Nuclear and Electron Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopies of Atomically Precise Gold Nanoclusters.

Atomically precise gold nanoclusters display properties that are unseen in larger nanoparticles. When the number of gold atoms is sufficiently small, the clusters exhibit molecular properties. Their study requires extensive use of classic molecular physical chemistry and, thus, methods such as vibrational spectroscopies, electrochemistry, density functional theory and molecular dynamics calculations, and of course nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopies. NMR and EPR studies have been mostly carried out on the benchmark, stable molecules Au25(SR)18, Au38(SR)24, Au102(SR)44, and Au144(SR)60 (where SR = thiolate). In this Account, we showcase examples primarily taken from our previous and ongoing NMR and EPR studies, which we hope will trigger further interest in the use of these sensitive, though often underutilized, techniques. Indeed, 1D and 2D NMR spectra of pure, atomically precise clusters can be very detailed and informative. Molecular clusters are molecules and, thus, have discrete energy levels and undergo stepwise oxidation or reduction. The effect of the charge state on the chemical shifts and line shapes is a function of the ligand type (ligands differ due to specific bonds with different Au atom types) and the position of the chemical group along the ligand backbone: for groups near the Au core, they can be very dramatic. Ligand-protected gold clusters are hard-soft molecules where a hard metal core is surrounded by a dynamic molecular layer. The latter provides a nanoenvironment that interfaces the cluster core with the surrounding environment and can be permeated by molecules and ions. NMR spectroscopy is especially useful to assess its structure. For example, the data show that whereas long alkanethiolates form bundles, shorter chains exhibit more conformational freedom and are quite folded. NMR spectroscopy allows studying diastereotopic effects and provides information on possible hydrogen bonds of ligands with sulfur or surface gold atoms. EPR spectroscopy is a very precise technique to check and characterize the magnetic state of gold clusters or clusters doped with foreign-metal atoms. Electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) provides a powerful tool to assess the interaction of an unpaired electron with nuclei, as we showed for 197Au and 1H. It can be used as a sensitive probe of the spin-density distribution in nanoclusters: for example, it showed that the singly occupied molecular orbital may span outside the Au core by nearly 6 Å. Solid-state EPR spectroscopy has provided compelling evidence that the specific ligands and the crystallinity degree are very important factors in determining the interactions between clusters in the solid state. Depending on the condition, paramagnetic, superparamagnetic, ferromagnetic, or antiferromagnetic behavior can be observed. Time-resolved EPR was successfully tested to determine the efficiency of singlet-oxygen generation via sensitization of Au25 clusters. This Account thus demonstrates some of the remarkable insights that can be gained into the properties of atomically precise clusters through detailed NMR and EPR studies.

Photolysis of endoperoxides in the presence of nitroxides: a laser flash photolysis study with optical and ESR detection.

Time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, transient absorption, and phosphorescence spectroscopy were used to investigate the spin polarization of a nitroxide free radical induced by interaction with singlet oxygen ((1)O2). The latter was generated by photolysis of endoperoxides of two anthracene derivatives. Although both anthracene endoperoxides are structurally similar, opposite spin polarization of the nitroxide was observed. Photolysis of one endoperoxide leads to absorptive nitroxide spin polarization due to interaction with the generated (1)O2. Photolysis of the other endoperoxide generated emissive nitroxide spin polarization, probably due to interaction of the endoperoxide triplet states with nitroxides.

Interplay of charge state, lability, and magnetism in the molecule-like Au25(SR)18 cluster.

