IgG Fc domains that bind C1q but not effector Fcγ receptors delineate the importance of complement-mediated effector functions.

Engineered crystallizable fragment (Fc) regions of antibody domains, which assume a unique and unprecedented asymmetric structure within the homodimeric Fc polypeptide, enable completely selective binding to the complement component C1q and activation of complement via the classical pathway without any concomitant engagement of the Fcγ receptor (FcγR). We used the engineered Fc domains to demonstrate in vitro and in mouse models that for therapeutic antibodies, complement-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CDCC) and complement-dependent cell-mediated phagocytosis (CDCP) by immunological effector molecules mediated the clearance of target cells with kinetics and efficacy comparable to those of the FcγR-dependent effector functions that are much better studied, while they circumvented certain adverse reactions associated with FcγR engagement. Collectively, our data highlight the importance of CDCC and CDCP in monoclonal-antibody function and provide an experimental approach for delineating the effect of complement-dependent effector-cell engagement in various therapeutic settings.

Induced phase separation of mutant NF2 imprisons the cGAS-STING machinery to abrogate antitumor immunity.

Missense mutations of the tumor suppressor Neurofibromin 2 (NF2/Merlin/schwannomin) result in sporadic to frequent occurrences of tumorigenesis in multiple organs. However, the underlying pathogenicity of NF2-related tumorigenesis remains mostly unknown. Here we found that NF2 facilitated innate immunity by regulating YAP/TAZ-mediated TBK1 inhibition. Unexpectedly, patient-derived individual mutations in the FERM domain of NF2 (NF2m) converted NF2 into a potent suppressor of cGAS-STING signaling. Mechanistically, NF2m gained extreme associations with IRF3 and TBK1 and, upon innate nucleic acid sensing, was directly induced by the activated IRF3 to form cellular condensates, which contained the PP2A complex, to eliminate TBK1 activation. Accordingly, NF2m robustly suppressed STING-initiated antitumor immunity in cancer cell-autonomous and -nonautonomous murine models, and NF2m-IRF3 condensates were evident in human vestibular schwannomas. Our study reports phase separation-mediated quiescence of cGAS-STING signaling by a mutant tumor suppressor and reveals gain-of-function pathogenesis for NF2-related tumors by regulating antitumor immunity.

The protein phosphatase PPM1A dephosphorylates and activates YAP to govern mammalian intestinal and liver regeneration.

The Hippo-YAP pathway responds to diverse environmental cues to manage tissue homeostasis, organ regeneration, tumorigenesis, and immunity. However, how phosphatase(s) directly target Yes-associated protein (YAP) and determine its physiological activity are still inconclusive. Here, we utilized an unbiased phosphatome screening and identified protein phosphatase magnesium-dependent 1A (PPM1A/PP2Cα) as the bona fide and physiological YAP phosphatase. We found that PPM1A was associated with YAP/TAZ in both the cytoplasm and the nucleus to directly eliminate phospho-S127 on YAP, which conferring YAP the nuclear distribution and transcription potency. Accordingly, genetic ablation or depletion of PPM1A in cells, organoids, and mice elicited an enhanced YAP/TAZ cytoplasmic retention and resulted in the diminished cell proliferation, severe gut regeneration defects in colitis, and impeded liver regeneration upon injury. These regeneration defects in murine model were largely rescued via a genetic large tumor suppressor kinase 1 (LATS1) deficiency or the pharmacological inhibition of Hippo-YAP signaling. Therefore, we identify a physiological phosphatase of YAP/TAZ, describe its critical effects in YAP/TAZ cellular distribution, and demonstrate its physiological roles in mammalian organ regeneration.

A mutagenic analysis of NahE, a hydratase-aldolase in the naphthalene degradative pathway.

