National critical incident reporting systems relevant to anaesthesia: a European survey.

BACKGROUND: Critical incident reporting is a key tool in the promotion of patient safety in anaesthesia. METHODS: We surveyed representatives of national incident reporting systems in six European countries, inviting information on scope and organization, and intelligence on factors determining success and failure. RESULTS: Some systems are government-run and nationally conceived; others started out as small, specialty-focused initiatives, which have since acquired a national reach. However, both national co-ordination and specialty enthusiasts seem to be necessary for an optimally functioning system. The role of reporting culture, definitional issues, and dissemination is discussed. CONCLUSIONS: We make recommendations for others intending to start new systems and speculate on the prospects for sharing patient safety lessons relevant to anaesthesia at European level.

[CIRRNET® - learning from errors, a success story]. / CIRRNET® - Aus Fehlern lernen, eine Erfolgsgeschichte.

CIRRNET® is the network of local error-reporting systems of the Swiss Patient Safety Foundation. The network has been running since 2006 together with the Swiss Society for Anaesthesiology and Resuscitation (SGAR), and network participants currently include 39 healthcare institutions from all four different language regions of Switzerland. Further institutions can join at any time. Local error reports in CIRRNET® are bundled at a supraregional level, categorised in accordance with the WHO classification, and analysed by medical experts. The CIRRNET® database offers a solid pool of data with error reports from a wide range of medical specialist's areas and provides the basis for identifying relevant problem areas in patient safety. These problem areas are then processed in cooperation with specialists with extremely varied areas of expertise, and recommendations for avoiding these errors are developed by changing care processes (Quick-Alerts®). Having been approved by medical associations and professional medical societies, Quick-Alerts® are widely supported and well accepted in professional circles. The CIRRNET® database also enables any affiliated CIRRNET® participant to access all error reports in the 'closed user area' of the CIRRNET® homepage and to use these error reports for in-house training. A healthcare institution does not have to make every mistake itself - it can learn from the errors of others, compare notes with other healthcare institutions, and use existing knowledge to advance its own patient safety.

Gastric intramucosal pH-guided therapy in patients after elective repair of infrarenal abdominal aneurysms: is it beneficial?

OBJECTIVE: To determine if gastric intramucosal pH (pHi)-guided therapy reduces the number of complications and length of stay in the intensive care unit (ICU) or the hospital after elective repair of infrarenal abdominal aortic aneurysms. DESIGN: Prospective, randomized study. SETTING: Surgical intensive care unit (SICU) of a University Hospital. PATIENTS: Fifty-five consecutive patients randomized to group 1 (pHi-guided therapy) or to group 2 (control). INTERVENTIONS: Patients of group 1 with a pHi of lower than 7.32 were treated by means of a prospective protocol in order to increase their pHi to 7.32 or more. MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS: pHi was determined in both groups on admission to the SICU and thereafter at 6-h intervals. In group 2, the treating physicians were blinded for the pHi values. Complications, APACHE II scores, duration of endotracheal intubation, fluid and vasoactive drug treatment, treatment with vasoactive drugs, length of stay in the SICU and in the hospital and hospital mortality were recorded. There were no differences between groups in terms of the incidence of complications. We found no differences in APACHE II scores on admission, the duration of intubation, SICU or hospital stay, or hospital mortality. In the two groups the incidence of pHi values lower than 7.32 on admission to the SICU was comparable (41% and 42% in groups 1 and 2, respectively). Patients with pHi lower than 7.32 had more major complications during SICU stay (p < 0.05), and periods more than 10 h of persistently low pHi values (< 7.32) were associated with a higher incidence of SICU complications (p < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Low pHi values (< 7.32) and their persistence are predictors of major complications. Treatment to elevate low pHi values does not improve postoperative outcome. Based on these data, we cannot recommend the routine use of gastric tonometers for pHi-guided therapy in these patients. Further studies are warranted to determine adequate treatment of low pHi values that results in beneficial effects on the patient's postoperative course and outcome.