Au25(SR)18 (R = -CH2-CH2-Ph) is a molecule-like nanocluster displaying distinct electrochemical and optical features. Although it is often taken as an example of a particularly well-understood cluster, very recent literature has provided a quite unclear or even a controversial description of its properties. We prepared monodisperse Au25(SR)18(0) and studied by cyclic voltammetry, under particularly controlled conditions, the kinetics of its reduction or oxidation to a series of charge states, -2, -1, +1, +2, and +3. For each electrode process, we determined the standard heterogeneous electron-transfer (ET) rate constants and the reorganization energies. The latter points to a relatively large inner reorganization. Reduction to form Au25(SR)18(2-) and oxidation to form Au25(SR)18(2+) and Au25(SR)18(3+) are chemically irreversible. The corresponding decay rate constants and lifetimes are incompatible with interpretations of very recent literature reports. The problem of how ET affects the Au25 magnetism was addressed by comparing the continuous-wave electron paramagnetic resonance (cw-EPR) behaviors of radical Au25(SR)18(0) and its oxidation product, Au25(SR)18(+). As opposed to recent experimental and computational results, our study provides compelling evidence that the latter is a diamagnetic species. The DFT-computed optical absorption spectra and density of states of the -1, 0, and +1 charge states nicely reproduced the experimentally estimated dependence of the HOMO-LUMO energy gap on the actual charge carried by the cluster. The conclusions about the magnetism of the 0 and +1 charge states were also reproduced, stressing that the three HOMOs are not virtually degenerate as routinely assumed: In particular, the splitting of the HOMO manifold in the cation species is severe, suggesting that the usefulness of the superatom interpretation is limited. The electrochemical, EPR, and computational results thus provide a self-consistent picture of the properties of Au25(SR)18 as a function of its charge state and may furnish a methodology blueprint for understanding the redox and magnetic behaviors of similar molecule-like gold nanoclusters.

Time-resolved EPR study of singlet oxygen in the gas phase.

X-band EPR spectra of singlet O2((1)Δg) and triplet O2((3)Σg(-)) were observed in the gas phase under low molecular-oxygen pressures PO2 = 0.175-0.625 Torr, T = 293-323 K. O2((1)Δg) was produced by quenching of photogenerated triplet sensitizers naphthalene C8H10, perdeuterated naphthalene, and perfluoronaphthalene in the gas phase. The EPR spectrum of O2((1)Δg) was also observed under microwave discharge. Integrated intensities and line widths of individual components of the EPR spectrum of O2((3)Σg(-)) were used as internal standards for estimating the concentration of O2 species and PO2 in the EPR cavity. Time-resolved (TR) EPR experiments of C8H10 were the main focus of this Article. Pulsed irradiation of C8H10 in the presence of O2((3)Σg(-)) allowed us to determine the kinetics of formation and decay for each of the four components of the O2((1)Δg) EPR signal, which lasted for only a few seconds. We found that the kinetics of EPR-component decay fit nicely to a biexponential kinetics law. The TR EPR 2D spectrum of the third component of the O2((1)Δg) EPR spectrum was examined in experiments using C8H10. This spectrum vividly presents the time evolution of an EPR component. The largest EPR signal and the longest lifetime of O2((1)Δg), τ = 0.4 s, were observed at medium pressure PO2 = 0.4 Torr, T = 293 K. The mechanism of O2((1)Δg) decay in the presence of photosensitizers is discussed. EPR spectra of O2((1)Δg) evidence that the spin-rotational states of O2((1)Δg) are populated according to Boltzmann distribution in the studied time range of 10-100 ms. We believe that this is the first report dealing with the dependence of O2((1)Δg) EPR line width on PO2 and T.

Effect of orientation of the peptide-bridge dipole moment on the properties of fullerene-peptide-radical systems.

We synthesized two series of compounds in which a nitroxide radical and a fullerene C(60) moiety were kept separated by a 3(10)-helical peptide bridge containing two intramolecular C═O···H-N hydrogen bonds. The direction of the resulting molecular dipole moment could be reversed by switching the position of fullerene and nitroxide with respect to the peptide nitrogen and carbon termini. The resulting fullerene-peptide-radical systems were compared to the behaviors of otherwise identical peptides but lacking either C(60) or the free radical moiety. Electrochemical analysis and chemical nitroxide reduction experiments show that the dipole moment of the helix significantly affects the redox properties of both electroactive groups. Besides providing evidence of a folded helical conformation for the peptide bridge, IR and NMR results highlight a strong effect of peptide orientation on the spectral patterns, pointing to a specific interaction of one of the helical orientations with the C(60) moiety. Time-resolved EPR spectra show not only that for both systems triplet quenching by nitroxide induces spin polarization of the radical spin sublevels, but also that the coupling interaction can be either weak or strong depending on the orientation of the peptide dipole. As opposed to the concept of dyads, the molecules investigated are thus better described as fullerene-peptide-radical systems to stress the active role of the bridge as an important ingredient capable of tuning the system's physicochemical properties.

