Severe hydralazine-induced lupus presenting as systemic lupus erythematosus.

Despite its long history of untoward side effects of a systemic autoimmune disease, drug-induced lupus can be difficult to recognize because of the disconnect between chronic drug usage and onset of symptoms. In this case, the patient was treated with hydralazine for two years when symptoms were initially reported, but a diagnosis of hydralazine-induced lupus was not considered for another half year. Despite treatment with steroidal and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications during this period, rheumatologic symptoms and signs continued to deteriorate, consistent with the diagnosis of systemic lupus erythematosus. Not until the patient voluntarily discontinued hydralazine did symptoms begin to improve, fully resolving over the subsequent 6-12 months largely in the absence of anti-inflammatory medication. This patient demonstrates that failure to recognize a drug-induced disease etiology can result in substantial worsening of rheumatologic symptoms over the subsequent six months, ultimately satisfying criteria for systemic lupus erythematosus. While symptoms and signs largely normalized, some laboratory abnormalities and occasional arthralgia remained two years after discontinuing hydralazine, suggesting smoldering inflammatory disease.

Disruption of positive selection of thymocytes causes autoimmunity.

To differentiate into T cells, immature thymocytes must engage, through their antigen-specific T-cell receptor, peptides derived from self proteins presented by cortical epithelial cells in the thymus, a process called positive selection. Despite this requirement for self-recognition during development, mature T cells do not normally show autoreactivity. Mice injected in the thymus with procainamide-hydroxylamine, a metabolite of procainamide, develop autoimmune features resembling drug-induced lupus. Here, we show that when thymocytes undergo positive selection in the presence of procainamide-hydroxylamine, they fail to establish unresponsiveness to low affinity selecting self antigens, resulting in systemic autoimmunity.

Multiple autoantigen binding capabilities of mouse monoclonal antibodies selected for rheumatoid factor activity.

We report that approximately 1/4 of monoclonal rheumatoid factors produced by hybridomas derived from fusions of spleen cells from MRL/lpr/lpr mice with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and arthritis exhibited multiple reactivities with other autoantigens, including dDNA , histones, and/or cytoskeletal-cytoplasmic elements. The patterns of reactivities of most of these clones differed, indicating that each had a separate B cell ancestor. Studies with eluted antibodies demonstrated that a single species of antibody molecules was responsible for the observed multiple reactivities. Inhibition experiments suggested that an antibody combining site may be large enough to accommodate dissimilar epitopes. These findings may provide further insights into the generation and extent of antibody diversity as well as the etiopathogenesis of systemic autoimmune diseases.

Transformation of lupus-inducing drugs to cytotoxic products by activated neutrophils.

Drug-induced lupus is a serious side effect of certain medications, but the chemical features that confer this property and the underlying pathogenesis are puzzling. Prototypes of all six therapeutic classes of lupus-inducing drugs were highly cytotoxic only in the presence of activated neutrophils. Removal of extracellular hydrogen peroxide before, but not after, exposure of the drug to activated neutrophils prevented cytotoxicity. Neutrophil-dependent cytotoxicity required the enzymatic action of myeloperoxidase, resulting in the chemical transformation of the drug to a reactive product. The capacity of drugs to serve as myeloperoxidase substrates in vitro was associated with the ability to induce lupus in vivo.

Drug-induced anti-histone autoantibodies display two patterns of reactivity with substructures of chromatin.

