Trimethyllysine Reader Proteins Exhibit Widespread Charge-Agnostic Binding via Different Mechanisms to Cationic and Neutral Ligands.

In the last 40 years, cation-π interactions have become part of the lexicon of noncovalent forces that drive protein binding. Indeed, tetraalkylammoniums are universally bound by aromatic cages in proteins, suggesting that cation-π interactions are a privileged mechanism for binding these ligands. A prominent example is the recognition of histone trimethyllysine (Kme3) by the conserved aromatic cage of reader proteins, dictating gene expression. However, two proteins have recently been suggested as possible exceptions to the conventional understanding of tetraalkylammonium recognition. To broadly interrogate the role of cation-π interactions in protein binding interactions, we report the first large-scale comparative evaluation of reader proteins for a neutral Kme3 isostere, experimental and computational mechanistic studies, and structural analysis. We find unexpected widespread binding of readers to a neutral isostere with the first examples of readers that bind the neutral isostere more tightly than Kme3. We find that no single factor dictates the charge selectivity, demonstrating the challenge of predicting such interactions. Further, readers that bind both cationic and neutral ligands differ in mechanism: binding Kme3 via cation-π interactions and the neutral isostere through the hydrophobic effect in the same aromatic cage. This discovery explains apparently contradictory results in previous studies, challenges traditional understanding of molecular recognition of tetraalkylammoniums by aromatic cages in myriad protein-ligand interactions, and establishes a new framework for selective inhibitor design by exploiting differences in charge dependence.

Stimulus-Induced Relief of Intentionally Incorporated Frustration Drives Refolding of a Water-Soluble Biomimetic Foldamer.

Frustrated, or nonoptimal, interactions have been proposed to be essential to a protein's ability to display responsive behavior such as allostery, conformational signaling, and signal transduction. However, the intentional incorporation of frustrated noncovalent interactions has not been explored as a design element in the field of dynamic foldamers. Here, we report the design, synthesis, characterization, and molecular dynamics simulations of the first dynamic water-soluble foldamer that, in response to a stimulus, exploits relief of frustration in its noncovalent network to structurally rearrange from a pleated to an intercalated columnar structure. Thus, relief of frustration provides the energetic driving force for structural rearrangement. This work represents a previously unexplored design element for the development of stimulus-responsive systems that has potential application to materials chemistry, synthetic biology, and molecular machines.

Comparative Analysis of Sulfonium-π, Ammonium-π, and Sulfur-π Interactions and Relevance to SAM-Dependent Methyltransferases.

We report the measurement and analysis of sulfonium-π, thioether-π, and ammonium-π interactions in a ß-hairpin peptide model system, coupled with computational investigation and PDB analysis. These studies indicated that the sulfonium-π interaction is the strongest and that polarizability contributes to the stronger interaction with sulfonium relative to ammonium. Computational studies demonstrate that differences in solvation of the trimethylsulfonium versus the trimethylammonium group also contribute to the stronger sulfonium-π interaction. In comparing sulfonium-π versus sulfur-π interactions in proteins, analysis of SAM- and SAH-bound enzymes in the PDB suggests that aromatic residues are enriched in close proximity to the sulfur of both SAM and SAH, but the populations of aromatic interactions of the two cofactors are not significantly different, with the exception of the Me-π interactions in SAM, which are the most prevalent interaction in SAM but are not possible for SAH. This suggests that the weaker interaction energies due to loss of the cation-π interaction in going from SAM to SAH may contribute to turnover of the cofactor.

Application of an Imprint-and-Report Sensor Array for Detection of the Dietary Metabolite Trimethylamine N-Oxide and Its Precursors in Complex Mixtures.

Trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) is produced in the gut via metabolism of dietary betaine, choline, and carnitine, and elevated TMAO in plasma is associated with adverse health effects, including cardiovascular events. Currently, we lack high throughput methods for sensing these metabolites and detecting high TMAO. Thus, we have adapted our previously described "imprint-and-report" fluorescent sensing method using dynamic combinatorial libraries (DCLs) to create a sensor array for these four metabolites that functions at physiologically relevant concentrations. Templation of DCLs with dye and subsequent addition of analytes generates a fluorescent fingerprint for each metabolite and allows for differentiation via principal component analysis (PCA). Furthermore, we demonstrate that this system can be used to characterize mixtures of the metabolites in both buffer and human plasma samples. Using three to six DCLs, we can distinguish between plasma samples with healthy and elevated levels of TMAO.

