Differential expression of VH gene families in peripheral B cell repertoires of newborn or adult immunoglobulin H chain congenic mice.

The pattern of VH gene family expression in the primary B cell repertoire of the mouse is strain dependent. In C57Bl/6 mice, the VH J558 family is expressed by more than 45% of the cells, while the expression of VH 7183, VH Q52, and VH 36-60 families together does not exceed 20%. In BALB/c mice, relative expression of VH J558 is lower than 35%, while the sum of the other three families reaches 25%. To assess which genetic loci control strain-specific VH gene family expression, we studied VH gene family usage in splenic B cell repertoires of different congenic strains of mice. Changes in major histocompatibility complex or immunoglobulin (Ig) K light chain genes did not modify VH gene family expression in adult mice. Differences at the IgH locus, however, modified VH gene family usage. In 1-d-old mice, the strain-specific VH gene family expression pattern is determined by the IgH haplotype. In adult mice, the VH gene family expression pattern of resting B cells is independent of the IgH locus and follows the genetic background of the congenic strain, while it is determined by the IgH haplotype among Ig-secreting spleen cells. In F1(B6 x BALB/c) mice, each of the two spleen B cell populations, sorted on the basis of mu heavy chain allotype expression, shows an independent VH gene family expression pattern, determined by the IgH locus. The implications of these results in the control of VH gene family expression, and in the selection of peripheral B cell repertoires are discussed.

Abnormal selection of antibody repertoires in retrovirus-induced murine AIDS.

The mature B cell repertoire in the course of murine AIDS (MAIDS) was investigated. The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to amplify a large diversity of rearranged Ig H chain genes in normal or infected mice, 2 and 8 wk after virus inoculation. Libraries were constructed from the polymerase chain reaction products. By sequencing V-D-J clones in these libraries and analyzing the respective complementary determining region 3 (CDR3), we have shown at 8 wk the emergence of a population of B cells with significantly less N diversity, some sequences lacking any N addition, a typical feature of fetal repertoires known for degeneracy, and autoreactivities. This decreased N diversity was not present 2 wk after inoculation and could not be related to a defect in terminal deoxytransferase expression because the steady-state levels of terminal deoxytransferase mRNA were found normal in MAIDS bone marrow 8 wk after inoculation. FACS analyses revealed a decreased number of bone marrow B cells (B220+, sIgM+) in MAIDS already present at 2 wk, suggesting an alteration in the pathway of B cell differentiation and resulting in a decrease of peripheral B cells renewal. A relative enrichment of spleen cells in long lived B cells as a consequence of this blockade may participate in the abnormal antibody repertoire selection occurring in MAIDS. These data suggest in the MAIDS pathogeny the relationship between an abnormal repertoire selection and the pathologic process.

Regulation of VH-gene expression is a lineage-specific developmental marker.

We have previously shown that in IgH congenic mice VH-gene family usage in neonatal spleen B cells and adult Ig-secreting cells is entirely determined by the IgH locus, while in adult resting B cells it is regulated by genetic element(s) located outside the IgH locus. Two observations reported here demonstrate that the differential expression of VH genes is an intrinsic property of the respective cell populations, determined by both the IgH locus and by a cis element(s) operating independently in the same animal. First, the study of F1 hybrids between the IgH congenic B6a and CB.20 strains demonstrates that cis elements control VH-gene family expression. Second, studies in irradiation chimeras showed that the environment in which cell differentiation proceeds is unable to overcome those controls. In chimeras of IgH congenic donors, VH-gene expression in fetal liver-derived splenic B cells and Ig-secreting cells is dictated by the IgH haplotype, while in bone marrow-derived B cells is entirely determined by the cis element(s). These results show a developmental and cell lineage-related restriction in VH-gene expression, and suggest that most adult splenic Ig-secreting cells may originate from precursors originally present in fetal liver, but which are rare among adult bone marrow precursors and CD5+ B cells.

Normal serum immunoglobulins participate in the selection of peripheral B-cell repertoires.

In B-cell development, expression of immunoglobulin heavy-chain variable-region (VH) gene repertoires is determined by genetic mechanisms that favor rearrangement of the most D-proximal genes, resulting in overutilization of the VH7183 gene family early in ontogeny and in differentiating B cells of the adult bone marrow. Maturation of the immune system is accompanied by a decreased expression of VH7183 genes in the peripheral immunocompetent B-cell pool of adult animals. By comparing VH gene family expression in the bone marrow (emergent) and peripheral (available and actual) B-cell repertoires of germ-free and conventionally raised BALB/c mice, we found that peripheral selection of VH gene family utilization does not occur in germ-free animals. Reconstitution of germ-free mice with normal serum immunoglobulins purified from syngeneic donors reestablishes selection of VH7183-expressing B cells. Our results indicate that preimmune B-cell repertoires are selected in normal animals by environmental antigens and serum immunoglobulins.

V region dependent selection of persistent resting peripheral B cells in normal mice.

