Health worker transfer processes within the public health sector in Ghana: a study of three districts in the Eastern Region.

INTRODUCTION: The lack of appropriate policies and procedures to ensure transparent transfer practices is an important source of dissatisfaction among health workers in low- and middle-income countries. In order to alter and improve current practices, a more in-depth and context-specific understanding is needed. This study aims to (1) identify rationales behind transfer decisions in Ghana and (2) examine how transfers are managed in practice versus in policies. METHODS: The study took place in 2014 in three districts in Eastern Ghana. The study population included (1) national, regional, and district health administrators with decision-making authority in terms of transfer decisions and (2) health workers who had transferred between 2011 and 2014. Data was collected through semi-structured and structured face-to-face interviews focusing on rationales behind transfer decisions, health administrators' role in managing transfers, and health workers' experience of transfers. A data triangulation approach was applied to compare identified practices with national policies and procedures. RESULTS: A total of 44 health workers and 21 administrators participated in the study. Transfers initiated by health workers were mostly based on family conditions and preferences to move away from rural areas, while transfers initiated by administrators were based on service requirements, productivity, and performance. The management of transfers was not guided by clear and explicit procedures and thus often depended on the discretion of decision-makers. Moreover, health workers frequently reported not being involved in transfer decision-making processes. We found existing staff perceptions of a non-transparent system. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest a need to foster incentives to attract and retain health workers in rural areas. Moreover, health worker-centered procedures and systems that effectively guide and monitor transfer practices must be developed to ensure that transfers are carried out in a timely, fair, and transparent way.

From PERFORM to PERFORM2Scale: Lessons from scaling-up a health management strengthening intervention to support Universal Health Coverage in three African countries.

Strengthening management and leadership competencies among district and local health managers has emerged as a common approach for health systems strengthening and to achieve Universal Health Coverage (UHC). While the literature is rich with localised examples of initiatives that aim to strengthen the capacity of district or local health managers, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, considerably less attention is paid to the science of how to scale-up these initiatives. The aim of this paper is thus to examine the process of scaling-up a management strengthening intervention (MSI) and identify new knowledge and key lessons learned that can be used to inform the scale-up process of other complex health interventions, in support of UHC. Qualitative methods were used to identify lessons learned from scaling-up the MSI in Ghana, Malawi and Uganda. We conducted 14 interviews with district health management team members, three scale-up assessments with 20 scale-up stakeholders, and three reflection discussions with 11 research team members. We also kept records of activities throughout MSI and scale-up implementation. Data was recorded, transcribed, and analysed against the Theory of Change to identify both scale-up outcomes and the factors affecting these outcomes. The MSI was ultimately scaled-up across 27 districts. Repeated MSI cycles over time were found to foster greater feelings of autonomy among district health management teams (DHMTs) to address longstanding local problems, a more innovative use of existing resources without relying on additional funding, and improved teamwork. The use of 'resource teams' and the emergence of MSI 'champions', were both instrumental in supporting scale-up efforts. Challenges to the sustainability of the MSI include limited government buy-in and lack of sustained financial investment.

Health of mobile pastoralists in the Sahel - assessment of 15 years of research and development.

In the Sahel, between Mauritania and Somalia including Northern Kenya, about 20-30 million people live as mobile pastoralists. The rhythm of their migration follows the seasons and the availability of resources such as water, pasture and salt. Despite their high exposure to zoonoses and problems caused by extreme climatic conditions, mobile pastoralists are virtually excluded from health services because the provision of social services adapted to their way of life is challenging. In cooperation with various partners in the region, the Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute has been active in research and development in the Sahel for 15 years. Based on the perceived needs of mobile pastoralists and the necessities of development, interdisciplinary research has considerably contributed to better understanding of their situation and their problems. Close contact between humans and livestock necessitates close cooperation between human and animal health specialists. Such useful approaches should be continued and extended.

La santé des pasteurs mobiles au Sahel - Bilan de 15 années de recherches et développement.