Increasing evidence suggests that autoantibodies in the rheumatic diseases are a consequence of immune selection by self-material, but the nature of the in vivo immunogen is unknown. Insight into this problem may be obtained by measuring autoantibody binding to various forms of a target antigen. Antihistone antibodies arising as a side effect of therapy with various drugs offer an opportunity to explore this premise because many forms of histone have been characterized and adapted to ELISA formats. Two patterns of antibody reactivity were observed. All 21 patients with symptomatic procainamide-induced lupus and 7 of 12 patients with quinidine-induced lupus had IgG antibodies reacting predominantly with the (H2A-H2B)-DNA complex and with chromatin. In contrast, antibodies in 19 of 24 patients taking procainamide without accompanying lupus-like symptoms did not show any pattern. The second pattern was observed in 18/19 chlorpromazine-treated patients and 14/17 patients with hydralazine-induced lupus in which IgM antibodies displayed more reactivity with DNA-free histones than with the corresponding histone-DNA complexes and almost no binding to H1-stripped chromatin. Absorption studies were entirely consistent with these results. Thus, the two patterns of reactivity with nucleosomal components reflect the molecular substructure of chromatin, suggesting that two processes underlie antihistone antibody induction by drugs. In one, IgG autoantibodies appear to be elicited by chromatin, whereas in the other, autoimmune tolerance to native chromatin appears largely intact, and IgM antibodies may be driven by DNA-free histone.

Metabolism of procainamide to the cytotoxic hydroxylamine by neutrophils activated in vitro.

An almost universal side effect of long-term therapy with procainamide is the appearance of serum autoantibodies and less frequently a syndrome resembling lupus erythematosus. Previous studies demonstrated that procainamide-hydroxylamine (PAHA), a metabolite generated by hepatic mixed function oxidases, was highly toxic to dividing cells, but evidence that PAHA could be formed in the circulation was lacking. This study examines the capacity of neutrophils to metabolize procainamide to reactive forms. Neutrophils activated with opsonized zymosan were cytotoxic only if procainamide was present, whereas N-acetyl procainamide, which does not induce autoimmunity, was inert in this bioassay. PAHA was detected by HPLC in the extracellular medium if ascorbic acid was present. Generation of PAHA and cytotoxic procainamide metabolites was inhibited by NaN3 and catalase but not by superoxide dismutase, indicating that H2O2 and myeloperoxidase were involved. Nonactivated neutrophils and neutrophils from patients with chronic granulomatous disease did not generate cytotoxic PAHA, demonstrating that H2O2 was derived from the respiratory burst accompanying neutrophil activation. These conclusions were supported by results of a cell-free system in which neutrophils were replaced by myeloperoxidase and H2O2 or an H2O2 generating system. These studies demonstrate the capacity of neutrophils to mediate metabolism of procainamide and establish the role of myeloperoxidase released during degranulation and H2O2 derived from the respiratory burst in the direct cooxidation of procainamide to PAHA. The profound biologic activity of this metabolite and its possible generation within lymphoid compartments implicate this process in the induction of autoimmunity by procainamide.

Autoantibodies associated with lupus induced by diverse drugs target a similar epitope in the (H2A-H2B)-DNA complex.

IgG reactivity with the (H2A-H2B)-DNA complex, a subunit of the nucleosome, has been detected in many patients with lupus induced by procainamide and quinidine, but the similarity among the epitopes targeted by these antibodies in this heterogeneous patient group as well as the prevalence of this specificity in lupus induced by other drugs is unknown. Studies with histone-DNA complexes formed by sequential addition on a solid phase demonstrated that complexes containing single histones had negligible antigenicity, indicating that DNA stabilizes a protein epitope in the H2A-H2B dimer or that the complete epitope is generated by a surface feature involving H2A-H2B and DNA. F(ab')2 isolated from a patient with procainamide-induced lupus blocked greater than 90% of the anti-[(H2A-H2B)-DNA] reactivity in six of six sera from patients with lupus induced by procainamide, four of four quinidine-induced patients and in sera from patients with lupus induced by acebutolol, penicillamine, and isoniazid, but not methyldopa or auto-antibodies to the component macromolecules. Fab fragments purified from the IgG of two quinidine-induced lupus patients and patients with isoniazid- and procainamide-induced lupus retained 39% +/- 8% of their original IgG reactivity compared to 34 +/- 28% of the original anti-tetanus toxoid activity of Fab fragments in two of the same sera and two normal sera. These results indicate that anti-[(H2A-H2B)-DNA] does not require divalent antigen-antibody complexes for stability, and that the complete epitope is created by the monomeric, trimolecular histone-DNA complex. We conclude that despite their pharmacologic and chemical heterogeneity, many lupus-inducing drugs elicit near identical autoantibodies.

