Lymphomatoid papulosis and associated cutaneous lymphoproliferative disorders exhibit a common clonal origin.

Determination of the clonal relationship among multiple lymphoproliferative disorders occurring in individual patients has been hampered by dependence on molecular biologic techniques that require analysis of advanced lesions containing high tumor clone densities to isolate dominant, clonal antigen-receptor gene rearrangements. Polymerase chain reaction/denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (PCR/DGGE) involves the amplification of T-cell receptor (TCR)-gamma gene rearrangements followed by their electrophoresis in denaturing gradient gels. This method detects dominant TCR-gamma gene rearrangements at tumor clone densities as low as 0.1%, making this assay suitable for analysis of early as well as late lesions. Using this approach, we analyzed skin lesions of lymphomatoid papulosis and either CD30+ large-cell lymphoma or early patch/plaque mycosis fungoides that developed in three patients. In each case, the dual specimens exhibited an identical band pattern by PCR/DGGE analysis, suggesting a common clonal origin. To confirm this clonal relationship, the dominant TCR-gamma gene rearrangements were eluted, amplified, cloned, and sequenced. In each case, they showed identical junctional sequences. These findings are significant for several reasons: 1) they demonstrate the common clonal origin of lymphomatoid papulosis and CD30+ large-cell lymphoma or mycosis fungoides occurring in individual patients; 2) they confirm that co-migrating PCR/DGGE bands exhibit identical nucleotide sequences; and 3) they provide a method for determining the sequence of a tumor-derived TCR-gamma gene rearrangement in early lesions containing a low tumor clone density. This latter feature should allow the prospective molecular staging of early cutaneous lymphoproliferative disorders.

Detection of clonal T-cell receptor gamma gene rearrangements in early mycosis fungoides/Sezary syndrome by polymerase chain reaction and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (PCR/DGGE).

We used a gene amplification strategy to analyze T-cell receptor (TCR) gene rearrangements in 185 specimens, including mycosis fungoides/Sezary syndrome (MF/SS), other cutaneous neoplasms, inflammatory dermatoses, reactive lymphoid tissues, and normal skin. Genomic DNA was extracted from lesional tissues and rearrangements of the TCR-gamma chain gene were amplified using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) with primers specific for rearrangements involving V gamma 1-8 or V gamma 9 gene segments. The resulting PCR products were then separated according to their nucleotide sequence as well as size by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE). Dominant clonal TCR-gamma gene rearrangements were detected in 61 of 68 MF/SS cases by PCR/DGGE. This sensitivity of 90% compared to a sensitivity of only 59% when dominant clonality was sought in 17 of these same cases by Southern blot analysis of TCR-beta gene rearrangements. This difference in sensitivity was greatest in early, minimally infiltrated skin lesions. PCR/DGGE was also more sensitive than Southern blot analysis for detecting peripheral blood involvement in two cases of early MF. Among 12 additional specimens of suspected MF/SS, nine (75%) showed clonal TCR-gamma gene rearrangements by PCR/DGGE including six of eight cases with a previously confirmed diagnosis of MF/SS and three of four cases without prior known MF/SS. Among 105 non-MF/SS specimens, dominant TCR-gamma gene rearrangements were detected in only six cases (6%). Four were diagnosed as chronic dermatitis and two were diagnosed as cutaneous lymphoid hyperplasia. We conclude that the large majority of MF/SS cases, including patch phase disease, possess dominant clonal TCR-gamma gene rearrangements. PCR/DGGE is more sensitive than Southern blot analysis for detecting dominant clonality and staging disease in patients with a confirmed diagnosis of MF/SS. However, because PCR/DGGE is sensitive enough to detect dominant TCR-gamma gene rearrangements in a subset of patients with chronic dermatitis, it cannot be used as the sole criterion for establishing a diagnosis of T-cell lymphoma. As with other molecular biologic clonality assays, clinicopathologic correlation is essential. Nevertheless, the detection of dominant clonality in some cases of histologically nonspecific dermatitis allows the identification of a previously unrecognized subset of patients, i.e., those with "clonal dermatitis." It will be important to determine the long-term risk of MF/SS among these patients because our study indicated that MF/SS can sometimes present with lesions indistinguishable from clonal dermatitis.

Evidence against a role for human T-cell lymphotrophic virus type I (HTLV-I) in the pathogenesis of American cutaneous T-cell lymphoma.

