Proton-coupled electron transfer of macrocyclic ring hydrogenation: The chlorinphlorin.

SignificanceThe chemical reduction of unsaturated bonds occurs by hydrogenation with H2 as the reductant. Conversely, in biology, the unavailability of H2 engenders the typical reduction of unsaturated bonds with electrons and protons from different cofactors, requiring olefin hydrogenation to occur by proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET). Moreover, the redox noninnocence of tetrapyrrole macrocycles furnishes unusual PCET intermediates, including the phlorin, which is an intermediate in tetrapyrrole ring reductions. Whereas the phlorin of a porphyrin is well established, the phlorin of a chlorin is enigmatic. By controlling the PCET reactivity of a chlorin, including the use of a hangman functionality to manage the proton transfer, the formation of a chlorinphlorin by PCET is realized, and the mechanism for its formation is defined.

Redox Behavior and Kinetics of Hydroxo Ligand Exchange on Iron Tetraphenylporphyrin: Comparison with Chloro Exchange and Consequences for Its Role in Self-Modulation of Molecular Catalysis of Electrochemical Reactions.

Thermodynamics and kinetics of hydroxide ion binding to iron tetraphenylporphyrin (TPPFe) at different redox states is investigated by electrochemistry and UV-vis spectroscopy. The reduction of initial TPPFe(III) drastically decreases the binding affinity of hydroxide ions. An activation-driving force correlation is revealed showing that the strongest the binding affinity, the largest the association rate constant and vice versa. Comparison with chloride ions shows that hydroxide ions are stronger ligands for iron tetraphenylporphyrin. However, kinetic data indicate that coordination and decoordination of chloride ions is intrinsically faster than coordination and decoordination of hydroxide ions. Finally, the consequence of hydroxide ion binding dynamics when TPPFe is used as a molecular catalyst for electrochemical reactions liberating hydroxides is discussed in the framework of self-modulation of catalytic processes.

Deciphering Reversible Homogeneous Catalysis of the Electrochemical H2 Evolution and Oxidation: Role of Proton Relays and Local Concentration Effects.

Nickel bisdiphosphine complexes bearing pendant amines form a unique series of catalysts (so-called DuBois' catalysts) capable of bidirectional/reversible electrocatalytic oxidation and production of dihydrogen. This unique behaviour is directly linked to the presence of proton relays installed close to the metal center. We report here for the arginine derivative [Ni(P2 Cy N2 Arg )2 ]6+ on a mechanistic model and its kinetic treatment that may apply to all DuBois' catalysts and show that it allows for a good fit of experimental data measured at different pH values, catalyst concentrations and partial hydrogen pressures. The bidirectionality of catalysis results from balanced equilibria related to hydrogen uptake/evolution on one side and (metal)-hydride installation/capture on the other side, both controlled by concentration effects resulting from the presence of proton relays and connected by two square schemes corresponding to proton-coupled electron transfer processes. We show that the catalytic bias is controlled by the kinetic of the H2 uptake/evolution step. Reversibility does not require that the energy landscape be flat, with redox transitions occurring at potentials up to 250 mV away for the equilibrium potential, although such large deviations from a flat energy landscape can negatively impacts the rate of catalysis when coupled with slow interfacial electron transfer kinetics.

Rhenium Carbonyl Molecular Catalysts for CO2 Electroreduction: Effects on Catalysis of Bipyridine Substituents Mimicking Anchorage Functions to Modify Electrodes.

Heterogenization of molecular catalysts on (photo)electrode surfaces is required to design devices performing processes enabling to store renewable energy in chemical bonds. Among the various strategies to immobilize molecular catalysts, direct chemical bonding to conductive surfaces presents some advantages because of the robustness of the linkage. When the catalyst is, as it is often the case, a transition metal complex, the anchoring group has to be connected to the complex through the ligands, and an important question is thus raised on the influence of this function on the redox and on the catalytic properties of the complex. Herein, we analyze the effect of conjugated and non conjugated substituents, structurally close to anchoring functions previously used to immobilize a rhenium carbonyl bipyridyl molecular catalyst for supported CO2 electroreduction. We show that carboxylic ester groups, mimicking anchoring the catalyst via carboxylate binding to the surface, have a drastic effect on the catalytic activity of the complex toward CO2 electroreduction. The reasons for such an effect are revealed via a combined spectro-electrochemical analysis showing that the reducing equivalents are mainly accumulated on the electron-withdrawing ester on the bipyridine ligand preventing the formation of the rhenium(0) center and its interaction with CO2. Alternatively, alkyl-phosphonic ester substituents, not conjugated with the bpy ligand, mimicking anchoring the catalyst via phosphonate binding to the surface, allow preserving the catalytic activity of the complex.

