Liquid-liquid miscibility gaps in drug-water binary systems: crystal structure and thermodynamic properties of prilocaine and the temperature-composition phase diagram of the prilocaine-water system.

EMLA cream, a "eutectic mixture of local anesthetics", was developed in the early 1980s by Astra Pharmaceutical Production. The mixture of anesthetics containing lidocaine, prilocaine, and water is liquid at room temperature, which is partly due to the eutectic equilibrium between prilocaine and lidocaine at 293 K, as was clear from the start. However, the full thermodynamic background for the stability of the liquid and its emulsion-like appearance has never been elucidated. In the present study of the binary system prilocaine-water, a region of liquid-liquid demixing has been observed, linked to a monotectic equilibrium at 302.4 K. It results in a prilocaine-rich liquid containing approximately 0.7 mol fraction of anesthetic. Similar behavior has been reported for the binary system lidocaine-water (Céolin, R.; et al. J. Pharm. Sci. 2010, 99 (6), 2756-2765). In the ternary mixture, the combination of the monotectic equilibrium and the above-mentioned eutectic equilibrium between prilocaine and lidocaine results in an anesthetic-rich liquid that remains stable below room temperature. This liquid forms an emulsion-like mixture in the presence of an aqueous solution saturated with anesthetics. Physical properties and the crystal structure of prilocaine are also reported.

The Phase Diagram of the API Benzocaine and Its Highly Persistent, Metastable Crystalline Polymorphs.

The availability of sufficient amounts of form I of benzocaine has led to the investigation of its phase relationships with the other two existing forms, II and III, using adiabatic calorimetry, powder X-ray diffraction, and high-pressure differential thermal analysis. The latter two forms were known to have an enantiotropic phase relationship in which form III is stable at low-temperatures and high-pressures, while form II is stable at room temperature with respect to form III. Using adiabatic calorimetry data, it can be concluded, that form I is the stable low-temperature, high-pressure form, which also happens to be the most stable form at room temperature; however, due to its persistence at room temperature, form II is still the most convenient polymorph to use in formulations. Form III presents a case of overall monotropy and does not possess any stability domain in the pressure-temperature phase diagram. Heat capacity data for benzocaine have been obtained by adiabatic calorimetry from 11 K to 369 K above its melting point, which can be used to compare to results from in silico crystal structure prediction.

Polymorphism of benzylthiouracil, an active pharmaceutical ingredient against hyperthyroidism.

The crystal structures of dimorphic benzylthiouracil, a drug against hyperthyroidism, have been redetermined and the atom coordinates of the two independent molecules of form I have been obtained for the first time. The dimorphism convincingly demonstrates the conformational versatility of the benzylthiouracil molecule. It has been established through calorimetric studies that the low-temperature form II transforms endothermically (ΔII→IH = 5.6(1.5) J g-1) into form I at 405.4(1.0) K. The high-temperature form I melts at 496.8(1.0) K (ΔI→LH = 152.6(4.0) J g-1). Crystallographic and thermal expansion studies show that form II is denser than form I, leading to the conclusion that the slope of the II-I equilibrium curve in the pressure-temperature phase diagram is positive. It follows that this dimorphism corresponds to a case of overall enantiotropic behaviour, which implies that both solid phases possess their own stable phase region irrespective of the pressure. Moreover, form II is clearly the stable polymorph under ambient conditions.

Crystalline tetrazepam as a case study on the volume change on melting of molecular organic compounds.

The volume change on melting is a rarely studied quantity and it is not well understood even if it must reflect the changes in interaction between the solid and the liquid state. It is part of the solid-state information for materials and pharmaceuticals and it is important for the reliability of polymorph stability study results. Using the crystal structure of monoclinic tetrazepam at 150 K and at room temperature, in addition to powder X-ray diffraction as a function of the temperature, the specific volume of tetrazepam has been determined over a large temperature domain. In combination with a pressure-temperature curve for the melting of tetrazepam, its volume change on melting could be determined. With this information and previous data from the literature, the assumption that the volume of the solid increases on average with 11% on melting has been investigated. It can be concluded that this value is not constant; however so far, no simple relationship has been found to relate the solid state to its volume change on melting and using 11% remains best practice. A comparison of the tetrazepam crystal structure with diazepam and nordiazepam has been provided too.

