The use of hyperventilation therapy after traumatic brain injury in Europe: an analysis of the BrainIT database.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the use of hyperventilation and the adherence to Brain Trauma Foundation-Guidelines (BTF-G) after traumatic brain injury (TBI). SETTING: Twenty-two European centers are participating in the BrainIT initiative. DESIGN: Retrospective analysis of monitoring data. PATIENTS AND PARTICIPANTS: One hundred and fifty-one patients with a known time of trauma and at least one recorded arterial blood-gas (ABG) analysis. MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS: A total number of 7,703 ABGs, representing 2,269 ventilation episodes (VE) were included in the analysis. Related minute-by-minute ICP data were taken from a 30 min time window around each ABG collection. Data are given as mean with standard deviation. (1) Patients without elevated intracranial pressure (ICP) (< 20 mmHg) manifested a statistically significant higher P(a)CO(2) (36 +/- 5.7 mmHg) in comparison to patients with elevated ICP (> or = 20 mmHg; P(a)CO(2): 34 +/- 5.4 mmHg, P < 0.001). (2) Intensified forced hyperventilation (P(a)CO(2) < or = 25 mmHg) in the absence of elevated ICP was found in only 49 VE (2%). (3) Early prophylactic hyperventilation (< 24 h after TBI; P(a)CO(2) < or = 35 mmHg, ICP < 20 mmHg) was used in 1,224 VE (54%). (4) During forced hyperventilation (P(a)CO(2) < or = 30 mmHg), simultaneous monitoring of brain tissue pO(2) or S(jv)O(2) was used in only 204 VE (9%). CONCLUSION: While overall adherence to current BTF-G seems to be the rule, its recommendations on early prophylactic hyperventilation as well as the use of additional cerebral oxygenation monitoring during forced hyperventilation are not followed in this sample of European TBI centers. DESCRIPTOR: Neurotrauma.

The effect of the results of the STICH trial on the management of spontaneous supratentorial intracerebral haemorrhage in Newcastle.

Recently, the Surgical Trial in IntraCerebral Haemorrhage (STICH) was unable to show an overall benefit from 'early surgery' compared with a policy of 'initial conservative treatment'. Here, we evaluated the impact of the STICH results on the management of spontaneous supratentorial intracerebral haemorrhage (ICH) in the Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals. The STICH results were released to the Neurosurgery Department at Newcastle General Hospital in November 2003; using ICD-10 data, we analysed ICH admissions before (2002) and after (2004, 2006, 2007) this. We assessed numbers of Neurosurgery and Stroke Unit admissions, numbers of clot evacuation procedures, and 30-day mortality rate (Neurosurgery vs. Stroke Unit admissions). Subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) admissions data were also collected to corroborate our findings. There were 478 spontaneous supratentorial ICH admissions in total; 156 in 2002, 120 in 2004, 106 in 2006 and 96 in 2007. SAH admissions remained remarkably constant over this period. Neurosurgery admissions decreased significantly across the four time periods, from 71% of total ICH admissions (n = 156) in 2002 to 55% (n = 96) in 2007, and Stroke Unit admissions increased significantly from 8% (n = 156) in 2002 to 30% (n = 96) in 2007 (chi(2) = 20.968, p < 0.001, df = 3). Clot evacuation procedures also decreased significantly from 32% (n = 111) of Neurosurgery admissions in 2002 to 17% (n = 53) in 2007 (chi(2) = 11.919, p = 0.008, df = 3). 30-day mortality increased in Neurosurgery from 14% of Neurosurgery admissions (n = 111) in 2002 to 26% (n = 53) in 2007, and decreased in the Stroke Unit, from 42% of Stroke Unit admissions (n = 12) in 2002 to 17% (n = 29) in 2007. The STICH results have significantly impacted ICH management in Newcastle, with a trend towards fewer Neurosurgery admissions and clot evacuations, and increased Stroke Unit admissions. The role of surgery for ICH remains controversial, and randomization continues in STICH II for patients with superficial lobar ICH.

The significance of crossovers after randomization in the STICH trial.

