Assessment of the implementation of HIV-rapid test kits at different levels of health institutions in Ethiopia.

OBJECTIVE: Evaluation and monitoring of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) testing reagents at the point of service is helpful to prevent the occurrence of problems related to testing and interpretation. To evaluate the implementation of HIV rapid test kits at the point of services in voluntarily counseling and testing (VCT) and diagnostic centers in Ethiopia. METHODS: The assessment was the third phase of evaluation of HIV rapid test kits in Ethiopia followed from phase-I and phase-II. Known proficiency testing panels, well-structured questionnaire (addressing type of tests, human resource and problems related to tests), onsite supervision and retesting of samples collected from sites were used to evaluate the performances of reagents and laboratories. RESULTS: Forty-four health institutions were included. Thirty-six (90.0%) health institutions had trained human resource on HIV testing. In 27 (61.4%) three types of HIV rapid test kits (Determine, Capillus and Unigold) were available. Serial-algorithm was used in all the laboratories. In 31 (70.4%) of them external quality control specimens were not used. Twenty two (50.0%) of the laboratories reported frequent shortage of reagents. All (100%) were able to identify negative specimens distributed. Positive proficiency panel samples were identified in 37 (94.8%) of the 39 laboratories. There was 98.3% agreement at a screening level between the sites and the central laboratory. Rate of discrepancy between screening and confirmatory assays was found to be 3.0% and 2.1% at the sites and at central laboratory, respectively. CONCLUSION: The test kits showed a good performance at the point of services in the field sites. However, continuous assessment of HIV test kits at the point of service and training of professionals on newly arrived techniques are recommended to have effective testing performance with acceptable sensitive and specific testing algorithm. Effective quality assurance program should be in place to support programs such as VCT, prevention of mother-to-child-transmission and antiretroviral therapy.

Evaluation of rapid HIV test kits on whole blood and development of rapid testing algorithm for voluntary testing and counseling centers in Ethiopia.

Five simple and rapid HIV antibody detection assays viz. Determine, Capillus, Oraquick, Unigold and Hemastrip were evaluated to examine their performance and to develop an alternative rapid test based testing algorithm for voluntary counseling and testing (VCT) in Ethiopia. All the kits were tested on whole blood, plasma and serum. The evaluation had three phases: Primary lab review, piloting at point of service and implementation. This report includes the results of the first two phases. A total of 2,693 specimens (both whole blood and plasma) were included in the evaluation. Results were compared to double Enzyme Linked Immuno-Sorbent Assay (ELISA) system. Discordant EIA results were resolved using Western Blot. The assays had very good sensitivities and specificities, 99-100%, at the two different phases of the evaluation. A 98-100% result agreement was obtained from those tested at VCT centers and National Referral Laboratory for AIDS (NRLA), in the quality control phase of the evaluation. A testing strategy yielding 100% [95% CI; 98.9-100.0] sensitivity was achieved by the sequential use of the three rapid test kits. Direct cost comparison showed serial testing algorithm reduces the cost of testing by over 30% compared to parallel testing in the current situation. Determine, Capillus/Oraquick (presence/absence of frefrigeration) and Unigold were recommended as screening, confirmation and tiebreaker tests, respectively.