the southwest Chinese Han population. A comparative study of DIP-STR markers and autosomal STR markers demonstrated that DIP-STR markers detected minor DNA at a ratio of 1:1000, while autosomal STR markers often failed to genotype minor DNA because of strong background noises caused by large amount of major DNA. However, the discrimination power was not high enough using these six DIPs alone. Therefore, we suggest that development of a panel with more loci is imperative and that a panel combined with DIP-STR and SNP-STR markers may be a possible way to achieve better discrimination power.

Application of DIP-STRs to sexual/physical assault investigations: Eight case reports.

DIP-STRs are compound markers formed by a deletion/insertion polymorphism linked to a microsatellite. They enable the deconvolution of unbalanced DNA mixtures from two individuals, up to 1000 fold excess of one contributor. In practice, this novel tool allows to test for the presence of a DNA of interest in traces appearing not useful because of the masking effect of the major DNA contributor. Thus far two sets of DIP-STRs have been published: the first set was described as proof-of-principle, while the second set was specifically developed for forensic applications. Here, we report on the first use of these markers in casework to show advantages and limitations in real examples. Traces, suggestive of containing unbalanced DNA mixtures (beyond standard STR mixture resolution), were selected from eight cases submitted to the Forensic Genetics Unit of the University Center of Legal Medicine of Lausanne-Geneva. Using 18 validated DIP-STRs, two to ten markers were selected for each case. A minor DNA contributor - undetected using conventional STRs - was detected for the trace samples of six cases. DIP-STR results contributed to each case, either by complementing Y-STRs results or by producing novel investigative leads. This was especially true with same sex unbalanced DNA mixtures, female minor/male major unbalanced DNA mixtures or when the source of the DNA mixture was said to come either from the suspect and the female complainant or from his brother and the female complainant. Interestingly, these markers were found to be more sensitive and specific than previously known. Positive results were obtained at 16,000-fold excess of major DNA using few picograms of input DNA, as well as from traces collected several months after the alleged offence. Likelihood ratios assigned to measure the strength of DIP-STRs' DNA evidence were modest (10), when accounted by only two DIP-STRs, and high (106) when determined by six markers. In some cases the detection of extra alleles from additional minor DNA contributors or because of extremely unbalanced DNA ratios, limited the interpretation of the results. In conclusion, the DIP-STRs often provide additional value to the analysis of traces that cannot be exploited by the use of standard methods.

Sensitive DIP-STR markers for the analysis of unbalanced mixtures from "touch" DNA samples.

Casework samples collected for forensic DNA analysis can produce genomic mixtures in which the DNA of the alleged offender is masked by high quantities of DNA coming from the victim. DIP-STRs are novel genetic markers specifically developed to enable the target analysis of a DNA of interest in the presence of exceeding quantities of a second DNA (up to 1000-fold). The genotyping system, which is based on allele-specific amplifications of haplotypes formed by a deletion/insertion polymorphism (DIP) and a short tandem repeat (STR), combines the capacity of targeting the DNA of an individual with a strong identification power. Finally, DIP-STRs are autosomal markers therefore they can be applied to any combination of major and minor DNA. In this study we aimed to assess the ability of DIP-STRs to detect the minor contributor on challenging "touch" DNA samples simulated with representative crime-associated substrates and to compare their performance to commonly used male-specific markers (Y-STRs). As part of a comprehensive study on the relative DNA contribution of two persons handling the same object, we selected 71 unbalanced contact traces of which 14 comprised a male minor DNA contributor mixed to a female major DNA contributor. Using a set of six DIP-STRs, one to four markers were found to be informative for the minor DNA detection across traces. When compared to Y-STRs (14 traces), the DIP-STRs showed similar sensitivity in detecting the minor DNA across substrate materials with a similar occurrence of allele drop-out. Conversely, because of the sex combination of the two users of the object, 57 remaining traces could only be investigated by DIP-STRs. Of these, 30 minor DNA contributors could be detected by all informative markers while 12 traces showed events of allele drop-out. Finally, 15 traces showed no amplification of the minor DNA. These last 15 samples were mostly characterized by a combination of short handling time of the object, low DNA recovery and/or one single informative DIP-STR. In conclusion, the DIP-STRs represent alternative markers to help solving unbalanced two-source DNA mixtures, and also those produced from contact stains. These markers, in addition to a novel set of 10 DIP-STRs specifically developed according to forensic technical standards, will offer a valuable tool complementary to Y-STR markers.