Developmental innervation of cranial dura mater and migraine headache: A narrative literature review.

INTRODUCTION: Migraine headache prevalence, etiology, and clinical presentations change from childhood to adulthood. Dural innervation plays a role in headache symptomatology, but the changes in innervation during development have not been fully explored in the literature. METHODS: A narrative literature review on developmental innervation of cranial dura mater in the context of migraine headache. RESULTS: Dural structures, nerve distributions, and pain attributed to migraine headache at varying stages of development are discussed herein with a focus on clinical findings and presentations. CONCLUSIONS: There are many differences in migraine presentation throughout development. Notably, the nervus spinosus and nervus tentorii may play a role in developmental differences in migraine headache presentations between children and adults.

3D digital subtracted CT angiography to evaluate the venous anatomy in extra-axial tumors invading the major dural venous sinuses.

Background Investigation of the venous system surrounding a tumor that is invading a dural sinus is of great use for guiding the surgical excision. Non-invasive imaging is often inadequate since enhancement of the tumor causes it to blend with the contrast of the venous vascular structures. Conventional two-dimensional angiography is also often insufficient. Objective The objective of this study was to report regarding the potential of three-dimensional digital subtracted computed tomography angiography (3D DS-CTA) as a technique to preoperatively explore these tumors. Methods We retrospectively studied the radiological and surgical features of patients explored with 3D DS-CTA for a tumor invading a major dural sinus. Results Three patients were included in this study, one hemangiopericytoma and two meningiomas. 3D DS-CTA allows for accurate assessment of the patency of the sinus, the location of the secondary intra- and trans-osseous venous outlets, and surgical guidance by neuronavigation. Conclusion 3D DS-CTA could be a promising guiding and diagnostic tool for the pre- and intraoperative treatment of vascular tumors invading the dural sinuses, for which the venous morbidity and mortality is substantial.

Developmental changes in human dural innervation.

INTRODUCTION: There is limited published work on the abundant innervation of the human dura mater, its role and responses to injury in humans. The dura not only provides mechanical support for the brain but may also have other functions, including control of the outflow of venous blood from the brain via the dural sinuses. The trigeminal nerve supplies sensory fibres to the dura as well as the leptomeninges, intracranial blood vessels, face, nose and mouth. Its relatively large size in embryonic life suggests an importance in development; the earliest fetal reflexes, mediated by the trigeminal, are seen by 8 weeks. Trigeminal functions vital to the fetus include the coordination of sucking and swallowing and the protective oxygen-conserving reflexes. Like other parts of the nervous system, the trigeminal undergoes pruning and remodelling throughout development. METHODS: We have investigated changes in the innervation of the human dura with age in 27 individuals aged between 31 weeks of gestation and 60 years of postnatal life. Using immunocytochemistry with antibodies to neurofilament, we have found significant changes in the density of dural innervation with age RESULTS: The density of innervation increased between 31 and 40 weeks of gestation, peaking at term and decreasing in the subsequent 3 months, remaining low until the sixth decade. CONCLUSIONS: Our observations are consistent with animal studies but are, to our knowledge, the first to show age-related changes in the density of innervation in the human dura. They provide new insights into the functions of the human dura during development.

A morphometric analysis of the infant calvarium and dura.

Literature addressing the anatomic development of the dura and calvarium during childhood is limited. Nevertheless, histological features of a subdural neomembrane (NM), including its thickness and vascularity, developing in response to an acute subdural hematoma (SDH) have been compared to the dura of adults to estimate when an injury occurred. Therefore, we measured the morphometric growth of the calvarium and dura and the vascular density within the dura during infancy. The mean thicknesses of the calvarium and dura as a function of occipitofrontal circumference (OFC), as well as the mean number of vessels per 25 × field, were determined from the right parasagittal midparietal bone lateral to the sagittal suture of 128 infants without a history of head trauma. Our results showed that as OFC increased, the mean thicknesses of the calvarium and dura increased while the vascular density within the dura decreased. Our morphometric data may assist in the interpretation of subdural NM occurring during infancy. We recommend future investigations to confirm and extend our present data, especially by evaluating cases during later infancy and beyond as well as by sampling other anatomic sites from the calvarium. We also recommend morphometric evaluation of subdural NM associated with SDH in infancy and childhood.