Development of "Imprint-and-Report" Dynamic Combinatorial Libraries for Differential Sensing Applications.

Sensor arrays using synthetic receptors have found great utility in analyte detection, resulting from their ability to distinguish analytes based on differential signals via indicator displacement. However, synthesis and characterization of receptors for an array remain a bottleneck in the field. Receptor discovery has been streamlined using dynamic combinatorial libraries (DCLs), but the resulting receptors have primarily been utilized in isolation rather than as part of the entire library, with only a few examples that make use of the complexity of a library of receptors. Herein, we demonstrate a unique sensor array approach using "imprint-and-report" DCLs that obviates the need for receptor synthesis and isolation. This strategy leverages information stored in DCLs in the form of differential library speciation to provide a high-throughput method for both developing a sensor array and analyzing data for analyte differentiation. First, each DCL is templated with analyte to give an imprinted library, followed by in situ fluorescent indicator displacement analysis. We further demonstrate that the reverse strategy, imprinting with the fluorescent reporter followed by displacement with each analyte, provides a more sensitive method for differentiating analytes. We describe the development of this differential sensing system using the methylated Arg and Lys post-translational modifications (PTMs). Altogether, 19 combinations of 3-5 DCL data sets that discriminate all 7 PTMs were identified. Thus, a comparable sensor array workflow results in a larger payoff due to the immense information stored within multiple noncovalent networks.

Mimicking Biological Recognition: Lessons in Binding Hydrophilic Guests in Water.

Selective molecular recognition of hydrophilic guests in water plays a fundamental role in a vast number of biological processes, but synthetic mimicry of biomolecular recognition in water still proves challenging both in terms of achieving comparable affinities and selectivities. This Review highlights strategies that have been developed in the field of supramolecular chemistry to selectively and non-covalently bind three classes of biologically relevant molecules: nucleotides, carbohydrates, and amino acids. As several groups have systematically modified receptors for a specific guest, an evolutionary perspective is also provided in some cases. Trends in the most effective binding forces for each class are described, providing insight into selectivity and potential directions for future work.

More Than π-π-π Stacking: Contribution of Amide-π and CH-π Interactions to Crotonyllysine Binding by the AF9 YEATS Domain.

Lysine crotonylation (Kcr) is a histone post-translational modification that is implicated in numerous epigenetic pathways and diseases. Recognition of Kcr by YEATS domains has been proposed to occur through intermolecular amide-π and alkene-π interactions, but little is known about the driving force of these key interactions. Herein, we probed the recognition of lysine crotonylation and acetylation by the AF9 YEATS domain through incorporation of noncanonical Phe analogs with distinct electrostatics at two positions. We found that amide-π interactions between AF9 and acyllysines are electrostatically tunable, with electron-rich rings providing more favorable interactions. This differs from trends in amide-heteroarene interactions and provides insightful information for therapeutic design. Additionally, we report for the first time that CH-π interactions at Phe28 directly contribute to AF9's recognition of acyllysines, illuminating differences among YEATS domains, as this residue is not highly conserved but has been shown to impart selectivity for specific post-translational modification.

Achieving High Affinity and Selectivity for Asymmetric Dimethylarginine by Putting a Lid on a Box.

The methylation states of Lys and Arg represent a particularly challenging set of targets to distinguish selectively in water using synthetic receptors. To date, trimethyllysine (Kme3) is the only post translational modification (PTM) of the eight possible methylation states of Lys and Arg that can be recognized selectively. Here, we report the first synthetic receptor capable of selectively recognizing asymmetric dimethylarginine (Rme2a). This was achieved by using a biased dynamic combinatorial chemistry (DCC) library to generate a receptor mimicking the 5-sided box-like shape of Rme2 reader proteins, a feature that has been hypothesized to impart selectivity. Additionally, we synthesized a thioether-linked analogue of the resulting receptor to provide a novel scaffold with maintained selectivity but greater stability. This work introduces strategies that can be applied towards achieving selectivity based on subtle differences in hydrophilic guests in aqueous solutions.