We used a standard polymerase chain reaction (PCR)/Southern blot assay (sensitivity > 10(-5)) to detect human T-cell lymphotrophic virus type I (HTLV-I) proviral pX, pol, and env genes in the lesional skin of 42 American patients with cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL). As in some prior reports using similar methods, a variable proportion of PCR tests were positive (seven of 42 for pX, three of 42 for pol, and two of 37 for env), resulting in an overall positive test rate of 12 of 121 (10%). To determine the significance of these positive test results, we performed several additional studies. D1S80 polymorphism analysis of CTCL cases and HTLV-I PCR analysis of non-CTCL dermatosis controls showed no evidence that positive PCR tests resulted from sample mislabeling, gross HTLV-I contamination, or human endogenous retroviruses. We then modified the standard PCR assay to incorporate ultraviolet (UV) light to destroy low-level PCR contamination. With this modified assay (sensitivity > 10(-5)), only three of 12 previously positive cases were still positive, suggesting that the earlier positives were due to trace contamination of PCR reagents or trace contamination of sample DNA. This interpretation was also supported by: (i) a match between pX and pol sequences cloned from one PCR-positive specimen and the MT4-positive control, (ii) our inability to confirm HTLV-I in any PCR-positive case using genomic dot blotting (sensitivity > 10(-2)), and (iii) negative PCR results when new samples from two of the remaining positive cases were analyzed. Finally, we used our modified UV/ PCR/Southern blot assay to test an additional 28 cases of American CTCL for pX. All of them were negative. Although these studies of 70 cases of American CTCL do not exclude the possibility that another virus is involved in the pathogenesis of this disease, they provide strong evidence against a role for HTLV-I. Furthermore, they emphasize the need for special strategies to control for false-positive PCR tests that can result from even trace levels of contamination with viral DNA. As a consequence, associations between diseases and viruses should be viewed skeptically if they are based primarily on conventional PCR data.

Molecular biology techniques for the diagnosis of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma.

The molecular biologic analysis of TCR gene rearrangements by Southern blot analysis and various PCR-based assays has contributed significantly to the understanding of CTCL. It is now known that CTCL is a monoclonal T-cell disorder like other T-cell neoplasms and that the same tumor clone is generally present in all sites of tissue involvement. Relative to histopathologic examination, the enhanced sensitivity of molecular biologic assays has allowed the diagnosis of CTCL at an early stage in many cases. In fact, molecular biologic analysis of TCR gene rearrangements suggests that CTCL may contain a dominant monoclonal tumor cell population from the time of its earliest clinically recognizable lesions, such as the cutaneous patches once termed large plaque parapsoriasis and now generally regarded as early CTCL. Furthermore, available data indicate that, at least in some cases, tumor cells are distributed widely among cutaneous and extracutaneous tissues at a time long before this involvement can be appreciated morphologically. It is apparent that, in addition to their value in the early diagnosis and staging of cutaneous lymphomas, these molecular biologic assays are valuable in monitoring the response to therapy, detecting early relapse, and improving understanding of the compartmentalization and trafficking of tumor cells. In order to reap the full clinical benefit from this new information, however, it is important to perform prospective long-term studies designed to determine the clinical significance of molecular biologic data. In addition, the complexity of cutaneous lymphoproliferative disorders dictates that molecular biologic clonality data should never be interpreted in a vacuum. In skin disease, dominant clonality does not always equate with clinical malignancy. The proper diagnosis of CTCL and other cutaneous lymphoproliferative diseases requires the thoughtful integration of molecular biologic data with the clinicopathologic and immunophenotypic findings.

Quantitation of T-cell DNA in cutaneous lymphoid infiltrates.

A method is described that allows the quantitation of T-cell DNA within a tissue biopsy specimen. This method is based on the densitometric evaluation of the multiband pattern of TCR-gamma gene rearrangements detectable in Southern blot analyses of polyclonal T-cell DNA digested with HindIII. These rearrangements can be detected down to a limit of approximately 5% T-cell DNA. The information derived from this type of analysis can be used to roughly assess the total T-cell content of lesional tissue specimens expressed as a percentage of total tissue DNA, and can be correlated with the pattern of T-cell infiltration visualized by immunohistology. This assessment can be used also to determine the threshold, expressed as a percentage of total lesional T-cell DNA instead of total tissue DNA, required for the detection of a monoclonal T-cell population by Southern blot analysis. These quantitative relationships may prove useful for studying cutaneous T-cell lymphoma and associated precursor conditions.