N-terminal deletion does not affect α-synuclein membrane binding, self-association and toxicity in human neuroblastoma cells, unlike yeast.

α-Synuclein causes Parkinson's disease if mutated or aberrantly produced in neurons. α-Synuclein-lipid interactions are important for the normal function of the protein, but can also contribute to pathogenesis. We previously reported that deletion of the first 10 N-terminal amino acids dramatically reduced lipid binding in vitro, as well as membrane binding and toxicity in yeast. Here we extend this study to human neuroblastoma SHSY-5Y cells, and find that in these cells the first 10 N-terminal residues do not affect α-synuclein membrane binding, self-association and cell viability, contrary to yeast. Differences in lipid composition, membrane fluidity and cytosolic factors between yeast and neuronal cells may account for the distinct binding behavior of the truncated variant in these two systems. Retinoic acid promotes differentiation and α-synuclein oligomer formation in neuroblastoma cells, while addition of a proteasomal inhibitor induces neurite outgrowth and toxicity to certain wild-type and truncated α-synuclein clones. Yeast recapitulate several features of α-synuclein (patho)biology, but its simplicity sets limitations; verification of yeast results in more relevant model systems is, therefore, essential.

Relative tolerance of an enzymatic molten globule and its thermostable counterpart to point mutation.

Enzyme structures reflect the complex interplay between the free energy of unfolding (DeltaG) and catalytic efficiency. Consequently, the effects of point mutations on structure, stability, and function are difficult to predict. It has been proposed that the mutational robustness of homologous enzymes correlates with a higher initial DeltaG. To examine this issue, we compared the tolerance of a natural thermostable chorismate mutase and an engineered molten globular variant to targeted mutation. These mutases possess similar sequence, structure, and catalytic efficiency but dramatically different DeltaG values. We find that analogous point mutations can have widely divergent effects on catalytic activity in these scaffolds. In a set of five rationally designed single-amino acid changes, the thermostable scaffold suffers activity losses ranging from 50-fold smaller, for an aspartate-to-glycine substitution at the active site, to 2-fold greater, for a phenylalanine-to-tryptophan substitution in the hydrophobic core, versus that of the molten globular scaffold. However, biophysical characterization indicates that the variations in catalytic efficiency are not caused by losses of either secondary structural integrity or thermodynamic stability. Rather, the activity differences between variant pairs are very much context-dependent and likely stem from subtle changes in the fine structure of the active site. Thus, in many cases, it may be more productive to focus on changes in local conformation than on global stability when attempting to understand and predict how enzymes respond to point mutations.

Simultaneous optimization of enzyme activity and quaternary structure by directed evolution.

Natural evolution has produced efficient enzymes of enormous structural diversity. We imitated this natural process in the laboratory to augment the efficiency of an engineered chorismate mutase with low activity and an unusual hexameric topology. By applying two rounds of DNA shuffling and genetic selection, we obtained a 400-fold more efficient enzyme, containing three non-active-site mutations. Detailed biophysical characterization of the evolved variant suggests that it exists predominantly as a trimer in solution, but is otherwise similarly stable as the parent hexamer. The dramatic structural and functional effects achieved by a small number of seemingly innocuous substitutions highlights the utility of directed evolution for modifying protein-protein interactions to produce novel quaternary states with optimized activities.

The first N-terminal amino acids of alpha-synuclein are essential for alpha-helical structure formation in vitro and membrane binding in yeast.

Alpha-synuclein (alpha-syn), a protein implicated in Parkinson's disease, is structurally diverse. In addition to its random-coil state, alpha-syn can adopt an alpha-helical structure upon lipid membrane binding or a beta-sheet structure upon aggregation. We used yeast biology and in vitro biochemistry to detect how sequence changes alter the structural propensity of alpha-syn. The N-terminus of the protein, which adopts an alpha-helical conformation upon lipid binding, is essential for membrane binding in yeast, and variants that are more prone to forming an alpha-helical structure in vitro are generally more toxic to yeast. beta-Sheet structure and inclusion formation, on the other hand, appear to be protective, possibly by sequestering the protein from the membrane. Surprisingly, sequential deletion of residues 2 through 11 caused a dramatic drop in alpha-helical propensity, vesicle binding in vitro, and membrane binding and toxicity in yeast, part of which could be mimicked by mutating aspartic acid at position 2 to alanine. Variants with distinct structural preferences, identified here by a reductionist approach, provide valuable tools for elucidating the nature of toxic forms of alpha-syn in neurons.

