Pervasive Regulatory Functions of mRNA Structure Revealed by High-Resolution SHAPE Probing.

mRNAs can fold into complex structures that regulate gene expression. Resolving such structures de novo has remained challenging and has limited our understanding of the prevalence and functions of mRNA structure. We use SHAPE-MaP experiments in living E. coli cells to derive quantitative, nucleotide-resolution structure models for 194 endogenous transcripts encompassing approximately 400 genes. Individual mRNAs have exceptionally diverse architectures, and most contain well-defined structures. Active translation destabilizes mRNA structure in cells. Nevertheless, mRNA structure remains similar between in-cell and cell-free environments, indicating broad potential for structure-mediated gene regulation. We find that the translation efficiency of endogenous genes is regulated by unfolding kinetics of structures overlapping the ribosome binding site. We discover conserved structured elements in 35% of UTRs, several of which we validate as novel protein binding motifs. RNA structure regulates every gene studied here in a meaningful way, implying that most functional structures remain to be discovered.

Discovery of a large-scale, cell-state-responsive allosteric switch in the 7SK RNA using DANCE-MaP.

7SK is a conserved noncoding RNA that regulates transcription by sequestering the transcription factor P-TEFb. 7SK function entails complex changes in RNA structure, but characterizing RNA dynamics in cells remains an unsolved challenge. We developed a single-molecule chemical probing strategy, DANCE-MaP (deconvolution and annotation of ribonucleic conformational ensembles), that defines per-nucleotide reactivity, direct base pairing interactions, tertiary interactions, and thermodynamic populations for each state in RNA structural ensembles from a single experiment. DANCE-MaP reveals that 7SK RNA encodes a large-scale structural switch that couples dissolution of the P-TEFb binding site to structural remodeling at distal release factor binding sites. The 7SK structural equilibrium shifts in response to cell growth and stress and can be targeted to modulate expression of P-TEFbresponsive genes. Our study reveals that RNA structural dynamics underlie 7SK function as an integrator of diverse cellular signals to control transcription and establishes the power of DANCE-MaP to define RNA dynamics in cells.

Hierarchy of RNA functional dynamics.

RNA dynamics play a fundamental role in many cellular functions. However, there is no general framework to describe these complex processes, which typically consist of many structural maneuvers that occur over timescales ranging from picoseconds to seconds. Here, we classify RNA dynamics into distinct modes representing transitions between basins on a hierarchical free-energy landscape. These transitions include large-scale secondary-structural transitions at >0.1-s timescales, base-pair/tertiary dynamics at microsecond-to-millisecond timescales, stacking dynamics at timescales ranging from nanoseconds to microseconds, and other "jittering" motions at timescales ranging from picoseconds to nanoseconds. We review various modes within these three different tiers, the different mechanisms by which they are used to regulate function, and how they can be coupled together to achieve greater functional complexity.

Mutation signature filtering enables high-fidelity RNA structure probing at all four nucleobases with DMS.

Chemical probing experiments have transformed RNA structure analysis, enabling high-throughput measurement of base-pairing in living cells. Dimethyl sulfate (DMS) is one of the most widely used structure probing reagents and has played a pivotal role in enabling next-generation single-molecule probing analyses. However, DMS has traditionally only been able to probe adenine and cytosine nucleobases. We previously showed that, using appropriate conditions, DMS can also be used to interrogate base-pairing of uracil and guanines in vitro at reduced accuracy. However, DMS remained unable to informatively probe guanines in cells. Here, we develop an improved DMS mutational profiling (MaP) strategy that leverages the unique mutational signature of N1-methylguanine DMS modifications to enable high-fidelity structure probing at all four nucleotides, including in cells. Using information theory, we show that four-base DMS reactivities convey greater structural information than current two-base DMS and SHAPE probing strategies. Four-base DMS experiments further enable improved direct base-pair detection by single-molecule PAIR analysis, and ultimately support RNA structure modeling at superior accuracy. Four-base DMS probing experiments are straightforward to perform and will broadly facilitate improved RNA structural analysis in living cells.

Single-Molecule Correlated Chemical Probing: A Revolution in RNA Structure Analysis.