Autoimmunity caused by disruption of central T cell tolerance. A murine model of drug-induced lupus.

A side effect of therapy with procainamide and numerous other medications is a lupus-like syndrome characterized by autoantibodies directed against denatured DNA and the (H2A-H2B)-DNA subunit of chromatin. We tested the possibility that an effect of lupus-inducing drugs on central T cell tolerance underlies these phenomena. Two intrathymic injections of procainamide-hydroxylamine (PAHA), a reactive metabolite of procainamide, resulted in prompt production of IgM antidenatured DNA antibodies in C57BL/6xDBA/2 F1 mice. Subsequently, IgG antichromatin antibodies began to appear in the serum 3 wk after the second injection and were sustained for several months. Specificity, inhibition and blocking studies demonstrated that the PAHA-induced antibodies showed remarkable specificity to the (H2A-H2B)-DNA complex. No evidence for polyclonal B cell activation could be detected based on enumeration of Ig-secreting B cells and serum Ig levels, suggesting that a clonally restricted autoimmune response was induced by intrathymic PAHA. The IgG isotype of the antichromatin antibodies indicated involvement of T cell help, and proliferative responses of splenocytes to oligonucleosomes increased up to 100-fold. As little as 5 microM PAHA led to a 10-fold T cell proliferative response to chromatin in short term organ culture of neonatal thymi. We suggest that PAHA interferes with self-tolerance mechanisms accompanying T cell maturation in the thymus, resulting in the emergence of chromatin-reactive T cells followed by humoral autoimmunity.

The central role of chromatin in autoimmune responses to histones and DNA in systemic lupus erythematosus.

To gain insight into the mechanisms of autoantibody induction, sera from 40 patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) were tested by ELISAs for antibody binding to denatured individual histones, native histone-histone complexes, histone-DNA subnucleosome complexes, three forms of chromatin, and DNA. Whole chromatin was the most reactive substrate, with 88% of the patients positive. By chi-square analysis, only the presence of anti-(H2A-H2B), anti-[(H2A-H2B)-DNA], and antichromatin were correlated with kidney disease measured by proteinuria > 0.5 g/d. SLE patients could be divided into two groups based on their antibody-binding pattern to the above substrates. Antibodies from about half of the patients reacted with chromatin and the (H2A-H2B)-DNA subnucleosome complex but displayed very low or no reactivity with native DNA or the (H3-H4)2-DNA subnucleosome complex. An additional third of the patients had antibody reactivity to chromatin, as well as to both subnucleosome structures and DNA. Strikingly, all sera that bound to any of the components of chromatin also bound to whole chromatin, and adsorption with chromatin removed 85-100% of reactivity to (H2A-H2B)-DNA, (H3-H4)2-DNA, and native DNA. Individual sera often bound to several different epitopes on chromatin, with some epitopes requiring quaternary protein-DNA interactions. These results are consistent with chromatin being a potent immunogenic stimulus in SLE. Taken together with previous studies, we suggest that antibody activity to the (H2A-H2B)-DNA component signals the initial breakdown of immune tolerance whereas responses to (H3-H4)2-DNA and native DNA reflect subsequent global loss of tolerance to chromatin.

Genesis and evolution of antichromatin autoantibodies in murine lupus implicates T-dependent immunization with self antigen.