Dans le Sahel, entre la Mauritanie et la Somalie incluant le Nord Kenya, environ 20 à 30 millions de personnes vivent en transhumance. Le rythme de leur migration suit l'évolution saisonnière du climat et la disponibilité des ressources, telle que l'eau, le pâturage et le sel. Malgré une exposition élevée à certaines maladies comme les zoonoses et les problèmes conditionnés liés au climat, les pasteurs mobiles sont parmi les populations quasiment exclues du système de santé, car la mise à disposition des services sociaux adaptés à un mode de vie mobile est difficile. Suivant l'objectif de recherche d'un meilleur accès aux soins des pasteurs mobiles, l'Institut Tropical et de Santé Publique Suisse, en partenariat avec plusieurs institutions dans la région, est actif au Sahel depuis 15 ans, aussi bien dans le domaine de la recherche, que celui des actions de développement. Basées sur une approche orientée vers les besoins des pasteurs mobiles pour leur développement, des recherches interdisciplinaires ont contribué à mieux comprendre la situation et les problèmes des éleveurs. En relation de la proximité entre l'homme et son bétail, une approche unissant la santé humaine et animale s'est avérée bonne et la valeur ajoutée d'une meilleure collaboration entre médecine humaine, animale et l'environnement a été démontrée. Ces approches utiles devraient être poursuivies et consolidées dans les recherches et le développement des actions futurs.

[Variability of diarrheal diseases in children under 5 living in an urban setting: observations in Rufisque, Senegal]. / Variabilité des maladies diarrhéiques chez les enfants de moins de 5 ans en milieu urbain: l'exemple de Rufisque au Sénégal.

Rapid urbanization has created numerous health risks in developing countries, but the exact impact on many diseases in function of living conditions is unclear. For insight into this complex relationship, a study on diarrheal diseases was carried out to obtain knowledge about the distribution of health risks in an urban setting. An epidemiological survey with a combined longitudinal and transverse design was conducted in Rufisque, Senegal, from April 2002 to March 2003 in a sample including households with children less than 5-years-old living in four areas presenting different levels of hygiene. Results showed a high overall incidence of diarrhea (6.5 episodes/child/year) but there were major discrepancies between the four study areas in direct relation with level of hygiene. The annual incidence per child was lower in the low-cost housing project (fair hygiene, 3.4 episodes) than in the Castors area (poor hygiene, 6.8 episodes), Diokoul Wague area (very poor hygiene, 7.3 episodes) and Goufe Aldiana area (no hygiene, 8.4 episodes). The study showed only a slight seasonal effect on diarrheal disease in the different areas. However, the differences observed between areas during the cold and hot dry seasons were considerably attenuated in the rainy season. This variability in the incidence rate that underlines the diversity of urban living conditions depends on a variety of risk factors (such as age and number of children) that may interact, although hygiene level remains critical. For issues usually given priority at the national level, multiplying studies aimed at fine analysis of factors underlying disease transmission is useful since this approach can improve understanding of public health policy in city environments characterized by the complex conditions (density and diversity) created by urbanization.

Diagnostic role of endothelial microparticles in vasculitis.

OBJECTIVE: Endothelial cells play a central pathogenetic role in ANCA-associated small-vessel vasculitis (AAV). Circulating endothelial cells (CECs), as a marker of endothelial damage, have been shown to be elevated in vasculitis. More recently, endothelial microparticles (EMPs) were found to be increased in active childhood vasculitis. The role of EMP in adult AAV and the relationship between EMP and CEC is unclear. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We studied 26 patients with AAV, 12 healthy volunteers and 10 patients with IgA nephropathy as disease control. Platelet-poor plasma was ultracentrifuged. MPs were identified and enumerated with flow cytometry, Annexin V, CD62E and CD105 antibodies. Leucocyte- and platelet-derived MPs were also measured. CEC were isolated and enumerated with CD146-driven immuno-magnetic isolation. RESULTS: EMPs are significantly elevated in patients with active vasculitis (CD62E: mean 248 MP/microl +/- 198 s.d.; CD105: 121 +/- 135/microl) compared with patients in remission/partial remission (CD62E: 55 +/- 30/microl, P = 0.001; CD105: 16 +/- 12/microl, P = 0.002) and healthy volunteers (CD62E: 66 +/- 33/microl, P = 0.002; CD105: 25 +/- 26/microl, P = 0.007). The MP count correlates with disease activity measured by the Birmingham Vasculitis Activity Score (BVAS) (CD62E: r = 0.703; CD105: r = 0.445, P < 0.023). CONCLUSION: EMPs are elevated in active adult AAV. EMP levels correlate with disease activity and might serve as a marker of endothelial activation and damage. Differential detection of endothelial, platelet- and leucocyte-derived MPs may provide more insight in to the pathogenesis of AAV.