Occlusive mesenteric ischemia and its effects on jejunal intramucosal pH, mesenteric oxygen consumption and oxygen tensions from surfaces of the jejunum in anesthetized pigs.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the effects of superior mesenteric artery (SMA) flow reduction on the jejunal intramucosal pH (pHi) and to compare these effects with corresponding changes of mesenteric oxygen transport variables and oxygen tensions on the surfaces of the jejunal serosa and mucosa. DESIGN: Prospective, randomized, controlled, experimental study. SETTING: Animal research laboratory. SUBJECTS: 20 domestic pigs. INTERVENTIONS: Mechanical flow reduction in the SMA. The animals were randomized to have an SMA flow of 0%, 25%, 38%, 50% or 100% (control). MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Measurements (baseline, ischemia, reperfusion) consisted of hemodynamic and oxygen transport variables, SMA blood flow, mesenteric oxygen transport variables, pHi and oxygen tensions of the jejunal serosa and mucosa. Flow reduction in the SMA resulted in a significant decrease of pHi indicating ischemia earlier than mesenteric oxygen transport variables. The relationship between mesenteric oxygen delivery (DO2ms) and pHi during acute ischemia is best described by a sigmoid curve. There was a linear correlation between the changes of the jejunal surface oxygen tensions and pHi due to SMA flow reduction. CONCLUSION: The sigmoid relationship between pHi and DO2ms indicated that pHi is a sensitive parameter for detecting ischemia at 50% of the baseline oxygen delivery and that below 25% there was no further decrease of pHi. In contrast, mesenteric and whole body oxygen transport parameters were not indicative of impaired mucosal oxygen supply.

Efficacy of specific aseptic precautions for preventing propofol-related infections: analysis by a quality-assurance programme using the explicit outcome method.

Specific aseptic precautions have been recommended for preventing infectious complications of propofol because its lipid base can support bacterial growth if contaminated. To study whether the precautions used at our institution prevent propofol-related infections, we retrospectively analysed the data covering 1 January, 1995 until 30 June, 1996 held in our quality-assurance database. The database contains prospectively collected, detailed and standardized information of each patient's risk factors, anaesthetic and surgical data, and postoperative outcome. Surgical patients who had received propofol for anaesthesia did not have a higher incidence of postoperative infection, thus demonstrating the efficacy of our aseptic precautions.

The anaesthesia critical incident reporting system: an experience based database.

To date there have been fewer than a dozen studies on the nature of, and contributory factors in, critical incidents (CI) in anaesthesia. The first of these, by Cooper and colleagues, showed that the vast majority of their CI involved human error [1]. Most recently, the on-going Australian Incident Monitoring Study (AIMS), with now more than 2000 reports, has shows that aspects of 'system failure' may constitute the bulk of the contributory factors, even though some human error may be detected in about 80% of the analysed cases [2]. We set up a Critical Incident Reporting System (CIRS) to collect anonymous CI in anaesthesia using a reporting form on the Internet. CIRS analysis of the first 60 cases corroborates the findings of previous CI studies. In addition, our preliminary results have shown certain important trends, especially those concerning the contributory factor of communication in the Operating Theatre. Although to date we are unable to assess the educational importance of these CI reports, we believe that there is great potential for this aspect of CIRS.

[Incident reporting as a tool for error analysis in medicine]. / "Incident Reporting" als Instrument zur Fehleranalyse in der Medizin.

Incident Reporting is a tool for error analysis that has its tradition in high-risk industries such as aviation, nuclear power plants or the chemical process industry. The main purpose is to detect insufficiencies in the system as well as in the individual process of each enterprise. In medicine, incident reporting has only rarely been used for error analysis. Pioneering is the domain of anaesthesiology when it comes to apply this tool. In this report the method of incident reporting is described in general with its indications, requirements as well as its limitations. Furthermore a model for the definition of a critical incident in medicine is described and the first conclusions out of a national program of incident reporting in Switzerland are given.

Patient safety in anesthesia.