Concepts and tools for mechanism and selectivity analysis in synthetic organic electrochemistry.

As an accompaniment to the current renaissance of synthetic organic electrochemistry, the heterogeneous and space-dependent nature of electrochemical reactions is analyzed in detail. The reactions that follow the initial electron transfer step and yield the products are intimately coupled with reactant transport. Depiction of the ensuing reactions profiles is the key to the mechanism and selectivity parameters. Analysis is eased by the steady state resulting from coupling of diffusion with convection forced by solution stirring or circulation. Homogeneous molecular catalysis of organic electrochemical reactions of the redox or chemical type may be treated in the same manner. The same benchmarking procedures recently developed for the activation of small molecules in the context of modern energy challenges lead to the establishment and comparison of the catalytic Tafel plots. At the very opposite, redox-neutral chemical reactions may be catalyzed by injection (or removal) of an electron from the electrode. This class of reactions has currently few, but very thoroughly analyzed, examples. It is likely that new cases will emerge in the near future.

Ligand "noninnocence" in coordination complexes vs. kinetic, mechanistic, and selectivity issues in electrochemical catalysis.

The world of coordination complexes is currently stimulated by the quest for efficient catalysts for the electrochemical reactions underlying modern energy and environmental challenges. Even in the case of a multielectron-multistep process, catalysis starts with uptake or removal of one electron from the resting state of the catalyst. If this first step is an outer-sphere electron transfer (triggering a "redox catalysis" process), the electron distribution over the metal and the ligand is of minor importance. This is no longer the case with "chemical catalysis," in which the active catalyst reacts with the substrate in an inner-sphere manner, often involving the transient formation of a catalyst-substrate adduct. The fact that, in most cases, the ligand is "noninnocent," in the sense that the electron density and charge gained (or removed) from the resting state of the catalyst are shared between the metal and the ligand, has become common-place knowledge over the last half-century. Insistent focus on a large degree of noninnocence of the ligand in the resting state of the catalyst, even robustly validated by spectroscopic techniques, may lead to undermining the essential role of the metal when such essential issues as kinetics, mechanisms, and product selectivity are dealt with. These points are general in scope, but their discussion is eased by adequately documented examples. This is the case for reactions involving metalloporphyrins as well as vitamin B12 derivatives and similar cobalt complexes for which a wealth of experimental data is available.

Driving force dependence of inner-sphere electron transfer for the reduction of CO2 on a gold electrode.

The kinetics of the inner-sphere electron transfer reaction between a gold electrode and CO2 was measured as a function of the applied potential in an aqueous environment. Extraction of the electron transfer rate constant requires deconvolution of the current associated with CO2 reduction from the competing hydrogen evolution reaction and mass transport. Analysis of the inner-sphere electron transfer reaction reveals a driving force dependence of the rate constant that has similar characteristics to that of a Marcus-Hush-Levich outer-sphere electron transfer model. Consideration of simple assumptions for CO2 adsorption on the electrode surface allows for the evaluation of a CO2,ads/CO2 •- ads standard potential of ∼-0.75 ± 0.05 V vs Standard Hydrogen Electrode (SHE) and a reorganization energy on the order of 0.75 ± 0.10 eV. This standard potential is considerably lower than that observed for CO2 reduction on planar metal electrodes (∼>-1.4 V vs SHE for >10 mA/cm2), thus indicating that CO2 reduction occurs at a significant overpotential and thus provides an imperative for the design of better CO2 reduction electrocatalysts.

Self-healing catalysis in water.

Principles for designing self-healing water-splitting catalysts are presented together with a formal kinetics model to account for the key chemical steps needed for self-healing. Self-healing may be realized if the catalysts are able to self-assemble at applied potentials less than that needed for catalyst turnover. Solution pH provides a convenient handle for controlling the potential of these two processes, as demonstrated for the cobalt phosphate (CoPi) water-splitting catalyst. For Co2+ ion that appears in solution due to leaching from the catalyst during turnover, a quantitative description for the kinetics of the redeposition of the ion during the self-healing process has been derived. The model reveals that OER activity of CoPi occurs with negligible film dissolution in neutral pH for typical cell geometries and buffer concentrations.