Autoantibodies reacting with chromatin and its components, histones and DNA, are characteristic of the human autoimmune disease SLE and drug-induced lupus, but the mechanisms of their induction remain unknown. Serial serum samples collected over short intervals from lupus-prone MRL/MP-lpr/lpr and BXSB mice were tested by ELISA on chromatin and its substructures to characterize the initial autoimmune response to these antigens. Direct binding studies demonstrated that the early autoantibodies recognized discontinuous epitopes on native chromatin and the (H2A-H2B)-DNA subnucleosome. As the immune response progressed, native DNA and other chromatin constituents generally became antigenic. Based on adsorption studies and IgG subclass restriction, antibodies to native DNA were more related to chromatin than to denatured DNA. The kinetics of autoantibody appearance and the Ig class distribution were similar to the kinetics and distribution seen in antibodies induced by immunization with an exogenous T-dependent antigen. These results are most consistent with the view that autoantibodies reacting with chromatin are generated by autoimmunization with chromatin, and antibodies to native DNA are a subset of the wide spectrum of antichromatin autoantibodies.

Heterogeneity and clinical significance of glomerular-binding antibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus.

We used an ELISA employing extracts of human glomerular basement membrane (GBM) to detect, characterize, and evaluate the clinical significance of glomerular-binding IgG in patients with SLE nephritis. Most patients with SLE nephritis exhibited GBM-binding IgG, although many patients with active nonrenal SLE or symptomatic, drug-induced lupus had similar reactivity, albeit at lower levels. IgG binding to GBM in SLE nephritis patients was decreased by DNase pretreatment of GBM, restored after DNase with nuclear antigens (most notably with nucleosomes), inhibited by exogenous nuclear antigens (particularly nucleosomes), but unaffected by exposure of serum to DNase/high ionic strength. The characteristics of IgG binding to GBM largely paralleled the patients' underlying autoimmune response, which was dominated either by antibodies to DNA/nucleosomes or to nucleosomes alone. Binding of lupus sera to nonrenal extracellular matrix (even with nucleosomes) was not equivalent to GBM. Collagenase pretreatment of GBM variably decreased IgG binding, depending on the level and type of binding. SLE nephritis patients with high levels of GBM-binding IgG exhibited more severe disease clinically, but the same renal histopathology, as patients with lower levels. The level of GBM-binding IgG at presentation did not predict the therapeutic response, but decreased in responders to therapy. In sum, glomerular-binding IgG in lupus nephritis binds to epitopes on chromatin, which adheres to GBM in part via collagen. These autoantibodies appear necessary, but not sufficient, for the development of nephritis, and correlate with clinical rather than histopathologic parameters of disease activity.

Linkage of immune self-tolerance with the positive selection of T cells.

Development and maturation of antigen-specific T cells take place in the thymus in a process dependent on recognition by the T cell antigen receptor (TCR) of endogenous self-peptides presented by several types of specialized stromal cells. Paradoxically, emerging T cells are not self-reactive, and it is commonly believed that deletion of high avidity autoreactive T cells is the principal mechanism for establishing self-tolerance. However, there is increasing evidence that the positive selection of T cells on self-peptides presented by thymic cortical epithelial cells must be linked with a process that prevents their subsequent activation when the same self-peptides are encountered in the periphery. Consequently, a higher activation threshold is established that can be overcome only with ligands of higher affinity, which would normally be foreign peptides. The molecular basis for this increase in activation threshold is unknown, but observations on differential signaling by peptide analogs, on increased TCR expression during T cell maturation and on energy induction in the absence of costimulation provide promising leads. Linkage of self-tolerance with positive selection is a simple and evolutionary sound explanation for self/non-self discrimination and offers a framework for understanding systemic autoimmunity.

A nondeletional mechanism for central T-cell tolerance.