In this study, we compare the VH gene family repertoire of persistent long-lived splenic B cells with that of the whole splenic B cell compartment. Persistent long-lived B cells were obtained by two independent strategies. Firstly, we studied cells that persist in the peripheral pools with or without cell division. We have transferred mature lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-reactive splenic B cells into LPS non-responder recipients and studied the donor population that could be recovered in host mice at differing time intervals after cell transfer. Secondly, we studied non-cycling resting long-lived B cells. These cells were obtained in normal mice after cytostatic treatment with hydroxyurea and in mice transgenic for the HSV-1 thymidine kinase gene after treatment with the anti-herpetic ganciclovir. Studying the VH gene family usage at the single level by in situ hybridization, we found that persistent B cells show an increased expression of the VHJ558 family and a diminished representation of the VH7183 family. These results demonstrate that in a normal non-immunized mouse, B cell survival and persistence in the resting state results from V region dependent selection.

The role of cellular competition in B cell survival and selection of B cell repertoires.

We studied the competitive repopulation by different B cells of irradiated mice reconstituted with bone marrow from either congenic or Ig-transgenic (TG) mice mixed at different ratios. We found that after reconstitution, the number of B cells recovered in the different chimeras is similar and independent of the ratio of injected cells. In chimeras hosting TG and non-TG cells, the relative representation of the donor cell lineages diverges from the ratios present in the inoculum, i.e. at the periphery, non-TG cells are preferentially selected. Selection of non-TG cells only occurs when population growth plateaus, i.e. when resources become limiting and competition starts to operate. Selection of non-TG cells depends on surface Ig expression, and they are selected because they have a longer survival. Finally, the life-expectancy of the same B cell population differs depending upon the second population present. The present results show that the life-span and the population size of each B cell clone can be altered (interfered with) by the presence of a second cell population, demonstrating the existence of cellular competition among B cells. Our findings establish the role of cellular competition in the selection of B cell repertoires and the existence of a hierarchy of B cell selection in the absence of antigenic stimulation. The implications of cellular competition on our understanding of the immune system are discussed.

On the origin of natural IgM in immunoglobulin transgenic mice.

Surface transgenic IgM was expressed by > 95% of small resting splenic B cells but only by 50% of CD5+ and CD5- peritoneal B cells from the mu-transgenic mouse line M54. Transgenic male M54 were crossed with female CBA/N mice carrying the Xid defect. Offspring F1 animals carrying the transgene were analysed for the presence of transgenic and endogenous IgM expressed both in the serum as well as on the surface of splenic and peritoneal B cells. We found that the levels of serum IgM coded for by the transgene were similar in both F1 male, which lack CD5 B cells, and female transgenic mice, which have CD5 B cells. Thus, the Xid defect does not influence the expression of the transgene at the level of naturally activated plasma cells, a finding substantiated by the fact that both male and female naturally activated splenic plasma cells express the transgene at the same frequency. F1 hybrid mice, like transgenic C57BI/6 M54 mice, have naturally activated splenic plasma cells that overexpress endogenous IgM coded for by the VH gene family Q52. The data indicate that normal serum IgM is not derived from CD5+ B cells and that the serum IgM coded for by the mu-transgene from M54 is produced at normal levels even in the male F1 mouse which lacks CD5+ B cells.

Genetic control of natural antibody repertoires: I. IgH, MHC and TCR beta loci.

Global analysis of natural antibody repertoires has revealed a marked conservation of reactivity patterns within inbred mouse strains, and characteristic strain-specific differences. We have now analyzed the genetic control of reactivity repertoires, aiming at identifying the respective selection mechanisms. Multiparametric statistics of a large number of serum antibody reactivities scored by quantitative Western blot analyses using extracts from homologous tissues and bacteria readily distinguish the reactivity patterns of C57BL/6 and BALB/c, revealing homogeneity among genetically identical individuals. Antibody repertoires in the prototype strains can also be segregated from those expressed by the respective IgH congenics, BC.8 and CB.20, demonstrating that IgH-linked genes contribute to determining natural antibody repertoires. Conversely, strains sharing IgH haplotype also express distinct reactivity patterns, indicating that other genes participate in the selection of serum IgM repertoires. Two such non-IgH loci were now identified. Thus, analysis of four MHC-congenic strains demonstrated that MHC-linked control of natural antibody repertoires is likely to operate through differential selection of T cell repertoires, since (1) mice that are congenic at the TCR beta locus, and (2) BALB/c nude mice grafted at birth with pure thymic epithelium from either C57BL/6 or BALB/c also differ in their natural antibody repertoires.

VH-gene family dominance in ageing mice.

The cellular composition and VH-gene family repertoire were compared in different B-cell compartments from young adult (8-12 weeks) and old (18-24 months) C57BL/6 and BALB/c mice. Ageing mice were found to have a higher frequency of peripheral mature B cells utilizing genes from a single VH-gene family. While in each individual old C57BL/6 mice cells expressing the VH J558 gene family consistently were over-represented, a marked individual variation was observed in old BALB/c mice with increased frequency of either the VH J558, Q52 or J606 families. Aged mice were found also to have a reduced number of bone-marrow pre-B cells and an augmented number of splenic Ig-secreting cells. These results suggest that old mice express less diversified antibody repertoires possibly as a consequence of reduced input from precursors and increased peripheral selection, which may be responsible for the progressive establishment of immunodeficiency.