Use of tissue glue to prevent collapse of the cortical mantle during and after cranial surgery in children: a technical note.

INTRODUCTION: Young children with significant ventricular dilatation or large intracranial fluid spaces often have a very thin cortical mantle as a result of persistently raised intracranial pressure. This rim of cortex has a tendency to fall away from the dura into the cavity during and after intracranial surgery, due to the lack of support, once the pressure in the fluid cavity has been reduced. This can lead to tearing of cortical bridging veins and the formation of post-operative subdural haematomas. METHODS: We describe a simple technique that attempts to prevent this phenomenon occurring using tissue glue. Once the craniotomy has been performed and the dura has been formally opened, tissue glue is applied to the underside of the dura around the edge of the wound, prior to corticotomy. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: This results in the cortical mantle adhering to the undersurface of the dura and prevents the mantle from falling into the cavity either during the procedure or post-operatively.

Demonstration of fluid channels in human dura and their relationship to age and intradural bleeding.

PURPOSE: This paper aims to make a systematic study of human dura to establish the presence of fluid transport channels and their relationship to age. METHODS: Samples of parasagittal dura from autopsy cases from mid-gestation to the ninth decade were examined by light microscopy. RESULTS: We have demonstrated the presence of unlined rounded spaces, uncommon in the fetus and neonate but increasingly evident after 30 weeks of postnatal life. We have shown that intradural bleeding is inversely correlated with the presence of these channels and with age. CONCLUSIONS: We suggest that dural maturation, involving the development of arachnoid granulations, may be related to dilatation of intradural fluid channels, allowing them to be identified histologically. The risk of reflux of blood into the dura appears to reduce with age.

Fluctuating asymmetry and developmental instability in sagittal craniosynostosis.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether premature sagittal craniosynostosis is associated with developmental instability in the skull by analyzing fluctuating asymmetry in skull shape. DESIGN: Cranial shape was quantified by collecting coordinate data from landmarks located on three-dimensional reconstructions of preoperative computed tomography (CT) images of 22 children with sagittal craniosynostosis and 22 age-matched controls. A fluctuating asymmetry application of Euclidean distance matrix analysis (EDMA) was used to quantify and compare asymmetry in cranial shape using these landmark data. RESULTS: In contrast to expectations, the sagittal craniosynostosis group did not show a statistically significant increase in the overall level of fluctuating asymmetry relative to the control group. However, we discerned statistically significant localized increases in fluctuating asymmetry in the sagittal craniosynostosis group at pterion and the anterior clinoid processes (alpha = .05). We also determined a significant correlation of fluctuating asymmetry values between the two groups (r = .71). CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that there is no evidence of a role for system-wide developmental instability in the etiology of nonsyndromic sagittal craniosynostosis. However, the localized evidence of asymmetry at the anterior clinoid processes in the sagittal synostosis group suggests an association with the tracts of dura mater that attach there.

The role of regional posterior frontal dura mater in the overlying suture morphology.

BACKGROUND: Craniosynostosis, the premature fusion of one or more cranial sutures, is a common developmental disorder resulting in morphologic and functional consequences. The rat model is useful for studying pathologic and normal suture fusion because the posterior frontal suture undergoes fusion but the remaining sutures remain patent. The authors investigated the influence of regional posterior frontal dura mater on the overlying suture morphology and fate. METHODS: In 8-day-old Sprague-Dawley rats, an 8-mm calvarial disk was excised without disrupting the underlying dura mater (n = 22) and flipped so that the previously ectocranial aspect was adjacent to the dura mater. The animals were humanely killed after 5, 7, 9, 11, and 28 days, and the posterior frontal sutures were analyzed histologically. A comparison was made to control animals in which the disk was excised and then placed back into its anatomical position (n = 5). Immunohistochemistry of the transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta isoforms was performed to investigate their differential, temporal, and spatial expression. RESULTS: Posterior frontal suture fusion occurred on the side adjacent to the dura mater (previously patent ectocranial aspect) in an anterior-to-posterior direction, similar to that in the control group. There was specific expression of the TGF-beta isoforms in the dura mater and suture mesenchyme adjacent to the dura mater. CONCLUSIONS: Regional dura mater plays an important role in suture morphology, and the posterior frontal-associated dura mater possesses potent, pro-osteogenic signals that influence the overlying suture fate. The differential expression pattern of TGF-beta signaling from the dura mater further supports the regional paracrine effect of the dura mater.

