Lessons from the Tc-99m shortage: implications of substituting Tl-201 for Tc-99m single-photon emission computed tomography.

BACKGROUND: In 2009, the Chalk River nuclear reactor closed for repairs that led to a critical shortage of technetium-99m (Tc-99m). Several centers used thallium-201 (Tl-201) as an alternative radiotracer for myocardial perfusion imaging. Because Tl-201 is considered by many as a suboptimal radiotracer, we sought to understand the impact of using Tl-201 (during the Tc-99m shortage) on downstream resource utilization. METHODS AND RESULTS: We performed a retrospective study at the Ottawa Heart Institute of 7402 patients (60% men; mean age, 62.6 ± 11.8 years), patients were referred for myocardial perfusion imaging between May 2008 and January 2011 (PRE_Tc-99m [2938 patients]), during (DURING_Tl-201 [2959 patients]), and after (POST_Tc-99m [1505 patients]) the Tc-99m shortage. Patients were followed for 6 months after their index myocardial perfusion imaging to determine subsequent rates of cardiac catheterization or noninvasive imaging. More downstream testing was seen in the Tl-201 cohort (639 [21.4%] patients) than the Tc-99m cohort (537 [12.1%] patients; P<0.001). After adjustment using propensity scores, differences in downstream referral rates were maintained. The downstream investigations resulted in an estimated increase in per-patient costs ($165.22; 95% confidence interval, 153.00-177.42) in the DURING_Tl-201 cohort compared with the Tc-99m cohort ($90.97; 95% confidence interval, 83.42-98.90; P<0.001). As well, the mean effective radiation dose per-patient was higher in DURING_Tl-201 (23.57 mSv; 95% confidence interval, 23.16-23.96) than in Tc-99m (12.92 mSv; 95% confidence interval, 12.55-13.40; P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: In this single-center study, the use of Tl-201 during the Tc-99m shortage was associated with an increase in downstream testing, cost, and patient radiation exposure, but these findings may not be generalizable to other centers. Although Tl-201 provided a short-term solution to the unexpected Tc-99m shortage, long-term cost-effective solutions should be areas of future study.

Cost-effectiveness and accuracy of exercise stress echocardiography in the non-invasive diagnosis of coronary heart disease.

BACKGROUND: Exercise stress echocardiography (ESE) is a more recent form of totally non-invasive stress testing which like exercise thallium SPECT scintigraphy (ETS) was developed to overcome the known limitations of ECG stress testing, namely the limited diagnostic accuracy and the inability of ECG stress testing to site the region of coronary artery disease (CAD) induced ischaemia. AIMS: To determine the sensitivity and specificity (and overall accuracy) of ESE in a group of patients referred for ETS imaging and compare the relative costs of each technique. METHODS: One hundred and fifteen patients referred for ETS consented to a simultaneous ESE. Of this group, 59 patients underwent coronary angiography which was utilised as the gold standard. RESULTS: The feasibility of ESE was 97% (112 of 115 patients of the total study population and 57 of the 59 patients who underwent coronary angiography). Of the 59 patients undergoing coronary angiography, the sensitivity of ESE and ETS were not significantly different (84.1% versus 91.3% respectively). However, despite the apparent marked difference in specificity (92.3% versus 61.5% respectively), p = NS (Fisher's exact test) as there were only 13 normals in the group who underwent coronary angiography. Overall accuracy was also closely similar (86.0% versus 84.7% respectively) and therefore also not significantly different. By contrast, agreement with coronary angiography as measured by the kappa statistic (kappa +/- SEk) was good for ESE (0.66 +/- 0.11) but only moderate for ETS (0.54 +/- 0.13). Moreover, there was a cost saving of at least $594.00 per patient in favour of ESE. CONCLUSION: ESE is a totally non-invasive, sensitive, specific and cost-effective imaging modality for the detection and localisation of CAD.

Comparison of thallium scintigraphy and positron emission tomography.

Assessment of tissue viability has become an important issue in recent years. Scintigraphic measurements have provided important diagnostic, therapeutic, and prognostic information in patients with myocardial dysfunction, who may improve in left ventricular function after revascularization. For detection of regional myocardial ischemia and viability, thallium 201 (201Tl) has been the most widely used tracer in single-photon scintigraphy. However, 201Tl scintigraphy may underestimate regional viability, especially after myocardial infarction. Positron emission tomography (PET) provides an advanced imaging technology that permits the accurate definition of regional tracer distribution. In combination with nitrogen (13N) ammonia, PET allows for the sensitive and specific detection of coronary artery disease. Several studies indicate the superiority of this approach in comparison with standard 201Tl tomographic (SPECT) imaging. In addition, regional blood flow can be accurately measured with 13N ammonia PET, and this approach can be employed in conjunction with pharmacologic stress imaging to quantify regional flow reserve. In combination with metabolic markers, such as fluorine 18 (18F) deoxyglucose, an indicator of glucose uptake, PET is capable of assessing myocardial viability. Furthermore, the PET approach may differentiate between various forms of cardiomyopathy. More studies are needed to define the cost-benefit ratio of both the 201Tl reinjection and the PET technique for the management of patients with coronary artery disease or cardiomyopathy.