A study of 2-component i, i + 3 peptide stapling using thioethers.

Peptides are promising scaffolds for use as therapeutics, targeting interactions previously considered to be "undruggable" by small molecules. While short peptides are generally unstructured in solution and rapidly degraded by proteases in the cell cytosol, peptide stapling offers an effective method to both stabilize peptides in a helical structure and increase resistance to proteolytic degradation. Most studies of peptide stapling have focused on residues with i, i + 4 and i, i + 7 spacing, while stapling of residues with i, i + 3 spacing has been understudied. Herein, we evaluated a suite of bifunctional linkers for stapling between residues with i, i + 3 spacing, comparing the ability of each compound to react with the peptide and the degree of helicity conferred. Finally, we evaluated the ability of the stapling to increase proteolytic resistance in cell lysates, comparing stapling of i, i + 3 and i, i + 4 spacing, with i, i + 3 spacing resulting in a greater increase in peptide half-life in the model system. This presents an effective stapling strategy, adding to the peptide stapling toolbox.

Investigation of Trimethyllysine Binding by the HP1 Chromodomain via Unnatural Amino Acid Mutagenesis.

Trimethyllysine (Kme3) reader proteins are targets for inhibition due to their role in mediating gene expression. Although all such reader proteins bind Kme3 in an aromatic cage, the driving force for binding may differ; some readers exhibit evidence for cation-π interactions whereas others do not. We report a general unnatural amino acid mutagenesis approach to quantify the contribution of individual tyrosines to cation binding using the HP1 chromodomain as a model system. We demonstrate that two tyrosines (Y24 and Y48) bind to a Kme3-histone tail peptide via cation-π interactions, but linear free energy trends suggest they do not contribute equally to binding. X-ray structures and computational analysis suggest that the distance and degree of contact between Tyr residues and Kme3 plays an important role in tuning cation-π-mediated Kme3 recognition. Although cation-π interactions have been studied in a number of proteins, this work is the first to utilize direct binding assays, X-ray crystallography, and modeling, to pinpoint factors that influence the magnitude of the individual cation-π interactions.

Optimization of a synthetic receptor for dimethyllysine using a biphenyl-2,6-dicarboxylic acid scaffold: insights into selective recognition of hydrophilic guests in water.

In the design of small molecule receptors for polar guests, much inspiration has been taken from proteins that have adapted effective ways to selectively bind polar molecules in aqueous environments. Nonetheless, molecular recognition of hydrophilic guests in water by synthetic receptors remains a challenging task. Here we report a new synthetic receptor, A2I, with improved affinity and selectivity for a biologically important polar guest, dimethyllysine (Kme2). A2I was prepared via redesign of a small molecule receptor (A2B) that preferentially binds trimethyllysine (Kme3) using dynamic combinatorial chemistry (DCC). We designed a new biphenyl-2,6-dicarboxylate monomer, I, with the goal of creating a buried salt bridge with Kme2 inside a synthetic receptor. Indeed, incorporation of I into the receptor A2I resulted in a receptor with 32-fold enhancement in binding affinity, which represents the highest affinity receptor for Kme2 in the context of a peptide to date and is tighter than most Kme2 reader proteins. It also exhibits a ∼2.5-fold increase in preference for Kme2 vs. Kme3 relative to the parent receptor, A2B. This work provides insight into effective strategies for binding hydrophilic, cationic guests in water and is an encouraging result toward a synthetic receptor that selectively binds Kme2 over other methylation states of lysine.

Supramolecular Affinity Labeling of Histone Peptides Containing Trimethyllysine and Its Application to Histone Deacetylase Assays.