Tunable ligand emission of napthylsalophen triple-decker dinuclear lanthanide(iii) sandwich complexes.

The fluorescent ligand 1,1'-((1E,1'E)-(1,2-phenylenebis(azanylylidene))bis(methanylylidene)) bis(naphthalen-2-ol) (H2L) was used to prepare lanthanide(iii) metal complexes. These were found to self-assemble as triple decker sandwich complexes of the type (Ln2L3), where Ln = Pr(iii), Nd(iii), Sm(iii), Eu(iii), Gd(iii), Tb(iii), Dy(iii), Ho(iii), Er(iii), Yb(iii), or Lu(iii). The structures of the complexes Nd2L3, Gd2L3, Tb2L3, Dy2L3, Ho2L3, Yb2L3, and Lu2L3 are structurally characterized by single crystal X-ray diffraction. In the Nd2L3 complex, both metals are 8 coordinate. Yb2L3, Tb2L3, Dy2L3, and Lu2L3 are isostructural. In these, as in the Gd2L3 and Ho2L3 complexes, one metal is 8 coordinate, one 7 coordinate. The ligand was found to have tunable emission in the solid state across the lanthanide series with a maximum at 556 nm for the Sm2L3 complex to 617 nm for Er2L3. Of these, most demonstrate only ligand-centered fluorescence at room temperature. The ligand was found to have much greater fluorescence in the complex Lu2L3. Here, we describe these distinctive triple decker complexes and their absorption and emission properties as both solids and solutions.

An example of unusual pyridine donor Schiff base uranyl (UO22+) complexes.

The pentadentate coordination environment of a 2,6-bis[1-[(2-hydroxyphenyl)imino]ethyl] pyridine ligand scaffold was designed to accommodate the larger atomic radius of uranium as the uranyl dioxo cation, while fully occupying its equatorial plane. Here, two new uranyl (UO22+) complexes utilizing this scaffold have been synthesized from successive condensation reactions and subsequent metal complexation. Surprising Zn fluorescence is also discussed.

Th(iv) and Ce(iv) napthylsalophen sandwich complexes: characterization of unusual thorium fluorescence in solution and solid-state.

The synthesis, characterization, and electronic spectroscopy of two ML2 sandwich complexes, where M = Ce(iv) or Th(iv) and L = napthylsalophen2- are described. The ThL2 complex, unlike the isovalent CeL2, complex possesses unusual fluorescence properties in both solution and solid-state. These observations are explained with TD-DFT.

Duration of residency in a non-endemic area and risk of severe malaria in African immigrants.

In malaria-endemic areas, adults very rarely succumb to severe malaria, suggesting that immunity to severe disease is life-long under conditions of repeated exposure. To what extent this protection persists in the absence of exposure remains to be established. The aim of this study was to assess whether duration of residency in a malaria-free country affects the risk for severe malaria in immigrants originating from sub-Saharan Africa. We conducted a retrospective chart review of 948 cases of malaria diagnosed in Stockholm, Sweden in 1995-2013. Among 501 adult patients with Plasmodium falciparum (315 of endemic origin and 186 of non-endemic origin, mainly Sweden), 41 (8.2%) had severe malaria according to WHO criteria (including 5% with parasitaemia), 22 (4.4%) had factors prognostic of poor outcome, and 35 (7.0%) were admitted to intensive care. Overall, patient origin did not affect the odds of severe malaria, according to any of these definitions. However, when the immigrants were stratified with regard to their duration of residency in Sweden, the risk of factors prognostic for poor outcome was associated with duration of prior residency in a malaria-free country among patients of endemic origin (p 0.02), and immigrants who had lived for ≥ 15 years in Sweden had a similar risk as non-immune travellers. The results of this explorative study suggest that, although immunity to severe malaria is maintained for several years in African adults, this protection might be lost with time without repeated re-exposure. A larger study, preferably including multiple centres, will be needed to confirm our findings.

