Influence of suspended solids on acute toxicity of carbofuran to Daphnia magna: I. Interactive effects.

This study explored the effects on Daphnia magna from exposure to the pesticide carbofuran in combination with stress from suspended solids exposure. Our objective was to assess whether suspended solids affects the toxicodynamic response of D. magna to carbofuran. A series of laboratory experiments was performed where animals were exposed to carbofuran concentrations ranging from 0 to 160 microg/l in combination with suspended solids concentrations ranging from 0 to 10000 mg/l. In the absence of suspended solids, effects of carbofuran were dose dependent and resulted in an EC(50) of 92 microg/l. Exposure to suspended solids, up to extreme levels that may be encountered in the environment and in the absence of carbofuran, showed no measurable toxicity. When D. magna were exposed to a constant carbofuran concentration, the numbers of affected organisms increased with increasing suspended solids concentrations. At a suspended solids concentration of 1000 mg/l, the EC(50) for carbofuran was reduced by half to 45 microg/l. The relationship between the toxicity of carbofuran (microg/l) and the concentration of suspended solids (mg/l) can be described with the following equation: carbofuran EC(50)=72 exp(-0.00014 [suspended solids]). An analysis of the data indicates that this relationship is consistent with a potentiated toxicity mechanism rather than an additive model.

Influence of suspended solids on acute toxicity of carbofuran to Daphnia magna: II. An evaluation of potential interactive mechanisms.

It has been demonstrated that simultaneous exposure of Daphnia magna to suspended solids and a carbamate pesticide potentiates the toxic response to the pesticide. The toxicodynamics between these stressors were investigated to determine possible mechanisms of interaction. Three experimental series were conducted with D. magna to determine: the effect of food availability on carbofuran toxicity; the effect of food availability on jointly administered carbofuran and suspended solids; and changes in the magnitude of effects which can occur with suspended solids of different composition. These experiments demonstrated that both carbofuran toxicity and the joint toxicity of carbofuran and suspended solids to D. magna can be modulated by food availability. While it is clear that food dilution could contribute to energy stress, it appears likely that additional interactive processes also contribute to the observed synergism between carbofuran and suspended solids. Additionally, decomposed peat was shown to be less of a stressor to these pelagic invertebrates than inorganic subsoil.