Lysine methylation is an important histone post-translational modification (PTM) for manipulating chromatin structure and regulating gene expression, and its dysregulation is associated with various diseases including many cancers. While characterization of Lys methylation has seen improvements over the past decade due to advances in proteomic mass spectrometry and methods involving antibodies, chemical methods for selective detection of proteins containing PTMs are still lacking. Here, we detail the development of a unique labeling method wherein a synthetic receptor probe for trimethyl lysine (Kme3), CX4-ONBD, is used to direct selective fluorescent labeling of Kme3 histone peptides. This supramolecular approach reverses the paradigm of ligand-directed affinity labeling by making the receptor the synthetic component and the ligand the component to be labeled. We show that the probe mediates a strong turn-on fluorescence response in the presence of a Kme3 histone peptide and shows >5-fold selectivity in covalent labeling over an unmethylated lysine peptide. We also demonstrate the utility of the probe through the design of a turn-on fluorescence assay for histone deacetylase (HDAC) activity and for inhibitor screening and IC50 determination. Our synthetic receptor-mediated affinity labeling approach broadens the scope of PTM detection by chemical means and may facilitate the development of more versatile in vitro enzymatic assays.

Investigation of a Catenane with a Responsive Noncovalent Network: Mimicking Long-Range Responses in Proteins.

We report a functional synthetic model for studying the noncovalent networks (NCNs) required for complex protein functions. The model [2]-catenane is self-assembled from dipeptide building blocks and contains an extensive network of hydrogen bonds and aromatic interactions. Perturbations to the catenane cause compensating changes in the NCNs structure and dynamics, resulting in long-distance changes reminiscent of a protein. Key findings include the notion that NCNs require regions of negative cooperativity, or "frustrated" noncovalent interactions, as a source of potential energy for driving the response. We refer to this potential energy as latent free energy and describe a mechanistic and energetic model for responsive systems.

Identification of a p53-based portable degron based on the MDM2-p53 binding region.

In recent years the ubiquitin proteasome system (UPS) has garnered increasing interest as a target for chemotherapeutics. Due to the success of the proteasome inhibitors Bortezomib and Carfilzomib in the treatment of multiple myeloma, several new compounds have been developed to target E3 ubiquitin ligases and the proteasome in numerous human cancers. This has increased the need for new analytical methods to precisely measure intracellular enzyme activity in cells. A key component of a desired analytical method is a substrate that is capable of rapid intracellular ubiquitination yet easily incorporated into the next generation of more sophisticated UPS reporters. Portable degradation sequences, or degrons, have the ability to bind to E3 ligases and promote substrate ubiquitination when the sequence is presented in isolation or appended to other entities such as fluorescent peptide-based reporters. Previous work identified an E3 ligase (MDM2)-binding element at p53 amino acids 92-112, which was later demonstrated to be rapidly ubiquitinated in cytosolic lysates effectively functioning as a transportable degron. In this work, a shortened p53 sequence within amino acids 92-112 that displayed rapid ubiquitination kinetics was identified. A nine-member peptide library was synthesized using sequence elements of various sizes and lengths, all based on the initial 22 amino acid long sequence, containing a single ubiquitination site lysine. The ubiquitination kinetics were determined using a combination of gel electrophoresis and analytical high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) to rank the members of the library and identify the optimal ubiquitination sequence. This analysis identified the five amino acid sequence, KGSYG, corresponding to residues 105-108 with an added N-terminal lysine, as a portable degron since this sequence demonstrated the most rapid ubiquitination kinetics.

From supramolecular chemistry to the nucleosome: studies in biomolecular recognition.

This review highlights the author's indirect path to research at the interface of supramolecular chemistry and chemical biology.

Investigation of the ß-sheet interactions between dHP1 chromodomain and histone 3.

Methylated lysine 9 on the histone 3 (H3) tail recruits heterochromatin protein 1 from Drosophila (dHP1) via its chromodomain and results in gene silencing. The dHP1 chromodomain binds H3 K9Me3 with an aromatic cage surrounding the trimethyllysine. The sequence selectivity of binding comes from insertion of the histone tail between two ß-strands of the chromodomain to form a three-stranded ß-sheet. Herein, we investigated the sequence selectivity provided by the ß-sheet interactions and how those interactions compare to other model systems. Residue Thr6 of the histone tail forms cross-strand interactions with Ala25 and Asp62 of the chromodomain. Each of these three residues was substituted for amino acids known to have high ß-sheet propensities and/or to form favorable side chain-side chain (SC-SC) interactions in ß-sheets, including hydrophobic, H-bonding, and aromatic interactions. We found that about 50% of the chromodomain mutants resulted in equal or tighter binding to the histone tail and about 25% of the histone tail mutants provided tighter binding compared to that of the native histone tail sequence. These studies provide novel insights into the sequence selectivity of the dHP1 chromodomain for the histone tail and relates the information gleaned from model systems and statistical studies to ß-sheet-mediated protein-protein interactions. Moreover, this work suggests that the development of designer histone-chromodomain pairs for chemical biology applications is feasible.