RNA molecules convey biological information both in their linear sequence and in their base-paired secondary and tertiary structures. Chemical probing experiments, which involve treating an RNA with a reagent that modifies conformationally dynamic nucleotides, have broadly enabled examination of short- and long-range RNA structure in diverse contexts, including in living cells. For decades, chemical probing experiments have been interpreted in a per-nucleotide way, such that the reactivity measured at each nucleotide reports the average structure at a position over all RNA molecules within a sample. However, there are numerous important cases where per-nucleotide chemical probing falls short, including for RNAs that are bound by proteins, RNAs that form complex higher order structures, and RNAs that sample multiple conformations.Recent experimental and computational innovations have started a revolution in RNA structure analysis by transforming chemical probing into a massively parallel, single-molecule experiment. Enabled by a specialized reverse transcription strategy called mutational profiling (MaP), multiple chemical modification events can be measured within individual RNA molecules. Nucleotides that communicate structurally through direct base pairing or large-scale folding-unfolding transitions will react with chemical probes in a correlated manner, thereby revealing structural complexity hidden to conventional approaches. These single-molecule correlated chemical probing (smCCP) experiments can be interpreted to directly identify nucleotides that base pair (the PAIR-MaP strategy) and to reveal long-range, through-space structural communication (RING-MaP). Correlated probing can also define the thermodynamic populations of complex RNA ensembles (DANCE-MaP). Complex RNA-protein networks can be interrogated by cross-linking proteins to RNA and measuring correlations between cross-linked positions (RNP-MaP).smCCP thus visualizes RNA secondary and higher-order structure with unprecedented accuracy, defining novel structures, RNA-protein interaction networks, time-resolved dynamics, and allosteric structural switches. These strategies are not mutually exclusive; in favorable cases, multiple levels of RNA structure ─ base pairing, through-space structural communication, and equilibrium ensembles ─ can be resolved concurrently. The physical experimentation required for smCCP is profoundly simple, and experiments are readily performed in cells on RNAs of any size, including large noncoding RNAs and mRNAs. Single-molecule correlated chemical probing is paving the way for a new generation of biophysical studies on RNA in living systems.

Global 5'-UTR RNA structure regulates translation of a SERPINA1 mRNA.

SERPINA1 mRNAs encode the protease inhibitor α-1-antitrypsin and are regulated through post-transcriptional mechanisms. α-1-antitrypsin deficiency leads to chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and liver cirrhosis, and specific variants in the 5'-untranslated region (5'-UTR) are associated with COPD. The NM_000295.4 transcript is well expressed and translated in lung and blood and features an extended 5'-UTR that does not contain a competing upstream open reading frame (uORF). We show that the 5'-UTR of NM_000295.4 folds into a well-defined multi-helix structural domain. We systematically destabilized mRNA structure across the NM_000295.4 5'-UTR, and measured changes in (SHAPE quantified) RNA structure and cap-dependent translation relative to a native-sequence reporter. Surprisingly, despite destabilizing local RNA structure, most mutations either had no effect on or decreased translation. Most structure-destabilizing mutations retained native, global 5'-UTR structure. However, those mutations that disrupted the helix that anchors the 5'-UTR domain yielded three groups of non-native structures. Two of these non-native structure groups refolded to create a stable helix near the translation initiation site that decreases translation. Thus, in contrast to the conventional model that RNA structure in 5'-UTRs primarily inhibits translation, complex folding of the NM_000295.4 5'-UTR creates a translation-optimized message by promoting accessibility at the translation initiation site.

Natural Selection Shapes Codon Usage in the Human Genome.

Synonymous codon usage has been identified as a determinant of translational efficiency and mRNA stability in model organisms and human cell lines. However, whether natural selection shapes human codon content to optimize translation efficiency is unclear. Furthermore, aside from those that affect splicing, synonymous mutations are typically ignored as potential contributors to disease. Using genetic sequencing data from nearly 200,000 individuals, we uncover clear evidence that natural selection optimizes codon content in the human genome. In deriving intolerance metrics to quantify gene-level constraint on synonymous variation, we discover that dosage-sensitive genes, DNA-damage-response genes, and cell-cycle-regulated genes are particularly intolerant to synonymous variation. Notably, we illustrate that reductions in codon optimality in BRCA1 can attenuate its function. Our results reveal that synonymous mutations most likely play an underappreciated role in human variation.