ENDOR evidence of electron-H2 interaction in a fulleride embedding H2.

An endofulleropyrrolidine, with H2 as a guest, has been reduced to a paramagnetic endofulleride radical anion. The magnetic interaction between the electron delocalized on the fullerene cage and the guest H2 has been probed by pulsed ENDOR. The experimental hyperfine couplings between the electron and the H2 guest were measured, and their values agree very well with DFT calculations. This agreement provides clear evidence of magnetic communication between the electron density of the fullerene host cage and H2 guest. The ortho-H2/para-H2 interconversion is revealed by temperature-dependent ENDOR measurements at low temperature. The conversion of the paramagnetic ortho-H2 to the diamagnetic para-H2 causes the ENDOR signal to decrease as the temperature is lowered due to the spin catalysis by the paramagnetic fullerene cage of the radical anion fulleride.

The spin chemistry and magnetic resonance of H2@C60. From the Pauli principle to trapping a long lived nuclear excited spin state inside a buckyball.

One of the early triumphs of quantum mechanics was Heisenberg's prediction, based on the Pauli principle and wave function symmetry arguments, that the simplest molecule, H(2), should exist as two distinct species-allotropes of elemental hydrogen. One allotrope, termed para-H(2) (pH(2)), was predicted to be a lower energy species that could be visualized as rotating like a sphere and possessing antiparallel ( upward arrow downward arrow) nuclear spins; the other allotrope, termed ortho-H(2) (oH(2)), was predicted to be a higher energy state that could be visualized as rotating like a cartwheel and possessing parallel ( upward arrow upward arrow) nuclear spins. This remarkable prediction was confirmed by the early 1930s, and pH(2) and oH(2) were not only separated and characterized but were also found to be stable almost indefinitely in the absence of paramagnetic "spin catalysts", such as molecular oxygen, or traces of paramagnetic impurities, such as metal ions. The two allotropes of elemental hydrogen, pH(2) and oH(2), may be quantitatively incarcerated in C(60) to form endofullerene guest@host complexes, symbolized as pH(2)@C(60) and oH(2)@C(60), respectively. How does the subtle difference in nuclear spin manifest itself when hydrogen allotropes are incarcerated in a buckyball? Can the incarcerated "guests" communicate with the outside world and vice versa? Can a paramagnetic spin catalyst in the outside world cause the interconversion of the allotropes and thereby effect a chemical transformation inside a buckyball? How close are the measurable properties of H(2)@C(60) to those computed for the "quantum particle in a spherical box"? Are there any potential practical applications of this fascinating marriage of the simplest molecule, H(2), with one of the most beautiful of all molecules, C(60)? How can one address such questions theoretically and experimentally? A goal of our studies is to produce an understanding of how the H(2) guest molecules incarcerated in the host C(60) can "communicate" with the chemical world surrounding it. This world includes both the "walls" of the incarcerating host (the carbon atom "bricks" that compose the wall) and the "outside" world beyond the atoms of the host walls, namely, the solvent molecules and selected paramagnetic molecules added to the solvent that will have special spin interactions with the H(2) inside the complex. In this Account, we describe the temperature dependence of the equilibrium of the interconversion of oH(2)@C(60) and pH(2)@C(60) and show how elemental dioxygen, O(2), a ground-state triplet, is an excellent paramagnetic spin catalyst for this interconversion. We then describe an exploration of the spin spectroscopy and spin chemistry of H(2)@C(60). We find that H(2)@C(60) and its isotopic analogs, HD@C(60) and D(2)@C(60), provide a rich and fascinating platform on which to investigate spin spectroscopy and spin chemistry. Finally, we consider the potential extension of spin chemistry to another molecule with spin isomers, H(2)O, and the potential applications of the use of pH(2)@C(60) as a source of latent massive nuclear polarization.

Understanding and controlling the efficiency of Au24M(SR)18 nanoclusters as singlet-oxygen photosensitizers.