Some may consider anesthesia a risky endeavor. However, anesthesia is safer now than ever before, and compared to other disciplines, anesthesiology is still among the leading disciplines with regard to patient safety. The presence of a knowledgeable, competent, careful, and vigilant anesthesia provider is the most important element in delivering safe anesthesia. Therefore, strong efforts have to be made to further improve our skills and to better understand the complex systems in which we work. Given the facts that errors and adverse events associated with patient harm and deaths continue to occur and that the complexity of our health care system will steadily increase, it is clear that more needs to be done in order to make anesthesia safer. With its proposals for training on patient safety, the European Society of Anesthesiology (ESA) makes an important contribution thereto, which merits expeditious and efficient implementation both in academia and everyday practice.

Effects of simulated hypovolaemia on haemodynamics, left ventricular function, mesenteric blood flow and gastric Pco2.

BACKGROUND: Compensated clinically silent hypovolaemia may lead to low cardiac output, hypoperfusion and ischaemia. We investigated the cardiovascular effects of simulated hypovolaemia to determine whether it caused mesenteric ischaemia detectable by gastric tonometry. METHODS: Thirteen healthy volunteers, aged 21-36 years, were investigated. Lower body negative pressure (LBNP) was used to simulate normotensive hypovolaemia. Cardiovascular parameters were measured using echocardiography. Mesenteric blood flow was investigated using Doppler sonography of the superior mesenteric artery (SMA). Gastric Pco(2) (P(g)co(2)) was measured using gas tonometry. Data were collected at baseline, LBNP and during a recovery period. RESULTS: Normotensive hypovolaemia was induced successfully in 11 volunteers. There were no significant differences in mean arterial pressure between the three data points (91 +/- 6, 93 +/- 10 and 95 +/- 9 mmHg, respectively). With the induction of LBNP, the heart rate increased from 64 +/- 16 to 73 +/- 16 beats/min (P < 0.001), the cardiac index decreased from 2.7 +/- 1.0 to 1.8 +/- 0.6 l/min/m(2) (P= 0.002) and the systemic vascular resistance increased from 1535 +/- 445 to 2270 +/- 550 dyn s/cm(5) (P < 0.001). The SMA mean flow velocity decreased from 53 +/- 18 to 37 +/- 20 cm/s (69 +/- 20%) (P= 0.007), and increased to 56 +/- 34 cm/s (106 +/- 38%) (P= 0.001) during reperfusion. The SMA resistance increased from 92 +/- 30 to 174 +/- 110 mmHg/l/min (P= 0.004). These changes were reversible after termination of LBNP. By contrast, there were no significant differences in P(g)co(2) between the three data points. CONCLUSIONS: In these volunteers, the mesenteric vascular bed contributed importantly to the maintenance of arterial pressure during normotensive hypovolaemia. However, this compensated hypovolaemia did not compromise the mesenteric perfusion sufficiently to increase P(g)co(2) and to allow detection by tonometry.

Aftermath of an adverse event: supporting health care professionals to meet patient expectations through open disclosure.

An important element of how adverse events are handled is effective communication between health care providers and patients and their families. This review addresses the main questions: What do patients expect in the aftermath of an adverse event? What is known about the practice of open disclosure? How can organizations support health care providers in the aftermath of an adverse event, both professionally and personally? Patients clearly expect open disclosure to include an explanation of what happened, an apology for harm done, that appropriate remedial action will be taken and an explanation of what will be done to learn from the event and to prevent recurrence. Research has found that open disclosure is not very common although the ethical duty to disclose is widely acknowledged. Barriers to open disclosure include discomfort and a lack of training how to disclose, a fear of litigation, a culture of infallibility among health professionals, and inadequate systems for analysis, discussion and learning from mistakes. Significant commitment is required from health care organizations and managers to develop frameworks for open disclosure to occur, to assure its quality and to support health care providers in this process. Organizations also need to address the emotional needs of health care professionals in the aftermath of an adverse event. Last but not least, adequate systems for debriefing and incident analysis need to be in place to learn from adverse events and to avoid recurrence.

[Complications of patient positioning]. / Lagerungsschäden.

Complications related to wrong or improper perioperative positioning are preventable events. Nevertheless patients may suffer from these complications much more than from the original pathology. In a short review a focus is set on the prone and supine position. Finally remarks for prevention are added.

[Complication-free early extubation following abdomino-thoracic esophagectomy]. / Komplikationslose Frühextubation nach abdomino-thorakaler Osophagusresektion.