Mast cells populations fluctuate along the spinal dura mater of the developing rat.

The present study reveals developmental changes in the number, the phenotype and the distribution pattern of mast cells (MCs) along the cervical, the thoracic and the lumbar parts of the spinal dura mater. Postnatal infiltration of spinal dura by MCs does not appear to follow a sequential developmental pattern and meningeal MCs are unevenly distributed along the various parts of the examined dura. At each spinal level, areas most densely populated by MCs are the dorsal dura and the dural sleeves of the dorsal (sensory) spinal roots The developmental time course of the total MCs number is characterized by significant fluctuations in all three parts examined, with notable increases at P1, P4, P21 and P60 (peak value) for the cervical part, at P1 (peak value), P7 and P21 for the thoracic part and at P1, P7 (peak value) and P30 for the lumbar part. At P180, MCs number declines to 56%, 33% and 13% of the peak values for the cervical, the thoracic and the lumbar part, respectively. However, a different developmental pattern is followed by each subpopulation of MCs identified on the basis of their staining characteristics, namely connective tissue type mast cells (CTMCs), mucosal type or cells with characteristics of immature mast cells (MTMCs) and mixed type MCs, in each part examined. The findings may be of importance in elucidating physiological and pathological processes in the dura mater and the vertebral column.

Dura mater-derived FGF-2 mediates mitogenic signaling in calvarial osteoblasts.

Although dura mater tissue is believed to have an important role in calvarial reossification in many in vivo studies, few studies have shown the direct effect of dura mater cells on osteoblasts. In addition, no reports have yet identified the potential factor(s) responsible for various biological activities exerted by dura mater on calvarial reossification (e.g., cell proliferation). In this study, we tested the effect of dura mater on calvarial-derived osteoblasts by performing both heterotypic coculture and by culturing osteoblast cells with conditioned media harvested from dura mater cells of juvenile (3-day-old) and adult (30-day-old) mice. The results presented here demonstrate that cellular proliferation of juvenile osteoblast cells was significantly increased by juvenile dura mater either in the coculture system or when dura mater cell-conditioned medium was applied to the osteoblast cells. Moreover, high levels of FGF-2 protein were detected in juvenile dura mater cells and their conditioned medium. In contrast, low levels of FGF-2 protein were detected in adult dura mater cells, whereas FGF-2 protein was not detectable in their conditioned medium. Abrogation of the mitogenic effect induced by juvenile dura mater cell-conditioned medium was achieved by introducing a neutralizing anti-FGF-2 antibody, thus indicating that FGF-2 may be responsible for the mitogenic effect of the juvenile dura mater. Moreover, data obtained by exploring the three major FGF-2 signaling pathways further reinforced the idea that FGF-2 might be an important paracrine signaling factor in vivo supplied by the underlying dura mater to the overlying calvarial osteoblasts.

Developmental changes of mast cell populations in the cerebral meninges of the rat.

It is known that both the dura and the pia mater attract and support the differentiation of mast cells. The present study shows that unevenly distributed mast cells in the cerebral meninges of the rat can be found in perivascular sites and vessel ramification points, but can also be unrelated to the meningeal vasculature. It also documents changes in the number, localization and staining preferences of the mast cells in the two meninges of the developing and mature rat brain. Quantitative examination of all types of histochemically differentiated meningeal mast cells reveals no major (although some exist) differences between right and left side subpopulations, but strongly suggests a different origin and fate of the dural and the pial mast cells. The number of dural mast cells, already high from postnatal day 0, although declining from postnatal day 21 onwards, remains conspicuous up to postnatal day 180. In contrast, pial mast cells are comparatively very few in the first day of the postnatal life, and despite a transient significant increase in the following two weeks, they reach almost zero levels from postnatal day 21.

Multiple differentiation potentials of neonatal dura mater-derived cells.