To be positively selected, immature thymocytes must receive signaling through their T-cell receptor (TCR), and engagement of relatively low-affinity self-peptides permits further T-cell maturation. However, mature T cells no longer overtly respond to such low-affinity antigens, indicating that T cells acquire a higher threshold for activation during thymopoiesis. We wondered whether partial interference in positive selection could produce T cells that respond to the selecting self-peptide. This possibility was tested by injecting procainamide-hydroxylamine (PAHA), a lupus-inducing drug, into the thymus of adult normal mice. Three weeks after the second injection, IgG antichromatin antibodies appeared in the circulation and remained for several months. The murine antichromatin antibodies reacted with the (H2A-H2B)-DNA subnucleosome complex, the predominant specificity in patients with procainamide-induced lupus. In thymus organ and reaggregate cultures, PAHA had no effect on negative selection of T cells with high affinity for a co-present antigen, but acted on CD4+ CD8+ immature T cells as they underwent positive selection. TCR transgenic T cells specific to cytochrome c peptide 88-104 acquired the capacity to respond to the low-affinity analogue at position 99 (lys-->ala) if PAHA was present during their development. PAHA also blocked the capacity of a T-cell line to become anergic after anti-CD3 treatment, suggesting that PAHA prevents the production of negative regulators that accumulate in response to partial signaling through the TCR. These results are consistent with the view that T cells acquire self-tolerance during positive selection, and disruption of this process can result in autoreactive T cells and systemic autoimmunity.

Effects of a program for evaluating child psychiatry fellows.

The authors describe their experience with the implementation of a systematic evaluation of child psychiatry fellows and adult psychiatry residents rotating through a child psychiatry program. They found that the semiannual evaluations not only defined the competence of fellows and residents but also enhanced the program by pointing out areas of weakness. The evaluation process had many other beneficial effects on the program, the faculty, the child psychiatry fellows, and the adult psychiatry residents.

Subnucleosome structures as substrates in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays.

Histone preparations preserving the tertiary and quaternary structure of histone-histone complexes and histone-DNA complexes, as well as individual histones, were isolated or reconstituted. Various parameters were tested in order to determine the suitability of these complexes for use as substrates in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays. The protein concentration required to saturate the solid phase was determined, and the amount of bound protein was quantified by the micro-bicinchoninic acid protein assay. In addition, the relative DNA content of solid phase antigen was measured by the binding of monoclonal anti-native DNA antibodies. Prototype sera representing different disease groups produced reproducible and unique patterns of reactivity on the panel of antigens, demonstrating the lack of substantial assay bias. Two substrates, the H2A-H2B dimer and the H2A-H2B-DNA complex, both appear to be oriented in a random manner on the solid phase, leaving a number of different epitopes exposed to the solution. This novel set of histone antigens can now be used to define the specificity of anti-histone antibodies in relation to the quaternary structure of chromatin.

Monoclonal antibody for DNA measurement in biological fluids.

Two highly sensitive immunoassays for measuring soluble DNA are described. These methods employ a purified mouse monoclonal anti-DNA antibody in enzyme-linked immunoassays. One assay is an antigen capture method utilizing immobilized antibody. Bound DNA is subsequently detected with biotinylated monoclonal anti-DNA antibody, avidin-coupled horseradish peroxidase and a chromogenic substrate. The limit of detection of the assay was 2 ng/ml of DNA. A competition assay relying on immobilized heat-denatured DNA was also designed. In this assay the solution to be analyzed is mixed in equal proportions with monoclonal anti-DNA antibody and the mixture is incubated in the DNA-containing microtiter plates. The inhibition of antibody binding as detected with peroxidase-conjugated anti-mouse IgG was proportional to the concentration of DNA in the sample. The competition assay was tested for its ability to detect DNA in human plasma. The detection limit of DNA in plasma was approximately 150 ng/ml. The assays were compared in their ability to detect various size fragments of DNA. The competition assay was capable of detecting DNA fragments as small as 30 base pairs. In contrast, the capture assay failed to detect low molecular weight fragments up to 150 base pairs although its sensitivity for undigested DNA was comparable to the competition assay. The assay may be of use in the rapid quantitation of low levels of DNA, especially low molecular weight DNA and may also be useful in measuring DNA in human plasma.

