Life conditions and quality of life of Palestinians living in the Biddu Enclave: a qualitative study.

BACKGROUND: Palestinians have been exposed to long-term violence, displacement, and conflict since the 1940s. Continued expropriation and fragmentation of the region has affected people's quality of life. The Biddu Enclave communities, located northwest of Jerusalem, are behind a barrier wall that detaches them from Jerusalem and the rest of the West Bank other than by access through a tunnel controlled by the Israeli authorities. The enclave is fully or partially under Israeli administration. We explored the effects of socioeconomic and geographical transformations and isolation on the quality of life of these communities, specifically on daily uncertainty, stress, and overall wellbeing of residents. METHODS: We included four communities-Beit Iksa, Qatanna, Biddu, and Beit A'nan-that have varied characteristics and circumstances. Between early October, 2018, and the end of November, 2019, we did in-depth interviews with 20 key informants, such as mayors, village council members, municipality employees, and teachers, and 16 residents older than 20 years and from a range backgrounds, including activists, retirees, and housewives. We also did two focus groups involving young adults from all four communities. Questions were asked about living conditions and consequences of the socioeconomic and geographic transformations in the study area. We analysed the data by repeated readings to identify patterns and themes. FINDINGS: We found poor overall quality of life, characterised by chronic daily uncertainty, insecurity and heightened vulnerability, leading to stress and reduced wellbeing. The main negative determinants of quality of life were poor infrastructure, dependence on work in the Israeli labour market, a precarious permit system, increasing land expropriation and expansion of Israeli settlements, separation from Jerusalem, and marginalisation by the Palestinian National Authority. Community characteristics, such as social solidarity and active community organisations were important in mediating some of these effects. Other variations in the characteristics of the communities, such as topography, having relatives living in the USA, levels of education, unemployment rate, and proximity to Israeli settlements seemed to play a role in the abilities of residents to endure conditions. INTERPRETATION: Our findings highlight the importance of political and socioeconomic transformations in the wellbeing of residents in the Biddu Enclave. Sustained insecurity and uncertainty, marginalisation, and isolation of the communities have negative effects on quality of life. More research focusing on these communities is needed to better understand the mechanisms by which these factors affect health and how they may lead to ill health and disease in the long term. FUNDING: Arab Council for Social Sciences.

Prevalence of negative child disciplinary practices and its associated factors as reported by mothers in the West Bank: a cross-sectional study.

BACKGROUND: For parents, how to manage child discipline is a difficult question in the task of raising a socially, emotionally, and physically mature adult. Negative discipline can be physical or psychological, and can negatively affect child development, mental health, and wellbeing. This study aimed to assess the prevalence of negative disciplinary methods (NDMs) and their associated factors in the West Bank, occupied Palestinian territory, as reported by mothers. METHODS: The survey was conducted in November and December, 2014, to explore the disciplinary methods that mothers used for one of their children (aged 0-12 years) during the previous 12 months. 1195 Palestinian mothers were studied based on a stratified multistage cluster sampling method and using the International Society for Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect (ISPCAN) Child Abuse and Screening Tool for Parents (ICAST-P). A scale was built from mothers' reports on the use of NDMs, with good internal consistency (Cronbach's α=0·75). The dataset was split according to whether the mother used 0-6 NDMs or 7-20 NDMs in the previous 12 months. Bivariate analyses were performed using the chi squared test to compare these two categories in terms of demographic and socioeconomic variables, and exposure to Israeli political violence. Binary logistic regression was performed to check for confounders. The Institute of Community and Public Health and Birzeit University approved the use of the data. FINDINGS: The mothers were aged between 15 and 55 years. 11·3% of mothers (135 of 1195) were 15-25 years old, 45·4% (541) were 26-35 years old, and 43·2% (515) were 36-55 years old. 52·5% of children (627 of 1195) were male, 34·0% (406) were 0-3 years old, and 66·0% (789) were 4-12 years old. 5·2% of children (62) were the only child, 4·4% of children (53) were the first child, 27·6% (330) were the middle child (a child that is not the first or the last child), and 62·8% (750) were the last child. 45·8% of the mothers and children (547) lived in the north of the West Bank, 23·3% (278) lived in the middle of the West Bank, and 31·0% (370) lived in the south of the West Bank. 5·3% of mothers (63) reported that their homes were bombed or shelled by the Israeli army. 83·8% of mothers (1002) reported using 0-6 NDMs and 16·2% (193) used 7-20 methods. Other demographic and socioeconomic variables collected were not significantly associated with NDMs. Binary logistic regression revealed that females were less likely to be exposed to NDMs than males (OR 0·63, 95% CI 0·45-0·88, p=0·0074), and that children aged 0-3 years were less likely to be exposed to NDMs than children aged 4-12 years (0·50, 0·33-0·76, p=0·0014). Compared with last children, first children (2·84, 1·46-5·51, p=0·0020) and middle children (1·49, 1·02-2·17, p=0·0375) were more likely to be exposed to NDMs. Compared with mothers aged 36-55 years, mothers aged 15-25 years (2·67, 1·47-4·85, p=0·0010) and 26-35 years (1·54, 1·05-2·26, p=0·0289) used more NDMs. Compared with children in the north of the West Bank, children in the south of the West Bank (2·46, 1·66-3·64, p<0·0001) and middle of the West Bank (1·90, 1·24-2·93, p=0·0034) were more likely to be exposed to NDMs. Compared with mothers whose houses were not bombed or shelled by the Israeli army, mothers whose houses were bombed or shelled were more likely to use a higher number of NDMs (2·71, 1·84-1·95, p=0·0012). INTERPRETATION: Negative child discipline is prevalent in Palestine and is associated with factors such as the child's gender, their age, their index in the family (whether they are the only child, first, middle, or last child), the mother's age, the district, and the political conditions in Palestine. Effort should be made to help families to understand alternative methods to address child discipline, through education, discussion, and parenting programmes. FUNDING: This study is part of a larger study of child discipline in Qatar and the occupied Palestinian territory. The study was conceptualised and planned with the funding of Qatar National Research.

