Sequence and expression of the dCMP deaminase gene (DCD1) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

The dCMP deaminase gene (DCD1) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae has been isolated by screening a Sau3A clone bank for complementation of the dUMP auxotrophy exhibited by dcd1 dmp1 haploids. Plasmid pDC3, containing a 7-kilobase (kb) Sau3A insert, restores dCMP deaminase activity to dcd1 mutants and leads to an average 17.5-fold overproduction of the enzyme in wild-type cells. The complementing activity of the plasmid was localized to a 4.2-kb PvuII restriction fragment within the Sau3A insert. Subcloning experiments demonstrated that a single HindIII restriction site within this fragment lies within the DCD1 gene. Subsequent DNA sequence analysis revealed a 936-nucleotide open reading frame encompassing this HindIII site. Disruption of the open reading frame by integrative transformation led to a loss of enzyme activity and confirmed that this region constitutes the dCMP deaminase gene. Northern analysis indicated that the DCD1 mRNA is a 1.15-kb poly(A)+ transcript. The 5' end of the transcript was mapped by primer extension and appears to exhibit heterogeneous termini. Comparison of the amino acid sequence of the T2 bacteriophage dCMP deaminase with that deduced for the yeast enzyme revealed a limited degree of homology which extends over the entire length of the phage polypeptide (188 amino acids) but is confined to the carboxy-terminal half of the yeast protein (312 amino acids). A potential dTTP-binding site in the yeast and phage enzymes was identified by comparison of homologous regions with the amino acid sequences of a variety of other dTTP-binding enzymes. Despite the role of dCMP deaminase in dTTP biosynthesis, Northern analysis revealed that the DCD1 gene is not subject to the same cell cycle-dependent pattern of transcription recently found for the yeast thymidylate synthetase gene (TMP1).

Isolation of the thymidylate synthetase gene (TMP1) by complementation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

The structural gene (TMP1) for yeast thymidylate synthetase (thymidylate synthase; EC 2.1.1.45) was isolated from a chimeric plasmid bank by genetic complementation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Retransformation of the dTMP auxotroph GY712 and a temperature-sensitive mutant (cdc21) with purified plasmid (pTL1) yielded Tmp+ transformants at high frequency. In addition, the plasmid was tested for the ability to complement a bacterial thyA mutant that lacks functional thymidylate synthetase. Although it was not possible to select Thy+ transformants directly, it was found that all pTL1 transformants were phenotypically Thy+ after several generations of growth in nonselective conditions. Thus, yeast thymidylate synthetase is biologically active in Escherichia coli. Thymidylate synthetase was assayed in yeast cell lysates by high-pressure liquid chromatography to monitor the conversion of [6-3H]dUMP to [6-3H]dTMP. In protein extracts from the thymidylate auxotroph (tmp1-6) enzymatic conversion of dUMP to dTMP was barely detectable. Lysates of pTL1 transformants of this strain, however, had thymidylate synthetase activity that was comparable to that of the wild-type strain.

Effect of tumor promoters on ultraviolet light-induced mutation and mitotic recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Recently, it has been suggested that mitotic recombination is involved in tumor promotion. On this basis, one might expect tumor promoters to be recombinagenic. D7 is a diploid strain of yeast in which both mutation and mitotic recombination can be measured. We have used this strain to assay the known tumor promoters, iodoacetate, anthralin, and 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate, and the cocarcinogen, catechol, for mutagenicity, recombinagenicity, and the ability to enhance ultraviolet light (UV)-induced genetic events. In the absence of preirradiation with UV, iodoacetate was found to be recombinagenic whereas catechol was mutagenic; however, in both cases, the effects were small. Iodoacetate, anthralin, and catechol potentiated UV-induced mitotic crossing-over, aberrant colony formation, and mutation, while catechol also increased UV-induced gene conversion. We were unable to detect any mutagenic or recombinagenic effect of 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate in either whole cells or spheroplasts. Our results do not indicate any consistent correlation between tumor-promoting activity and the ability of an agent to induce mitotic recombination in yeast. However, the ability to potentiate UV-induced mutation and mitotic recombination may reflect the cocarcinogenic activity of certain promoters.

Kinetics of mutation induction by ultraviolet light in excision-deficient yeast.