Singlet oxygen, 1O2, can be generated by molecules that upon photoexcitation enable the 3O2 → 1O2 transition. We used a series of atomically precise Au24M(SR)18 clusters, with different R groups and doping metal atoms M. Upon nanosecond photoexcitation of the cluster, 1O2 was efficiently generated. Detection was carried out by time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance (TREPR) spectroscopy. The resulting TREPR transient yielded the 1O2 lifetime as a function of the nature of the cluster. We found that: these clusters indeed generate 1O2 by forming a triplet state; a more positive oxidation potential of the molecular cluster corresponds to a longer 1O2 lifetime; proper design of the cluster yields results analogous to those of a well-known reference photosensitizer, although more effectively. Comprehensive kinetic analysis provided important insights into the mechanism and driving-force dependence of the quenching of 1O2 by gold nanoclusters. Understanding on a molecular basis why these molecules may perform so well in 1O2 photosensitization is instrumental to controlling their performance.

Magnetic properties and vapochromic reversible guest-induced transformation in a bispyrazolato copper(II) polymer: an experimental and dispersion-corrected density functional theory study.

Dispersion-corrected density functional theory (DFT-D) calculations, Electron Spin Resonance spectroscopy (EPR), and variable temperature magnetic moment measurements were used to investigate the structure and the electronic/magnetic properties of bispyrazolato-copper(II) coordination polymer and of its hydration product. The Cu(II) ions are antiferromagnetically coupled through the sigma system of the pyrazolate rings in both compounds. Theoretical electron density maps reveal that water molecules interact simultaneously and to a comparable extent with two Cu(II) centers (through the electronegative O end) and two pyrazolate rings (through the partly positively charged H atoms), which is compatible with the observed internuclear distances. DFT-D calculations indicate that low kinetic barriers are involved in the rearrangement of the host structure.

Nitroxide paramagnet-induced para-ortho conversion and nuclear spin relaxation of H2 in organic solvents.

The kinetics of para-ortho conversion and nuclear spin relaxation of H 2 in chloroform- d 1 were investigated in the presence of nitroxides as paramagnetic catalysts. The back conversion from para-hydrogen ( p-H 2) to ortho-hydrogen ( o-H 2) was followed by NMR by recording the increase in the intensity of the signal of o-H 2 at regular intervals of time. The nitroxides proved to be hundreds of times more effective at inducing relaxation among the spin levels of o-H 2 than they are in bringing about transitions between p-H 2 and the levels of o-H 2. The value of the encounter distance d between H 2 and the paramagnetic molecule, calculated from the experimental bimolecular conversion rate constant k 0, using the Wigner theory of para-ortho conversion, agrees perfectly with that calculated from the experimental relaxivity R 1 using the force free diffusion theory of spin-lattice relaxation.

Paramagnet enhanced nuclear relaxation of H2 in organic solvents and in H2@C60.

We have measured the bimolecular contribution (relaxivity) R1 (M(-1) s(-1)) to the spin-lattice relaxation rate for the protons of H2 and H2@C60 dissolved in organic solvents in the presence of paramagnet nitroxide radicals. It is found that the relaxation effect of the paramagnets is enhanced 5-fold in H2@C60 compared to H2 under the same conditions. 13C relaxivity in C60 induced by nitroxide has also been measured. The resulting value of R1 for 13C is substantially smaller relative to the 1H relaxation in H2@C60 than expected solely on the basis of the smaller magnetic moment of 13C. The observed values of R1 have been analyzed quantitatively using an outer-sphere model for bimolecular spin relaxation to extract an encounter distance, d, as the dependent variable. The resulting values of d for H2 and (13)C60 are similar to the sum of the van der Waals radii for the radical and the corresponding molecule. The value of d for (1)H2@C60 is substantially smaller than the corresponding van der Waals estimates, corresponding to larger than expected values of R1. A possible explanation for the enhanced relaxivity is a contribution from hyperfine coupling. Based on the results reported here, it seems that not only is the hydrogen molecule in H2@C60 not insulated from magnetic contact with the outside world but also the interaction with paramagnets is even stronger than expected based on distance alone.

Demonstration of a chemical transformation inside a fullerene. The reversible conversion of the allotropes of H2@C60.

