The variable success of in vitro maturation: can we do better?

The efficiency of in vitro assisted reproductive technologies, consisting of the transfer of embryos obtained in vitro through in vitro maturation, in vitro fertilization and early embryo culture is still limited. The quality of the oocytes is pivotal for assisted reproductive efficiency and the maturation of the oocyte represents the first key limiting step of the in vitro embryo production system. At the time of removal from the antral follicles, the oocyte is still completing the final growth and differentiation steps, needed to provide the so-called developmental competence, i.e. the machinery required to sustain fertilization and embryo development. In mono-ovular species only one oocyte per cycle is available for procreation, therefore the current assisted reproduction techniques strive to overcome this natural boundary. However, the success is still limited and overall the effectiveness does not exceed the efficiency achieved in millions of years of mammalian evolution. One of the problems lies in the intrinsic heterogeneity of the oocytes that are subjected to in vitro maturation and in the lack of dedicated in vitro approaches to finalize the differentiation process. In this review we will try to overview some of the salient aspects of current practices by emphasizing the most critical and fundamental features in oocyte differentiation that should be carefully considered for improving current techniques

The variable success of in vitro maturation: can we do better?

The efficiency of in vitro assisted reproductive technologies, consisting of the transfer of embryos obtained in vitro through in vitro maturation, in vitro fertilization and early embryo culture is still limited. The quality of the oocytes is pivotal for assisted reproductive efficiency and the maturation of the oocyte represents the first key limiting step of the in vitro embryo production system. At the time of removal from the antral follicles, the oocyte is still completing the final growth and differentiation steps, needed to provide the so-called developmental competence, i.e. the machinery required to sustain fertilization and embryo development. In mono-ovular species only one oocyte per cycle is available for procreation, therefore the current assisted reproduction techniques strive to overcome this natural boundary. However, the success is still limited and overall the effectiveness does not exceed the efficiency achieved in millions of years of mammalian evolution. One of the problems lies in the intrinsic heterogeneity of the oocytes that are subjected to in vitro maturation and in the lack of dedicated in vitro approaches to finalize the differentiation process. In this review we will try to overview some of the salient aspects of current practices by emphasizing the most critical and fundamental features in oocyte differentiation that should be carefully considered for improving current techniques(AU)

Large-scale chromatin structure and function changes during oogenesis: theinterplay between oocyte and companioncumulus cell

The process of chromatin configuration remodeling within the mammalian oocyte nucleus or germinal vesicle (GV), which occurs towards the end of its differentiation phase before meiotic resumption, has received much attention and has been studied in several mammals. This review is aimed to highlight the relationship between changes in chromatin configurations and to both functional and structural modifications occurring in the oocyte nuclear compartment. During the extensive phase of meiotic arrest at the diplotene stage, the chromatin enclosed within the GV is subjected to several levels of regulation. Morphologically, the chromosomes lose their individuality and form a loose chromatin mass. Then the decondensed chromatin undergoes profound rearrangements during the final stages of oocyte growth in tight association with the acquisition of meiotic and developmental competence. Functionally, the discrete stages of chromatin condensation are characterized by different level of transcriptional activity, DNA methylation and covalent histone modifications. Interestingly, the program of chromatin rearrangement is not completely intrinsic to the oocyte, but follicular cells exert their regulatory actions through gap junction mediated communications and intracellular messenger dependent mechanism(s). With this in mind and since oocyte growth mostly relies on the bidirectional crosstalk with the follicular cells, experimental manipulation of large-scale chromatin configuration is discussed. Besides providing tools to determine the key cellular pathways involved in genome-wide chromatin modifications , the present findings will aid to the refinement of physiological culture systems that can have important implications in treating human infertility as well as managing breeding schemes in animal husband .