We have measured the frequency of UV-induced reversions (locus plus suppressor) for the ochre alleles ade2-1 and lys2-1 and forward mutations (ade2 adex double auxotrophs) in an excision-deficient strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (rad2-20). For very low UV doses, both mutational systems exhibit linear induction kinetics. However, as the dose increases, a strikingly different response is observed: in the selective reversion system a transition to higher order induction kinetics occurs near 9 ergs/mm2 (25% survival), whereas in the nonselective forward system the mutation frequency passes through a maximum near 14 ergs/mm2 (4.4% survival) and then declines. This contrast in kinetics cannot be explained in any straightforward way by current models of induced mutagenesis, which have been developed primarily on the basis of bacterial data. The bacterial models are designed to accommodate the quadratic induction kinetics that are frequently observed in these systems. We have derived a mathematical expression for mutation frequency that enables us to fit both the forward and reversion data on the assumptions that mutagenesis is basically a "single event" Poisson process, and that mutation and killing are not necessarily independent of one another. In particular, the dose-response relations are consistent with the idea that the sensitivity of the revertants is about 25% less than that of the original cell population, whereas the sensitivity of the forward mutants is about 29% greater than the population average. We argue that this relatively small differential sensitivity of mutant and nonmutant cells is associated with events that take place during mutation expression and clonal growth.

Heteroduplex repair as an intermediate step of UV mutagenesis in yeast.

We have measured UV-induced mutation frequencies in yeast in a forward, nonselective assay system by scoring white adex ade2 double auxotrophs among parental red-pigmented ade2 clones. The frequencies of sectored and pure mutant clones were determined separately. In excision-defective strains carrying the genes rad1-1, rad3-2 and rad4-4, as well as in the double mutants, rad 1-1 rad 3-2 and rad 1-1 rad 4-4, considerably more sectored than pure clones are induced in the low-dose range; in repair-competent strains, pure mutant clones substantially outnumber the sectored clones. These results can be explained on the basis of known differences in the timing of error-prone repair during the cell division cycle; that is, we assume that error-prone repair occurs primarily before replication in RAD wild-type strains but after replication in excision-deficient mutants. It has been suggested that excision deficiency has a pleiotropic effect on heteroduplex repair and nucleotide excision repair; however, the high percentage (36.6%) of half-sectored clones found in the rad1-1 strain is hard to reconcile with this hypothesis. We propose that heteroduplex repair occurs subsequent to error-prone repair in both excision-proficient and excision-deficient strains.

Induction of intrachromosomal recombination in yeast by inhibition of thymidylate biosynthesis.

The biosynthesis of thymidylate in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae can be inhibited by antifolate drugs. We have found that antifolate treatment enhances the formation of leucine prototrophs in a haploid strain of yeast carrying, on the same chromosome, two different mutant leu2 alleles separated by Escherichia coli plasmid sequences. That this effect is a consequence of thymine nucleotide depletion was verified by the finding that provision of exogenous thymidylate eliminates the increased production of Leu+ colonies. DNA hybridization analysis revealed that recombination, including reciprocal exchange, gene conversion and unequal sister-chromatid crossing over, between the duplicated genes gave rise to the induced Leu+ segregants. Although gene conversion unaccompanied by crossing over was responsible for the major fraction of leucine prototrophs, events involving reciprocal exchange exhibited the largest increase in frequency. These data show that recombination is induced between directly repeated DNA sequences under conditions of thymine nucleotide depletion. In addition, the results of this and previous studies are consistent with the possibility that inhibition of thymidylate biosynthesis in yeast may create a metabolic condition that provokes all forms of mitotic recombination.

Quantitative aspects of the interactive killing effects between X rays and other mutagens in microorganisms.

Recently we presented a mathematical description of the synergistic interaction which occurs when Escherichia coli B/r is exposed to both X rays and 254 nm ultraviolet light (D. D. Ager and R. H. Haynes, Radiat. Res. 110, 129-141 (1987]. Here we extend this approach to other bacteria and describe a graphical technique which can be used to determine the nature and relative importance of second and third degree terms in the function h(x, y), which describes the dose dependence of such effects. In most cases, interaction functions appear to be dominated, in the biologically interesting dose range, by a second degree term in the product, xy, of the doses of the two agents. We find that the magnitudes of these interactions vary among the organisms examined and can be surprisingly large. Finally, we show that the simple xy dependence observed for most interactions does not carry any unambiguous implications with respect to previous speculations on the mechanisms of these effects.