The combined thoracoabdominal procedure for patients with esophageal cancer is still associated with a high rate of pulmonary complications. Many institutions believe prophylactic postoperative mechanical ventilation to be the most effective measure against pulmonary complications. On the other hand, the duration of mechanical ventilation can have a significant influence on the incidence of pulmonary complications, which are increased after prolonged ventilatory support. Interstitial pulmonary edema is a frequent pathological finding with a poor prognosis after esophageal surgery. Increased water retention in the lung means a greater risk of atelectasis or pneumonia. At the St. Clara Hospital, Basle, patients with esophagectomy were extubated on the day of surgery. Despite early extubation there was a very low rate of minor pulmonary complications. To clarify possible factors contributing to this uncomplicated postoperative course, 20 patients with thoracoabdominal resection of the esophagus were evaluated. All patients were operated upon using a combination of thoracic epidural and light general anesthesia. At the end of the operation all were breathing spontaneously. After a short period of pressure support ventilation and continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP), the mean extubation time was 3 h 10 min postoperatively. Local anesthetics and morphine given by the epidural route and the simultaneous use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs made possible an uneventful and pain-free postoperative course. Early extubation, the immediate use of a CPAP mask system 2-3-hourly and an effective cough were the main points of respiratory therapy.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Epidural abscess complicating epidural anesthesia and analgesia. An analysis of the literature.

BACKGROUND: Epidural abscess is a serious complication of epidural block. Because of its low incidence, the risk factors and the symptoms and cause of epidural abscess related to epidural anesthesia and analgesia are not well known by anesthesiologists. METHODS: A computer-assisted search of the literature on epidural catheter-related abscess was performed to describe the clinical course and bacteriology of this complication, to determine possible risk factors, and to assess the index of suspicion among physicians. RESULTS: Forty-two patients with a catheter-related epidural abscess were identified. Only in 15 patients was the correct diagnosis considered initially. The time from insertion of the epidural catheter to symptoms varied between 1 and 60 d. Initial symptoms included back pain, fever, and leukocytosis. The time from symptoms to treatment was a few hours to 108 d. Interval from first symptoms to treatment was significantly longer in patients with persistent neurologic deficits compared with patients who completely recovered. Staphylococcus aureus was the most common etiologic agent. Outcome was reported in 39 patients, but only 19 made a full recovery. CONCLUSION: The index of suspicion among anesthesiologists, other physicians and nurses taking care of patients with epidural catheters must be increased for this complication; this should shorten the interval from symptoms to treatment and lower the incidence of neurological sequelae.

Haemodynamic response to fibreoptic versus laryngoscopic nasotracheal intubation under total intravenous anaesthesia.

Thirty ASA physical status I and II patients scheduled for elective maxillofacial surgery received total intravenous anaesthesia with propofol, fentanyl and atracurium and were randomly allocated to undergo either fibreoptic or orthodox nasotracheal intubation. Haemodynamic responses to intubation were similar for both techniques. The peak values for heart rate and blood pressure after induction were not significantly different from the baseline values for each group. There was no significant difference in the time required to complete intubation. SpO2 and end-tidal CO2 were similar for both techniques.

[Pulmonary atresia with ventricular septal defect: the significance of collateral lung perfusion for the prognosis of corrective operations]. / Pulmonalatresie mit Ventrikelseptumdefekt: Die Bedeutung der kollateralen Lungenperfusion für die Erfolgsaussichten von Korrekturoperationen.