Comparing disciplinary methods used by mothers in Palestine and Qatar.

This paper explores child disciplinary methods used by parents in Qatar and Palestine. In this study ICAST-P, an internationally recognized tool, was used with mothers reporting on one of their children up to their 12th birthday. It questions about disciplinary methods: nonviolent; physical: moderate and severe; and psychological methods that had been used in the previous year on the index child in the family. A comparative national cross-sectional household survey of mothers aged 25-50 years old was conducted in both Qatar and Palestine, both Arabic Muslim states, but with very different socio-economic and political contexts that place Qataris in a much more advantageous position. Our results show that the 1299 Palestinian mothers interviewed were younger, had more children and less education compared to the 1018 Qatari mothers. Fewer mothers from Palestine were working. The index child in Palestine tended to be younger with 60% being under 5 years, while 73.7% of Qatari children were over 5 years of age. Severe physical disciplinary methods were reported significantly more often, in Palestine, e.g. Kicking the child (P value < 0.001), using hand or pillow to prevent breathing (P value < 0.001) and hitting child with object or fist (P value < 0001). Moderate as well as psychological disciplinary methods were also significantly higher among Palestinian mothers (P value < 0.001). Our results suggest that challenging circumstances that Palestinian mothers experience, as compared to their Qatari peers, are associated with greater prevalence of the harsher forms of discipline. Our findings have policy implications and preventative strategies for child maltreatment in both countries.

Women's health in the occupied Palestinian territories: Contextual influences on subjective and objective health measures.

The links between two commonly used measures of health-self-rated health (SRH) and self-reported illness (SRI)-and socio-economic and contextual factors are poorly understood in Low and Middle Income Countries (LMICs) and more specifically among women in conflict areas. This study assesses the socioeconomic determinants of three self-reported measures of health among women in the occupied Palestinian territories; self-reported self-rated health (SRH) and two self-reported illness indicators (acute and chronic diseases). Data were obtained from the 2010 Palestinian Family Health Survey (PFHS), providing a sample of 14,819 women aged 15-54. Data were used to construct three binary dependent variable-SRH (poor or otherwise), and reporting two SRI indicators-general illness and chronic illness (yes or otherwise). Multilevel logistic regression models for each dependent variable were estimated, with individual level socioeconomic and sociodemographic predictors and random intercepts at the governorate and community level included, to explore the determinants of inequalities in health. Consistent socioeconomic inequalities in women's reports of both SRH and SRI are found. Better educated, wealthier women are significantly less likely to report an SRI and poor SRH. However, intra-oPt regional disparities are not consistent across SRH and SRI. Women from the Gaza Strip are less likely to report poor SRH compared to women from all other regions in the West Bank. Geographic and residential factors, together with socioeconomic status, are key to understanding differences between women's reports of SRI and SRH in the oPt. More evidence is needed on the health of women in the oPt beyond the ages currently included in surveys. The results for SRH show discrepancies which can often occur in conflict affected settings where a combination of ill-health and poor access to health services impact on women's health. These results indicate that future policies should be developed in a holistic manner by targeting physical and mental health and well-being in programmes addressing the health needs of women, especially those in conflict affected zones.

Child discipline in Qatar and Palestine: A comparative study of ICAST-R.

To compare the nature and determinants of child discipline in Qatar and Palestine among young adults through retrospective survey to develop legislation, policies and interventions for effective prevention of child maltreatment, and educational materials to promote positive discipline among parents and caregivers. Cross-sectional random household surveys were conducted in each country (Qataris N=697, Palestinians N=2064) using ISPCAN Child Abuse Screening Tool-Retrospective (ICAST-R) for young adults (18-24 years), to investigate child discipline methods into the maltreatment range. Qatari young adults were more educated (p<0.001) and had more full-time employment (p=0.004) than Palestinian young adults. Qatar reported lower physical and emotional abuse compared to their counterparts in Palestine, e.g. Hit/Punch, Kick (p<0.001) and Insult/Criticize, Threaten to be hurt/killed (p<0.001). Qatari participants found any harsh discipline they received in childhood was not reasonable and not justified compared to Palestinian participants. The more advantaged Qatari population was less likely to experience disciplinary methods that experts developing the ICAST-R defined as abuse compared to Palestinians where the higher incidence of child abuse could be attributed to lower economic advantage, lower level of education and greater exposure to violence. Suggestions are made for future studies in Qatar and Palestine to develop survey methodology with a more culturally appropriate level of intrusion, such as indirect yet meaningful child maltreatment questions.