Magnetic resonance imaging predicts outcomes of conservative treatment in patients with lateral epicondylitis.

BACKGROUND: The clinical validity of positive magnetic resonance imaging findings in lateral epicondylitis is controversial. We hypothesized that magnetic resonance imaging could predict the outcome of conservative treatment. This study determined the relationship between magnetic resonance imaging-defined disease severity and treatment outcomes in patients with lateral epicondylitis. METHODS: This retrospective single-cohort study included 43 conservatively managed and 50 surgically treated patients with lateral epicondylitis. The magnetic resonance imaging scores and clinical outcomes were examined six months post-treatment, and the former was compared between patients with good and poor treatment outcomes. We developed operating characteristic curves of magnetic resonance imaging scores for treatment outcomes, and divided patients into magnetic resonance imaging-mild and severe groups according to the obtained cut-off value of the scores. We compared the outcomes of conservative treatment with that of surgery for each magnetic resonance imaging severity. RESULTS: Twenty-nine (67.4%) conservatively treated patients had good outcomes, while 14 (32.6%) had poor outcomes. The magnetic resonance imaging score was higher in patients with poor outcomes; the cut-off value was 6. Forty-three (86.0%) surgically treated patients had good outcomes, while 7 (14.0%) had poor outcomes. There was no significant difference in magnetic resonance imaging scores between patients with good and poor surgical outcomes. In the magnetic resonance imaging-mild group (score ≤ 5), the outcome showed no significant difference between the conservative and surgical treatment groups. In the magnetic resonance imaging-severe group (score≥6), the outcome of conservative treatment was significantly worse than that of surgical treatment. CONCLUSIONS: The magnetic resonance imaging score was associated with conservative treatment outcomes. A treatment strategy that includes surgery should be considered for patients with severe magnetic resonance imaging findings; this is not recommended for those with mild magnetic resonance imaging findings. Magnetic resonance imaging is helpful in determining the best treatment strategies for patients with lateral epicondylitis. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III, Retrospective cohort study.

Pathophysiology of sex difference in refractoriness in lateral epicondylitis: Biomechanical study of wrist torque.

Eccentric contractions of the wrist extensors worsen lateral epicondylitis (LE), whose pathophysiology may involve sex differences in wrist torque. This study aimed to investigate sex differences in wrist torque in patients with LE. The wrist extension and flexion torques of 22 patients with LE (11 males and 11 females) were measured. Maximum muscle output over time was measured for 20 s, initial torque was defined as muscle strength, and the degree of eccentric contraction was quantified and defined as the eccentric contraction index (ECI). The affected/unaffected side ratio of the wrist extensor, extensor/flexor ratio of muscle strength, and affected/unaffected side difference of ECI between sexes were statistically analyzed. Furthermore, correlations between wrist extensor torque, ECI, and Visual Analog Scale of pain during the examination were evaluated. Females were found to display lower affected/unaffected side ratios of the wrist extensor and wrist extension/flexion ratios for the affected side, compared with males; however, no differences were found in the wrist extension/flexion ratios for the unaffected side in both sexes. Additionally, females presented with larger differences between the affected and unaffected sides in the ECI. Based on correlations between wrist torques, ECI, and pain, females tended to suppress muscle output to prevent pain from eccentric contraction of wrist extensors more than males, which would induce an imbalance in muscle strength of the wrist extensors and flexors. This imbalance may result in chronic eccentric contraction of the wrist extensors with gripping, exacerbating LE.

Sex differences in wrist torque and endurance-Biomechanical factors associated with developing lateral epicondylitis of the humerus.

Since eccentric contractions contribute to the development of tendinopathy, sex differences in wrist torque and endurance may be involved in the pathophysiology of lateral epicondylitis and its refractoriness. Therefore, the present study investigated sex differences in wrist torque and endurance. The wrist extension and flexion torques of the 100 wrists of 25 males and 25 females were measured. The following parameters were assessed: muscle strength at the starting- and end point for the measurement, Δ muscle strength, that is, the amount of a loss over time, and the muscle endurance ratio, that is, the decrease rate over time. Each parameter in males and females was statistically analyzed. In wrist extension, muscle strength at the starting point was 6.1 Nm for males and 3.3 Nm for females (p < 0.001); Δ Muscle strength was -0.052 Nm/s for males and -0.038 Nm/s for females (p = 0.036); The muscle endurance ratio was 99.1%/s for males and 98.8%/s for females (p = 0.015). In wrist flexion, muscle strength at the starting point and absolute value of Δ muscle strength were significantly larger in males than in females; No significant difference was observed in the muscle endurance ratio in wrist flexion between males and females. These results revealed sex differences in wrist torque and endurance. The muscle endurance ratio of the wrist extensors was lower in females than in males, which suggests that females need to exert more effort to maintain the wrist extension position under resistance. This may predispose the wrist extensor muscles in females to eccentric contractions.

Individual Evaluation of the Common Extensor Tendon and Lateral Collateral Ligament Improves the Severity Diagnostic Accuracy of Magnetic Resonance Imaging for Lateral Epicondylitis.

The effectiveness of magnetic resonance imaging for diagnosing lateral epicondylitis severity is controversial. We aimed to verify whether individual evaluations of the common extensor tendon and lateral collateral ligament would improve the severity diagnostic accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging for lateral epicondylitis. We obtained coronal images of the lateral elbow in three groups: healthy, clinically mild, and clinically severe. We used our scoring system for evaluation using combined and individual methods. We developed the receiver operating characteristic curve for diagnosis using the scores of the healthy and mild groups and that for severity diagnosis using the scores of the mild and severe groups. The scores, in decreasing value, were those of the severe, mild, and healthy groups, with a significant difference in both methods. The curve for diagnosis showed an area under the curve of 0.85 for the combined evaluation and 0.89 for the individual evaluation, without a significant difference between the methods (p = 0.23). The curve for severity diagnosis showed an area under the curve of 0.69 for combined and 0.81 for individual evaluation, with a significant difference between the methods (p = 0.046). Individual evaluation of the common extensor tendon and lateral collateral ligament improved the severity diagnostic accuracy of lateral epicondylitis.