RESUMO
Decision-making in fetal cardiology is fraught with ethical issues yet education in bioethics for trainees is limited or nonexistent. In this innovation report, we describe the development of a fetal cardiology bioethics curriculum designed to address this gap. The curriculum was developed to supplement the core curriculum for cardiology fellows and fetal cardiology subspecialty trainees. The series combines didactic and interactive teaching modalities and contains 5 key components: (1) introduction to bioethics and its role in fetal cardiology, (2) counseling and pathways for compassionate terminal care, (3) case vignette-based ethical analysis and discussion cases, (4) fetal counseling considerations for shared decision-making and recommendations, (5) facilitated communications role play. The curriculum was refined using session evaluations from end users. This report describes the innovative curriculum as a starting point for further incorporation and study of bioethical education in pediatric cardiology and fetal training programs.
Assuntos
Bioética , Cardiologia , Internato e Residência , Criança , Feminino , Gravidez , Humanos , Currículo , Bioética/educação , Cardiologia/educação , Cuidado Pré-NatalRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Using extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) in paediatric and neonatal intensive care units (PICU/NICU) creates ethical challenges and carries a high risk for moral distress, burn out and team conflicts. AIM: The study aimed to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the underlying factors affecting moral distress when using ECMO for infants and children by examining the attitudes of ECMO nurses. METHODS: Four focus groups discussions were conducted with 21 critical care nurses working in a Swiss University Children's Hospital. Purposive sampling was adopted to identify research participants. The data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. RESULTS: Unlike "miracle machine" stories in online media reports, specialized nurses working in PICU/NICU expressed both their hopes and fears towards this technology. Their accounts also contained references to events and factors that triggered experiences of moral distress: the unspeakable nature of the death of a child or infant; the seemingly lack of honest and transparent communication with parents; the apparent loss of situational awareness among doctors; the perceived lack of recognition for the role of nurses and the variability in end-of-life decision-making; the length of time it takes doctors to take important treatment decisions; and the resource intensity of an ECMO treatment. CONCLUSION: The creation of a multidisciplinary moral community with transparent information among all involved health care professionals and the definition of clear treatment goals as well as the implementation of paediatric palliative care for all paediatric ECMO patients should become a priority if we want to alleviate situations of moral distress. RELEVANCE FOR CLINICAL PRACTICE: The creation of a multidisciplinary moral community, clear treatment goals and the implementation of palliative care for all paediatric ECMO patients are crucial to alleviate situations of moral distress for nurses, and thus to improve provider well-being and the quality of patient care in PICU/NICU.
Assuntos
Atitude do Pessoal de Saúde , Enfermagem de Cuidados Críticos , Oxigenação por Membrana Extracorpórea , Grupos Focais , Unidades de Terapia Intensiva Pediátrica , Humanos , Feminino , Masculino , Suíça , Unidades de Terapia Intensiva Neonatal , Recém-Nascido , Pesquisa Qualitativa , Adulto , Lactente , Criança , Tomada de DecisõesRESUMO
Globally exacerbated surgical waitlists have provided the opportunity to reflect on prioritization and resource allocation decisions. The unique circumstances of paediatric surgery and consequences of surgical delay prompted the study reported in this paper. As part of a larger project to attend to prioritization in our surgical waitlists, we conducted a Quality Improvement study, the purpose of which is to understand surgeon's perspectives regarding the ethical and practical realities of surgical prioritization at our institution. The study comprises semi-structured interviews with nine full-time paediatric surgeons from a variety of subspecialties conducted at our institution, which is a tertiary paediatric hospital with ten surgical subspecialties in a publicly funded healthcare system. Participants articulated how they prioritize their waitlists, and how they understand ethical prioritization. These findings resonate with the growing public concern for ethical practice in healthcare delivery and transparency in prioritization and resource allocation practices. Specifically, more transparency, consistency, and support is required in prioritization practices. This work highlights the importance of institutional dialogue regarding surgical case prioritization. Because quality improvement work is necessarily site-specific, concrete generalizations cannot be offered. However, the insights gleaned from these interviews and the process by which they were gleaned are a valuable knowledge-sharing resource for any institution that is interested in ongoing quality improvement work. The objectives here were to clarify the goals of prioritization within the institution, improve prioritization practices, and make them more ethical and transparent.