Mathematical description of the interactions between cellular inactivating agents.

A mathematical technique for characterizing the interactive effects that may occur when cells are treated with two or more toxic agents is developed. This technique is used to account for the previously unexplained properties of the dose-response relations for the uv-X-ray interaction in Escherichia coli B/r.

Mutagenesis and mathematics: the allure of numbers.

This paper sets out the "formal," "empirical," and "mechanistic" equations that my colleagues and I have developed for the description and analysis of dose-response data on the lethal and genetic effects of mutagens in microorganisms. These three types of equations are interrelated inasmuch as they are all based ultimately on the use of the Poisson distribution in the formal definition of lethal and mutational hit functions. Explicit mathematical expressions for these functions can be written down in either empirical or mechanistic terms. The empirical equations are obtained simply by writing the hit functions as finite polynomials with adjustable coefficients. The mechanistic equations are based on the assumptions of the "DNA damage-repair hypothesis." The mathematical formulation of this hypothesis entails an important change in the definition of the word "hit" from that used in the classical hit/target theory of radiation biology. The theoretical and practical applications of these various equations in mutation research are summarized briefly and their merits are assessed in light of recent advances in our understanding of the biochemical basis of mutagenesis.

HIV and human endogenous retroviruses: an hypothesis with therapeutic implications.

The enzyme dUTP pyrophosphatase (dUTPase, EC 3.6.1.23) is essential for cellular DNA replication and cell viability by virtue of its role in reducing the availability of dUTP as a substrate for DNA polymerases. Several members of the onco- and lentivirus families of retroviruses encode dUTPases and mutant strains of these viruses defective in this enzyme exhibit suboptimal replication kinetics. Among the lentiviruses there exists a surprising phylogenetic discontinuity in the distribution of dUTPase genes: non-primate viruses (EIAV, CAEV, FIV, visna) contain such genes whereas the primate viruses (HIVs, SIVs) do not. The reason for this difference is unknown. We suggest the following explanation: (1) the nuclear and mitochondrial compartmentalization of the mammalian dUTPase, combined with the cytoplasmic location of ribonucleotide reductase, leads to the net synthesis of dUTP, together with dCTP, dGTP and dATP in the cytoplasm; (2) this combination of dNTPs serves as a "toxic cocktail" for viral replication by virtue of its ability to promote the synthesis of uracil-substituted DNA; (3) many viruses have adapted to this challenge by encoding dUTPases that are free of normal cellular regulatory constraints; and (4) the fortuitous expression of a dUTPase encoded by one or more human endogenous retroviruses (HERVs) has led to the evolutionary loss of the putative ancestral dUTPase gene of primate lentiviruses. Thus, we propose that efficient replication of HIV in humans depends upon expression of a dUTPase encoded by an endogenous retrovirus. If this proposal is correct, then the entry of HIV into target cells is necessary, but not sufficient, for replication of the virus in humans.

dUTP pyrophosphatase as a potential target for chemotherapeutic drug development.

Aberrant dUTP metabolism plays a critical role in the molecular mechanism of cell killing induced by inhibitors of dihydrofolate reductase and thymidylate synthase. While considerable effort has been directed towards discovering new, more potent inhibitors of these two enzymes, little attention has been given dUTP pyrophosphatase (dUTPase)--the key modulator of cellular dUTP levels--as a potential target for chemotherapeutic drug development. Recent studies have provided evidence that dUTPase is vital for cellular and, in some cases, viral DNA replication. Furthermore, some retroviruses encode dUTPases--a fact which suggests that cellular dUTP metabolism may be more important than previously realized. Here, we briefly review current knowledge of cellular and viral dUTPases and discuss the potential of these enzymes as targets for cancer chemotherapeutic and anti-viral drug development.

Analysis of interactions between mutagens, I. Heat and ultraviolet light in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

A new mathematical approach to the description of interaction data (Ager and Haynes, 1987) is applied here to the interaction between heat and ultraviolet light (UV) in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. A strong synergism for cell killing is found to be associated with large increases in gene conversion (of up to 8-fold), and mutation (of up to 14-fold). Analysis of the interaction data for both wild-type and repair-deficient strains indicates that the heat-UV synergism arises via the inhibition of two different repair pathways. Unambiguous conclusions regarding the molecular mechanisms by which these repair processes are inhibited cannot be drawn on the basis of dose-response data alone. However, this approach does enable one to make well defined, empirical comparisons of the nature and kinetics of such interactions.