OBJECTIVE: The involvement of the dura mater in calvarial development and bone healing lead to a hypothesis that progenitor cells with multiple differentiation potentials exist within this tissue. The present study investigated the differentiation potentials of dura mater-derived cells by driving them into several cell-restricted lineages. METHODS: Dissected dura mater tissue of neonatal rats was washed, finely minced, and enzymatically digested. The harvested cells were exposed to different differentiation (osteogenic, adipogenic, and chondrogenic) and basic media. RESULTS: At defined time points, dura mater-derived cells were observed to differentiate into osteoblastic, adipoblastic, and chondroblastic cells, evidenced by specific biochemical staining. In addition, gene expressions of osteogenesis (alkaline phosphatase, osteocalcin, and osteopontin), chondrogenesis (collagen Type II and aggrecan core protein) and adipogenesis (peroxisome proliferator activated receptor gamma-2) were up-regulated in the differentiated dura mater-derived cells, confirmed by polymerase chain reaction. CONCLUSION: Preliminarily, it was concluded that a subpopulation of multiple potential mesenchymal cells exists in neonatal dura mater, which explains the function of the dura mater on neurocranium development and calvarial bone healing.

Cellular dynamics and tissue interactions of the dura mater during head development.

During development and growth of the neurocranium, the dura mater regulates events in the underlying brain and overlying skull by the release of soluble factors and cellular activity. Morphogenesis of the cranial bones and sutures is dependent on tissue interactions with the dura mater, which control the size and shape of bones as well as sutural patency. Development of the brain also involves interactions with dura mater: secretion of stromal derived factor 1 (SDF-1) is a critical event in directing migration of the external granular layer precursors of the cerebellar cortex and the Cajal-Retzius (CR) cells of the cerebral cortex. The dura mater is also required for growth of the hippocampal dentate gyrus. Wnt1Cre/R26R transgenic reporter mice were used to study the origin and fates of the cells of dura mater during head development. The dura mater of mammals is derived entirely from the cranial neural crest. Beginning around neonatal day 10 (N 10), the dura mater is infiltrated by cells derived from paraxial mesoderm, which later come to predominate. Over the course of infancy, the neural crest-derived cells of the dura mater become sequestered in niche-like distribution characteristic of stem cells. Simultaneously, dura mater cells underlying the sagittal suture migrate upward into the mesodermally-derived mesenchyme separating the parietal bones. Although initially the parietal bones are formed entirely from paraxial mesoderm, the cellular composition gradually becomes chimeric and is populated mainly by neural crest-derived cells by N 30. This occurs as a consequence of osteoblastic differentiation at the dura mater interface and intravasation of neural crest-derived osteoclastic and other hematopoietic precursors. The isolated cells of the dura mater are multipotent in vitro, giving rise to osteoblasts, neuronal cells and other derivatives characteristic of cranial neural crest, possibly reflecting the multipotent nature of dura mater cells in vivo.

Age-dependent residual tensile strains are present in the dura mater of rats.

The objectives of this study were to determine whether residual tensile strains exist in the dura mater of mammals in vivo, and whether the strains are age-dependent. We made incisions in the parietal dura mater of immature and mature rats, and measured the retraction of the dura mater from each incision. We then used a finite-element model to calculate the strain present in the parietal dura mater of each rat. We found that age-dependent residual tensile strains are present in the dura mater of rats. The mean average residual strain of the immature rats was significantly larger than that of the mature rats (4.96+/-1.54% (s.d.) versus 0.39+/-0.13%, p<0.0001), with the mean strain calculated in the mature rats of the order of the minimum measurement that could be made using our experimental approach. In addition, in the immature rats mean residual strain in the longitudinal direction was significantly larger than mean residual strain in the transverse direction (6.11+/-3.62% versus 3.82+/-2.64%, p=0.0218). Our findings show that age-dependent residual tensile strains exist in the dura mater of rats. We speculate that these strains may reflect the rate and direction of cranial growth and may also influence cranial healing.

Mechanical strain affects dura mater biological processes: implications for immature calvarial healing.