RNA base-pairing complexity in living cells visualized by correlated chemical probing.

RNA structure and dynamics are critical to biological function. However, strategies for determining RNA structure in vivo are limited, with established chemical probing and newer duplex detection methods each having deficiencies. Here we convert the common reagent dimethyl sulfate into a useful probe of all 4 RNA nucleotides. Building on this advance, we introduce PAIR-MaP, which uses single-molecule correlated chemical probing to directly detect base-pairing interactions in cells. PAIR-MaP has superior resolution compared to alternative experiments, can resolve multiple sets of pairing interactions for structurally dynamic RNAs, and enables highly accurate structure modeling, including of RNAs containing multiple pseudoknots and extensively bound by proteins. Application of PAIR-MaP to human RNase MRP and 2 bacterial messenger RNA 5' untranslated regions reveals functionally important and complex structures undetected by prior analyses. PAIR-MaP is a powerful, experimentally concise, and broadly applicable strategy for directly visualizing RNA base pairs and dynamics in cells.

Direct Duplex Detection: An Emerging Tool in the RNA Structure Analysis Toolbox.

While a variety of powerful tools exists for analyzing RNA structure, identifying long-range and intermolecular base-pairing interactions has remained challenging. Recently, three groups introduced a high-throughput strategy that uses psoralen-mediated crosslinking to directly identify RNA-RNA duplexes in cells. Initial application of these methods highlights the preponderance of long-range structures within and between RNA molecules and their widespread structural dynamics.

An RNA structure-mediated, posttranscriptional model of human α-1-antitrypsin expression.

Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) affects over 65 million individuals worldwide, where α-1-antitrypsin deficiency is a major genetic cause of the disease. The α-1-antitrypsin gene, SERPINA1, expresses an exceptional number of mRNA isoforms generated entirely by alternative splicing in the 5'-untranslated region (5'-UTR). Although all SERPINA1 mRNAs encode exactly the same protein, expression levels of the individual mRNAs vary substantially in different human tissues. We hypothesize that these transcripts behave unequally due to a posttranscriptional regulatory program governed by their distinct 5'-UTRs and that this regulation ultimately determines α-1-antitrypsin expression. Using whole-transcript selective 2'-hydroxyl acylation by primer extension (SHAPE) chemical probing, we show that splicing yields distinct local 5'-UTR secondary structures in SERPINA1 transcripts. Splicing in the 5'-UTR also changes the inclusion of long upstream ORFs (uORFs). We demonstrate that disrupting the uORFs results in markedly increased translation efficiencies in luciferase reporter assays. These uORF-dependent changes suggest that α-1-antitrypsin protein expression levels are controlled at the posttranscriptional level. A leaky-scanning model of translation based on Kozak translation initiation sequences alone does not adequately explain our quantitative expression data. However, when we incorporate the experimentally derived RNA structure data, the model accurately predicts translation efficiencies in reporter assays and improves α-1-antitrypsin expression prediction in primary human tissues. Our results reveal that RNA structure governs a complex posttranscriptional regulatory program of α-1-antitrypsin expression. Crucially, these findings describe a mechanism by which genetic alterations in noncoding gene regions may result in α-1-antitrypsin deficiency.

Direct identification of base-paired RNA nucleotides by correlated chemical probing.

Many RNA molecules fold into complex secondary and tertiary structures that play critical roles in biological function. Among the best-established methods for examining RNA structure are chemical probing experiments, which can report on local nucleotide structure in a concise and extensible manner. While probing data are highly useful for inferring overall RNA secondary structure, these data do not directly measure through-space base-pairing interactions. We recently introduced an approach for single-molecule correlated chemical probing with dimethyl sulfate (DMS) that measures RNA interaction groups by mutational profiling (RING-MaP). RING-MaP experiments reveal diverse through-space interactions corresponding to both secondary and tertiary structure. Here we develop a framework for using RING-MaP data to directly and robustly identify canonical base pairs in RNA. When applied to three representative RNAs, this framework identified 20%-50% of accepted base pairs with a <10% false discovery rate, allowing detection of 88% of duplexes containing four or more base pairs, including pseudoknotted pairs. We further show that base pairs determined from RING-MaP analysis significantly improve secondary structure modeling. RING-MaP-based correlated chemical probing represents a direct, experimentally concise, and accurate approach for detection of individual base pairs and helices and should greatly facilitate structure modeling for complex RNAs.