Kinetics and thermodynamics of ligand binding to a molten globular enzyme and its native counterpart.

An engineered monomeric chorismate mutase (mMjCM) has been found to combine high catalytic activity with the characteristics of a molten globule. To gain insight into the dramatic structural changes that accompany binding of a transition-state analog, we examined mMjCM by isothermal calorimetry and compared it with its dimeric parent protein, MjCM (CM from Methanococcus jannaschii), a thermostable and conventionally folded enzyme. As expected for a ligand-induced ordering process, there is a large entropic penalty for binding to the monomer relative to the dimer (-TDeltaDeltaS=5.1+/-0.5 kcal/mol, at 20 degrees C). However, this unfavorable entropy term is largely offset by enthalpic gains (DeltaDeltaH=-3.5+/-0.4 kcal/mol), presumably arising from tightening of non-covalent interactions throughout the monomeric complex. Stopped-flow kinetic measurements further reveal that the catalytic molten globule binds and releases ligands significantly faster than its natural counterpart, demonstrating that partial structural disorder can speed up molecular recognition. These results illustrate how structural plasticity may strongly perturb the thermodynamics and kinetics of transition-state recognition while negligibly affecting catalytic efficiency.

Novel enzymes through design and evolution.

The generation of enzymes with new catalytic activities remains a major challenge. So far, several different strategies have been developed to tackle this problem, including site-directed mutagenesis, random mutagenesis (directed evolution), antibody catalysis, computational redesign, and de novo methods. Using these techniques, a broad array of novel enzymes has been created (aldolases, decarboxylases, dehydratases, isomerases, oxidases, reductases, and others), although their low efficiencies (10 to 100 M(-1) s(-l)) compared to those of the best natural enzymes (10(6) to 10(8) M(-1) s(-1)) remains a significant concern. Whereas rational design might be the most promising and versatile approach to generating new activities, directed evolution seems to be the best way to optimize the catalytic properties of novel enzymes. Indeed, impressive successes in enzyme engineering have resulted from a combination of rational and random design.

Structure and dynamics of a molten globular enzyme.

Although protein dynamics has been recognized as a potentially important contributor to enzyme catalysis, structural disorder is generally considered to reduce catalytic efficiency. This widely held assumption has recently been challenged by the finding that an engineered chorismate mutase combines high catalytic activity with the properties of a molten globule, a loosely packed and highly dynamic conformational ensemble. Taking advantage of the ordering observed upon ligand binding, we have now used NMR spectroscopy to characterize this enzyme in complex with a transition-state analog. The complex adopts a helix-bundle structure, as designed, but retains unprecedented flexibility on the millisecond timescale across its entire length. Moreover, pre-steady-state kinetics data show that binding occurs by an induced-fit mechanism on the same timescale as the enzymatic reaction, linking global conformational plasticity with efficient catalysis.

An active enzyme constructed from a 9-amino acid alphabet.

Nature employs a set of 20 amino acids to produce a repertoire of protein structures endowed with sophisticated functions. Here, we combined design and selection to create an enzyme composed entirely from a set of only 9 amino acids that can rescue auxotrophic cells lacking chorismate mutase. The simplified protein captures key structural features of its natural counterpart but appears to be somewhat less stable and more flexible. The potential of a dramatically reduced amino acid alphabet to produce an active catalyst supports the notion that primordial enzymes may have possessed low amino acid diversity and suggests that combinatorial engineering strategies, such as the one used here, may be generally applied to create enzymes with novel structures and functions.

An enzymatic molten globule: efficient coupling of folding and catalysis.

A highly active, monomeric chorismate mutase, obtained by topological redesign of a dimeric helical bundle enzyme from Methanococcus jannaschii, was investigated by NMR and various other biochemical techniques, including H/D exchange. Although structural disorder is generally considered to be incompatible with efficient catalysis, the monomer, unlike its natural counterpart, unexpectedly possesses all of the characteristics of a molten globule. Global conformational ordering, observed upon binding of a transition state analog, indicates that folding can be coupled to catalysis with minimal energetic penalty. These results support the suggestion that many modern enzymes might have evolved from molten globule precursors. Insofar as their structural plasticity confers relaxed substrate specificity and/or catalytic promiscuity, molten globules may also be attractive starting points for the evolution of new catalysts in the laboratory.