Chromatin-remodeling factors: machines that regulate?

Chromatin has shifted into the focus of attention as a key to understanding the regulation of nuclear processes such as transcription. Protein machines have been described that use the energy of ATP to render chromatin dynamic and hence active, but which may also be involved in chromatin assembly. The discovery of three different Drosophila nucleosome remodeling complexes that contain imitation switch (ISWI), an ATPase with a high degree of sequence conservation from yeast to human, points to a central function of this ATPase in chromatin dynamics.

ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling factors: nucleosome shufflers with many missions.

This review addresses recent developments in the field of ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling factors. These factors use the energy of ATP hydrolysis to introduce superhelical torsion into DNA, which suggests a common mechanistic basis of action. Chromatin remodeling factors function both in transcriptional activation and repression, but they may have roles outside of transcriptional regulation such as DNA repair. A study of the nucleosome dependent ATPase ISWI in yeast illustrates the involvement of ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling in transcriptional repression by setting up inaccessible chromatin structures at promoters. However, factors such as ISWI are also involved in the restructuring of large chromatin domains and even whole chromosomes. Transcriptional regulation by ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling factors occurs in concert with histone modifying enzymes such as histone acetyltransferases and histone deacetylases: In yeast, SWI/SNF targeting is a requirement for histone acetyltransferases activity at promoters that are active at late stages of mitosis, when the chromatin is still condensed. This demonstrates that ATP-dependent remodeling factors facilitate covalent histone modifications. However, they are also regulated by histone modifications and in some circumstances they function in parallel with histone modifications towards the same goal.

Sequence of the Octopus dofleini hemocyanin subunit: structural and evolutionary implications.

Sequencing of the subunit of the hemocyanin of Octopus dofleini has been completed from a cDNA library. This represents the first molluscan hemocyanin to be completely sequenced. The sequence determined is for one of the two distinguishable cDNAs which have been recognized for this protein. The protein subunit has 2896 amino acids and contains seven functional units, each carrying two sets of three invariant histidine residues constituting the binding sites (A and B) for two copper atoms. The accompanying paper identifies this site in the C-terminal functional unit (Odg). Differences in sequence for the two cDNAs, for the region in which both are available, are concentrated in the "linker regions" between functional units. The sequences of the seven units exhibit high similarity, averaging about 40% identity, with a concentration of conserved sequences in the region surrounding the copper binding sites. The sequences around the B-site show significant homology to the sequences of arthropod hemocyanins. Comparison of the functional unit sequences in terms of hydrophobicity and surface exposure profiles, as well as regions of probable secondary structure, indicate that all functional units probably have a common tertiary folding; the protein subunit is a string of similarly folded beads. A number of putative N-linked carbohydrate binding sites can be recognized in the sequence; one of these corresponds to the carbohydrate observed in the X-ray diffraction study of functional unit Odg as disclosed in the accompying paper. Phylogenetic analysis of the sequences of the O. dofleini functional units, and comparison with other available molluscan sequences indicates that the multi-domain subunit structure must have arisen over a relatively brief period, preceeding the differentiation of major molluscan types.

Transcription factor-mediated chromatin remodelling: mechanisms and models.

The association of DNA with nucleosomes in chromatin severely restricts the access of the regulatory factors that bring about transcription. In vivo active promoters are characterised by altered, almost transparent chromatin structures that allow the interaction of the transcriptional machinery. Recently, enzymatic activities have been discovered that facilitate the binding of transcription factors to chromatin by modifying nucleosomal structures in a process that requires energy. The mechanisms by which chromatin is remodelled may involve nucleosome movements, their transient unfolding, their partial or even complete disassembly. The dynamic properties of chromatin that underlie these structural changes are fundamental to the process of regulated gene expression.

Competition between linker histones and HMG1 for binding to four-way junction DNA: implications for transcription.

Both lysine-rich histones and high mobility group proteins 1 and 2 bind to linker DNA in chromatin. While the members of the histone H1 class are considered general repressors of transcription, HMG1/2 are viewed as activators. Using stable four-way junction DNA as a model for cross-overs of linker DNA at the entry and exit to nucleosomes, we show that HMG1 can compete efficiently with H1 for binding to four-way junctions. In contrast, the erythrocyte-specific histone H5 seems to be refractory to displacement by HMG1. The results suggest that replacement of histone H1 by HMG1 may be part of the transcriptional activation by HMG1.

Preferential binding of histone H1 to four-way helical junction DNA.

Histone H1 is a major chromatin protein, which stabilizes the nucleosome, has an essential role in organizing nucleosomes into higher order structures, and may have a role as a repressor of transcription (van Holde, K. E. (1989) Chromatin, Springer Publishing Co., New York). Here we show that H1 forms a defined complex with a synthetic four-way junction of DNA strands even in the presence of an excess of linear nonspecific competitor DNA. The four-way junction also competes efficiently against two duplex DNA molecules, which together have the same sequence information as the four-way junction molecule. Another major chromatin protein, high mobility group protein 1, also binds four-way junction structures specifically (Bianchi, M. E., Beltrame, M., and Paonessa, G. (1989) Science 243, 1056-1059), and this similar behavior may indicate a related function of these proteins. Our finding may suggest that four-way DNA junction is a structural equivalent to the main H1 binding site in the nucleosome: a crossover of double helical DNA at the point where the DNA enters and exits the nucleosome (Allan, J., Hartman, P. G., Crane-Robinson, C., and Aviles, F. X. (1980) Nature 288, 675-679).