INTRODUCTION: Of all forms of stroke, spontaneous intracerebral haemorrhage (ICH) causes the highest morbidity and mortality. The Surgical Trial in Intracerebral Haemorrhage (STICH) found no difference in outcomes between patients randomized to surgical or conservative treatment. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Of 530 patients randomized to initial conservative treatment, 140 crossed over to surgery. This study examines the variables associated with crossover. RESULTS: Dominant features of the crossover group were: male, (p = 0.04), right-sided clot (p = 0.03), lobar clot (p = 0.003), clot volume (median 64 mL for crossovers vs. 38 mL for others, p < 0.00001), midline shift (median 6 mm for crossovers vs. 3 mm for others, p < 0.00001), superficial clot (median 1.3 mm for crossovers vs. 11.5 mm for others, p < 0.00001), and randomization within 12 hours of ictus (p < 0.0005). Thalamic location (p = 0.002) was under-represented. Intraventricular haemorrhage, hydrocephalus, and focal deficits were not associated with crossover. Craniotomy was the method of evacuation in 85% of crossover patients. CONCLUSIONS: Crossover to surgery was more likely when ICH had these features: Right side, lobar location, superficial, large volume, big shift, and early randomization. Crossovers formed a worse prognostic group compared to non-crossovers. Surgery did not affect trial results, which were analyzed by intention-to-treat.

Development of a measure of professional collaboration in primary health care.

STUDY OBJECTIVE: The aim was to develop indices of the degree of collaboration between district nurses, general practitioners, and health visitors. DESIGN: Semistructured interviews were conducted with each member of a pair of professionals who had patients in common. In each district a stratified random sample of six general practitioners and six community nurses was drawn, and for each a "partner" of the other profession was sampled. SETTING: A stratified random sample of 20 district health authorities in England. PARTICIPANTS: Complete interviews were obtained with 148 doctor-nurse and 161 doctor-health visitor pairs. MAIN RESULTS: Only 27% of general practitioners and district nurses with patients in common and 11% of general practitioners and health visitors collaborate. Stepwise logistic discriminant analysis was used to develop measures of collaboration between general practitioners and district nurses and between general practitioners and health visitors. The indices of collaboration were calculated from the responses of the community nurse to at most 10 questions. CONCLUSIONS: The indices developed here might be used as a measure of one aspect of the quality of service offered by a primary health care team or to assess the effect of changes in working patterns or the degree of collaboration within the organisation.

Issues of recruitment and maintaining high response rates in a longitudinal study of older hospital patients in England--pathways through care study.

STUDY OBJECTIVES: To describe and discuss the methods used to recruit and maintain an unbiased sample of older discharged hospital patients in a study of the process and outcomes of hospital care. DESIGN: Prospective longitudinal interview study of consecutive patients admitted to hospital over a 12 month period and followed up for six months. Interviews took place in hospital five days after admission, at home 10 days after discharge, and six months after admission. SETTING: Six hospital locations: three in the north of England and three in the south. PARTICIPANTS: People aged 65 and over admitted to hospital with a new stroke or fractured neck of femur, their significant other, and nursing staff caring for them. MAIN RESULTS: Of 3105 patients referred to the study, 2111 were eligible and 1671 (79%) were recruited. Recruited stroke patients were younger than those not recruited and rates differed between locations for both stroke and fractured neck of femur. By six months after admission 25% had died. Outcome data were obtained for 85% of the surviving patients. Patients who died were older and frailer before admission. Among survivors, outcome data for stroke patients were less likely to be obtained for men, those more able initially, and those who were married. Response rates to each interview differed according to respondent types. Interviews were more likely to be obtained with significant others than patients. Patients who were not able to be interviewed were older and frailer; significant others were less likely to be interviewed if the patients were younger and more able. CONCLUSIONS: High response rates can be achieved with very frail older people if strategies are adopted to maintain their interest and if self reported data are supplemented by interviewing significant others.

Costs of formal care for frail older people in England: the resource implications study of the MRC cognitive function and ageing study (RIS MRC CFAS).