The solid state of anti-inflammatory morniflumate diniflumate: A cocrystalline salt.

Morniflumate diniflumate, a molecular compound involving niflumic acid and its ß-morpholino ethyl ester (morniflumate) in the mole ratio 2:1, is found to crystallize in a triclinic P - 1 space group with a unit-cell volume of 2203.4(5) Å3. It is a cocrystal between a morniflumate+ niflumate- salt and a neutral niflumic acid molecule. The co-crystalline salt forms endothermically with a positive excess volume and it melts incongruently at 382.3(8) K. Differential scanning calorimetry executed at heating rates above 20 K⋅min-1, leads to congruent melting at 387.8(9)K with an enthalpy change of ΔfusH = 80(2) J g-1. The rare occurrence that incongruent and congruent melting can be observed for the same cocrystal may be due to the conformational versatility of the niflumic acid molecule and its slow conversion between the different conformations due to weak intramolecular hydrogen bonding.

[60]Fullerene for Medicinal Purposes, A Purity Criterion towards Regulatory Considerations.

Since the early nineties countless publications have reported promising medicinal applications for [60]fullerene (C60) related to its unparalleled affinity towards free radicals. Yet, until now no officially approved C60-based drug has reached the market, notably because of the alleged dangers of C60. Nevertheless, since the publication of the effects of C60 on the lifespan of rodents, a myriad of companies started selling C60 worldwide for human consumption without any approved clinical trial. Nowadays, several independent teams have confirmed the safety of pure C60 while demonstrating that previously observed toxicity was due to impurities present in the used samples. However, a purity criterion for C60 samples is still lacking and there are no regulatory recommendations on this subject. In order to avoid a public health issue and for regulatory considerations, a quality-testing strategy is urgently needed. Here we have evaluated several analytical tools to verify the purity of commercially available C60 samples. Our data clearly show that differential scanning calorimetry is the best candidate to establish a purity criterion based on the sc-fcc transition of a C60 sample (Tonset ≥ 258 K, ∆sc-fccH ≥ 8 J g-1).

Polymorphism of even-numbered carbon atom n-alkanes revisited through topological P-T diagrams.

The phase relationships involving the metastable orthorhombic (R(I)) phase and the stable triclinic (T) phase were established for even-numbered carbon atom n-alkanes in the range of 8-20 carbon atoms. It is shown that the R(I) phase behaves monotropically whatever the pressure and temperature (i.e., the R(I) phase exhibits no stable pressure-temperature (P-T) region). Then, the incidence of the overall monotropic behavior of the R(I) phase on the construction of the temperature-composition (T-x) phase diagrams involving at least one even member was examined through four temperature-molar fraction (T-x) phase diagrams. Discussion on the location of the R(I)-T-vapor (upsilon) triple points in the P-T diagrams of this series of n-alkanes was determined and extended to higher even members.

Polymorphism of spironolactone: An unprecedented case of monotropy turning to enantiotropy with a huge difference in the melting temperatures.

Spironolactone form I melts at about 70 degrees lower than form II, which is very unusual for two co-existing polymorphs. The phase relationships involving this unprecedented case of dimorphism have been investigated by constructing a topological pressure-temperature phase diagram. The transition from polymorph I to polymorph II is unambiguously exothermic while it is accompanied with an increase in the specific volume. This indicates that the dP/dT slope of the I-II equilibrium curve is negative. The convergence of the melting equilibrium lines at high pressure leads to a topological P-T diagram in which polymorph I possesses a stable phase region at high pressure. Thus, forms I and II are monotropically related at ordinary pressure and turn to an enantiotropic relationship at high pressure. Given that polymorph I is the densest form, it negates the rule of thumb that the densest form is also the most stable form at room temperature, similar to the case of paracetamol.

The Pressure-Temperature Phase Diagram of Metacetamol and Its Comparison to the Phase Diagram of Paracetamol.