Chromatin remodeling by GAGA factor and heat shock factor at the hypersensitive Drosophila hsp26 promoter in vitro.

The chromatin structure at the Drosophila hsp26 promoter in vivo is characterized by two DNase I-hypersensitive (DH) sites harboring regulatory elements. Proximal and distal DH sites are separated by a positioned nucleosome. To study the contribution of transcription factors to the establishment of this specific chromatin configuration we assembled nucleosomes on the hsp26 promoter using a cell-free reconstitution system derived from fly embryos. Both DH sites were readily reconstituted from extract components. They were separated by a nucleosome which was less strictly positioned than its in vivo counterpart. The interactions of GAGA factor and heat shock factor with their binding sites in chromatin occurred in two modes. Their interaction with binding sites in the nucleosome-free regions did not require ATP. In the presence of ATP both factors interacted also with nucleosomal binding sites, causing nucleosome rearrangements and a refinement of nucleosome positions. While chromatin remodeling upon transcription factor interaction has previously been interpreted to involve nucleosome disruption, the data suggest energy-dependent nucleosome sliding as main principle of chromatin reorganization.

Linker histones affect patterns of digestion of supercoiled plasmids by single-strand-specific nucleases.

The effect of histone H1 binding on the cleavage of superhelical plasmids by single-strand-specific nucleases was investigated. Mapping of P1 cleavage sites in pBR322, achieved by EcoRI digestion after the original P1 attack, showed an intriguing phenomenon: preexisting susceptible sites became "protected," whereas some new sites appeared at high levels of H1. Similar results were obtained with another single-strand-specific nuclease, S1. Disappearance of cutting at preexisting sites and appearance of new sites was also observed in a derivative plasmid that contains a 36-bp stretch of alternating d(AT) sequence that is known to adopt an altered P1-sensitive conformation. On the other hand, H1 titration of a dimerized version of the d(AT)18-containing plasmid led to protection of all preexisting sites except the d(AT)18 inserts, which were still cut even at high H1 levels; in this plasmid no new sites appeared. The protection of preexisting sites is best explained by long-range effects of histone H1 binding on the superhelical torsion of the plasmid. The appearance of new sites, on the other hand, probably also involves a local effect of stabilization of specific sequences in Pl-sensitive conformation, due to direct H1 binding to such sequences. That such binding involves linker histone N- and/or C-terminal tails is indicated by the fact that titration with the globular domain of H5, while causing disappearance of preexisting sites, does not lead to the appearance of any new sites.

In vitro chromatin remodelling by chromatin accessibility complex (CHRAC) at the SV40 origin of DNA replication.

DNA replication is initiated by binding of initiation factors to the origin of replication. Nucleosomes are known to inhibit the access of the replication machinery to origin sequences. Recently, nucleosome remodelling factors have been identified that increase the accessibility of nucleosomal DNA to transcription regulators. To test whether the initiation of DNA replication from an origin covered by nucleosomes would also benefit from the action of nucleosome remodelling factors, we reconstituted SV40 DNA into chromatin in Drosophila embryo extracts. In the presence of T-antigen and ATP, a chromatin-associated cofactor allowed efficient replication from a nucleosomal origin in vitro. In search of the energy-dependent cofactor responsible we found that purified 'chromatin accessibility complex' (CHRAC) was able to alter the nucleosomal structure at the origin allowing the binding of T-antigen and efficient initiation of replication. These experiments provide evidence for the involvement of a nucleosome remodelling machine in structural changes at the SV40 origin of DNA replication in vitro.

Binding of histones H1 and H5 and their globular domains to four-way junction DNA.

We have compared chicken erythrocyte linker histones H1 and H5 binding to a synthetic four-way DNA junction. Each histone binds to form a single complex, with an affinity which permits competition against a large excess of linear duplex DNA. The affinity of H5 is higher than that of H1. The globular domain from either protein will also bind strongly, but in this case multiple binding occurs. Binding of intact H1 is inhibited by cations: Mg2+ and spermidine are very effective, Na+ much less so. This inhibition is not likely to be a general ion-competition effect, for Mg2+ is much less effective in inhibiting the binding of H1 to linear DNA. Instead, the inhibition of binding may be due to ion-dependent changes in the conformation of the four-way junction, which are known to occur under similar conditions. These results strongly suggest that the angle formed between the arms of the DNA junction could be a major determinant in the interaction of H1 with DNA crossovers.

Energy-dependent chromatin accessibility and nucleosome mobility in a cell-free system.