Multielectron, multisubstrate molecular catalysis of electrochemical reactions: Formal kinetic analysis in the total catalysis regime.

Cyclic voltammetry responses are derived for two-electron, two-step homogeneous electrocatalytic reactions in the total catalysis regime. The models developed provide a framework for extracting kinetic information from cyclic voltammograms (CVs) obtained in conditions under which the substrate or cosubstrate is consumed in a multielectron redox process, as is particularly prevalent for very active catalysts that promote energy conversion reactions. Such determination of rate constants in the total catalysis regime is a prerequisite for the rational benchmarking of molecular electrocatalysts that promote multielectron conversions of small-molecule reactants. The present analysis is illustrated with experimental systems encompassing various limiting behaviors.

Elucidation of a Redox-Mediated Reaction Cycle for Nickel-Catalyzed Cross Coupling.

A reaction cycle for redox-mediated, Ni-catalyzed aryl etherification is proposed under both photoredox and electrochemically mediated conditions. We demonstrate that a self-sustained Ni(I/III) cycle is operative in both cases by chemically synthesizing and characterizing a common paramagnetic Ni intermediate and establishing its catalytic activity. Furthermore, deleterious pathways leading to off-cycle Ni(II) species have been identified, allowing us to discover optimized conditions for achieving self-sustained reactivity at a ∼15-fold increase in the quantum yield and a ∼3-fold increase in the faradaic yield. These results highlight the importance of leveraging insight of complete reaction cycles for increasing the efficiency of redox-mediated reactions.

Catalysis at the nanoscale may change selectivity.

Among the many virtues ascribed to catalytic nanoparticles, the prospect that the passage from the macro- to the nanoscale may change product selectivity attracts increasing attention. To date, why such effects may exist lacks explanation. Guided by recent experimental reports, we propose that the effects may result from the coupling between the chemical steps in which the reactant, intermediates, and products are involved and transport of these species toward the catalytic surface. Considering as a thought experiment the competitive formation of hydrogen and formate upon reduction of hydrogenocarbonate ions on metals like palladium or platinum, a model is developed that allows one to identify the governing parameters and predict the effect of nanoscaling on selectivity. The model leads to a master equation relating product selectivity and thickness of the diffusion layer. The latter parameter varies considerably upon passing from the macro- to the nanoscale, thus predicting considerable variations of product selectivity. These are subtle effects in the sense that the same mechanism might exhibit a reverse variation of the selectivity if the set of parameter values were different. An expression is given that allows one to predict the direction of the effect. There has been a tendency to assign the catalytic effects of nanoscaling to chemical reactivity changes of the active surface. Such factors might be important in some circumstances. We, however, insist on the likely role of short-distance transport on product selectivity, which could have been thought, at first sight, as the exclusive domain of chemical factors.

Efficient electrolyzer for CO2 splitting in neutral water using earth-abundant materials.

Low-cost, efficient CO2-to-CO+O2 electrochemical splitting is a key step for liquid-fuel production for renewable energy storage and use of CO2 as a feedstock for chemicals. Heterogeneous catalysts for cathodic CO2-to-CO associated with an O2-evolving anodic reaction in high-energy-efficiency cells are not yet available. An iron porphyrin immobilized into a conductive Nafion/carbon powder layer is a stable cathode producing CO in pH neutral water with 90% faradaic efficiency. It is coupled with a water oxidation phosphate cobalt oxide anode in a home-made electrolyzer by means of a Nafion membrane. Current densities of approximately 1 mA/cm(2) over 30-h electrolysis are achieved at a 2.5-V cell voltage, splitting CO2 and H2O into CO and O2 with a 50% energy efficiency. Remarkably, CO2 reduction outweighs the concurrent water reduction. The setup does not prevent high-efficiency proton transport through the Nafion membrane separator: The ohmic drop loss is only 0.1 V and the pH remains stable. These results demonstrate the possibility to set up an efficient, low-voltage, electrochemical cell that converts CO2 into CO and O2 by associating a cathodic-supported molecular catalyst based on an abundant transition metal with a cheap, easy-to-prepare anodic catalyst oxidizing water into O2.

Properties of Site-Specifically Incorporated 3-Aminotyrosine in Proteins To Study Redox-Active Tyrosines: Escherichia coli Ribonucleotide Reductase as a Paradigm.

