Does bone penetration of cement differ by cement type and application time-point?

Intrusion of cement into bone is often considered an indirect indicator for implant stability in cemented joint replacement procedures. However, the influence of cement type (different viscosities/manufacturers) and application time-point on penetration of cements continues to be debated. This study aimed to quantify the effect of cement type and application time-point on the depth of penetration using porcine tibial specimens. Four different bone cements were applied to 60 resected porcine cadaveric tibias at three time-points within the working window (1, 2, and 3 min after dough time). Penetration was measured using computed tomography, utilizing two rigorous methods from the literature and a newly proposed volumetric method. Application time-point had a strong influence on the thickness of the cement layer above the resected tibia (0.25, 0.49, 0.73 mm at the three time-points). No significant variation in penetration depth metrics with cement type or application time-point was found, except percentage area covered by cement at 2 mm depth. This metric was significantly different between 1 and 3-minute time-points (12% and 6% respectively). Time-point of application had a significant influence on thickness of pure cement layer over resected bone. However, penetration depth was not significantly affected by cement type or application time-point. The clinical significance of these findings is that it may be better to apply cement relatively soon after dough time to avoid excessively thick cement mantle between implant and bone. Further, the choice of cement type may have minimal impact on cement penetration, indicating that long standing principles of good cement application maybe more important.