Tuning RNA folding and function through rational design of junction topology.

Structured RNAs such as ribozymes must fold into specific 3D structures to carry out their biological functions. While it is well-known that architectural features such as flexible junctions between helices help guide RNA tertiary folding, the mechanisms through which junctions influence folding remain poorly understood. We combine computational modeling with single molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) and catalytic activity measurements to investigate the influence of junction design on the folding and function of the hairpin ribozyme. Coarse-grained simulations of a wide range of junction topologies indicate that differences in sterics and connectivity, independent of stacking, significantly affect tertiary folding and appear to largely explain previously observed variations in hairpin ribozyme stability. We further use our simulations to identify stabilizing modifications of non-optimal junction topologies, and experimentally validate that a three-way junction variant of the hairpin ribozyme can be stabilized by specific insertion of a short single-stranded linker. Combined, our multi-disciplinary study further reinforces that junction sterics and connectivity are important determinants of RNA folding, and demonstrates the potential of coarse-grained simulations as a tool for rationally tuning and optimizing RNA folding and function.

Functional complexity and regulation through RNA dynamics.

Changes to the conformation of coding and non-coding RNAs form the basis of elements of genetic regulation and provide an important source of complexity, which drives many of the fundamental processes of life. Although the structure of RNA is highly flexible, the underlying dynamics of RNA are robust and are limited to transitions between the few conformations that preserve favourable base-pairing and stacking interactions. The mechanisms by which cellular processes harness the intrinsic dynamic behaviour of RNA and use it within functionally productive pathways are complex. The versatile functions and ease by which it is integrated into a wide variety of genetic circuits and biochemical pathways suggests there is a general and fundamental role for RNA dynamics in cellular processes.

Secondary structure encodes a cooperative tertiary folding funnel in the Azoarcus ribozyme.

A requirement for specific RNA folding is that the free-energy landscape discriminate against non-native folds. While tertiary interactions are critical for stabilizing the native fold, they are relatively non-specific, suggesting additional mechanisms contribute to tertiary folding specificity. In this study, we use coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations to explore how secondary structure shapes the tertiary free-energy landscape of the Azoarcus ribozyme. We show that steric and connectivity constraints posed by secondary structure strongly limit the accessible conformational space of the ribozyme, and that these so-called topological constraints in turn pose strong free-energy penalties on forming different tertiary contacts. Notably, native A-minor and base-triple interactions form with low conformational free energy, while non-native tetraloop/tetraloop-receptor interactions are penalized by high conformational free energies. Topological constraints also give rise to strong cooperativity between distal tertiary interactions, quantitatively matching prior experimental measurements. The specificity of the folding landscape is further enhanced as tertiary contacts place additional constraints on the conformational space, progressively funneling the molecule to the native state. These results indicate that secondary structure assists the ribozyme in navigating the otherwise rugged tertiary folding landscape, and further emphasize topological constraints as a key force in RNA folding.

Efficient in silico exploration of RNA interhelical conformations using Euler angles and WExplore.

HIV-1 TAR RNA is a two-helix bulge motif that plays a critical role in HIV viral replication and is an important drug target. However, efforts at designing TAR inhibitors have been challenged by its high degree of structural flexibility, which includes slow large-amplitude reorientations of its helices with respect to one another. Here, we use the recently introduced algorithm WExplore in combination with Euler angles to achieve unprecedented sampling of the TAR conformational ensemble. Our ensemble achieves similar agreement with experimental NMR data when compared with previous TAR computational studies, and is generated at a fraction of the computational cost. It clearly emerges from configuration space network analysis that the intermittent formation of the A22-U40 base pair acts as a reversible switch that enables sampling of interhelical conformations that would otherwise be topologically disallowed. We find that most previously determined ligand-bound structures are found in similar location in the network, and we use a sample-and-select approach to guide the construction of a set of novel conformations which can serve as the basis for future drug development efforts. Collectively, our findings demonstrate the utility of WExplore in combination with suitable order parameters as a method for exploring RNA conformational space.