The aim of this paper is to quantify service use and costs of supporting frail older people at home in the community, using data collected in a longitudinal multicentre stratified randomised study for 1055 mentally frail, physically frail, and mentally and physically frail subjects. Average costs per person per week were found to total 64.45 Pounds Sterling, with a small number of services accounting for a large proportion of the total costs. The level of services offered by the nonstatutory voluntary and private sectors was found to be small. To highlight issues for policy makers, the extent of cost variations between a number of different subgroups were calculated. These bivariate analyses revealed substantial variation in costs, especially according to household structure, type of frailty, whether admission to continuing care accommodation occurred and survival. Multiple regression analysis demonstrated that 26% of the variation in log average weekly costs could be explained by a number of socio-demographic and health status variables. A particularly close relationship was observed between costs and whether admission to continuing care accommodation occurred, highlighting a need for policy-makers to examine the nature and scale of provision of alternative community based care packages. The results demonstrate that descriptive cost data such as those presented can provide information useful to the planning process, enabling more informed choices to be made over the provision of services for particular groups of people.

A review of the literature on the midwife and community-based maternity care.

OBJECTIVE: to review the UK literature relating to community-based maternity care. DESIGN: all UK research studies published between 1970 and 1998 relating to community-based maternity care were included. Searches were made via a number of electronic databases using defined search terms. All papers included were independently reviewed by a minimum of two researchers. Study findings were tabulated using a pro-forma. Findings are summarised in this paper. FINDINGS: a total of 241 papers were deemed to meet all inclusion criteria. The majority of studies used descriptive methods with only 11 papers reporting findings from randomised controlled trials. Findings are reported relating to clinical outcomes, the care process and the views of women and health professionals. CONCLUSION AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS: the overall quality of the evidence in the papers reviewed was very mixed. What limited evidence there is suggests that, for the majority of women, care in community settings is as safe and as acceptable to women as care provided in hospital. Despite a large volume of literature, the amount that is known about midwives' contribution to care, and what women think about it, is limited. There is a need for controlled studies to compare outcomes for different patterns of care and for well-designed observational studies to provide information on the care process.

Regional differences in outcome from subarachnoid haemorrhage.

BACKGROUND: Surgeons are increasingly placed under pressure to accept publication of their results and to abide by recommendations to change practice which others derive. Considerable concern exists about misinterpretation of such data. The issue is well illustrated by this study. METHOD: Data on outcome following treatment for subarachnoid haemorrhage were prospectively collected from 1993-1998 in two centres in the British Isles: Newcastle and Nottingham. FINDINGS: Initial examination of this data suggest a substantial difference in the performance favouring Nottingham over Newcastle. The odds of a poor outcome was 1:1.86 in Newcastle compared with 1:4.26 in Nottingham giving an odds ratio of 2.3 in favour of Nottingham and this difference was highly significant with p<0.00001. On a more detailed examination taking account of confounding variables, this difference disappeared entirely. Newcastle was able to operate a less selective admissions policy than Nottingham because of the deficiency of beds at the latter unit. A summary of these results has been published elsewhere. INTERPRETATION: These results illustrate the dangers of applying statistical tools developed for simpler situations such as industrial process control to complex medical problems. We conclude that comprehensive and accurate data on all factors likely to influence the outcome for a particular treatment should be collected as an absolute prerequisite to any judgments being made on apparent statistical differences between the performances of differing units.

General practitioners and postgraduate education in the Northern Region.

We describe a survey of general practitioners in the Northern Region which was carried out during the summer of 1977 as the result of a commission from the Education Committee of the North of England Faculty of the Royal College of General Practitioners. Seventy-five per cent of a one in two random sample of general practitioner principals returned a postal questionnaire in which their perceptions of postgraduate education were sought and their behaviour measured by the number of sessions they attended during the previous year at their 'usual' and other postgraduate centres. Almost half the respondents had more than a basic qualification and all but three per cent had held full-time hospital appointments, two thirds of them at the level of senior house officer or above. Their experience as general practitioner principals averaged 15 years and 57 per cent held part-time appointments outside their practices. Only four per cent had not attended any postgraduate events during the previous year but the remaining respondents had attended eight sessions on average, six of which were at their usual centres. Those attending more than the average number of sessions tended to have registered between 1950 and 1969, to work in larger practices, to hold additional appointments, or to be trainers or College tutors. Most of the respondents were conservative in their perceptions of teaching methods, the topics discussed at meetings, and the contributors to postgraduate education but the younger general practitioners and a group of established general practitioners affiliated to the Royal College of General Practitioners held more radical views. They agreed about the primacy of traditional clinical topics but were sceptical of the value of ward rounds and formal lectures and favoured the seminar and clinical attachments. They saw a need for more material about practice management and wanted experienced general practitioners and community paramedical staff as teachers in addition to hospital consultants. Most of the respondents believed that their usual centres were well organized and managed but failed to cater for the special requirements of general practitioners in non-clinical aspects of practice. Lunchtime and evenings were seen as the most convenient for weekday meetings and Sunday as the most convenient day of the week. A majority of respondents believed that post-graduate education had altered their practice of clinical medicine but only 15 per cent believed it had caused changes in their practice organization.

