Ethylene Glycol Quenching of Nitrogenase Catalysis: An Electron Paramagnetic Resonance Spectroscopic Study of Nitrogenase Turnover States and CO Bonding.

Most hydrophilic organic solvents inhibit enzymatic activity. Nitrogenase is shown to be approximately 3 times more sensitive to organic inhibition than most other soluble enzymes. Ethylene glycol (EG) is demonstrated to rapidly inhibit nitrogenase activity without uncoupling ATP hydrolysis. Our data suggest the mechanism of inhibition is EG's blocking of binding of MgATP to the nitrogenase Fe protein. EG quenching allows, for the first time, the observation of the relaxation of the intermediate reaction states at room temperature. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy is used to monitor the room-temperature decay of the nitrogenase turnover states following EG quenching of catalytic activity. The return of the intermediate states to the resting state occurs in multiple phases over 2 h. During the initial stage, nitrogenase still possesses the ability to generate CO-induced EPR signals even though catalytic activity has ceased. During the last phase of relaxation, the one-electron reduced state of the MoFe protein (E1) relaxes to the resting state (E0) in a slow first-order reaction.

Ligand binding to the FeMo-cofactor: structures of CO-bound and reactivated nitrogenase.

The mechanism of nitrogenase remains enigmatic, with a major unresolved issue concerning how inhibitors and substrates bind to the active site. We report a crystal structure of carbon monoxide (CO)-inhibited nitrogenase molybdenum-iron (MoFe)-protein at 1.50 angstrom resolution, which reveals a CO molecule bridging Fe2 and Fe6 of the FeMo-cofactor. The µ2 binding geometry is achieved by replacing a belt-sulfur atom (S2B) and highlights the generation of a reactive iron species uncovered by the displacement of sulfur. The CO inhibition is fully reversible as established by regain of enzyme activity and reappearance of S2B in the 1.43 angstrom resolution structure of the reactivated enzyme. The substantial and reversible reorganization of the FeMo-cofactor accompanying CO binding was unanticipated and provides insights into a catalytically competent state of nitrogenase.

Turnover-dependent inactivation of the nitrogenase MoFe-protein at high pH.

Proton uptake accompanies the reduction of all known substrates by nitrogenase. As a consequence, a higher pH should limit the availability of protons as a substrate essential for turnover, thereby increasing the proportion of more highly reduced forms of the enzyme for further study. The utility of the high-pH approach would appear to be problematic in view of the observation reported by Pham and Burgess [(1993) Biochemistry 32, 13725-13731] that the MoFe-protein undergoes irreversible protein denaturation above pH 8.65. In contrast, we found by both enzyme activity and crystallographic analyses that the MoFe-protein is stable when incubated at pH 9.5. We did observe, however, that at higher pHs and under turnover conditions, the MoFe-protein is slowly inactivated. While a normal, albeit low, level of substrate reduction occurs under these conditions, the MoFe-protein undergoes a complex transformation; initially, the enzyme is reversibly inhibited for substrate reduction at pH 9.5, yet in a second, slower process, the MoFe-protein becomes irreversibly inactivated as measured by substrate reduction activity at the optimal pH of 7.8. The final inactivated MoFe-protein has an increased hydrodynamic radius compared to that of the native MoFe-protein, yet it has a full complement of iron and molybdenum. Significantly, the modified MoFe-protein retains the ability to specifically interact with its nitrogenase partner, the Fe-protein, as judged by the support of ATP hydrolysis and by formation of a tight complex with the Fe-protein in the presence of ATP and aluminum fluoride. The turnover-dependent inactivation coupled to conformational change suggests a mechanism-based transformation that may provide a new probe of nitrogenase catalysis.

Effects of substrates (methyl isocyanide, C2H2) and inhibitor (CO) on resting-state wild-type and NifV(-)Klebsiella pneumoniae MoFe proteins.

We report the use of electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) spectroscopy to examine how the metal sites in the FeMo-cofactor cluster of the resting nitrogenase MoFe protein respond to addition of the substrates acetylene and methyl isocyanide and the inhibitor carbon monoxide. 1H, 57Fe and 95Mo ENDOR measurements were performed on the wild-type and the NifV(-)proteins from Klebsiella pneumoniae. Among the molecules tested, only the addition of acetylene to either protein induced widespread changes in the 57Fe ENDOR spectra. Acetylene also induced increases in intensity from unresolved protons in the proton ENDOR spectra. Thus we conclude that acetylene may bind to the resting-state MoFe protein to perturb the FeMo-cofactor environment. On the other hand, the present results show that methyl isocyanide and carbon monoxide do not substantially alter the FeMo cofactor's geometric and electronic structures. We interpret this as lack of interaction between those two molecules and the FeMo cofactor in the resting state MoFe protein. Thus, although it is generally accepted that substrates or inhibitors bind to the FeMo-cofactor only under turnover condition, this work provides evidence that at least one substrate can perturb the active site of nitrogenase under non-catalytic conditions.