The human brain grows rapidly during the first 2 years of life. This growth generates tensile strain in the overlying dura mater and neurocranium. Interestingly, it is largely during this 2-year growth period that infants are able to reossify calvarial defects. This clinical observation is important because it suggests that calvarial healing is most robust during the period of active intracranial volume expansion. With a rat model, it was previously demonstrated that immature dura mater proliferates more rapidly and produces more osteogenic cytokines and markers of osteoblast differentiation than does mature dura mater. It was therefore hypothesized that mechanical strain generated by the growing brain induces immature dura mater proliferation and increases osteogenic cytokine expression necessary for growth and healing of the overlying calvaria. Human and rat (n = 40) intracranial volume expansion was calculated as a function of age. These calculations demonstrated that 83 percent of human intracranial volume expansion is complete by 2 years of age and 90 percent of Sprague-Dawley rat intracranial volume expansion is achieved by 2 months of age. Next, the maximal daily circumferential tensile strains that could be generated in immature rat dura mater were calculated, and the corresponding daily biaxial tensile strains in the dura mater during this 2-month period were determined. With the use of a three-parameter monomolecular growth curve, it was calculated that rat dura mater experiences daily equibiaxial strains of at most 9.7 percent and 0.1 percent at birth (day 0) and 60 days of age, respectively. Because it was noted that immature dural cells may experience tensile strains as high as approximately 10 percent, neonatal rat dural cells were subjected to 10 percent equibiaxial strain in vitro, and dural cell proliferation and gene expression profiles were analyzed. When exposed to mechanical strain, immature dural cells rapidly proliferated (5.8-fold increase in proliferating cell nuclear antigen expression at 24 hours). Moreover, mechanical strain induced marked up-regulation of dural cell osteogenic cytokine production; transforming growth factor-beta1 messenger RNA levels increased 3.4-fold at 3 hours and fibroblast growth factor-2 protein levels increased 4.5-fold at 24 hours and 5.6-fold at 48 hours. Finally, mechanical strain increased dural cell expression of markers of osteoblast differentiation (2.8-fold increase in osteopontin levels at 3 hours). These findings suggest that mechanical strain can induce changes in dura mater biological processes and gene expression that may play important roles in coordinating the growth and healing of the neonatal calvaria.

Unicoronal suture autotransplantation in the rabbit.

INTRODUCTION: Our hypothesis was that a neurocranial suture autograft will, when shielded from dura, grow and be incorporated into the calvarium. METHODS: Growth was monitored by marker separation in three isohistogenic groups of rabbits, between postnatal days 9 and 90. In order to simulate increased neurocapsular expansion force, the left-sided coronal suture of a group of 20 rabbits was immobilised with a resorbable suture on gestational day 25. The other group of 10 rabbits was sham-operated. On postnatal day 9, 10 of the experimental rabbits underwent transplantation of the suture contralateral to the defect resulting from extirpation of the immobilised suture. The transplant was shielded from dural influence by a platinum foil. RESULTS: The growth of the immobilised coronal sutures was severely impaired, and also that of the contralateral unicoronal sutures to a lesser extent. A significant catch-up of growth occurred in the transplanted unicoronal sutures. Overgrowth occurred at the donor sites. CONCLUSION: The results allow us to consider suture transplantation combined with endosteal dura stripping in craniosynostosis surgery.

The role of fibroblast growth factor (FGF) and type beta transforming growth factor (TGF-beta 1-beta 2-beta 3) during rat craniofacial development.

Growth factors seem to be part of a complex cellular signalling language, in which individual growth factors are the equivalents of the letters that compose words. According to this analogy, informational content lies, not in an individual growth factor, but in the entire set of growth factors and others signals to which a cell is exposed. The ways in which growth factors exert their combinatorial effects are becoming clearer as the molecular mechanisms of growth factors actions are being investigated. A number of related extracellular signalling molecules that play widespread roles in regulating development in both invertebrates and vertebrates constitute the Fibroblast Growth Factor (FGF) and type beta Transforming Growth Factor (TGF beta). The latest research literature about the role and fate of these Growth factors and their influence in the craniofacial bone growth ad development is reviewed.

Regional differentiation of cranial suture-associated dura mater in vivo and in vitro: implications for suture fusion and patency.