Utility of preoperative radionuclide scanning for primary hyperparathyroidism.

This study retrospectively reviews 60 cases of primary hyperparathyroidism, 21 of whom underwent technetium 99 sestamibi scanning and 10 of whom underwent thallium 201/technetium 99 pertechnetate scanning preoperatively. The sestamibi and thallium scans demonstrated an 89.5% and a 62.5% sensitivity rate for adenoma, respectively. Neither scan demonstrated hyperplastic glands well. Although the scans localized adenomatous glands to the correct side well, the ability to localize them more discretely was 68.4% and 62.5%, respectively. In cases of solitary adenoma the effect of an accurate preoperative scan on operative time for bilateral exploration was not significant, whereas the experience of the attending surgeon was significant. Also, the cost of the scans at our institution was greater than the cost of the time saved in performing even unilateral neck exploration. Thus preoperative radionuclide scanning is not cost-effective for the initial exploration of patients with primary hyperparathyroidism and is insufficiently sensitive to make routine unilateral neck exploration for adenoma consistently effective.

Exercise tomographic thallium-201 imaging in patients with severe coronary artery disease and normal electrocardiograms.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the incremental value and cost-effectiveness of exercise tomographic thallium-201 imaging compared with clinical and exercise electrocardiographic variables for detecting three-vessel or left main coronary artery disease in patients with normal at-rest electrocardiograms. DESIGN: Prospective cohort study. PARTICIPANTS: 411 patients (77 [19%] had three-vessel or left main disease) with normal at-rest electrocardiograms who underwent exercise tomographic thallium-201 studies and subsequently had coronary angiography. MEASUREMENTS: Clinical, exercise, and thallium-201 variables; univariate followed by multivariate logistic regression analysis to determine predictors of three-vessel or left main disease (clinical variables; clinical and exercise electrocardiographic variables; and clinical, exercise, and thallium-201 variables). Patients were classified by each of these models into low-, intermediate-, and high-risk groups. SETTING: A tertiary referral center. RESULTS: Among the clinical variables, diabetes mellitus, sex, age, and typical angina were independently associated with severe coronary disease (46% of patients were correctly classified into low- or high-risk groups). The peak exercise heart rate-blood pressure product and the magnitude of the exercise-induced ST depression added independent information to clinical variables. Among the thallium variables, the change in the global thallium-201 score (a measure of redistribution) added independent information to clinical and exercise variables, resulting in only 3% of the patients being reclassified regarding their predicted risk for severe coronary disease. The cost per additional reclassification was estimated to be $20,550. Twenty-one cardiac events occurred (7 cardiac deaths and 14 myocardial infarctions) after thallium study (follow-up, 2.8 +/- 1.0 years). Event-free survival was 94% to 97% regardless of the predicted probability of developing three-vessel or left main coronary artery disease by any model. CONCLUSIONS: When the at-rest electrocardiogram is normal, thallium-201 scintigraphy adds little information to clinical and exercise variables in identifying patients with severe coronary artery disease. The high cost of this information may not justify the routine use of sophisticated imaging for this purpose.

Separate acquisition rest thallium-201/stress technetium-99m sestamibi dual-isotope myocardial perfusion single-photon emission computed tomography: a clinical validation study.