Virus inactivation and protein modifications by ethyleneimines.

Virus inactivation by ethyleneimines was first introduced more than 30 years ago. Selective targeting of nucleic acids was reported for oligomeric ethyleneimines. In this study, trimeric ethyleneimine (TEI) was used to inactivate minute virus of mice (MVM; Parvoviridae) and Semliki forest virus (SFV; Togaviridae). The pH-dependency of the inactivation kinetics observed with MVM was different compared to the kinetics reported for other viruses. The higher inactivation rate at higher pH favoured the idea of a mechanism involving protein modifications. Alteration of the isoelectric point and changes in mass could be observed after treatment of soluble proteins with TEI. The uptake of MVM by host cells was reduced or completely blocked by TEI treatment, as shown by monitoring viral internalisation of DNA into target cells. The observed loss of virus infectivity coincided with the inhibition of virus uptake. Thus, virus inactivation by TEI is most likely also a result of chemical modifications of viral surface proteins.

Analysis of the cuticular collagens of Ascaris suum.

The nematode cuticle is an extracellular structure composed mainly of collagens, with an insoluble epicuticle on the surface. The extracted collagens from adult Ascaris suum can be separated by SDS-PAGE into three major groups of polypeptides with apparent molecular masses of 34, 60-70 and 120-140 kDa. Densitometric evaluation of the polypeptide bands indicated that the three groups are present in the ratio of 1:2:6. Rotary shadowing of reduced, extracted molecules showed fibers 45 nm in length. This length is in excellent agreement with the calculated total length of amino acids in (Gly-X-Y) regions deduced from the collagen gene sequence of Caenorhabditis elegans and A. suum. It is proposed that the three groups of collagen polypeptides found in SDS-PAGE correspond to collagen monomers, dimers and trimers, and that the molecules in the dimeric and trimeric forms are cross-linked via non-reducible bonds.

A cost-effectiveness analysis of vaccination strategies against N. meningitidis meningitis in sub-Saharan African countries.

This analysis evaluates the cost-effectiveness (C/E) of routine vaccination against Neisseria meningitidis. Three different preventive strategies are analyzed: mass vaccination during epidemics (the current standard of care), routine preventive vaccination and a combination strategy of routine vaccination with mass vaccination during epidemics. A Markov model is used to simulate the epidemics of meningitis in a cohort of 5-year old children and compare these different strategies. The results show that mass vaccination strategy is dominated by the two other strategies. The incremental C/E ratios are US$50/QALY for the routine vaccination, and US$199/QALY for the combination strategy. The costs per fatal case averted are US$1161 for the routine vaccination, and US$2397 for the combination strategy. The C/E ratios are sensitive to: the incidence of meningococcal meningitis, the costs of treating cases, the costs of routine vaccination and the costs and effectiveness of mass immunization campaign. However the rank ordering of the strategies is almost never altered. In conclusion, the results of this analysis suggest that mass vaccination in sub-Saharan Africa in case of epidemics should be reconsidered. Routine vaccination against meningococcal meningitis at an early age, with or without mass vaccination during epidemics is more effective, with a C/E ratio within the range of other vaccination strategies currently in place in Africa.

An exercise in improving suicide reporting in print media.