Chromatin structure must be flexible to allow the binding of regulatory proteins and to accommodate different levels of gene activity. Chromatin assembled in a cell-free system derived from Drosophila embryos contains an activity that hydrolyses ATP to render entire nucleosome arrays mobile. Nucleosome movements, most likely their sliding, occurred even in the presence of the linker histone H1. The dynamic state of chromatin in the presence of the activity and ATP globally increased the accessibility of nucleosomal DNA to incoming proteins. This unprecedented demonstration of energy-dependent nucleosome mobility identifies a new principle which is likely to be fundamental to the mechanism of chromatin remodelling and the binding of regulatory proteins.

Chromatin-remodelling factor CHRAC contains the ATPases ISWI and topoisomerase II.

Repressive chromatin structures need to be unravelled to allow DNA-binding proteins access to their target sequences. This de-repression constitutes an important point at which transcription and presumably other nuclear processes can be regulated. Energy-consuming enzyme complexes that facilitate the interaction of transcription factors with chromatin by modifying nucleosome structure are involved in this regulation. One such factor, nucleosome-remodelling factor (NURF), has been isolated from Drosophila embryo extracts. We have now identified a chromatin-accessibility complex (CHRAC) which uses energy to increase the general accessibility of DNA in chromatin. However, unlike other known chromatin remodelling factors, CHRAC can also function during chromatin assembly: it uses ATP to convert irregular chromatin into a regular array of nucleosomes with even spacing. CHRAC combines enzymes that modulate nucleosome structure and DNA topology. Using mass spectrometry, we identified two of the five CHRAC subunits as the ATPase ISWI, which is also part of NURF, and topoisomerase II. The presence of ISWI in different contexts suggests that chromatin remodelling machines have a modular nature and that ISWI has a central role in different chromatin remodelling reactions.

Acf1, the largest subunit of CHRAC, regulates ISWI-induced nucleosome remodelling.

The chromatin accessibility complex (CHRAC) was originally defined biochemically as an ATP-dependent 'nucleosome remodelling' activity. Central to its activity is the ATPase ISWI, which catalyses the transfer of histone octamers between DNA segments in cis. In addition to ISWI, four other potential subunits were observed consistently in active CHRAC fractions. We have now identified the p175 subunit of CHRAC as Acf1, a protein known to associate with ISWI in the ACF complex. Interaction of Acf1 with ISWI enhances the efficiency of nucleosome sliding by an order of magnitude. Remarkably, it also modulates the nucleosome remodelling activity of ISWI qualitatively by altering the directionality of nucleosome movements and the histone 'tail' requirements of the reaction. The Acf1-ISWI heteromer tightly interacts with the two recently identified small histone fold proteins CHRAC-14 and CHRAC-16. Whether topoisomerase II is an integral subunit has been controversial. Refined analyses now suggest that topoisomerase II should not be considered a stable subunit of CHRAC. Accordingly, CHRAC can be molecularly defined as a complex consisting of ISWI, Acf1, CHRAC-14 and CHRAC-16.

Two histone fold proteins, CHRAC-14 and CHRAC-16, are developmentally regulated subunits of chromatin accessibility complex (CHRAC).

The ISWI ATPase of Drosophila is a molecular engine that can drive a range of nucleosome remodelling reactions in vitro. ISWI is important for cell viability, developmental gene expression and chromosome structure. It interacts with other proteins to form several distinct nucleosome remodelling machines. The chromatin accessibility complex (CHRAC) is a biochemical entity containing ISWI in association with several other proteins. Here we report on the identification of the two smallest CHRAC subunits, CHRAC-14 and CHRAC-16. They contain histone fold domains most closely related to those found in sequence-specific transcription factors NF-YB and NF-YC, respectively. CHRAC-14 and CHRAC-16 interact directly with each other as well as with ISWI, and are associated with functionally active CHRAC. The developmental expression profiles of both subunits suggest specialized roles in chromatin remodelling reactions in the early embryo for both histone fold subunits.

HuCHRAC, a human ISWI chromatin remodelling complex contains hACF1 and two novel histone-fold proteins.

Chromatin remodelling complexes containing the nucleosome-dependent ATPase ISWI were first isolated from Drosophila embryos (NURF, CHRAC and ACF). ISWI was the only common component reported in these complexes. Our purification of human CHRAC (HuCHRAC) shows that ISWI chromatin remodelling complexes can have a conserved subunit composition in completely different cell types, suggesting a conserved function of ISWI. We show that the human homologues of two novel putative histone-fold proteins in Drosophila CHRAC are present in HuCHRAC. The two human histone-fold proteins form a stable complex that binds naked DNA but not nucleosomes. HuCHRAC also contains human ACF1 (hACF1), the homologue of Acf1, a subunit of Drosophila ACF. The N-terminus of mouse ACF1 was reported as a heterochromatin-targeting domain. hACF1 is a member of a family of proteins with a related domain structure that all may target heterochromatin. We discuss a possible function for HuCHRAC in heterochromatin dynamics. HuCHRAC does not contain topoisomerase II, which was reported earlier as a subunit of Drosophila CHRAC.