3-Aminotyrosine (NH2Y) has been a useful probe to study the role of redox active tyrosines in enzymes. This report describes properties of NH2Y of key importance for its application in mechanistic studies. By combining the tRNA/NH2Y-RS suppression technology with a model protein tailored for amino acid redox studies (α3X, X = NH2Y), the formal reduction potential of NH2Y32(O•/OH) ( E°' = 395 ± 7 mV at pH 7.08 ± 0.05) could be determined using protein film voltammetry. We find that the Δ E°' between NH2Y32(O•/OH) and Y32(O•/OH) when measured under reversible conditions is ∼300-400 mV larger than earlier estimates based on irreversible voltammograms obtained on aqueous NH2Y and Y. We have also generated D6-NH2Y731-α2 of ribonucleotide reductase (RNR), which when incubated with ß2/CDP/ATP generates the D6-NH2Y731•-α2/ß2 complex. By multifrequency electron paramagnetic resonance (35, 94, and 263 GHz) and 34 GHz 1H ENDOR spectroscopies, we determined the hyperfine coupling (hfc) constants of the amino protons that establish RNH2• planarity and thus minimal perturbation of the reduction potential by the protein environment. The amount of Y in the isolated NH2Y-RNR incorporated by infidelity of the tRNA/NH2Y-RS pair was determined by a generally useful LC-MS method. This information is essential to the utility of this NH2Y probe to study any protein of interest and is employed to address our previously reported activity associated with NH2Y-substituted RNRs.

Homogeneous Molecular Catalysis of Electrochemical Reactions: Manipulating Intrinsic and Operational Factors for Catalyst Improvement.

Benchmarking and optimization of molecular catalysts for electrochemical reactions have become central issues in the efforts to match contemporary renewable energy challenges. In view of some confusion in the field, we precisely define the notions and parameters (potentials, overpotentials, turnover frequencies) involved in the accomplishment of these objectives and examine the correlations that may link them, thermodynamically and/or kinetically to each other (catalytic Tafel plots, scaling relationships, "iron laws"). To develop this tutorial section, we have picked as the model catalytic reaction scheme a moderately complex mechanism, general enough to illustrate the essential issues to be encountered and sufficiently simple to avoid the algebraic nightmare that a systematic study of all possible pathways would entail. The notion of scaling relations will be the object of particular attention, having notably in mind the delimitation of their domain of applicability. At this occasion, emphasis will be put on the necessity of clearly separating what is relevant to intrinsic characteristics (through standard quantities) to what deals with the effect of varying the reactant concentrations. It will be also stressed that the occurrence of such scaling relations, otherwise named "iron laws", is not a general phenomenon but rather concerns families of catalysts. Likewise, the search of a general correlation between the maximal turnover frequency and the equilibrium free energy of the electrochemical reaction appears as irrelevant and misleading. This general analysis will then be illustrated by experimental data previously obtained with the O2-to-H2O conversion catalyzed by ironIII/II porphyrins in N, N'-dimethylformamide in the presence of Brönsted acids.

Direct Electrochemical P(V) to P(III) Reduction of Phosphine Oxide Facilitated by Triaryl Borates.

Triaryl borate Lewis acids facilitate the direct two-electron reduction of the P(V) center of triphenylphosphine oxide (TPPO) to the P(III) center of triphenylphosphine at faradaic efficiencies of 37%. Insight from direct P(V) to P(III) reduction is provided from cyclic voltammetry. The electrochemical reduction of TPPO proceeds through an unusual ECrECi mechanism in which the breaking of the phosphoryl bond in a two-electron-reduced association complex with the triaryl borate is rate-determining. The rate and faradaic efficiency for TPPO reduction are tuned by judicious choice of substituents on triaryl borate, with tris(4-methoxyphenyl) borate demonstrating the highest for both. These results suggest that an attractive route toward the room-temperature reduction of phosphate for phosphorus reclamation is greatly facilitated by the stabilization of reduced phosphate intermediates through their association with Lewis acids.

Nanodiffusion in electrocatalytic films.