This study was conducted to support the publication of guidelines for media reporting on suicide. First, quantitative and qualitative aspects of suicide reporting in Swiss print media were surveyed over a time span of 8 months. The results were presented at a national press conference, and written guidelines for suicide reporting were sent out to all newspaper editors. The results of the survey and the guidelines were discussed in a personal meeting with the Editor-in-Chief of the main tabloid. After the publication of the guidelines a second, identical survey was conducted. The main variables regarding frequency, form, and content of the newspaper reports before and after the press conference were compared. The number of articles, on the one hand, increased over the 3 years between the first and second survey, but the quality of reporting clearly improved on the other. The personal contact with the editor of the tabloid was probably the most effective means of intervention.

Utilisation of government and private health services in Dar es Salaam.

Following the liberalisation of medical practice in Tanzania since the early 1990's, and the introduction of user fees in public hospitals in 1993, a household survey evaluated utilisation of health care in Dar es Salaam. A sample of 6,589 inhabitants was interviewed in April 1995 by means of a two-stage cluster sampling technique. Of the respondents, 32% reported some use of health care within the previous two weeks. Among these respondents, 35% had used government health services, 41% had used private services and self-treatment was chosen by 27%. The user patterns identified reveal that adults aged 15-49 years used government health service least often. Use of government services clearly decreased as the level of education, socioeconomic class and wealth status of the zone of residence of the ill person increased. Conversely in the study sample, there was an apparent tendency for people with a high level of education or belonging to a rich socio-economic class to use private facilities more often. The data also indicate that already after two years the private sector plays an important role in providing medical care and that a two-tier system of health care delivery is developing. In order to render the private sector complementary to public services, there is need for a coherent policy on legislation, development, regulation and control of private sector health services as well as a monitoring system to reinforce the policies.

[Health care centre attendance by Arab nomadic pastoralists. A case study in Kanem, Chad]. / Utilisation d'un centre de santé par des pasteurs nomades arabes--une etude de cas au Kanem, Tchad.

Attendence at a rural health centre in a nomadic setting was monitored over several months to gain insight into factors determining accessibility to permanent primary health facilities by nomadic people. Multiple interactions between favorable and unfavorable factors for health care seeking in a nomadic setting were identified for a health care center particularly appreciated by pastoral nomads.

[Health care services for nomadic people. Lessons learned from research and implementation activities in Chad]. / Quels types de services de santé pour les populations nomades? Apprentissages des activités de recherche et d'action au Tchad.

To overcome barriers of access to health care of nomadic people and to alleviate inequities in health, a transdisciplinary team has initiated research and intervention activities among three nomadic groups of Chad: Foulbé, Arabes and Gouranes. A regular and consistent communication among all actors involved (nomadic groups, researchers, planners and administrators of health and veterinary services, etc.) through repetitive meetings and workshops showed to be a crucial element for success. Differences between ethnic nomadic groups made it necessary to develop specific communication strategies adapted to each group. As to interventions to improve the vaccination coverage, mixed teams combining health and veterinary specialists were able to vaccinate an important number of children and women and showed to have a high potential in terms of organisational and logistic feasibility, acceptability as well as good cost-effectiveness. With regard to improving access to health care, Information--Education and Communication approaches adapted to the intervention context and linked to the provision of essential services and generic drugs showed to be crucial.

[An innovative approach combining human and animal vaccination campaigns in nomadic settings of Chad: experiences and costs]. / Approche novatrice des vaccinations en santé publique et en médecine vétérinaire chez les pasteurs nomades au Tchad: expériences et coûts.