Secondary Binding Interactions in a Synthetic Receptor for Trimethyllysine.

We have systematically studied how secondary interactions with neighboring lysine (Lys) and arginine (Arg) residues influence the binding and selectivity of the synthetic receptor A2 N for trimethyllysine (Kme3 ). Multiple secondary binding sites on A2 N are formed by carboxylates rigidly positioned over aromatic rings, a motif that has been shown to stabilize salt bridges. We varied the spacing between KmeX (X=0, 3) and an ancillary Lys or Arg and measured binding by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). These studies revealed that both neighboring residues improve the binding of A2 N to KmeX by approximately 1 kcal mol(-1) , with little influence of the spacing. Nonetheless, the improvement in affinity caused by Arg is enthalpically driven, while for Lys it is entropically driven, suggesting different mechanisms by which the residues interact with the secondary binding site.

Late stage modification of receptors identified from dynamic combinatorial libraries.

Small molecule receptors are attractive potential sensors of post-translational modifications, including methylated lysine and methylated arginine. Using dynamic combinatorial chemistry (DCC), our lab previously identified a suite of receptors that bind to Kme3 with a range of affinities ranging from low micromolar to high nanomolar, each with a unique selectivity for Kme3 over the lower methylation states. To enable these receptors to have broad application as Kme3 sensors, we have developed a method for their late-stage modification, which we used to synthesize biotinylated derivatives of A2B, A2D, and A2G in a single step. For our most attractive receptor for applications, A2N, we needed to develop an alternative method for its selective functionalization, which we achieved by "activating" the carboxylic acids on the constituent monomer A or N by pre-functionalizing them with glycine (Gly). Using the resulting Gly-A and Gly-N monomers, we synthesized the novel A2N variants A2Gly-N, Gly-A2N, and Gly-A2Gly-N, which enabled the late stage biotinylation of A2N wherever Gly was incorporated. Finally, we performed ITC and NMR binding experiments to study the effect that carboxylate spacing has on the affinity and selectivity of A2Gly-N and Gly-A2N for KmeX guests compared to A2N. These studies revealed the proximity of the carboxylates to play a complex role in the molecular recognition event, despite their positioning on the outside of the receptor.

Contributions of pocket depth and electrostatic interactions to affinity and selectivity of receptors for methylated lysine in water.

Dynamic combinatorial chemistry was used to generate a set of receptors for peptides containing methylated lysine (KMen, n = 0-3) and study the contribution of electrostatic effects and pocket depth to binding affinity and selectivity. We found that changing the location of a carboxylate resulted in an increase in preference for KMe2, presumably based on ability to form a salt bridge with KMe2. The number of charged groups on either the receptor or peptide guest systematically varied the binding affinities to all guests by approximately 1-1.5 kcal mol(-1), with little influence on selectivity. Lastly, formation of a deeper pocket led to both increased affinity and selectivity for KMe3 over the lower methylation states. From these studies, we identified that the tightest binder was a receptor with greater net charge, with a Kd of 0.2 µM, and the receptor with the highest selectivity was the one with the deepest pocket, providing 14-fold selectivity between KMe3 and KMe2 and a Kd for KMe3 of 0.3 µM. This work provides key insights into approaches to improve binding affinity and selectivity in water, while also demonstrating the versatility of dynamic combinatorial chemistry for rapidly exploring the impact of subtle changes in receptor functionality on molecular recognition in water.

A catalyst selection protocol that identifies biomimetic motifs from ß-hairpin libraries.

Assaying a solid-phase library of histidine-containing ß-hairpin peptides by a reactive tagging scheme in organic solvents selects for catalysts that reproduce the strategies used by His-based enzyme active sites to accelerate acyl- and phosphonyl-transfer reactions. Rate accelerations (k(rel)) in organic solvents of up to 2.4 × 10(8) are observed.