RESUMO
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Therapies for paediatric congenital and acquired heart disease continue to evolve and the appropriateness of pursuing life sustaining interventions at margins of standard therapy is ethically challenging. RECENT FINDINGS: With ongoing emphasis on shared decision making, recent literature explored physician and parental perspectives on communication with families and offering interventions for complex congenital heart disease and advanced heart failure. The inclusion of parental values and views in this process is now widely accepted. Identified outstanding challenges include difficulty with prognostication from the outset, adjusting long-term goals of care to changes in clinical parameters, need for consistency in communication including regular review meetings with family or surrogate decision-makers. Bioethics consultation and multidisciplinary team reviews may be helpful supports. Palliative care involvement in this population improves quality of life and alleviates parental distress but this collaboration is not optimized. SUMMARY: Decision to offer, forgo, or discontinue life-sustaining therapies for children with heart disease has nuanced and context-specific considerations, and must integrate burdens of interventions with patient and family values. Thus, decision making remains complex and demands thoughtful review of not only risks and benefits, but views and values, clearly communicated to team and family.
Assuntos
Insuficiência Cardíaca , Qualidade de Vida , Criança , Comunicação , Tomada de Decisões , Humanos , Cuidados PaliativosRESUMO
Are all children extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) candidates? Navigating ECMO decisions represents an enormous challenge in pediatric critical care. ECMO cannulation should not be a default option as it will not confer benefit for "all" critically ill children; however, "all" children deserve well-considered decisions surrounding their ECMO candidacy. The complexity of the decision demands a systematic, "well-reasoned" and "dynamic" approach. Due to clinical urgency, this standard cannot always be met prior to initiation of ECMO. We challenge the paradigm of "candidacy" as a singular decision that must be defined prior to ECMO initiation. Rather, the determination as to whether ECMO is in the patient's best interest is applicable regardless of cannulation status. The priority should be on collaborative, interdisciplinary decision-making processes aligned with principles of transparency, relevant reasoning, accountability, review, and appeal. To ensure a robust process, it should not be temporally constrained by cannulation status. We advocate that this approach will decrease both the risk of not initiating ECMO in a patient who will benefit and the risk of prolonged, nonbeneficial support. We conclude that to ensure fair decisions are made in a patient's best interest, organizations should develop procedurally fair processes for ECMO decision-making that are not tied to a particular time point and are revisited along the management trajectory.
Assuntos
Oxigenação por Membrana Extracorpórea , Cateterismo , Criança , Cuidados Críticos , Dissidências e Disputas , Humanos , Responsabilidade SocialRESUMO
OBJECTIVES: To identify unique latent safety threats spanning routine pediatric critical care activities and categorize them according to their underlying work system factors (i.e., "environment, organization, person, task, tools/technology") and associated clinician behavior (i.e., "legal": expected compliance with or "illegal-normal": deviation from and "illegal-illegal": disregard for standard policies and protocols). DESIGN: A prospective observational study with contextual inquiry of clinical activities over a 5-month period. SETTING: Two PICUs (i.e., medical-surgical ICU and cardiac ICU) in an urban free-standing quaternary children's hospital. SUBJECTS: Attending physicians and trainees, nurse practitioners, registered nurses, respiratory therapists, dieticians, pharmacists, and patient services assistants were observed. INTERVENTIONS: None. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Conducted 188 hours of observations to prospectively identify unique latent safety threats. Qualitative observational notes were analyzed by human factors experts using a modified framework analysis methodology to summarize latent safety threats and categorize them based on associated clinical activity, predominant work system factor, and clinician behavior. Two hundred twenty-six unique latent safety threats were observed. The latent safety threats were categorized into 13 clinical activities and attributed to work system factors as follows: "organization" (n = 83; 37%), "task" (n = 52; 23%), "tools/technology" (n = 40; 18%), "person" (n = 32; 14%), and "environment" (n = 19; 8%). Twenty-three percent of latent safety threats were identified when staff complied with policies and protocols (i.e., "legal" behavior) and 77% when staff deviated from policies and protocols (i.e., "illegal-normal" behavior). There was no "illegal-illegal" behavior observed. CONCLUSIONS: Latent safety threats span various pediatric critical care activities and are attributable to many underlying work system factors. Latent safety threats are present both when staff comply with and deviate from policies and protocols, suggesting that simply reinforcing compliance with existing policies and protocols, the common default intervention imposed by healthcare organizations, will be insufficient to mitigate safety threats. Rather, interventions must be designed to address the underlying work system threats. This human factors informed framework analysis of observational data is a useful approach to identifying and understanding latent safety threats and can be used in other clinical work systems.
