Association Between Increased Levels of Cystatin C and the Development of Cardiovascular Events or Mortality: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis / Associação entre Níveis Elevados de Cistatina C e o Desenvolvimento de Eventos Cardiovasculares ou Mortalidade: Uma Revisão Sistemática e Meta-Análise

Abstract Background: Cystatin C seems promising for evaluating the risk of cardiovascular events and mortality. Objective: To evaluate the association between high levels of cystatin C and the development of cardiovascular events or mortality. Methods: The articles were selected in the Medline/PubMed, Web of Science, and Scielo databases. The eligibility criteria were prospective cohort observational trials that assessed the association of high serum levels of cystatin C with the development of cardiovascular events or mortality in individuals with normal renal function. Only studies that evaluated the mortality outcome compared the fourth with the first quartile of cystatin C and performed multivariate Cox's proportional hazard regression analysis were included in the meta-analysis. A p value < 0,05 was considered significant. Results: Among the 647 articles found, 12 were included in the systematic review and two in the meta-analysis. The risk of development of adverse outcomes was assessed by eight studies using the hazard ratio. Among them, six studies found an increased risk of cardiovascular events or mortality. The multivariate regression analysis was performed by six studies, and the risk of developing adverse outcomes remained significant after the analysis in four of these studies. The result of the meta-analysis [HR = 2.28 (1.70-3.05), p < 0.001] indicated that there is a significant association between high levels of cystatin C and the risk of mortality in individuals with normal renal function. Conclusion: There is a significant association between high levels of cystatin C and the development of cardiovascular events or mortality in individuals with normal renal function.

Resumo Fundamento: A cistatina C tem-se mostrado promissora para avaliação do risco de eventos cardiovasculares e mortalidade. Objetivo: Avaliar a associação entre níveis elevados de cistatina C e o desenvolvimento de eventos cardiovasculares ou mortalidade. Métodos: A seleção dos artigos foi realizada por meio das bases de dados Medline/PubMed, Web of Science e Scielo. Os critérios de elegibilidade foram estudos observacionais de coorte prospectivos que avaliaram a associação entre níveis séricos elevados de cistatina C e o desenvolvimento de eventos cardiovasculares ou mortalidade em indivíduos com função renal normal. Apenas os estudos que avaliaram o desfecho mortalidade, que compararam o quarto com o primeiro quartil de cistatina C e que realizaram análise de regressão multivariada de riscos proporcionais de Cox foram incluídos na meta-análise. Foi considerado significativo o valor p < 0,05. Resultados: Dentre os 647 artigos encontrados, 12 foram incluídos na revisão sistemática e dois na meta-análise. O risco de desenvolvimento dos desfechos adversos foi avaliado por oito estudos por meio do cálculo do hazard ratio. Dentre estes, seis estudos encontraram um maior risco de eventos cardiovasculares ou mortalidade. A análise de regressão multivariada foi realizada por seis destes estudos, e o risco de desenvolvimento dos desfechos adversos permaneceu significativo após realização desta análise em quatro destes estudos. O resultado da meta-análise [HR = 2,28 (1,70-3,05), p < 0,001] indicou que há uma associação significativa entre níveis elevados de cistatina C e o risco de mortalidade nos indivíduos com função renal normal. Conclusão: Há uma associação significativa entre níveis elevados de cistatina C e o desenvolvimento de eventos cardiovasculares ou mortalidade em indivíduos com função renal normal.

Association Between Increased Levels of Cystatin C and the Development of Cardiovascular Events or Mortality: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.

BACKGROUND: Cystatin C seems promising for evaluating the risk of cardiovascular events and mortality. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the association between high levels of cystatin C and the development of cardiovascular events or mortality. METHODS: The articles were selected in the Medline/PubMed, Web of Science, and Scielo databases. The eligibility criteria were prospective cohort observational trials that assessed the association of high serum levels of cystatin C with the development of cardiovascular events or mortality in individuals with normal renal function. Only studies that evaluated the mortality outcome compared the fourth with the first quartile of cystatin C and performed multivariate Cox's proportional hazard regression analysis were included in the meta-analysis. A p value < 0,05 was considered significant. RESULTS: Among the 647 articles found, 12 were included in the systematic review and two in the meta-analysis. The risk of development of adverse outcomes was assessed by eight studies using the hazard ratio. Among them, six studies found an increased risk of cardiovascular events or mortality. The multivariate regression analysis was performed by six studies, and the risk of developing adverse outcomes remained significant after the analysis in four of these studies. The result of the meta-analysis [HR = 2.28 (1.70-3.05), p < 0.001] indicated that there is a significant association between high levels of cystatin C and the risk of mortality in individuals with normal renal function. CONCLUSION: There is a significant association between high levels of cystatin C and the development of cardiovascular events or mortality in individuals with normal renal function.