Understanding the polymorphic behavior of active pharmaceutical ingredients is important for formulation purposes and regulatory reasons. Metacetamol is an isomer of paracetamol and it similarly exhibits polymorphism. In the present article, it has been found that one of the polymorphs of metacetamol is only stable under increased pressure, which has led to the conclusion that metacetamol like paracetamol is a monotropic system under ordinary (= laboratory) conditions and that it becomes enantiotropic under pressure with the I-II-L triple point coordinates for metacetamol TI-II-L = 535 ± 10 K and PI-II-L = 692 ± 70 MPa. However, whereas for paracetamol the enantiotropy under pressure can be foreseen, because the metastable polymorph is denser, in the case of metacetamol this is not possible, as the metastable polymorph is less dense than the stable one. The existence of the stability domain for the less dense polymorph of metacetamol can only be demonstrated by the construction of the topological phase diagram as presented in this article. It is a delicate interplay between the specific volume differences and the enthalpy differences causing the stability domain of the less dense polymorph to be sandwiched between the denser polymorph and the liquid. Metacetamol shares this behavior with bicalutamide and fluoxetine nitrate.

Crystal Structures and Phase Relationships of 2 Polymorphs of 1,4-Diazabicyclo[3.2.2]nonane-4-Carboxylic Acid 4-Bromophenyl Ester Fumarate, A Selective α-7 Nicotinic Receptor Partial Agonist.

Two polymorphs of the 1:1 fumarate salt of 1,4-diazabicyclo[3.2.2]nonane-4-carboxylic acid 4-bromophenyl ester, developed for the treatment of cognitive symptoms of schizophrenia and Alzheimer disease, have been characterized. The 2 crystal structures have been solved, and their phase relationships have been established. The space group of form I is P21/c with a unit-cell volume of 1811.6 (5) Å(3) with Z = 4. The crystals of form I were 2-component nonmerohedral twins. The space group of form II is P21/n with a unit-cell volume of 1818.6 (3) Å(3) with Z = 4. Relative stabilities have been inferred from experimental and topological P-T diagrams exhibiting an overall enantiotropic relationship between forms I and II although the solid-solid transition has never been observed. The slope of the I-II equilibrium in the P-T diagram is negative, form II is the stable phase below the solid-solid transition temperature of 371 K, and form I exhibits a stable melting equilibrium. The I-II transition temperature has been obtained from the intersection of the sublimation curves of the 2 solid forms.

Stability hierarchy between Piracetam forms I, II, and III from experimental pressure-temperature diagrams and topological inferences.

The trimorphism of the active pharmaceutical ingredient piracetam is a famous case of polymorphism that has been frequently revisited by many researchers. The phase relationships between forms I, II, and III were ambiguous because they seemed to depend on the heating rate of the DSC and on the history of the samples or they have not been observed at all (equilibrium II-III). In the present paper, piezo-thermal analysis and high-pressure differential thermal analysis have been used to elucidate the positions of the different solid-solid and solid-liquid equilibria. The phase diagram, involving the three solid phases, the liquid phase and the vapor phase, has been constructed. It has been shown that form III is the high-pressure, low-temperature form and the stable form at room temperature. Form II is stable under intermediary conditions and form I is the low pressure, high temperature form, which possesses a stable melting point. The present paper demonstrates the strength of the topological approach based on the Clapeyron equation and the alternation rule when combined with high-pressure measurements.

Polymorphism of paracetamol: relative stabilities of the monoclinic and orthorhombic phases inferred from topological pressure-temperature and temperature-volume phase diagrams.