Topological constraints are major determinants of tRNA tertiary structure and dynamics and provide basis for tertiary folding cooperativity.

Recent studies have shown that basic steric and connectivity constraints encoded at the secondary structure level are key determinants of 3D structure and dynamics in simple two-way RNA junctions. However, the role of these topological constraints in higher order RNA junctions remains poorly understood. Here, we use a specialized coarse-grained molecular dynamics model to directly probe the thermodynamic contributions of topological constraints in defining the 3D architecture and dynamics of transfer RNA (tRNA). Topological constraints alone restrict tRNA's allowed conformational space by over an order of magnitude and strongly discriminate against formation of non-native tertiary contacts, providing a sequence independent source of folding specificity. Topological constraints also give rise to long-range correlations between the relative orientation of tRNA's helices, which in turn provides a mechanism for encoding thermodynamic cooperativity between distinct tertiary interactions. These aspects of topological constraints make it such that only several tertiary interactions are needed to confine tRNA to its native global structure and specify functionally important 3D dynamics. We further show that topological constraints are conserved across tRNA's different naturally occurring secondary structures. Taken together, our results emphasize the central role of secondary-structure-encoded topological constraints in defining RNA 3D structure, dynamics and folding.

Noncanonical secondary structure stabilizes mitochondrial tRNA(Ser(UCN)) by reducing the entropic cost of tertiary folding.

Mammalian mitochondrial tRNA(Ser(UCN)) (mt-tRNA(Ser)) and pyrrolysine tRNA (tRNA(Pyl)) fold to near-canonical three-dimensional structures despite having noncanonical secondary structures with shortened interhelical loops that disrupt the conserved tRNA tertiary interaction network. How these noncanonical tRNAs compensate for their loss of tertiary interactions remains unclear. Furthermore, in human mt-tRNA(Ser), lengthening the variable loop by the 7472insC mutation reduces mt-tRNA(Ser) concentration in vivo through poorly understood mechanisms and is strongly associated with diseases such as deafness and epilepsy. Using simulations of the TOPRNA coarse-grained model, we show that increased topological constraints encoded by the unique secondary structure of wild-type mt-tRNA(Ser) decrease the entropic cost of folding by ∼2.5 kcal/mol compared to canonical tRNA, offsetting its loss of tertiary interactions. Further simulations show that the pathogenic 7472insC mutation disrupts topological constraints and hence destabilizes the mutant mt-tRNA(Ser) by ∼0.6 kcal/mol relative to wild-type. UV melting experiments confirm that insertion mutations lower mt-tRNA(Ser) melting temperature by 6-9 °C and increase the folding free energy by 0.8-1.7 kcal/mol in a largely sequence- and salt-independent manner, in quantitative agreement with our simulation predictions. Our results show that topological constraints provide a quantitative framework for describing key aspects of RNA folding behavior and also provide the first evidence of a pathogenic mutation that is due to disruption of topological constraints.

Single transcriptional and translational preQ1 riboswitches adopt similar pre-folded ensembles that follow distinct folding pathways into the same ligand-bound structure.

Riboswitches are structural elements in the 5' untranslated regions of many bacterial messenger RNAs that regulate gene expression in response to changing metabolite concentrations by inhibition of either transcription or translation initiation. The preQ1 (7-aminomethyl-7-deazaguanine) riboswitch family comprises some of the smallest metabolite sensing RNAs found in nature. Once ligand-bound, the transcriptional Bacillus subtilis and translational Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis preQ1 riboswitch aptamers are structurally similar RNA pseudoknots; yet, prior structural studies have characterized their ligand-free conformations as largely unfolded and folded, respectively. In contrast, through single molecule observation, we now show that, at near-physiological Mg(2+) concentration and pH, both ligand-free aptamers adopt similar pre-folded state ensembles that differ in their ligand-mediated folding. Structure-based Go-model simulations of the two aptamers suggest that the ligand binds late (Bacillus subtilis) and early (Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis) relative to pseudoknot folding, leading to the proposal that the principal distinction between the two riboswitches lies in their relative tendencies to fold via mechanisms of conformational selection and induced fit, respectively. These mechanistic insights are put to the test by rationally designing a single nucleotide swap distal from the ligand binding pocket that we find to predictably control the aptamers' pre-folded states and their ligand binding affinities.