Analytical variation concerning total 25-hydroxyvitamin D measurement, where are we now? A DEQAS review of current assay performance.

ABSTRACT

The Vitamin D External Quality Assessment Scheme (DEQAS) distributes serum samples globally, on a quarterly basis, to assess participants' performance of specific methods for 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25OHD) and other vitamin D metabolites. In this review an assessment of the state of the art in the performance of 25OHD methods is presented. This assessment is based on an analysis of data submitted by scheme participants for the 2021/22 distribution cycle, which comprised of four distributions each containing five DEQAS samples. These distributions enabled the assessment of performance across a wide concentration range and included samples containing endogenous 25OHD2. Overall analytical performance continues to improve, but there is still significant method variation and bias in some automated methods. These automated methods continue to be challenged in measuring 25OHD at the extremes of the measuring range and in the presence of 25OHD2. LC-MS/MS methods still show superior performance with regards to bias, but are out-performed by some automated methods in terms of assay variability. Through participating in an accuracy based EQA scheme, such as DEQAS, laboratories are able to assess the accuracy of their methods in comparison to a gold standard reference measurement procedure. It is crucial for all laboratories to be aware of the performance and limitations of their 25OHD assays and to educate their users accordingly in order to ensure reliable assessment of vitamin D status.