Large-scale chromatin structure and function changes during oogenesis: theinterplay between oocyte and companioncumulus cell

The process of chromatin configuration remodeling within the mammalian oocyte nucleus or germinal vesicle (GV), which occurs towards the end of its differentiation phase before meiotic resumption, has received much attention and has been studied in several mammals. This review is aimed to highlight the relationship between changes in chromatin configurations and to both functional and structural modifications occurring in the oocyte nuclear compartment. During the extensive phase of meiotic arrest at the diplotene stage, the chromatin enclosed within the GV is subjected to several levels of regulation. Morphologically, the chromosomes lose their individuality and form a loose chromatin mass. Then the decondensed chromatin undergoes profound rearrangements during the final stages of oocyte growth in tight association with the acquisition of meiotic and developmental competence. Functionally, the discrete stages of chromatin condensation are characterized by different level of transcriptional activity, DNA methylation and covalent histone modifications. Interestingly, the program of chromatin rearrangement is not completely intrinsic to the oocyte, but follicular cells exert their regulatory actions through gap junction mediated communications and intracellular messenger dependent mechanism(s). With this in mind and since oocyte growth mostly relies on the bidirectional crosstalk with the follicular cells, experimental manipulation of large-scale chromatin configuration is discussed. Besides providing tools to determine the key cellular pathways involved in genome-wide chromatin modifications , the present findings will aid to the refinement of physiological culture systems that can have important implications in treating human infertility as well as managing breeding schemes in animal husband .(AU)

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection in the horse: the ultimate blind date

Background: Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) has become a useful technology to produce foals when availability of semen is limited or when in-vitro fertilization is desired, as is the need for subfertile mares. However, its application into clinical practice is challenging. The purpose of this review was to discuss some fundamental molecular aspects of oocyte maturation that should be considered when performing ICSI and to report factors of age and subfertility affecting the success of a commercial ICSI program. Review: The molecular synchrony of oocyte maturation included nuclear, epigenetic and cytoplasmic maturation. Oocyte developmental competence was found to be dependent on the ability to remain in meiotic arrest until the initiation of final maturation, requiring the adequate timing involved with follicular maturation prior to ovulation. Studies performed in cattle and humans have demonstrated that in-vivo oocyte maturation results in high pregnancy rates per oocyte fertilized. Therefore, determining precise maturation of the oocyte would be valuable for the timing of ICSI and subsequent embryo development. Reproductive aging in the mare was characterized by a decline in fertility. Using RT-PCR, quantitative and temporal differences were found in mRNA content of key regulatory maturation genes in granulosa and cumulus cells and in oocytes during in vivo maturation in young and old mares. These results suggested premature oocyte maturation in aged mares that potentially could result in subfertility. Consequently, the timing of oocyte retrival after gonadotropin administration should be carefully evaluated when performing ICSI. In a commercial program, equine patients were classified into normal mares (2.5 to 15 years), problem mares (15-23 years that had not been producing embryos or pregnancies) and old mares (>24 years). Old mares were assessed for endocrine, physical and nutritional imbalances. Follicular and oocyte maturation were induced with a dominant follicle >30 mm in diameter after a normal growth and blood flow and uterine edema with a combination of hCG and GnRH. Transvaginal oocyte retrieval was performed 20 hours after administration of gonadotropins. Oocytes were further cultured in vitro for 12 to 20 hours. Frozen semen was used for all sperm injections. Injected oocytes were further cultured in vitro for at least 24 hours. Embryos were then transferred surgically into oviducts of synchronized recipients. Oocyte recovery rate was 94% (523/557 cycles), cycles per month were 3.3, 2 and 1.3 for young, problem and old mares respectively. Cleavage rates were different (p < 0.05) between young (82 %), problem (70 %) and old (52%) mares. Pregnancy rates at day 60 were also different (p < 0.05) for young (68 %), problem (50 %) and old (23%) mares. Number of pregnancies obtained from a single straw of frozen semen ranged from 2 to 12. Reproductive senescence was observed in 10% of old mares. In addition, Cushing's disease and elevated diestrus FSH were observed in 80% of the old mares. Foaling rates were evaluated in 55 pregnancies; 5% were lost in the last trimester and the remaining foals have shown no apparent abnormalities. Conclusion: More studies are needed to further elucidate the mechanisms of oocyte maturation and activation in the horse, as well as more objective methods to determine oocyte maturity and quality. A clinical ICSI program required an understanding of gamete physiology and detailed mare reproductive management. Our clinical data demonstrated that aging affects fertility profoundly in ways that may be difficult to address with current technology; nonetheless, ICSI has provided the equine industry an alternative to produce offspring from valuable mares and stallions that are subfertile.