Despite its prevalence, the etiopathogenesis of craniosynostosis is poorly understood. To better understand the biomolecular events that occur when normal craniofacial growth development goes awry, we must first investigate the mechanisms of normal suture fusion. Murine models in which the posterior frontal (PF) suture undergoes programmed sutural fusion shortly after birth provide an ideal model to study these mechanisms. In previous studies, our group and others have shown that sutural fate (i.e., fusion vs. patency) is regulated by the dura mater (DM) directly underlying a cranial suture. These studies have led to the hypothesis that calvarial DM is regionally differentiated and that this differentiation guides the development of the overlying suture. To test this hypothesis, we evaluated the messenger RNA (mRNA) expression of osteogenic cytokines (transforming growth factor beta1 [TGF-beta1] and TGF-beta3) and bone-associated extracellular matrix (ECM) molecules (collagen I, collagen III, osteocalcin, and alkaline phosphatase) in freshly isolated, rat dural tissues associated with the PF (programmed to fuse) or sagittal (SAG; remains patent) sutures before histological evidence of sutural fusion (postnatal day 6 [N6]). In addition, osteocalcin protein expression and cellular proliferation were localized using immunohistochemical staining and 5-bromo-2'deoxyuridine (BrdU) incorporation, respectively. We showed that the expression of osteogenic cytokines and bone-associated ECM molecules is potently up-regulated in the DM associated with the PF suture. In addition, we showed that cellular proliferation in the DM associated with the fusing PF suture is significantly less than that found in the patent SAG suture just before the initiation of sutural fusion N6. Interestingly, no differences in cellular proliferation rates were noted in younger animals (embryonic day 18 [E18] and N2). To further analyze regional differentiation of cranial suture-associated dural cells, we established dural cell cultures from fusing and patent rat cranial sutures in N6 rats and evaluated the expression of osteogenic cytokines (TGF-beta1 and fibroblast growth factor 2 [FGF-2]) and collagen I. In addition, we analyzed cellular production of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA). These studies confirmed our in vivo findings and showed that dural cell cultures derived from the fusing PF suture expressed significantly greater amounts of TGF-beta1, FGF-2, and collagen I. In addition, similar to our in vivo findings, we showed that PF suture-derived dural cells produced significantly less PCNA than SAG suture-derived dural cells. Finally, coculture of dural cells with fetal rat calvarial osteoblastic cells (FRCs) revealed a statistically significant increase in proliferation (*p < 0.001) in FRCs cocultured with SAG suture-derived dural cells as compared with FRCs cocultured alone or with PF suture-derived dural cells. Taken together, these data strongly support the hypothesis that the calvarial DM is regionally differentiated resulting in the up-regulation of osteogenic cytokines and bone ECM molecules in the dural tissues underlying fusing but not patent cranial sutures. Alterations in cytokine expression may govern osteoblastic differentiation and ECM molecule deposition, thus regulating sutural fate. Elucidation of the biomolecular events that occur before normal cranial suture fusion in the rat may increase our understanding of the events that lead to premature cranial suture fusion.

Cranial sutures as intramembranous bone growth sites.

Intramembranous bone growth is achieved through bone formation within a periosteum or by bone formation at sutures. Sutures are formed during embryonic development at the sites of approximation of the membranous bones of the craniofacial skeleton. They serve as the major sites of bone expansion during postnatal craniofacial growth. For sutures to function as intramembranous bone growth sites, they need to remain in an unossified state, yet allow new bone to be formed at the edges of the overlapping bone fronts. This process relies on the production of sufficient new bone cells to be recruited into the bone fronts, while ensuring that the cells within the suture remain undifferentiated. Unlike endochondral growth plates, which expand through chondrocyte hypertrophy, sutures do not have intrinsic growth potential. Rather, they produce new bone at the sutural edges of the bone fronts in response to external stimuli, such as signals arising from the expanding neurocranium. This process allows growth of the cranial vault to be coordinated with growth of the neurocranium. Too little or delayed bone growth will result in wide-open fontanels and suture agenesis, whereas too much or accelerated bone growth will result in osseous obliteration of the sutures or craniosynostosis. Craniosynostosis in humans, suture fusion in animals, and induced suture obliteration in vitro has been associated with mutations or alterations in expression of several transcription factors, growth factors, and their receptors. Much of the data concerning signaling within sutures has been garnered from research on cranial sutures; hence, only the cranial sutures will be discussed in detail in this review. This review synthesizes classic descriptions of suture growth and pathology with modern molecular analysis of genetics and cell function in normal and abnormal suture morphogenesis and growth in a unifying hypothesis. At the same time, the reader is reminded of the importance of the suture as an intramembranous bone growth site.