GFR estimation based on standardized creatinine and cystatin C: a European multicenter analysis in older adults.

BACKGROUND: Although recommended by the Kidney Disease Improving Global Outcomes, the Chronic Kidney Disease Epidemiology Collaboration (CKD-EPICR) creatinine equation was not targeted to estimate glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) among older adults. The Berlin Initiative Study (BIS1CR) equation was specifically developed in older adults, and the Lund-Malmö revised (LMRCR) and the Full Age Spectrum (FASCR) equations have shown promising results in older adults. Our aim was to validate these four creatinine equations, including addition of cystatin C in a large multicenter cohort of Europeans ≥70 years. METHODS: A total of 3226 individuals (2638 with cystatin C) underwent GFR measurement (mGFR; median, 44 mL/min/1.73 m2) using plasma iohexol clearance. Bias, precision (interquartile range [IQR]), accuracy (percent of estimates ±30% of mGFR, P30), eGFR accuracy diagrams and probability diagrams to classify mGFR<45 mL/min/1.73 m2 were compared. RESULTS: The overall results of BIS1CR/CKD-EPICR/FASCR/LMRCR were as follows: median bias, 1.7/3.6/0.6/-0.7 mL/min/1.73 m2; IQR, 11.6/12.3/11.1/10.5 mL/min/1.73 m2; and P30, 77.5%/76.4%/80.9%/83.5% (significantly higher for LMR, p<0.001). Substandard P30 (<75%) was noted for all equations at mGFR<30 mL/min/1.73 m2, and at body mass index values <20 and ≥35 kg/m2. LMRCR had the most stable performance across mGFR subgroups. Only LMRCR and FASCR had a relatively constant small bias across eGFR levels. Probability diagrams exhibited wide eGFR intervals for all equations where mGFR<45 could not be confidently ruled in or out. Adding cystatin C improved P30 accuracy to 85.7/86.8/85.7/88.7 for BIS2CR+CYS/CKD-EPICR+CYS/FASCR+CYS/MEANLMR+CAPA. CONCLUSIONS: LMRCR and FASCR seem to be attractive alternatives to CKD-EPICR in estimating GFR by creatinine-based equations in older Europeans. Addition of cystatin C leads to important improvement in estimation performance.

Multicenter Evaluation of Cystatin C Measurement after Assay Standardization.

BACKGROUND: Since 2010, a certified reference material ERM-DA471/IFCC has been available for cystatin C (CysC). This study aimed to assess the sources of uncertainty in results for clinical samples measured using standardized assays. METHODS: This evaluation was performed in 2015 and involved 7 clinical laboratories located in France and Belgium. CysC was measured in a panel of 4 serum pools using 8 automated assays and a candidate isotope dilution mass spectrometry reference measurement procedure. Sources of uncertainty (imprecision and bias) were evaluated to calculate the relative expanded combined uncertainty for each CysC assay. Uncertainty was judged against the performance specifications derived from the biological variation model. RESULTS: Only Siemens reagents on the Siemens systems and, to a lesser extent, DiaSys reagents on the Cobas system, provided results that met the minimum performance criterion calculated according to the intraindividual and interindividual biological variations. Although the imprecision was acceptable for almost all assays, an increase in the bias with concentration was observed for Gentian reagents, and unacceptably high biases were observed for Abbott and Roche reagents on their own systems. CONCLUSIONS: This comprehensive picture of the market situation since the release of ERM-DA471/IFCC shows that bias remains the major component of the combined uncertainty because of possible problems associated with the implementation of traceability. Although some manufacturers have clearly improved their calibration protocols relative to ERM-DA471, most of them failed to meet the criteria for acceptable CysC measurements.

Paradoxical effects of thyroid function on glomerular filtration rate estimated from serum creatinine or standardized cystatin C in patients with Japanese Graves' disease.