Assuntos
Pessoal de Saúde , Unidades de Terapia Intensiva Pediátrica , Criança , Cuidados Críticos , Humanos , Estudos ProspectivosRESUMO
As part of the invited supplement on Death and Dying in the PICU, we reviewed ethical, cultural, and social considerations for the bedside healthcare practitioner prior to engaging with children and families in decisions about limiting therapies, withholding, or withdrawing therapies in a PICU. Clarifying beliefs and values is a necessary prerequisite to approaching these conversations. Striving for medical consensus is important. Discussion, reflection, and ethical analysis may determine a range of views that may reasonably be respected if professional disagreements persist. Parental decisional support is recommended and should incorporate their information needs, perceptions of medical uncertainty, child's condition, and their role as a parent. Child's involvement in decision making should be considered, but may not be possible. Culturally attuned care requires early examination of cultural perspectives before misunderstandings or disagreements occur. Societal influences may affect expectations and exploration of such may help frame discussions. Hospital readiness for support of social media campaigns is recommended. Consensus with family on goals of care is ideal as it addresses all parties' moral stance and diminishes the risk for superseding one group's value judgments over another. Engaging additional supportive services early can aid with understanding or resolving disagreement. There is wide variation globally in ethical permissibility, cultural, and societal influences that impact the clinician, child, and parents. Thoughtful consideration to these issues when approaching decisions about limitation or withdrawal of life-sustaining therapies will help to reduce emotional, spiritual, and ethical burdens, minimize misunderstanding for all involved, and maximize high-quality care delivery.
Assuntos
Tomada de Decisões , Pais/psicologia , Assistência Terminal/normas , Suspensão de Tratamento/ética , Criança , Estado Terminal/psicologia , Estado Terminal/terapia , Assistência à Saúde Culturalmente Competente , Feminino , Humanos , Unidades de Terapia Intensiva Pediátrica/normas , Masculino , Participação do Paciente/psicologia , Mídias SociaisRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: We aimed to determine the prevalence and risk factors for electrographic seizures in neonates and children requiring extracorporeal membrane oxygenation support. DESIGN: Prospective quality improvement project. SETTING: Quaternary care pediatric institution. PATIENTS: Consistent with American Clinical Neurophysiology Society electroencephalographic monitoring recommendations, neonates and children requiring extracorporeal membrane oxygenation support underwent clinically indicated electroencephalographic monitoring. INTERVENTIONS: We performed a 2-year quality improvement study from July 2013 to June 2015 evaluating electrographic seizure prevalence and risk factors. MAIN RESULTS: Ninety-nine of 112 patients (88%) requiring extracorporeal membrane oxygenation support underwent electroencephalographic monitoring. Electrographic seizures occurred in 18 patients (18%), of whom 11 patients (61%) had electrographic status epilepticus and 15 patients (83%) had exclusively electrographic-only seizures. Electrographic seizures were more common in patients with low cardiac output syndrome (p = 0.03). Patients with electrographic seizures were more likely to die prior to discharge (72% vs 30%; p = 0.01) and have unfavorable outcomes (54% vs 17%; p = 0.004) than those without electrographic seizures. CONCLUSIONS: Electrographic seizures occurred in 18% of neonates and children requiring extracorporeal membrane oxygenation support, often constituted electrographic status epilepticus, and were often electrographic-only thereby requiring electroencephalographic monitoring for identification. Low cardiac output syndrome was associated with an increased risk for electrographic seizures. Electrographic seizures were associated with higher mortality and unfavorable outcomes. Further investigation is needed to determine whether electrographic seizures identification and management improves outcomes.