From 1970 to 1986, 43 patients with pulmonary atresia and ventricular septal defect (PA-VSD) were diagnosed in our hospital. 19 children had a collateral lung perfusion via a ductus botalli (DB), three children had a DB and systemico-pulmonary collateral arteries (SPCA), and 21 children had only SPCA. Patients with a DB alone had significantly larger pulmonary arteries. Children with SPCA always had hypoplastic pulmonary arteries and intrapulmonary arborization anomalies and in a high percentage (19 patients) they showed intrapulmonary stenoses. 26 palliative operations were performed in 24 children. After palliative operations in 15 cases (patients with DB: RVOT-Patch: one patient, aortopulmonary shunt: three patients, Brock procedure: one patient, patients with SPCA: RVOT-Patch: five patients, aortopulmonary shunt: four patients, Brock procedure: one patient) we checked the possibility of corrective surgery with the equation of Alfieri. According to this equation, corrective surgery without excessive right ventricular pressure would have been possible in all post-operatively catheterized patients with DB after primary palliative operations but, due to the pulmonary artery anomalies, only in seven out of nine patients with SPCA (one patient of the latter group was operated twice, Brock procedure and RVOT-Patch). In four cases we could prove the value of the Alfieri equation after corrective operations. There was an excellent correlation between the predicted relation of PRV/PLV and the actually measured pressures. In our opinion, the Alfieri equation forms a valuable aid in the preoperative assessment of children with PA-VSD.

[Perioperative gastrointestinal ischemia in abdominal aortic aneurysm operations]. / Perioperative gastrointestinale Ischämien bei abdominalen Aortenaneurysma-Operationen.

QUESTIONS UNDER STUDY: Surgery of abdominal aortic aneurysms involves a high risk of postoperative complications. It has been suggested that the incidence of postoperative complications is related to the development of gastrointestinal acidotic episodes of the mucosa. The goal of this study was, therefore, to determine the incidence of gastrointestinal acidotic episodes during repair of abdominal aortic aneurysms, and to test the hypothesis that these episodes predict an adverse postoperative course. METHODS: In 49 consecutive patients undergoing elective surgery for repair of an abdominal aneurysm, intramucosal gastric pH (pHi) was measured perioperatively. The length of the surgical procedure, perioperative intravenous fluid intake, use of vasoactive drugs, APACHE-II scores, days with an endotracheal tube in place, days of intensive care and major postoperative complications were prospectively assessed. The patients were assigned to either a group with a pHi > or = 7.35 or a group with pHi < 7.35 measured towards the end of the surgical procedure, and then compared. RESULTS: The pHi decreased from 7.42 +/- 0.09 after induction of anesthesia to 7.37 +/- 0.07 (p < 0.05) during clamping of the aorta, and continued to decrease to 7.34 +/- 0.08 (p < 0.001) towards the end of surgery and on admission to the surgical intensive care unit (mean +/- standard deviation). The percentage of patients with pHi < 7.35 increased from 10% at the beginning of the operation to 55% on admission to the intensive care unit (p < 0.0001). There was no difference in the postoperative course between patients with pHi > or = 7.35 and those with pHi < 7.35 measured after declamping of the aorta. Patients who had a major complication during their stay in the intensive care unit had lower perioperative pHi values than patients without complications (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Perioperative gastrointestinal acidotic episodes of the mucosa are common during repair of abdominal aortic aneurysms. The perioperative course, however, is not influenced by these acidotic episodes, despite the fact that patients with complications during their stay in the intensive care unit had lower perioperative pHi values. The routine use of pHi measurements during elective surgery of abdominal aortic aneurysms, therefore, is not justified.

Repeated dural punctures increase the incidence of postdural puncture headache.

Previous studies have failed to find a significant correlation between the number of dural punctures and the incidence of postdural puncture headache (PDPH), questioning the hypothesis that leakage of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) through the dural tear is the cause of PDPH. We hypothesized that insufficient statistical power of these studies was the cause for this unexpected finding, and re-examined whether repeated dural punctures increase the incidence of PDPH by analyzing prospectively collected data on 8034 spinal anesthetics. Uneventful spinal anesthetics, including a single subarachnoid injection of local anesthetics, occurred in 7865 (97.9%) cases, whereas failed spinal anesthetics requiring repeated dural puncture for a second subarachnoid injection of local anesthetics occurred in 165 (2.1%) cases. The two groups were similar with regard to age, sex, and ASA physical status. We found that repeated dural punctures significantly increased the incidence of PDPH. We conclude that increased risk of PDPH is a disadvantage of performing a second subarachnoid injection of local anesthetics after a failed spinal anesthetic. Moreover, this result suggests that leakage of CSF through the dural tear is the most plausible cause of PDPH.