BACKGROUND: Estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) is clinically valuable for evaluating renal function. Recently, serum cystatin C (sCysC) measurement has been standardized and has demonstrated utility as a novel indicator of renal function. Thyroid hormone is known to affect serum creatinine (sCr) and sCysC, however, the clinical significance of post-treatment renal function evaluation is yet to be completely elucidated. This study examined the effects of thyroid hormones on eGFR by sCr (eGFRCr), and standardized sCysC (eGFRCysC) in patients with Japanese Graves' disease (GD). METHODS: Serum samples were obtained from 113 outpatients with GD. Following pharmacotherapy, 41 of the 113 outpatients with GD achieved remission. Renal function was evaluated by eGFRCr and eGFRCysC. Reference method used Chronic Kidney Disease Epidemiology Collaboration (CKD-EPI) equations. RESULTS: eGFRCr levels significantly increased whereas eGFRCysC levels significantly decreased with elevated FT3 and FT4 levels in patients with GD. In the remission group, eGFRCr levels significantly decreased and eGFRCysC levels significantly increased. No significant differences between eGFRCr and eGFRCysC levels were observed. Furthermore, CKD-EPI equations show a similar trend and eGFRCr-CysC levels were no significant differences regardless of before and after treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Renal function evaluation by eGFRCr and eGFRCysC had clinical utility in post-treatment euthyroidism.

Generation of a new cystatin C-based estimating equation for glomerular filtration rate by use of 7 assays standardized to the international calibrator.

BACKGROUND: Many different cystatin C-based equations exist for estimating glomerular filtration rate. Major reasons for this are the previous lack of an international cystatin C calibrator and the nonequivalence of results from different cystatin C assays. METHODS: Use of the recently introduced certified reference material, ERM-DA471/IFCC, and further work to achieve high agreement and equivalence of 7 commercially available cystatin C assays allowed a substantial decrease of the CV of the assays, as defined by their performance in an external quality assessment for clinical laboratory investigations. By use of 2 of these assays and a population of 4690 subjects, with large subpopulations of children and Asian and Caucasian adults, with their GFR determined by either renal or plasma inulin clearance or plasma iohexol clearance, we attempted to produce a virtually assay-independent simple cystatin C-based equation for estimation of GFR. RESULTS: We developed a simple cystatin C-based equation for estimation of GFR comprising only 2 variables, cystatin C concentration and age. No terms for race and sex are required for optimal diagnostic performance. The equation, [Formula: see text] is also biologically oriented, with 1 term for the theoretical renal clearance of small molecules and 1 constant for extrarenal clearance of cystatin C. CONCLUSIONS: A virtually assay-independent simple cystatin C-based and biologically oriented equation for estimation of GFR, without terms for sex and race, was produced.

Analytic and clinical validation of a standardized cystatin C particle enhanced turbidimetric assay (PETIA) to estimate glomerular filtration rate.

BACKGROUND: Cystatin C is an alternative biomarker for assessing glomerular filtration rate (GFR), yet lack of standardization could hinder its widespread use. In this study we analytically and clinically validated a newer cystatin C particle-enhanced turbidimetric assay (PETIA) traceable to a certified reference material and compared it to the more commonly used particle-enhanced nephelometric assay (PENIA). METHODS: Samples from four patient cohorts at the Mayo Clinic were studied: 1) clinical convenience samples (n=50); 2) samples from patients undergoing iothalamate urinary clearance testing for clinical indications (n=101); 3) volunteers without kidney disease (n=292); 4) samples from 1999-2000 with previous cystatin C measurements. RESULTS: The cystatin C PETIA was analytically robust between 0.15 mg/L and 8.36 mg/L. PETIA cystatin C values were 27.5% higher than PENIA results. Furthermore, PENIA results were 12.9% lower in 2010 than in 2000. PETIA cystatin C values and existing equations performed reasonably well to estimate GFR with an overall -7.4% bias for all patients analyzed. Age and gender specific reference intervals were established for the PETIA cystatin C. CONCLUSIONS: Cystatin C can be precisely measured by PETIA traceable to the international reference material, ERM-DA471/IFCC, using a routine chemistry autoanalyzer. There are important biases between this assay and the widely employed Siemens PENIA. This study highlights the importance of assay standardization if cystatin C is to be widely used to estimate GFR.