Measurement of outcomes within a multicentred randomized controlled trial in the evaluation of the experimental NHS nursing homes.

This paper reports outcome data from a multicentred randomized controlled trial (RCT) undertaken as part of the evaluation of the experimental NHS nursing homes. A small sample size within centres and differential non-response due to death and physical or mental frailty limits the statistical power of this trial and biases subject-reported outcomes toward the views of elderly people who were less frail. There were no significant differences in survival or personal well-being, or changes in behavioural ability, mental state or perceived health status between propositi and controls. There were significant differences in the views of responding propositi and controls suggesting that the experimental NHS nursing homes were preferred by residents. The results of this pragmatic trial suggest that there is no evidence to conclude that NHS nursing homes should not be provided as NHS continuing-care accommodation. Policy decisions should also take account of the other studies undertaken as part of the evaluation. Further research is needed to develop more appropriate outcome measures for this client group.

Estimation of a multiproduct cost function for physically frail older people.

Using the theory of multiproduct cost functions, this paper derives a cost function for physically frail older people living in private households, based on data collected between 1991 and 1995, for 472 subjects aged 65 years of age or over in four areas of England. The main characteristic of the cost function is that output categories are classified in terms of movements between different health states. These were measured by changes in activities of daily living (ADL) over 2 years, with 'low' ADL representing better functional ability than 'high' ADL. Empirical application of the approach, using four states defined in terms of worsening progression (stable low ADL; deteriorated or improved ADL; stable high ADL; deceased), indicated more favourable states were associated with lower costs. Multivariate analysis showed that the derived states were significantly related to costs which, when combined with variables indicating presence of particular chronic health conditions (diabetes or previous stroke), admission to continuing care accommodation and household structure, explained one-fifth of the variation in log average costs per week. Variables such as age, sex, carer input, social networks and level of cognitive functioning had no independent impact on costs. These findings could be used as a starting point for those interested in predicting the cost implications associated with the ageing population.

Trends over time in the management of subarachnoid haemorrhage in newcastle: review of 1609 patients.

This article reviews trends in the management of subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) at the Regional Neurosurgery Unit in Newcastle over 9 years. This is a comprehensive analysis of prospectively collected data on patients with SAH. We review the changes in clinical therapy and outcome with regards to conservative (non-surgical), surgical and endovascular therapy. Since 1990, the demographic and management/outcome details of patients with SAH have been recorded systematically. This study involves patients admitted over the 9 years, from January 1990 to December 1998. The data were computerized using Microsoft Access (Microsoft Inc. USA), and analysed using SPSS statistical package. A total of 1609 had aneurysmal SAH confirmed with CT, lumbar puncture and/or angiography. Sixty-seven per cent (1,073 patients) were female with a female to male ratio of 2:1. This ratio was maintained from 1990 to date. The mean age has slowly increased from 49 years in 1990 to 55 years of age in 1998, (range 18-91). Overall, 53.9% (from 66.3% in 1990 to 35.3% in 1998) were surgically treated, 8.1% had embolization (range 0.6-18.4%) and 38% (range 28.2-46.4%) were managed without surgical intervention for the aneurysm. The proportion of patients undergoing surgery has decreased since 1994 with improvements in endovascular therapy, participation in the ISAT trial and increased admission of poor grade patients (WFNS grades 4 and 5, from 17% in 1990 to 31% in 1998). The mortality rate has doubled over the years under review (18-32%). The percentage of severely disabled patients has remained constant at about 7% with none in a vegetative state. Only 54% had a favourable outcome in 1998 compared with 78% in 1990. Total morbidity and mortality has increased particularly during the last 3 years. This has been associated with double the number of admissions in grade 5. Favourable outcome occurred in 90% of good grade patients (WFNS 1 and 2) with 6.2% mortality in surgical candidates and 5.5% in patients treated endovascularly. The mortality for poor grade (WFNS 4 and 5) patients was 64%.