Interaction of acetylene and cyanide with the resting state of nitrogenase alpha-96-substituted MoFe proteins.

The nitrogenase MoFe protein contains the active site metallocluster called FeMo-cofactor [7Fe-9S-Mo-homocitrate] that exhibits an S = 3/2 EPR signal in the resting state. No interaction with FeMo-cofactor is detected when either substrates or inhibitors are incubated with MoFe protein in the resting state. Rather, the detection of such interactions requires the incubation of the MoFe protein together with its obligate electron donor, called the Fe protein, and MgATP under turnover conditions. This indicates that a more reduced state of the MoFe protein is required to accommodate substrate or inhibitor interaction. In the present work, substitution of an arginine residue (alpha-96(Arg)) located next to the active site FeMo-cofactor in the MoFe protein by leucine, glutamine, alanine, or histidine is found to result in MoFe proteins that can interact with acetylene or cyanide in the as-isolated, resting state without the need for the Fe protein, or MgATP. The dithionite-reduced, resting states of the alpha-96(Leu)-, alpha-96(Gln)-, alpha-96(Ala)-, or alpha-96(His)-substituted MoFe proteins show an S = 3/2 EPR signal (g = 4.26, 3.67, 2.00) similar to that assigned to FeMo-cofactor in the wild-type MoFe protein. However, in contrast to the wild-type MoFe protein, the alpha-96-substituted MoFe proteins all exhibit changes in their EPR spectra upon incubation with acetylene or cyanide. The alpha-96(Leu)-substituted MoFe protein was representative of the other alpha-96-substituted MoFe proteins examined. The incubation of acetylene with the alpha-96(Leu) MoFe protein decreased the intensity of the normal FeMo-cofactor signal with the appearance of a new EPR signal having inflections at g = 4.50 and 3.50. Incubation of cyanide with the alpha-96(Leu) MoFe protein also decreased the FeMo-cofactor EPR signal with concomitant appearance of a new EPR signal having an inflection at g = 4.06. The acetylene- and cyanide-dependent EPR signals observed for the alpha-96(Leu)-substituted MoFe protein were found to follow Curie law 1/T dependence, consistent with a ground-state transition as observed for FeMo-cofactor. The microwave power dependence of the EPR signal intensity is shifted to higher power for the acetylene- and cyanide-dependent signals, consistent with a change in the relaxation properties of the spin system of FeMo-cofactor. Finally, the alpha-96(Leu)-substituted MoFe protein incubated with (13)C-labeled cyanide displays a (13)C ENDOR signal with an isotropic hyperfine coupling of 0.42 MHz in Q-band Mims pulsed ENDOR spectra. This indicates the existence of some spin density on the cyanide, and thus suggests that the new component of the cyanide-dependent EPR signals arise from the direct bonding of cyanide to the FeMo-cofactor. These data indicate that both acetylene and cyanide are able to interact with FeMo-cofactor contained within the alpha-96-substituted MoFe proteins in the resting state. These results support a model where effective interaction of substrates or inhibitors with FeMo-cofactor occurs as a consequence of both increased reactivity and accessibility of FeMo-cofactor under turnover conditions. We suggest that, for the wild-type MoFe protein, the alpha-96(Arg) side chain acts as a gatekeeper, moving during turnover in order to permit accessibility of acetylene or cyanide to a specific [4Fe-4S] face of FeMo-cofactor.

Azotobacter vinelandii nitrogenases containing altered MoFe proteins with substitutions in the FeMo-cofactor environment: effects on the catalyzed reduction of acetylene and ethylene.