OBJECTIVES: This study assessed the validity of a novel approach to myocardial perfusion scintigraphy that provides the opportunity to avoid the drawbacks of standard same-day rest/stress technetium-99m sestamibi myocardial perfusion studies by using separate-acquisition dual-isotope rest thallium-201 and exercise technetium-99m sestamibi single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT). BACKGROUND: Standard same-day rest/stress technetium-99m sestamibi myocardial perfusion studies are cumbersome, associated with a potential decrease in perceived stress defect severity compared with thallium-201 due to the presence of rest technetium-99m sestamibi and may be unable to differentiate hibernating from infarcted myocardium. METHODS: The dual-isotope procedure was performed in 63 patients without previous myocardial infarction undergoing coronary angiography to evaluate sensitivity and specificity for coronary artery disease and in 107 patients with a low (< 5%) likelihood of coronary artery disease to evaluate normalcy rate. To validate defect reversibility, the dual-isotope SPECT study was compared with stress/rest technetium-99m sestamibi SPECT studies in a separate group of 31 patients with previous documented myocardial infarction who underwent a rest technetium-99m sestamibi study in addition to the dual-isotope SPECT study. RESULTS: In angiographic correlations, dual-isotope SPECT demonstrated high sensitivity for detecting patients with > or = 50% stenosis (91%, 55 patients) and > or = 70% stenosis (96%, 52 patients). In a small group of patients, high specificity was also observed (75% for < 50% stenosis [8 patients] and 82% for < 70% stenosis [11 patients]). A very high normalcy rate of 95% was also found. In the patient group assessed for defect reversibility, in zones with no previous myocardial infarction, segmental agreement for defect type between rest thallium-201 and rest technetium-99m sestamibi studies was 97% (kappa = 0.79, p < 0.001). In myocardial infarct zones, segmental agreement for defect type was 98% (kappa = 0.93, p < 0.001). Image quality was generally good to excellent. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings demonstrate that separate-acquisition dual-isotope myocardial perfusion SPECT is accurate for coronary artery disease detection, correlates well with rest-stress sestamibi studies for assessment of defect reversibility and results in good to excellent image quality. This approach provides an excellent method for the combined assessment of stress myocardial perfusion and myocardial viability.

Unilateral parathyroidectomy: the value of the localizing scan.

Surgery for correction of primary hyperparathyroidism utilizing a standard bilateral neck exploration has a success rate of approximately 90 to 95%. With the inception of pre-operative localization studies that were 90% accurate in localizing the diseased gland, the concept arose that a unilateral exploration could be as successful as a bilateral exploration. Bilateral exploration of the neck for hyperparathyroidism exposes the patient to a greater potential of morbidity for hypoparathyroidism and recurrent laryngeal nerve injury. It is our feeling based on personal experience that unilateral parathyroidectomy in selective cases can be as successful as the bilateral operation and be more cost effective, saving over $1,100 (U.S.) per case.

Starting up stress thallium cardiac imaging services.

This paper presents an evaluation of alternative methods for a hospital to establish stress thallium cardiac imaging services at a group of physicians' office. Volume-cost-profit analysis, break-even analysis and capital budgeting techniques were used to determine the most feasible method from a financial perspective without sacrificing quality of services. The main focus of this evaluation centers upon three alternative methods of procuring an imaging camera: (1) purchasing a new camera, (2) purchasing used equipment, or (3) leasing a new camera. Budgeted income statements were constructed using relevant revenue and cost information for each alternative. The payback period, net present value and the internal rate of return for each method of procuring a camera was computed. In addition, the break-even point was also determined for each alternative. After the analysis was completed, it was concluded that the method of choice, without sacrificing quality of service delivery, was that of purchasing a used camera.

Prognostic value of exercise thallium scintigraphy in patients with good exercise tolerance and a normal or abnormal exercise electrocardiogram and suspected or confirmed coronary artery disease.

Exercise thallium scintigraphy is widely used to assess prognosis in patients with suspected or proven coronary artery disease. The incremental prognostic value of this technique in patients who have good exercise tolerance has not been well studied. Two hundred ninety-nine patients with known or suspected coronary artery disease without prior myocardial infarction or revascularization procedure referred for exercise myocardial perfusion imaging and able to exercise to greater than or equal to stage III of the Bruce protocol were included. After a mean follow-up of 50 +/- 10 months, there were 15 cardiac events (5%). The incidence of cardiac events was 10 versus 3% (p less than 0.001) in patients with an abnormal versus normal thallium-201 scan, and 9 versus 3% (p = 0.03) for an abnormal versus normal exercise electrocardiogram. When the 185 patients with a normal exercise electrocardiogram were examined, the incidence of cardiac events was 3% (5 of 150) in patients with a normal scan versus 0% (0 of 35) in patients with an abnormal scan. In the 114 patients with an abnormal exercise electrocardiogram, an abnormal thallium-201 scan was predictive of cardiac events (18% [8 of 44] versus 3% [2 of 70]; p = 0.006). Stepwise logistic regression analysis selected an abnormal thallium-201 scan and abnormal exercise electrocardiogram, low peak exercise heart rate, and male gender as independent variables associated with a significant increased risk of cardiac events. Thus, in patients with known or suspected coronary artery disease and good exercise tolerance, the addition of thallium-201 imaging in patients with an abnormal exercise electrocardiogram provides useful prognostic information.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)