The interconversion of the two allotropes of the hydrogen molecule (para-H2 and ortho-H2) incarcerated inside the fullerene C60 is reported (oH2@C60 and pH2@C60, respectively). For conversion, oH2@C60 was adsorbed at the external surface of the zeolite NaY and immersed into liquid oxygen at 77 K. Equilibrium was reached in less than 0.5 h. Rapid removal of oxygen provides a sample of enriched pH2@C60 that is stable for many days in the absence of paramagnetic catalysts (half-life approximately 15 days). Enriched pH2@C60 is nonvolatile and soluble in organic solvents. At room temperature in the presence of a paramagnetic catalyst (dissolved O2 or the nitroxide Tempo) a slow back conversion into oH2@C60 was observed by 1H NMR. A bimolecular rate constant for conversion of pH2@C60 to oH2@C60 using Tempo of kTempo approximately 4 x 10-5 M-1 s-1 was observed, which is approximately 3 orders of magnitudes slower than that for dissolved pH2 in organic solvents which is not protected by the C60 shell.

Can H2 inside C60 communicate with the outside world?

The quenching rate constants of singlet oxygen by C60, H2@C60, D2@C6o, H2, and D2 in solution were measured. The presence of a hydrogen (H2@C60) or deuterium (D2@C60) molecule inside the fullerene did not produce any observable effect based on triplet lifetime or EPR measurements. However, a remarkable effect was found for the 1O2 quenching by C60, H2@C60, D2@C6o, H2, and D2. Singlet oxygen was generated by photosensitization or by thermal decomposition of naphthalene endoperoxide derivatives. Comparison of the rate constants for quenching of 1O2 by H2@C60 and D2@C60 demonstrates a significant vibrational interaction between oxygen and H2 inside the fullerene. The quenching rate constant for H2 is 1 order of magnitude higher than that of D2, in agreement with the results observed for the quenching of 1O2 with H2@C60 or D2@C60.

Magnetic Ordering in Gold Nanoclusters.

Several research groups have observed magnetism in monolayer-protected gold cluster samples, but the results were often contradictory, and thus, a clear understanding of this phenomenon is still missing. We used Au25(SCH2CH2Ph)18 0, which is a paramagnetic cluster that can be prepared with atomic precision and whose structure is known precisely. Previous magnetometry studies only detected paramagnetism. We used samples representing a range of crystallographic orders and studied their magnetic behaviors using electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR). As a film, Au25(SCH2CH2Ph)18 0 exhibits a paramagnetic behavior, but at low temperature, ferromagnetic interactions are detectable. One or few single crystals undergo physical reorientation with the applied field and exhibit ferromagnetism, as detected through hysteresis experiments. A large collection of microcrystals is magnetic even at room temperature and shows distinct paramagnetic, superparamagnetic, and ferromagnetic behaviors. Simulation of the EPR spectra shows that both spin-orbit (SO) coupling and crystal distortion are important to determine the observed magnetic behaviors. Density functional theory calculations carried out on single cluster and periodic models predict the values of SO coupling and crystal-splitting effects in agreement with the EPR-derived quantities. Magnetism in gold nanoclusters is thus demonstrated to be the outcome of a very delicate balance of factors. To obtain reproducible results, the samples must be (i) controlled for composition and thus be monodisperse with atomic precision, (ii) of known charge state, and (iii) well-defined in terms of crystallinity and experimental conditions.

Correction to "Magnetic Ordering in Gold Nanoclusters".

[This corrects the article DOI: 10.1021/acsomega.7b00472.].

A magnetic look into the protecting layer of Au25 clusters.

The field of molecular metal clusters protected by organothiolates is experiencing a very rapid growth. So far, however, a clear understanding of the fine interactions between the cluster core and the capping monolayer has remained elusive, despite the importance of the latter in interfacing the former to the surrounding medium. Here, we describe a very sensitive methodology that enables comprehensive assessment of these interactions. Pulse electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) was employed to study the interaction of the unpaired electron with the protons of the alkanethiolate ligands in four structurally related paramagnetic Au25(SR)018 clusters (R = ethyl, propyl, butyl, 2-methylpropyl). Whereas some of these structures were known, we present the first structural description of the highly symmetric Au25(SPr)018 cluster. Through knowledge of the structural data, the ENDOR signals could be successfully related to the types of ligand and the distance of the relevant protons from the central gold core. We found that orbital distribution affects atoms that can be as far as 6 Å from the icosahedral core. Simulations of the spectra provided the values of the hyperfine coupling constants. The resulting information was compared with that provided by 1H NMR spectroscopy, and molecular dynamics calculations provided useful hints to understanding differences between the ENDOR and NMR results. It is shown that the unpaired electron can be used as a very precise probe of the main structural features of the interface between the metal core and the capping ligands.