The thermodynamic relationships between the two known polymorphs of paracetamol have been investigated, and the subsequent pressure-temperature and temperature-volume phase diagrams were constructed using data from crystallographic and calorimetric measurements as a function of the temperature. Irrespective of temperature, monoclinic Form I and orthorhombic Form II are stable phases at ordinary and high pressures, respectively. The I and II phase regions in the pressure-temperature diagram are bordered by the I-II equilibrium curve, for which a negative slope (dp/dT approximately -0.3 MPa x K(-1)) was determined although it was not observed experimentally. This curve goes through the I-II-liquid triple point whose coordinates (p approximately 234 MPa, T approximately 505 K) correspond to the crossing point of the melting curves, for which dp/dT values of +3.75 MPa x K(-1) (I) and +3.14 MPa x K(-1) (II) were calculated from enthalpy and volume changes upon fusion. More generally, this case exemplifies how the stability hierarchy of polymorphs may be inferred from the difference in their sublimation curves, as topologically positioned with respect to each other, using the phase rule and simple inferences resorting to Gibbs equilibrium thermodynamics.

Rotigotine: Unexpected Polymorphism with Predictable Overall Monotropic Behavior.

Crystallization of polymorphs still has a touch of art, as even prior observations of polymorphs do not guarantee their crystallization. However, once crystals of various polymorphs have been obtained, their relative stabilities can be established with a straightforward thermodynamic approach even if the conclusion will depend on the quality of the experimental data. Rotigotine is an active pharmaceutical ingredient, which has suffered the same setback as Ritonavir: a sudden appearance of a more stable crystalline polymorph than the one used for the formulation. Although the cause of the defect in the formulation was quickly established, the interpretation of the phase behavior of rotigotine has been lacking in clarity. In the present paper, data published in the patents resulting from the discovery of the new polymorph have been used to establish the pressure-temperature phase diagram of the two known solid forms of rotigotine. The analysis clearly demonstrates that form II is the stable solid phase and form I is metastable in the entire pressure-temperature domain: form I is overall monotropic in relation to form II. Thus, it was a sensible decision of European Medicines Agency to ask for a reformulation, as the first formulation was metastable even if crystallization appeared to be very slow.

Degradation pathways study of the natriuretic and ß-adrenoceptor antagonist tienoxolol using liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization multistage mass spectrometry.

Tienoxolol is a pharmacologically active molecule designed with the functional groups ketothiophene, alkyl benzoate and arylpropanolamine so as to combine a diuretic and a ß-adrenoreceptor antagonist into a single molecule. Its degradation products generated in several stress media have been determined by high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) coupled to a hybrid mass spectrometer with a triple quadrupole-linear trap. A Polaris(®) column with a C18-A stationary phase and a linear gradient mobile phase composed of a mixture of trifluoroacetic acid 1% (v/v) and acetonitrile allowed for optimal separation. Structural elucidation of the degradation products has been based on MS/MS techniques, by comparing their fragmentation patterns to the precursor's data. Up to seven degradation products of the active ingredient, resulting from hydrolysis, oxidation, dehydration and transamidation have been identified, covering a range of possible degradation pathways for derivatives with such functional groups. Kinetics have been studied to assess the molecule's shelf life and to identify the most important degradation factor.

Rimonabant dimorphism and its pressure-temperature phase diagram: a delicate case of overall monotropic behavior.

Crystalline polymorphism occurs frequently in the solid state of active pharmaceutical ingredients, and this is problematic for the development of a suitable dose form. Rimonabant, an active pharmaceutical ingredient developed by Sanofi and discontinued because of side effects, exhibits dimorphism; both solid forms have nearly the same melting temperatures, melting enthalpies, and specific volumes. Although the problem may well be academic from an industrial point of view, the present case demonstrates the usefulness of constructing pressure-temperature phase diagrams by direct measurement as well as by topological approach. The system is overall monotropic and form II is the more stable solid form. Interestingly, the more stable form does not possess any hydrogen bonds, whereas the less stable one does.

Benzocaine polymorphism: pressure-temperature phase diagram involving forms II and III.

Understanding the phase behavior of an active pharmaceutical ingredient in a drug formulation is required to avoid the occurrence of sudden phase changes resulting in decrease of bioavailability in a marketed product. Benzocaine is known to possess three crystalline polymorphs, but their stability hierarchy has so far not been determined. A topological method and direct calorimetric measurements under pressure have been used to construct the topological pressure-temperature diagram of the phase relationships between the solid phases II and III, the liquid, and the vapor phase. In the process, the transition temperature between solid phases III and II and its enthalpy change have been determined. Solid phase II, which has the highest melting point, is the more stable phase under ambient conditions in this phase diagram. Surprisingly, solid phase I has not been observed during the study, even though the scarce literature data on its thermal behavior appear to indicate that it might be the most stable one of the three solid phases.