An improved ELISA for anti-native DNA by elimination of interference by anti-histone antibodies.

We evaluated an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for antibodies to native DNA (nDNA) in which protamine was used to link DNA to polystyrene. Elevated anti-nDNA was largely restricted to patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), and within this group good correlation between ELISA and the ammonium sulfate assay was obtained. However, substantial background immunoglobulin binding to protamine coated wells was commonly observed, and it was necessary to subtract this activity from each anti-DNA determination. Many of the SLE sera also contained anti-histone antibodies, and this antibody activity showed significant correlation with the binding to protamine. In contrast, methylated bovine serum albumin (mBSA) did not bind anti-histone antibodies and provided a substrate for coupling nDNA to polystyrene. This modified ELISA allowed the quantitation of antibodies to native DNA without the simultaneous binding of anti-histone antibodies.

The effect of high antigen density on solid-phase radioimmunoassays for antibody regardless of immunoglobulin class.

Human sera containing antibody to casein or to bovine serum albumin were used to assess the validity and utility of a solid-phase assay for quantitating antibody activity. Rabbit anti-human immunoglobulin radiolabeled with 125I and capable of reacting with all human immunoglobulin classes was used to detect antibody bound to antigen immobilized to polystyrene tubes by a new covalent technique. This method results in very high antigen concentrations in highly stable association with polystyrene tubes. Kinetic and absorption studies demonstrated that low avidity antibodies are better detected when antigen is immobilized by the covalent method than when passively adsorbed. Conditions are described for minimizing artifactual interactions and for obtaining results similar to those obtained with conventional, liquid-phase assays. Failure to reach equilibrium in solid-phase assays and other problems are proposed to explain, in part, the inability to obtain a better correlation between solid- and liquid-phase immunoassays.

Serologic changes during induction of lupus-like disease by procainamide.

Procainamide-induced lupus is a well-recognized syndrome, but the events leading up to clinical symptoms are obscure. In the present study, serologic changes in a 69-year-old man were monitored during his treatment with procainamide and after discontinuation of procainamide because of symptoms of drug-induced lupus. Antihistone antibodies of unique specificity and in vivo complement activation were detected after one year of procainamide therapy during a period prior to development of significant clinical symptoms. Antihistone antibodies and complement activation substantially increased during a full-blown episode of lupus-like symptoms. Progressive return to normal laboratory findings occurred after procainamide was discontinued. The antihistone/complement profile may be useful in the diagnosis of drug-induced lupus and warn of impending clinical deterioration in patients with minimal symptoms.

Initiation of autoimmunity by a reactive metabolite of a lupus-inducing drug in the thymus.

Drug-induced lupus is a side effect of deliberate ingestion of various medications, but its etiology, underlying mechanisms, and pathogenesis are puzzling. In vivo metabolic transformation of lupus-inducing drugs to reactive products explains how a heterogeneous set of drugs can mediate the same disease syndrome. Evidence has accumulated that drugs are transformed by extracellular oxidation from reactive oxygen species and myeloperoxidase produced when neutrophils are activated, maximizing the in situ accumulation of reactive drug metabolites within lymphoid compartments. The metabolite of procainamide, procainamide hydroxylamine, displays diverse biologic properties, but no apparent autoimmune effect has been observed. However, when procainamide hydroxylamine was introduced into the thymus of young adult normal mice, a delayed but robust autoimmune response developed. Disruption of central T-cell tolerance by intrathymic procainamide hydroxylamine resulted in the production of chromatin-reactive T cells that apparently drove the autoantibody response in the periphery. Drug-induced autoantibodies in this mouse model were remarkably similar to those in patients with procainamide-induced lupus. Therefore, this system has considerable promise to provide insight into the initiating events in drug-induced lupus and may provide a paradigm for how other xenobiotics might induce systemic autoimmunity.