Assuntos
Cuidados Críticos , Eletroencefalografia , Oxigenação por Membrana Extracorpórea/efeitos adversos , Convulsões/diagnóstico , Convulsões/etiologia , Adolescente , Criança , Pré-Escolar , Cuidados Críticos/métodos , Feminino , Humanos , Lactente , Recém-Nascido , Unidades de Terapia Intensiva Pediátrica , Masculino , Prevalência , Estudos Prospectivos , Melhoria de Qualidade , Fatores de Risco , Convulsões/epidemiologia , Estado Epiléptico/diagnóstico , Estado Epiléptico/epidemiologia , Estado Epiléptico/etiologiaRESUMO
OBJECTIVES: Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation is often used in children with single-ventricle anomalies. We aimed to describe extracorporeal membrane oxygenation use in single-ventricle patients to test the hypothesis that despite increasing prevalence, mortality has not improved and overall burden measure by hospital charges and length of stay have increased. DESIGN: Retrospective analysis of the Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project Kids' Inpatient Database was performed with sample weighting to generate national estimates. PATIENTS: Pediatric patients (age ≤ 20) with a diagnosis of single ventricle heart disease requiring extracorporeal membrane oxygenation support from 2000 to 2009. INTERVENTIONS: None. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Seven hundred one children (95% CI, 559-943) with single ventricle were supported with extracorporeal membrane oxygenation in the reporting period. Mortality was 57% and did not improve over time (2000 = 52%, 2003 = 63%, 2006 = 57%, and 2009 = 55%; p = 0.66). Single-ventricle patients who required extracorporeal membrane oxygenation were more likely to have had a cardiac procedure (90% vs 46%; p < 0.001), a diagnosis of arrhythmia (22% vs 13%; p < 0.001), cerebrovascular or neurologic insult (9% vs 1%; p < 0.001), heart failure (24% vs 12%; p < 0.001), acute renal failure (28% vs 3%; p < 0.001), or sepsis (28% vs 8%; p < 0.001). By multivariable analysis, acute renal failure was a risk factor for mortality (adjusted odds ratio, 3.12; 95% CI, 1.95-4.98; p < 0.001). The length of stay for single-ventricle patients with extracorporeal membrane oxygenation increased from 25.2 days in 2000 to 55.6 days in 2009 (p < 0.001). Total inflation-adjusted charges increased from $358,021 (95% CI, $278,658-439,765) in 2000 to $732,349 (95% CI, $671,781-792,917) in 2009 (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation support is uncommon with single-ventricle admissions occurring in 2.3% of all hospitalizations. Among those patients, the mortality rate was 57% with no change over time. Acute renal failure was an independent risk factor for mortality during hospitalization. In addition, length of stay for these patients increased and hospital charges doubled. Further studies are needed to determine suitability and cost-effectiveness of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation in single-ventricle patients.
Assuntos
Oxigenação por Membrana Extracorpórea/mortalidade , Cardiopatias Congênitas/terapia , Preços Hospitalares/tendências , Tempo de Internação/tendências , Adolescente , Criança , Pré-Escolar , Oxigenação por Membrana Extracorpórea/economia , Feminino , Ventrículos do Coração/anormalidades , Mortalidade Hospitalar , Humanos , Lactente , Recém-Nascido , Tempo de Internação/economia , Masculino , Estudos Retrospectivos , Fatores de Risco , Resultado do Tratamento , Estados Unidos/epidemiologiaRESUMO
Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) is a life support technology provided to children to support respiratory failure, cardiac failure, or cardiopulmonary resuscitation after failure of conventional management. Over the decades, ECMO has expanded in use, advanced in technology, shifted from experimental to a standard of care, and evidence supporting its use has increased. The expanded ECMO indications and medical complexity of children have also necessitated focused studies in the ethical domain such as decisional authority, resource allocation, and equitable access.
Assuntos
Reanimação Cardiopulmonar , Oxigenação por Membrana Extracorpórea , Insuficiência Cardíaca , Insuficiência Respiratória , Criança , HumanosRESUMO
AIM: This summary from the American Heart Association provides guidance for the provision of primary and subspecialty palliative care in pediatric congenital and acquired heart disease. METHODS: A comprehensive literature search was conducted from January 2010 to December 2021. Seminal articles published before January 2010 were also included in the review. Human subject studies and systematic reviews published in English in PubMed, ClinicalTrials.gov, and the Cochrane Collaboration were included. Structure: Although survival for pediatric congenital and acquired heart disease has tremendously improved in recent decades, morbidity and mortality risks remain for a subset of young people with heart disease, necessitating a role for palliative care. This scientific statement provides an evidence-based approach to the provision of primary and specialty palliative care for children with heart disease. Primary and specialty palliative care specific to pediatric heart disease is defined, and triggers for palliative care are outlined. Palliative care training in pediatric cardiology; diversity, equity, and inclusion considerations; and future research directions are discussed.