Overall stability for the ibuprofen racemate: experimental and topological results leading to the pressure-temperature phase relationships between its racemate and conglomerate.

Enantiomer resolution is much sought after for pharmaceutical applications, because many optically active drug molecules have only one pharmaceutically active enantiomer. Although it is always possible to force separation, it will come at a cost. The present method, based on thermodynamics, provides a relatively easy approach to investigate whether separation can be thermodynamically spontaneous. A topological phase diagram of the binary enantiomer system at 0.5 mol-fraction is constructed as a function of temperature and pressure after analysis of pressure and heat related quantities. It is demonstrated that for ibuprofen, an optically active analgesic, the racemate is the only stable solid form; the phase relationship between the racemate and the conglomerate is analogous to dimorphism with overall monotropy in pure chemical compounds.

Crystal structure and solid-state studies of aged samples of tienoxolol, an API designed against hypertension.

Aging of drug molecules is generally studied following regulatory procedures, i.e. under forced conditions and for relatively limited storage time; therefore naturally aged samples are rare and provide scientific reference data beyond regulatory considerations. Tienoxolol was studied after 25 years of storage in the dark under ambient conditions. About 86% of the samples still consisted of tienoxolol and the main impurity (13%) was caused by the hydrolysis of the ester moiety. Protection from humidity is therefore important. Other sensitive groups containing nitrogen and sulfur appear to be quite stable with less than 0.8% conversion over 25 years. In addition, the crystal structure has been solved. Tienoxolol orange needles were found to crystallize in the orthorhombic non-centrosymmetric space group Iba2, indicating that the crystal is a racemic compound. The unit cell parameters at room temperature are a=10.069(5)Å, b=45.831(10)Å, and c=9.822(5)Å and the unit cell volume is 4533(3)Å(3) with Z=8.

Pressure-temperature state diagram for the phase relationships between benfluorex hydrochloride forms I and II: a case of enantiotropic behavior.

The active pharmaceutical ingredient racemic benfluorex hydrochloride (benfluorex-HCl) has an interesting phase behavior due to an elusive solid-solid phase transition. The stability hierarchy between different phases is often determined based on heat-related experiments only or slurry interconversion. It is shown that if pressure and volume are taken into account, not only the phase equilibria are correctly positioned in the pressure-temperature phase diagram, but the experimental data also improves. Thus, it has been found that the racemic benfluorex-HCl is enantiotropic under "ordinary conditions" with polymorph II and polymorph I, respectively, being the low- and the high-temperature phases. Above ∼ 151 MPa, the system becomes monotropic and polymorph II is the single stable phase.

Topological and experimental approach to the pressure-temperature-composition phase diagram of the binary enantiomer system d- and l-camphor.

In 1981, Jacques, Collet, and Wilen already put forward the idea to use pressure to influence equilibria in binary enantiomer systems in analogy with temperature (Jacques et al. Enantiomers, Racemates and Resolutions; John Wiley & Sons: New York, 1981). Whereas temperature is used routinely to study phase equilibria, pressure is an all but forgotten parameter. This is therefore possibly the first paper on the influence of pressure on a binary enantiomer system: d- and l-camphor. The study consists of two parts, a topological approach, which uses data obtained from routine measurements (differential scanning calorimetry, X-ray diffraction), and the experimental determination of phase transitions as a function of pressure and temperature. This has resulted in two topological pressure-temperature phase diagrams of the pure enantiomer d-camphor and of the racemic mixture dl-camphor; both have been verified by the experiments as a function of pressure. In turn, these results have been used to construct part of the pressure-temperature-composition phase diagram of d- and l-camphor. A method to obtain the excess Gibbs energy from these binary phase diagrams as a function of pressure is proposed.