Analysis of interactions between mutagens, II. Ethyl methanesulfonate and ultraviolet light in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

The results of this study indicate the existence of a strong interaction between ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) and ultraviolet light (UV) for cell killing in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Conversely, mutation and gene conversion frequencies observed for the combined treatment of EMS and UV do not deviate significantly from that expected on the basis of simple additivity. Studies involving repair-deficient mutants (rad mutants) reveal that the synergistic interaction for cell killing depends on RAD52 function (recombinational repair), but not on RAD3 function (excision repair). On the basis of this analysis, the interaction between EMS and UV in S. cerevisiae might arise from the inhibition of double-strand break repair by one, or both agents.

Induction of pure and sectored mutant clones in excision-proficient and deficient strains of yeast.

We have found that UV-induced mutation frequency in a forward non-selective assay system (scoring white adex ade2 double auxotroph mutants among the red pigmented ade2 clones) increases linearly with dose up to a maximum frequency of about 3 X 10(-3) mutants per survivor and then declines in both RAD wild-type and rad2 excision deficient strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Mutation frequencies of the RAD and the rad2 strains plotted against survival are nearly identical over the entire survival range. On this basis we conclude that unexcised pyrimidine dimers are the predominant type of pre-mutational lesions in both strains. In the RAD wild-type strain pure mutant clones outnumber sectors in a 10:1 ratio at all doses used; in rad2 this ratio varies from 1:1 at low doses up to 10:1 at high doses. As others have concluded for wild-type strains we find also in the rad2 strain that pure clone formation cannot be accounted for quantitatively by lethal sectoring events alone. We conclude that heteroduplex repair is a crucial step in pure mutant clone formation and we examine the plausibility of certain macromolecular mechanisms according to which heteroduplex repair may be coupled with replication, repair and sister strand exchange in yeast mutagenesis.

Quantitative measures of mutagenicity and mutability based on mutant yield data.

We described how mutant yield data (mutants per cell treated) can be used both to compare the mutagenicity of different mutagens, and to characterize the mutability of different cell types. Yield curves reveal the net effect of the lethal and genetic actions of mutagens on cells. Normally, yields are the quantities measured in assays for mutagenesis, and rectilinear plots of such data baldly reveal the amount of experimental error and the extent of actual mutant induction above the background level. Plots of yield versus lethal hits can be used to quantify the relative mutagenic efficiency (RME) of agents whose physical exposure doses otherwise would be incommensurable, as well as the relative mutability (Rmt) of different strains to the same mutagen. Plots of yield versus log dose provide an unambiguous way of assessing the relative mutational sensitivities (Rms) and mutational resolutions (Rmr) of different strains against a given mutagen. Such analysis is important for evaluation of the relative merits of excision-proficient and excision-deficient strains of the same organism as mutagen-testing systems. The mathematical approach outlined here is applied, by way of example, to measurements of UV and 4-NQO induced mutagenesis in both repair-deficient and repair-proficient haploid strains of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Analysis of non-linearities in mutation frequency curves.

Mutation frequency curves for ultraviolet light and other mutagens often exhibit non-linear, as well as linear components. A common pattern observed for UV-induced reversion of auxotrophy in yeast is a biphasic, linear-quadratic (or higher order) response. The non-linear component in such a biphasic frequency curve can arise in two distinct, but non-mutually exclusive, ways: (i) as a result of the existence of two-hit processes in the molecular mechanism(s) of mutagenesis; and (ii) as a result of the possible stochastic dependence of mutation and killing, such that the probability of clone formation by the mutant cells differs from that of the non-mutant cells in the population. We describe here a simple mathematical method for distinguishing between these two sources of non-linearity. It is based on the calculation of a quantity that we call 'apparent survival.' This is given, for any mutagen dose chi, by the ratio of the mutant yield to the corresponding linear component of mutation frequency. If the apparent survival rises to values greater than unity before declining at high doses, then there must exist positive two-hit (or higher order) components in the mutational mechanism. If the final slope of the apparent survival curve differs from that of the measured survival curve, then there also exists some degree of stochastic dependence between mutation and killing.