Falha na sexagem por inibição do desenvolvimento de embriões bovinos produzidos in vitro com anticorpos anti H-Y / Failure of sexing by developmental arrest of bovine embryos in vitro produced with H-Y antisera

Embriões bovinos produzidos in vitro, em estádio de mórula, foram cultivados em meio contendo anticorpos anti H-Y de alto título proveniente de ratos por 24h e, após este tempo, classificados em dois grupos: 1) embriões inibidos em estádio de mórula (classificados como machos) e 2) embriões que se desenvolveram e formaram a blastocele (classificados como fêmeas). O sexo de 311 embriões, distribuídos em três grupos de concentração dos anticorpos, 3 por cento, 5 por cento ou 7 por cento, foi identificado pela reação em cadeia da polimerase. Não houve desvio da proporção entre machos e fêmeas (P>0,05) nos grupos em que se utilizaram os anticorpos anti H-Y, quando comparadas ao grupo-controle, sem adição de anticorpos anti H-Y. Diferentemente dos resultados obtidos utilizando-se embriões bovinos produzidos in vivo, a sexagem com anticorpos anti H-Y de alto título em embriões produzidos in vitro não propiciou sucesso.(AU)

In vitro produced bovine embryos at morula stage were cultured in medium containing high titer of rat H-Y antisera for 24h. The embryos were classified in two groups: 1) embryos arrested at morula stage (classified as males); and 2) embryos that developed and formed a blastocoele (classified as female). The sex of 311 embryos, divided in three groups of concentration of H-Y antisera, 3 percent, 5 percent or 7 percent, was identified by polimerase chain reaction. The results showed no difference (P>0.05) on sexual deviation in groups in which the H-Y antisera was added, in relation to control group, in which no H-Y antisera was added. In contrast with results obtained with in vivo produced bovine embryos, the sexing of in vitro produced bovine embryos with high H-Y antisera titer did not succed.(AU)

Efeito do bloqueio meiótico na expressão, atividade e distribuição do fator promotor da meiose (MPF) e da proteína cinase ativada por mitógenos (MAPK) em oócitos bovinos / Effect of meiosis block on expression, activity and distribution of meiosis promoting factor (MPF) and mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) in bovine oocytes