Cystatin C as a marker of glomerular filtration rate: prospects and limitations.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: There is much interest in cystatin C to replace or supplement serum creatinine to estimate the glomerular filtration rate (GFR). Here we review the performance of cystatin C and combined creatinine-cystatin C estimating equations compared to creatinine-based estimating equations in chronic and acute kidney disease. RECENT FINDINGS: Drift in the cystatin C assay has had a large effect on the results reported using cystatin C, but these issues are not routinely considered in evaluation of GFR-estimating equations. The recently released primary reference material for cystatin C will allow less difference among assays in the future. There does not appear to be a consistent message among published studies as to whether cystatin C-based equations are better than creatinine-based equations in the general population or those with chronic kidney disease (CKD), as well as those with reduced muscle mass or chronic illness, or acute kidney injury. Cystatin C could be used in combination with creatinine as a confirmatory test for estimated GFR from creatinine. SUMMARY: Cystatin C may have a role to estimate GFR in selected circumstances, and the next set of studies should be directed at developing implementation strategies for its use.

Preliminary reference intervals for cystatin C and beta-trace protein in preterm and term neonates.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the reference intervals for serum cystatin C (CysC) and beta-trace protein (BTP) as markers of renal function in preterm and term neonates. DESIGN AND METHODS: Blood samples of 128 neonates (34% female) admitted to the NICU were analyzed to determine the levels of serum creatinine (enzymatically), CysC and BTP (nephelometric, Siemens Health Care). RESULTS: The reference intervals, categorized by age, were reported for the 128 neonates. Median (lower/upper limit) BTP were 1.85 (0.57/3.16) and 1.27 (0.51/2.07) mg/L on days 1 and 3. In keeping with maturation of renal function after birth, CysC and BTP fell from days one to day three after birth, whereas creatinine did not. CONCLUSION: Our data provides reference intervals for the levels of creatinine, CysC, and BTP in neonates on days 1 and 3 after birth and demonstrates that CysC and BTP reflect neonatal renal function, whereas creatinine reflects maternal renal function.

Changes in the concentrations of creatinine, cystatin C and NGAL in patients with acute paraquat self-poisoning.

An increase in creatinine > 3 µmol/L/h has been suggested to predict death in patients with paraquat self-poisoning and the value of other plasma biomarkers of acute kidney injury has not been assessed. The aim of this study was to validate the predictive value of serial creatinine concentrations and to study the utility of cystatin C and neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin (NGAL) as predictors of outcome in patients with acute paraquat poisoning. The rate of change of creatinine (dCr/dt) and cystatin C (dCyC/dt) concentrations were compared between survivors and deaths. Receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curves were constructed to determine the best threshold for predicting death. Paraquat was detected in 20 patients and 7 of these died between 18 h and 20 days post-ingestion. The dCr/dt ROC curve had an area of 0.93 and the cut-off was > 4.3 µmol/L/h (sensitivity 100%, specificity 85%, likelihood ratio 7). The dCyC/dt ROC curve had an area of 0.97 and the cutoff was > 0.009 mg/L/h (sensitivity 100%, specificity 91%, likelihood ratio 11). NGAL did not separate survivors from deaths. Death due to acute paraquat poisoning is associated with changes in creatinine and cystatin concentrations. Further validation of these measurements is needed before they can be adopted in guiding intensive treatments.

Performance evaluation of the Roche Tina-quant Cystatin C assay and reference interval for cystatin C in healthy blood donors.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the performance of the Roche Diagnostics Tina-quant Cystatin C particle enhanced immuno turbidimetric assay for the measurement of plasma and serum cystatin C, and to establish reference intervals for cystatin C in healthy blood donors. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The cystatin C measurements were performed on the Roche Modular Analytics P automated clinical chemistry analyzer. RESULTS: The cystatin C assay was linear in the measuring range 0.40-7.00 mg/L. Within-run CVs < or = 2.0%, between-run CVs < or = 4.2%, and total CVs < or = 5.5% in plasma pools and in commercial cystatin C control materials (range 1.0-4.7 mg/L). Recovery was 99.4-109.3%. No interference was detected from haemoglobin < 0.9 mmol/L, bilirubin < 330 micromol/L and Intralipid < 20 g/L. Measurement of cystatin C in Li-heparin plasma did not differ significantly from cystatin C measured in serum. Forty patient samples run on the Modular Analytics P (y) were compared to the Siemens Cystatin C assay on the BN II (x): y = 0.817x + 0.270, Sy.x = 0.168 (Deming regression). The non-parametric reference interval for cystatin C was calculated to be 0.41-0.91 mg/L in females (n = 86), and 0.43-0.94 mg/L in males (n = 76). The Mann-Whitney U test showed a significant difference between the two genders (p = 0.015), but the difference was without clinical relevance. A common reference interval for both genders (n = 162) was calculated to be 0.41-0.92 mg/L. CONCLUSION: The performance of the Tina-quant Cystatin C assay was acceptable for clinical use.