Altered MoFe proteins of Azotobacter vinelandii Mo-nitrogenase, with amino acid substitutions in the FeMo-cofactor environment, were used to probe interactions among C(2)H(2), C(2)H(4), CO, and H(2). The altered MoFe proteins used were the alpha-195(Asn) or alpha-195(Gln) MoFe proteins, which have either asparagine or glutamine substituting for alpha-histidine-195, and the alpha-191(Lys) MoFe protein, which has lysine substituting for alpha-glutamine-191. On the basis of K(m) determinations, C(2)H(2) was a particularly poor substrate for the nitrogenase containing the alpha-191(Lys) MoFe protein. Using C(2)D(2), a correlation was shown between the stereospecificity of proton addition to give the products, cis- and trans-C(2)D(2)H(2), and the propensity of nitrogenase to produce ethane. The most extensive loss of stereospecificity occurred with nitrogenases containing either the alpha-195(Asn) or the alpha-191(Lys) MoFe proteins, which also exhibited the highest rate of ethane production from C(2)H(2). These data are consistent with the presence of a common ethylenic intermediate on the enzyme, which is responsible for both ethane production and loss of proton-addition stereochemistry. C(2)H(4) was not a substrate of the nitrogenase with the alpha-191(Lys) MoFe protein and was a poor substrate of the nitrogenases incorporating either the wild-type or the alpha-195(Gln) MoFe protein, both of which had a low V(max) and high K(m) (120 kPa). Ethylene was a somewhat better substrate for the nitrogenase with the alpha-195(Asn) MoFe protein, which exhibited a K(m) of 48 kPa and a specific activity for C(2)H(6) formation from C(2)H(4) 10-fold higher than the others. Neither the wild-type nitrogenase nor the nitrogenase containing the alpha-195(Asn) MoFe protein produced cis-C(2)D(2)H(2) when turned over under trans-C(2)D(2)H(2). These results suggest that the C(2)H(4)-reduction site is affected by substitution at residue alpha-195, although whether the effect is related to the substrate-reduction site directly or is mediated through disturbance of the delivery of electrons/protons is unclear. Ethylene inhibited total electron flux, without uncoupling MgATP hydrolysis from electron transfer, to a similar extent for all four A. vinelandii nitrogenases. This observation indicates that this C(2)H(4) flux-inhibition site is remote from the C(2)H(4)-reduction site. Added CO eliminated C(2)H(4) reduction but did not fully relieve its electron-flux inhibition with all four A. vinelandii nitrogenases, supporting the suggestion that electron-flux inhibition by C(2)H(4) is not directly connected to C(2)H(4) reduction. Thus, C(2)H(4) has two binding sites, and the presence of CO affects only the site at which it binds as a substrate. When C(2)H(2) was added, it also eliminated C(2)H(6) production from C(2)H(4) and also did not relieve electron-flux inhibition fully. Thus, C(2)H(2) and C(2)H(4) are likely reduced at the same site on the MoFe protein. Two schemes are presented to integrate the results of the interactions of C(2)H(2) and C(2)H(4) with the MoFe proteins.

Evidence for multiple substrate-reduction sites and distinct inhibitor-binding sites from an altered Azotobacter vinelandii nitrogenase MoFe protein.

The arginine-277 residue of the alpha-subunit of the nitrogenase MoFe protein was targeted for substitution because it is (i) a close neighbor of alpha-cysteine-275, which is one of only two residues anchoring the FeMo cofactor to the polypeptide, and (ii) a component of a potential channel for entry/exit of substrates/products and for accepting FeMo cofactor during MoFe-protein maturation. Several of the eight mutant strains constructed were capable of good diazotrophic growth and also contained FeMo cofactor as indicated by its biologically unique S = 3/2 EPR spectrum. These observations indicate that the positively charged alpha-arginine-277 residue is not required for acceptance of the negatively charged FeMo cofactor by the separately synthesized, cofactor-deficient, apo-MoFe protein. The wide range of nitrogen-fixation phenotypes shown by these mutant strains generally correlated well with their C2H2- and proton-reduction activities, which range from 5 to 65% of wild-type activity. One notable exception is the histidine-substituted strain, DJ788 (alpha-277His). This strain, although unable to fix N2 and grow diazotrophically, elaborates an altered alpha-277His MoFe protein that catalyzes the reduction of the alternative substrates, C2H2, HCN, HN3, and protons. These observations are best explained if multiple redox levels are available to the MoFe protein but the alpha-277His MoFe protein is incapable of reaching the more-reduced redox levels required for nitrogen fixation. Under nonsaturating CO concentrations, the alpha-277His MoFe-protein-catalyzed reduction of C2H2 showed sigmoidal kinetics, which is consistent with inhibitor-induced cooperativity among two C2H4-evolving sites and indicates the presence of three sites, which can be simultaneously occupied, on the MoFe protein. Similar kinetics were not observed for alpha-277His MoFe-protein-catalyzed reduction of either HCN or HN3 with nonsaturating CO levels, indicating that these substrates are unlikely to share common binding sites with C2H2. Further, CN- did not induce cooperativity in C2H2 reduction and, therefore, CO and CN- are unlikely to share a common binding site. These changed substrate specificities, reinforced by changes in the FeMo-cofactor-derived S = 3/2 EPR spectrum, clearly indicate the importance of the alpha-277 residue in catalysis and the delicate control exerted on the properties of bound FeMo cofactor by its polypeptide environment.

Synthesis of the iron-molybdenum cofactor of nitrogenase is inhibited by a low-molecular-weight metabolite of Klebsiella pneumoniae.

The in vitro synthesis of the iron-molybdenum cofactor nitrogenase was inhibited by a low-molecular-weight factor. This inhibitory factor was present in the membrane extracts of wild-type and nif mutant strains of Klebsiella pneumoniae that were grown under conditions that either repressed or derepressed nitrogenase expression. In vitro, the inhibition was specific for the NifB protein. Addition of this factor to K. pneumoniae cells at various times during nif derepression decreased nitrogenase activity, presumably through inhibition of iron-molybdenum cofactor synthesis. The inhibitor was purified by solvent extraction and chromatography on DEAE-cellulose, silica gel, and aluminum oxide columns.