Apesar dos grandes avanços na produção in vitro (PIV) de embriões bovinos, a produção de blastocistos se mantém ainda aquém do observado in vivo, indicando que melhorais ainda são necessárias no processo de PIV. A competência para o desenvolvimento de oócitos tem sido relacionada, entre outros fatores, à interrupção do período de capacitação. Foi sugerido que o bloqueio meiótico poderia permitir ao oócito um tempo adicional para adquirir a competência. Embora ainda não se tenha melhorado o desenvolvimento embrionário com esse procedimento, o bloqueio meiótico com inibidores de cinases dependentes de ciclinas (CDK), como a butirolactona I (BLI), pode ser uma ferramenta útil na compreensão do desenvolvimento do oócito. O presente trabalho teve por objetivo averiguar o efeito da inibição de CDK com BLI, para bloquear temporariamente a retomada da meiose, sobre fatores que controlam o ciclo celular meiótico de oócitos bovinos. Oócitos bovinos obtidos de abatedouros foram bloqueados em vesícula germinativa (VG) in vitro com 10 µM de BLI por 24 h (BVG - bloqueado imaturo). Parte desses oócitos foi depois maturada in vitro por mais 24 h (BMII - bloqueado maturado). Como controles foram utilizados oócitos recém-aspirados dos folículos (VG - controle imaturo) ou maturados in vitro sem bloqueio meiótico prévio (MII - controle maturado). Os diferentes grupos de oócitos foram avaliados quanto a: 1) expressão de RNAm dos componentes do MPF (p34cdc2 e ciclina B1) e da MAPK; 2) expressão das proteínas do MPF (p34cdc2 e ciclina B1) e MAPK (p44 e p42); 3) atividade das proteínas MPF e MAPK durante a maturação in vitro de oócito submetidos ou não ao bloqueio da meiose pré-maturação e 4) a localização subcelular das proteínas p34cdc2, ciclina B1 e MAPK nos oócitos. Foi observado que: 1) a abundância relativa do RNAm de p34cdc2 e MAPK reduziu-se com a maturação, enquanto a ciclina B1 menteve-se estável; o bloqueio meiótico manteve o mesmo padrão de acordo com o estádio de maturação; 2) as proteínas de p34cdc2 e MAPK mantiveram-se estáveis durante a maturação, enquanto a ciclina B1 não foi detectada em oócitos imaturos e o foi nos maturados; o bloqueio meiótico também manteve a expressão das proteínas de acordo com o estádio de maturação; 3) as atividades de MPF e MAPK foram pouco afetadas pelo bloqueio meiótico; 4) as proteínas foram todas detectadas no citoplasma dos oócitos imaturos (bloqueados ou não) e maturados (bloqueados ou não), sendo apenas a p34cdc2 também localizada no núcleo de oócitos imaturos (bloqueados ou não). Diante dos resultados conclui-se que o bloqueio da meiose mantém o mesmo padrão de expressão, atividade e localização subcelular do MPF e da MAPK em oócitos imaturos e maturados, sugerindo que a tradução das mensagens, a ativação das cinases e a distribuição das proteínas foram controladas de acordo com o estádio da meiose, não sendo afetadas pelo bloqueio

Although there have been great improvements in in vitro production (IVP) of bovine embryos, blastocyst production is still beyond that observed in vivo, indicating that more improvements are necessary in the IVP system. Developmental competence of oocytes has been related to, among other factors, the interruption in oocyte capacitation. Is has been suggested that meiosis block would allow the oocyte additional time to acquire competence. Although this procedure has not been successful in increasing embryo development, meiosis block with cyclin dependent kinase (CDK) inhibitors, such as butyrolactone I (BLI) can be a useful tool to study oocyte development. The present study aimed to assess the effects CDK inhibition with BLI, to temporarily block meiosis resumption, on factors involved in meiosis cell cycle control in bovine oocytes. Oocytes, obtained form slaughterhouse ovaries, were maintained in germinal vesicle (GV) arrest in vitro with 10 µM BLI for 24 h (BVG - blocked immature). A part of these oocytes was matured in vitro for another 24 h (BMII - blocked and matured). As controls, oocytes were also assessed soon after follicle aspiration (GV -immature control) or matured in vitro for 24 h without prior meiosis block (MII - matured control). The different groups of oocytes were assessed for: 1) mRNA expression for the MPF components (p34cdc2 and cyclin B1) and MAPK; 2) expression of MPF (p34cdc2 and cyclin B1) and MAPK (p44 and p42) proteins; 3) MPF and MAPK activities during maturation of oocytes submitted or not to prematuration meiosis block and 4) p34cdc2, cyclin B1 and MAPK subcellular localization within oocytes. During the study it was observed that: 1) relative abundance of p34cdc2 and MAPK mRNA was reduced after maturation, while cyclin B1 mRNA remained stable; meiosis block maintained the same pattern according to maturation stage; 2) p34cdc2 and MAPK proteins remained stable after maturation while cyclin B1 protein was undetected in immature oocytes and detected in the matured ones; meiosis block also maintained the same protein expression according to maturation stage; 3) MPF and MAPK activities were little affected by meiosis block and 4) all proteins were detected in the cytoplasm of immature (blocked or not) and matured (blocked or not) oocytes, and only showed a specific nuclear localizations in immature oocytes (blocked or not). According to the results it may be concluded that meiosis block maintained the same pattern of MPF and MAPK expression, activity and subcellular localization in immature and matured oocytes, suggesting that mRNA translation, kinase activation and protein distribution were controlled according to the maturation stage and were not affected by meiosis block