Pragmatic and explanatory trials in the evaluation of the experimental National Health Service nursing homes.

This paper reviews the issues which arose in the design of a randomized controlled trial of three experimental National Health Service nursing homes. Problems associated with the implementation of the trial included ethical issues, choice of sample size and recruitment of subjects to the trial, choice and validity of measures of outcome, evaluation of outcomes and replicability of findings. The distinction between explanatory and pragmatic trials is shown to overcome some of these problems.

The implementation of a multicentred randomized controlled trial in the evaluation of the experimental National Health Service nursing homes.

This paper reviews the implementation of a pragmatic multicentred randomized controlled trial in the evaluation of three experimental nursing homes. The organization of services for the care of elderly people varied between the three centres, and each used different criteria for selecting subjects for the trial and different methods of seeking informed consent. Data presented show that in each centre two truly randomized samples have been selected. However, differences between centres, in the characteristics of selected subjects, reflect the implementation of the trials in each of the centres. These findings emphasize the importance of good collaboration between health professionals providing the service, an independent research team, and the establishment of rigorous criteria for inclusion and exclusion of subjects at the outset.

Psychological distress among informal supporters of frail older people at home and in institutions. The Resource Implications Study Group of the MRC Cognitive Function and Ageing Study.

OBJECTIVE: Investigate presence of psychiatric morbidity in informal carers using 30-item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ) and examine which factors best predict psychiatric morbidity. DESIGN: Two-year longitudinal, panel survey of informal supporters of frail elderly subjects, using semi-structured interview schedules. Subjects were those defined as frail after screening stratified random sample of people aged 65 or over. SETTING: Informal supporters of frail elderly subjects residing in private households or residential or nursing homes in four UK districts. RESPONDENTS: 623 informal supporters of subjects living at home, 129 regular visitors of those in long-term care. MEASURE: 30-item GHQ (cross-sectional analysis). RESULTS: Stepwise multiple regression indicated main predictors of high GHQ scores in key supporters were: subjects had at least three problems of behaviour (b = 1.56, 95% CI 1.25-1.94); supporters had to alter working hours (b = 1.70, 95% CI 1.15-2.51); supporters were female (b =1.26, 95% CI 1.06-1.50). The following variables predicted low GHQ scores: supporters able to leave subject all day (b = 0.71, 95% CI 0.64-0.80); subjects never wandered (b = 0.78, 95% CI 0.62-0.99); supporters were 'other relatives' or friends of subject (b = 0.74, 95% CI 0.59-0.91). For visitors, spouses were most likely to have high GHQ scores (b = 2.46, 95% CI 1.32-4.57). CONCLUSIONS: Results suggest the need for greater collaboration between formal and informal care. Little work has been carried out to ascertain which interventions are most effective in alleviating carer stress: a series of randomized controlled trials to determine long-term effectiveness of various interventions for different groups of carers is required.

Elderly patients with severe head injury in coma from the outset--has anything changed?

Advancing age is known to be a determinant of outcome in head injury. We have sought to discover whether there has been any change in the outcome of elderly patients with severe head injury in Newcastle, where these patients have continued to be treated with maximum intervention. A review of prospectively collected data from the Newcastle Head Injury Database for the period 1990 to 2000 was carried out. All patients aged 70 years and above who had sustained a severe head injury (Glasgow Coma Score of 8 or less from the outset) were included. The Glasgow Outcome Score (GOS) was determined at 6 months. Seventy-one patients were identified. Fifty-seven (80%) died and 2 (3%) were in a vegetative state, 11 (16%) had severe disability, 1 (1%) had moderate disability and no patients made a good recovery. The natural history of this condition remains unchanged and due consideration should be given to this when evaluating interventions for elderly patients with a severe head injury.

Interprofessional collaboration in primary health care.

A study of interprofessional collaboration involving 148 general practitioner and district nurse pairs and 161 general practitioner and health visitor pairs was undertaken in 20 health districts throughout England in 1982-83. Data were collected using personal interviews and a prospective record of referrals and consultations. The ratings of collaboration recorded showed that only 27% of general practitioner-district nurse pairs and 11% of general practitioner-health visitor pairs were working in partial or full collaboration. Structural arrangements such as attachment, the number of general practitioners that community nurses work with, and working from the same building were found to be strongly associated with collaboration.