Time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance of photoinduced ion pairs in blends of polythiophene and fullerene derivatives.

Substituted polythiophene and triethylenglycolpyrrolidino-C(60) blends are examined by time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance (TR-EPR) at different temperatures. TR-EPR spectra recorded on the microsecond time scale after a short laser pulse are assigned to polythiophene and fullerene radical ion pairs, generated by electron transfer from the excited state of polythiophene to fullerene. At low temperatures, TR-EPR spectra show polarized lines with an antiphase emission/absorption pattern. The origin of the polarization pattern is described in the frame of spin correlated radical pair theory, in which two unpaired electron spins (on radical cation and anion, respectively) interact through isotropic spin exchange and anisotropic dipolar interactions. The polarization pattern is accounted for assuming a singlet excited state as the precursor of the charge-separated state. Spectral simulations yield dipolar and spin exchange coupling constants between unpaired electrons of the radical ion pair. Their values correspond to a mean distance between opposite charges of 22 A. When the temperature is increased, the spectra gradually loose their antiphase character and eventually consist of a signal totally in emission. This behavior is explained by a polarization mechanism involving a spin-selective charge recombination (ST(-1) mixing). The polarization pattern at different temperatures is examined in detail, and its generating mechanism is discussed.

Solar cells based on a fullerene-azothiophene dyad.

A power conversion efficiency of 0.37%, under white light of 80 mW cm-2 intensity, was obtained when a fullerene-azothiophene dyad was used as the active layer of a photovoltaic cell.

Gold nanowired: a linear (Au25)(n) polymer from Au25 molecular clusters.

Au25(SR)18 has provided fundamental insights into the properties of clusters protected by monolayers of thiolated ligands (SR). Because of its ultrasmall core, 1 nm, Au25(SR)18 displays molecular behavior. We prepared a Au25 cluster capped by n-butanethiolates (SBu), obtained its structure by single-crystal X-ray crystallography, and studied its properties both experimentally and theoretically. Whereas in solution Au25(SBu)18(0) is a paramagnetic molecule, in the crystal it becomes a linear polymer of Au25 clusters connected via single Au-Au bonds and stabilized by proper orientation of clusters and interdigitation of ligands. At low temperature, [Au25(SBu)18(0)]n has a nonmagnetic ground state and can be described as a one-dimensional antiferromagnetic system. These findings provide a breakthrough into the properties and possible solid-state applications of molecular gold nanowires.

Au25(SEt)18, a nearly naked thiolate-protected Au25 cluster: structural analysis by single crystal X-ray crystallography and electron nuclear double resonance.

X-ray crystallography has been fundamental in discovering fine structural features of ultrasmall gold clusters capped by thiolated ligands. For still unknown structures, however, new tools capable of providing relevant structural information are sought. We prepared a 25-gold atom nanocluster protected by the smallest ligand ever used, ethanethiol. This cluster displays the electrochemistry, mass spectrometry, and UV-vis absorption spectroscopy features of similar Au25 clusters protected by 18 thiolated ligands. The anionic and the neutral form of Au25(SEt)18 were fully characterized by (1)H and (13)C NMR spectroscopy, which confirmed the monolayer's properties and the paramagnetism of neutral Au25(SEt)18(0). X-ray crystallography analysis of the latter provided the first known structure of a gold cluster protected by a simple, linear alkanethiolate. Here, we also report the direct observation by electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) of hyperfine interactions between a surface-delocalized unpaired electron and the gold atoms of a nanocluster. The advantages of knowing the exact molecular structure and having used such a small ligand allowed us to compare the experimental values of hyperfine couplings with DFT calculations unaffected by structure's approximations or omissions.