Interação núcleo-citoplasmática em embriões e expressão de genes "imprinted" em fetos bovinos produzidos in vivo, in vitro e partenogenéticos

A maturação oocitária é marcada pela retomada da primeira divisão da meiose, com progressão do estádio de Vesícula Germinativa (GV) da Prófase I até a Metáfase II (MII), e inclui todos os eventos necessários para que o oócito expresse seu potencial máximo de desenvolvimento após a fecundação. Para avaliarmos a eficiência da maturação in vitro (MIV), utilizamos oócitos classificados em viáveis (graus I, II e III) e inviáveis (atrésico e desnudo), e acompanhamos a progressão nuclear e a distribuição dos grânulos corticais (GC) como indício de maturação citoplasmática, após MIV em TCM 199 com soro fetal bovino, hormônios, antibiótico e piruvato, por 24h em 5% de CO2 em ar. Maturação nuclear (78,4-87,8%) e citoplasmática (GC periféricos; 67,2-79,3%) foram semelhantes entre as diferentes classes de oócitos e apresentaramse como eventos independentes. Para o acompanhamento dos eventos desencadeados pelo espermatozóide, avaliamos a dinâmica nuclear e de microtúbulos, em intervalos de 2h, após fecundação in vitro (FIV), em meio TALP com heparina, PHE e sêmen preparado em gradiente de Percoll. Observamos que o estádio de MII foi predominante de 2 a 8h; MII e Anáfase/Telófase (A/T) predominaram às 10h; MII, A/T e estádio pronuclear (PN) de 14 a 16h; e PN a partir de 18h. A penetração do espermatozóide ocorreu após 4h da inseminação dos oócitos; a diferenciação dos PN 14 masculino e feminino pelo tamanho foi possível de 14 a 18h e a singamia ocorreu a partir de 24h. O período de 10h pode ser suficiente para que a FIV seja efetiva em oócitos bovinos, nas condições aqui descritas

We aimed to evaluate events involved in in vitro maturation, fertilization and development, and parthenogenetic activation of bovine oocytes assessed by nuclear-cytoplasmic interaction and gene expression. Oocyte morphological selection did not affect nuclear maturation (78.4-87.8%) and cytoplasmic cortical granule distribution (67.2-79.3%). Following nuclear and microtubular dynamics after fertilization (IVF), we observed sperm penetration 4h after insemination; male and female pronuclei differentiation by size from 14 to 18h; syngamy after 24h; and sufficient co-incubation of spermatozoa and oocytes for 10h. Pronuclear transfer to study the interaction between nucleus (N) and cytoplasm (C) in parthenogenetic embryos produced by ionomycin followed by strontium (S) or 6-DMAP (D) was assessed by cleavage, eight-cell, and blastocyst development rates: CSND (76.5, 36.4, and 6.8%) and CDNS (69.5, 25.0, and 4.9%). S cytoplasm promoted dominant effect on D nucleus. Higher rates of developmental arrest up to the eight-cell stage were observed by the combination of cytoplasm and nucleus produced by the two different activation treatments. We recovered parthenogenetic D fetuses on Day 35, which were small but normal in formation and in appearance of chorio-alantoic membranes. Genomic imprinting of IGF2 was observed, but XIST was maternally expressed in extra-embryonic tissues. In vitro culture promoted higher expression of IGF2 and H19 genes and also increased IGF2/IGF2r ratio in IVF embryos compared to in vivo produced ones