The purpose of this report is to describe a network of public health care workers, veterinarians and nomadic pastoralists that was set up in Chad to increase vaccination coverage to nomadic children and women who had rarely been vaccinated before. The objectives of the project were to provide human vaccination in conjunction with existing veterinary services, to evaluate the feasibility and limitations of such campaigns, to determine what other services could be provided concurrently, and to estimate the savings for public health care cases in comparison with carrying out vaccination separately. In a series of 12 vaccination campaigns in the Chari-Baguirmi and Kanem districts, more than 2100 children, 2100 women and 52000 cattle were fully immunized. These results confirmed the feasibility of joint campaigns in nomadic settings and provided important experience for improving organization. Information-Education-Communication (IEC) campaigns adapted to the realities of the pastoral setting were an important factor in mobilizing nomadic pastoralists for attendance at vaccination clinics. The savings in logistics costs (i.e., personnel, transportation and cold chain costs excluding vaccine costs) was 15% in Gredaya where 3 out of 6 campaigns were carried out together with veterinarians and 4% in Chaddra/Am Dobak where only 1 out of 6 campaigns was carried out in conjunction with veterinarians. The cost per fully immunized child (FIC) was considerably higher in Chaddra/Am Dobak than Gredaya (EUR 29.2 vs. EUR 11.5). The joint vaccination campaign approach is innovative, appreciated by nomadic pastoralists and less expensive than separate vaccination. By using the mobility of veterinarians in remote zones far from health care facilities, vaccination can be provided to nomadic children and women in countries with limited resources.

Can action research strengthen district health management and improve health workforce performance? A research protocol.

INTRODUCTION: The single biggest barrier for countries in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) to scale up the necessary health services for addressing the three health-related Millennium Development Goals and achieving Universal Health Coverage is the lack of an adequate and well-performing health workforce. This deficit needs to be addressed both by training more new health personnel and by improving the performance of the existing and future health workforce. However, efforts have mostly been focused on training new staff and less on improving the performance of the existing health workforce. The purpose of this paper is to disseminate the protocol for the PERFORM project and reflect on the key challenges encountered during the development of this methodology and how they are being overcome. METHODS: The overall aim of the PERFORM project is to identify ways of strengthening district management in order to address health workforce inadequacies by improving health workforce performance in SSA. The study will take place in three districts each in Ghana, Tanzania and Uganda using an action research approach. With the support of the country research teams, the district health management teams (DHMTs) will lead on planning, implementation, observation, reflection and redefinition of the activities in the study. Taking into account the national and local human resource (HR) and health systems (HS) policies and practices already in place, 'bundles' of HR/HS strategies that are feasible within the context and affordable within the districts' budget will be developed by the DHMTs to strengthen priority areas of health workforce performance. A comparative analysis of the findings from the three districts in each country will add new knowledge on the effects of these HR/HS bundles on DHMT management and workforce performance and the impact of an action research approach on improving the effectiveness of the DHMTs in implementing these interventions. DISCUSSION: Different challenges were faced during the development of the methodology. These include the changing context in the study districts, competing with other projects and duties for the time of district managers, complexity of the study design, maintaining the anonymity and confidentiality of study participants as well as how to record the processes during the study. We also discuss how these challenges are being addressed. The dissemination of this research protocol is intended to generate interest in the PERFORM project and also stimulate discussion on the use of action research in complex studies such as this on strengthening district health management to improve health workforce performance.

Decentralization and central and regional coordination of health services: the case of Switzerland.

As part of reforms in the health care delivery sector, decentralization is currently promoted in many countries as a means to improve performance and outcomes of national health care systems. Switzerland is an example of a country with a long-standing tradition of decentralized organization for many purposes, including health care delivery. Apart from the few aspects where the responsibility is at the federal level, it is the task of the 26 cantons to organize the provision of health services for the population of around 7 million people. This permits the system to be responsive to local priorities and interest as well as to new developments in medical and public health know-how. However, the increasing and complex difficulties of most health care delivery systems raise questions about the need for mechanisms for coordination at federal level, as well as about the equity and the effectiveness of the decentralized approach. The Swiss case shows that in a strongly decentralized system, health policy and strategy elaboration, as well as coordination mechanisms among the regional components of the system, are very hard to establish. This situation may lead to strong regional inequities in the financing of health care as well as to differences in the distribution of financial, human and material inputs into the health system. The study of the Swiss health system reveals also that, within a decentralized framework, the promotion of cost-effective interventions through a well-balanced approach towards promotional, preventive and curative services, or towards ambulatory and hospital care, is difficult to achieve, as agreements between relatively autonomous regions are difficult to obtain. Therefore, a decentralized system is not necessarily the most equitable and cost-effective way to deliver health care.