Lack of glucocorticoid flexibility is indicative of wear-and-tear in Hyla versicolor tadpoles from agricultural environments.

ABSTRACT

In habitats where stressors are frequent or persistent, it can become increasingly difficult for wildlife to appropriately match their endocrine responses to these more challenging environments. The dynamic regulation of glucocorticoid (GC) hormones plays a crucial role in determining how well individuals cope with environmental changes. Amphibians exposed to agricultural stressors can dampen aspects of their GC profile (baseline, agitation, recovery, stress responsiveness, and negative feedback) to cope in these stressful environments, but this dampening can lead to reductions in an individual's reactive scope and a loss of endocrine flexibility. Organic agriculture could potentially limit some of these effects, however, little is known about how amphibians respond physiologically to organic agricultural environments. We compared GC profiles of Hyla versicolor tadpoles from three treatments natural ponds (<5% agriculture within 500m), ponds near organic farms, and ponds near conventional farms. We hypothesized that tadpoles would cope with agricultural habitats by dampening stress responsiveness and exhibiting more efficient negative feedback and that the magnitude of these changes in response would differ based on agricultural method. We found that tadpoles from conventional and organic ponds were less likely to downregulate GCs via negative feedback after stressor exposure than tadpoles from natural ponds. For agricultural tadpoles that did downregulate GCs after the stressor, we found lower stress responsiveness and faster downregulation to baseline corticosterone than tadpoles from natural ponds. These results point to an accumulation of wear-and-tear, leading to an overall reduction in reactive scope and limited GC flexibility in our agricultural tadpoles. Regardless of agricultural method used, agricultural tadpoles exhibited the same patterns of GC response, indicating that current efforts to incentivize farmers to switch to organic farming methods may not be sufficient to address negative agricultural impacts on amphibians.