Analysis of non-linearities in frequency curves for UV-induced mitotic recombination in wild-type and excision-repair-deficient strains of yeast.

Frequency curves for UV-induced mitotic recombination often are linear at low doses. As dose increases, these curves either increase at higher powers of dose and/or reach a maximum induced frequency and then decline. Similar dose-response patterns have been observed previously for mutation. The non-linearities can arise from higher order effects inherent in the molecular mechanisms of mutagenesis and/or from 'delta-effects' (Eckardt and Haynes, 1977a), i.e., differential probabilities of clone formation for mutant and non-mutant cells. Previously, we have shown that one can distinguish between these two possibilities by plotting the ratio of the induced mutant yield to the linear component of frequency as a function of dose (Haynes et al., 1985). In this study, we have used this ratio, a quantity we call 'apparent survival', to analyse the non-linear regions of the dose-response curves for UV-induced mitotic crossing-over and gene conversion in wild-type (RAD) and excision-repair-deficient (rad3) strains of yeast. Plots of apparent survival versus dose reveal the existence of a positive, non-linear component associated with UV-induced gene conversion in RAD, but not rad3, cells. A high dose decline in frequency, which is observed for UV-induced recombination in both strains, can be attributed to delta-effects.

Repair of UV-induced DNA damage and survival in yeast. I. Dimer excision.

The amount of pyrimidine dimer UV photoproduct lost from the DNA of irradiated yeast cells during dark incubation has been measured in various conditions. It was found that no dimers were lost when cells were incubated in saline. When the cells were incubated, with aeration, in a full growth medium, dimers were lost, most excision being complete within 4 h. Not all dimers were lost and the number lost was a function of UV dose. Maximum loss, amounting to 50 000 dimers per genome was observed after 4000 or 6000 erg/mm2 of UV. At higher doses, the number excised declined. Making the assumptions that dimers are the principal lethal product of UV, that a single dimer remaining in its genome is enough to prevent a cell from multiplying and that excision is the principal dark-repair process in yeast, these data were incorporated into the repair term of an expression relating survival to repair8 and it was found that the survival of yeast at doses up to 2000 erg/mm2 of UV could be quite accurately predicted. This is the first time it has been possible to account for survival in terms of measured repair. It is suggested that the divergence of the predicted and observed curves at higher doses is due to other processes known to exist in yeast.

Mathematical parameters for quantification of mutational responses in bacteria.

This paper introduces a new parameter, derivable from dose-response data for induced mutagenesis in bacteria, that can be used to quantify mutational responses in short-term tests. We called this parameter the mutational response of the bipartite experimental system (agent plus cells). We defined it as being jointly proportional to the efficiency of the mutagen and the sensitivity of the test. We show how this quantity can be used to rank order chemical carcinogens on the basis of their mutagenicity and to determine the strength of any quantitative correlation that may exist between mutagenicity in bacteria and carcinogenicity in rodents. We find that this particular measure of mutational response for 10 direct-acting monofunctional alkylating agents correlates remarkably well with the rodent carcinogenicity of these chemicals measured in terms of their reciprocal TD50 values.

Yeast mutants sensitive to trimethoprim.

Wild-type strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae are resistant to growth inhibition by the folate antagonist trimethoprim. A mutant strain sensitive to trimethoprim was isolated. It was found to be sensitive to both ultraviolet light and X-irradiation. Genetic tests revealed that it was allelic with a known radiation-sensitive strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, rad 6-I. Strains harbouring a variety of mutant alleles conferring radiation-sensitivity were tested for sensitivity to trimethoprim. It was found that rad 6-I and each of the four known alleles of rad 18 conferred sensitivity to the drug, but all other rad mutants tested were trimethoprim-resistant. All trimethoprim-sensitive strains, including double mutants of rad 6 rad 18, gave rise to trimethoprim-resistant outgrowths at a rather high frequency (similar to 10-minus 5). Several resistant outgrowths were analysed. A wide variation in phenotype with respect of UV-sensitivty was found. Genetical analysis revealed that resistance to trimethoprim resulted from forward mutations at separate loci rather than back mutations of rad 6 or rad 18 alleles.