In the active interest aroused by electrochemical reactions' catalysis, related to modern energy challenges, films deposited on electrodes are often preferred to homogeneous catalysts. A particularly promising variety of such films, in terms of efficiency and selectivity, is offered by sprinkling catalytic nanoparticles onto a conductive network. Coupled with the catalytic reaction, the competitive occurrence of various modes of substrate diffusion-diffusion toward nanoparticles ('nanodiffusion') against film linear diffusion and solution linear diffusion-is analysed theoretically. It is governed by a dimensionless parameter that contains all the experimental factors, thus allowing one to single out the conditions in which nanodiffusion is the dominant mode of mass transport. These theoretical predictions are illustrated experimentally by proton reduction on a mixture of platinum nanoparticles and carbon dispersed in a Nafion film deposited on a glassy carbon electrode. The density of nanoparticles and the scan rate are used as experimental variables to test the theory.

Efficient and selective molecular catalyst for the CO2-to-CO electrochemical conversion in water.

Substitution of the four paraphenyl hydrogens of iron tetraphenylporphyrin by trimethylammonio groups provides a water-soluble molecule able to catalyze the electrochemical conversion of carbon dioxide into carbon monoxide. The reaction, performed in pH-neutral water, forms quasi-exclusively carbon monoxide with very little production of hydrogen, despite partial equilibration of CO2 with carbonic acid-a low pKa acid. This selective molecular catalyst is endowed with a good stability and a high turnover frequency. On this basis, prescribed composition of CO-H2 mixtures can be obtained by adjusting the pH of the solution, optionally adding an electroinactive buffer. The development of these strategies will be greatly facilitated by the fact that one operates in water. The same applies for the association of the cathode compartment with a proton-producing anode by means of a suitable separator.

Homogeneous Molecular Catalysis of Electrochemical Reactions: Catalyst Benchmarking and Optimization Strategies.

Modern energy challenges currently trigger an intense interest in catalysis of redox reactions-electrochemical and photochemical-particularly those involving small molecules such as water, hydrogen, oxygen, proton, carbon dioxide. A continuously increasing number of molecular catalysts of these reactions, mostly transition metal complexes, have been proposed, rendering necessary procedures for their rational benchmarking and fueling the quest for leading principles that could inspire the design of improved catalysts. The search of "volcano plots" correlating catalysis kinetics to the stability of the key intermediate is a popular approach to the question in catalysis by surface-active sites, with as foremost example the electrochemical reduction of aqueous proton on metal surfaces. We discussed here for the first time, on theoretical and experimental grounds, the pertinence of such an approach in the field of molecular catalysis. This is the occasion to insist on the virtue of careful mechanism assignments. Particular emphasis is put on the interest of expressing the catalysts' intrinsic kinetic properties by means of catalytic Tafel plots, which relate kinetics and overpotential. We also underscore that the principle and strategies put forward for the catalytic activation of the above-mentioned small molecules are general as illustrated by catalytic applications out of this particular field.

Catalysis and Inhibition in the Electrochemical Reduction of CO2 on Platinum in the Presence of Protonated Pyridine. New Insights into Mechanisms and Products.

In the framework of modern energy challenges, the reduction of CO2 into fuels calls for electrogenerated low-valent transition metal complexes catalysts designed with considerable ingenuity and sophistication. For this reason, the report that a molecule as simple as protonated pyridine (PyH+) could catalyze the formation of methanol from the reduction of CO2 on a platinum electrode triggered great interest and excitement. Further investigations revealed that no methanol is produced. It appears that CO2 is not really reduced but rather participates, on the basis of its aquation into carbonic acid, in hydrogen evolution. Actually, the situation is not that straightforward, as revealed by scrutinizing what happens at the platinum electrode surface. The present study confirms the lack of methanol formation upon bulk electrolysis of PyH+ solutions at Pt and provides a detailed account of the Faradaic yield for H2 production as a function of the electrode potential, but the main finding is that CO2 reduction is accompanied by a strong inhibition of the electrode process taking place when it is carried out in the presence of acids such as PyH+ and AcOH. Cyclic voltammetry and in situ infrared spectroscopy were closely combined to investigate and understand the nature and consequences of the inhibition process. Constant comparison between the two acids was required to decipher the course of the reaction owing to the fact that the IR responses are perturbed by PyH+ adsorption. It finally appears that inhibition is caused by the reduction of CO2 into CO, whose high affinity with platinum triggers the formation of a Pt-CO film that prevents the reaction process. Thus, a paradoxical situation develops in which the high affinity of Pt for CO helps to decrease the overpotential for the reduction of CO2 and therefore blocks the electrode, preventing the reaction process.