NahE is a hydratase-aldolase that converts o-substituted trans-benzylidenepyruvates (H, OH, or CO2-) to benzaldehyde, salicylaldehyde, or 2-carboxybenzaldehyde, respectively, and pyruvate. The enzyme is in a bacterial degradative pathway for naphthalene, which is a toxic and persistent environmental contaminant. Sequence, crystallographic, and mutagenic analysis identified the enzyme as a member of the N-acetylneuraminate lyase (NAL) subgroup in the aldolase superfamily. As such, it has a conserved lysine (Lys183) and tyrosine (Tyr155), for Schiff base formation, as well as a GXXGE motif for binding of the pyruvoyl carboxylate group. A crystal structure of the selenomethionine derivative of NahE shows these active site elements along with nearby residues that might be involved in the mechanism and/or specificity. Mutations of five active site amino acids (Thr65, Trp128, Tyr155, Asn157, and Asn281) were constructed and kinetic parameters measured in order to assess the effect(s) on catalysis. The results show that the two Trp128 mutants (Phe and Tyr) have the least effect on catalysis, whereas amino acids with bulky side chains at Thr65 (Val) and Asn281 (Leu) have the greatest effect. Changing Tyr155 to Phe and Asn157 to Ala also hinders catalysis, and the effects fall in between these extremes. These observations are put into a structural context using a crystal structure of the Schiff base of the reaction intermediate. Trapping experiments with substrate, Na(CN)BH3, and wild type enzyme and selected mutants mostly paralleled the kinetic analysis, and identified two salicylaldehyde-modified lysines: the active site lysine (Lys183) and one outside the active site (Lys279). The latter could be responsible for the observed inhibition of NahE by salicylaldehyde. Together, the results provide new insights into the NahE-catalyzed reaction.

Enzyme-mediated depletion of serum l-Met abrogates prostate cancer growth via multiple mechanisms without evidence of systemic toxicity.

Extensive studies in prostate cancer and other malignancies have revealed that l-methionine (l-Met) and its metabolites play a critical role in tumorigenesis. Preclinical and clinical studies have demonstrated that systemic restriction of serum l-Met, either via partial dietary restriction or with bacterial l-Met-degrading enzymes exerts potent antitumor effects. However, administration of bacterial l-Met-degrading enzymes has not proven practical for human therapy because of problems with immunogenicity. As the human genome does not encode l-Met-degrading enzymes, we engineered the human cystathionine-γ-lyase (hMGL-4.0) to catalyze the selective degradation of l-Met. At therapeutically relevant dosing, hMGL-4.0 reduces serum l-Met levels to >75% for >72 h and significantly inhibits the growth of multiple prostate cancer allografts/xenografts without weight loss or toxicity. We demonstrate that in vitro, hMGL-4.0 causes tumor cell death, associated with increased reactive oxygen species, S-adenosyl-methionine depletion, global hypomethylation, induction of autophagy, and robust poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) cleavage indicative of DNA damage and apoptosis.

Kinetic, Inhibition, and Structural Characterization of a Malonate Semialdehyde Decarboxylase-like Protein from Calothrix sp. PCC 6303: A Gateway to the non-Pro1 Tautomerase Superfamily Members.

The amino-terminal proline (Pro1) has long been thought to be a mechanistic imperative for tautomerase superfamily (TSF) enzymes, functioning as a general base or acid in all characterized reactions. However, a global examination of more than 11,000 nonredundant sequences of the TSF uncovered 346 sequences that lack Pro1. The majority (∼85%) are found in the malonate semialdehyde decarboxylase (MSAD) subgroup where most of the 294 sequences form a separate cluster. Four sequences within this cluster retain Pro1. Because these four sequences might provide clues to assist in the identification and characterization of activities of nearby sequences without Pro1, they were examined by kinetic, inhibition, and crystallographic studies. The most promising of the four (from Calothrix sp. PCC 6303 designated 437) exhibited decarboxylase and tautomerase activities and was covalently modified at Pro1 by 3-bromopropiolate. A crystal structure was obtained for the apo enzyme (2.35 Šresolution). The formation of a 3-oxopropanoate adduct with Pro1 provides clues to build a molecular model for the bound ligand. The modeled ligand extends into a region that allows interactions with three residues (Lys37, Arg56, Glu98), suggesting that these residues can play roles in the observed decarboxylation and tautomerization activities. Moreover, these same residues are conserved in 16 nearby, non-Pro1 sequences in a sequence similarity network. Thus far, these residues have not been implicated in the mechanisms of any other TSF members. The collected observations provide starting points for the characterization of the non-Pro1 sequences.

Kinetic and thermodynamic analysis defines roles for two metal ions in DNA polymerase specificity and catalysis.

Magnesium ions play a critical role in catalysis by many enzymes and contribute to the fidelity of DNA polymerases through a two-metal ion mechanism. However, specificity is a kinetic phenomenon and the roles of Mg2+ ions in each step in the catalysis have not been resolved. We first examined the roles of Mg2+ by kinetic analysis of single nucleotide incorporation catalyzed by HIV reverse transcriptase. We show that Mg.dNTP binding induces an enzyme conformational change at a rate that is independent of free Mg2+ concentration. Subsequently, the second Mg2+ binds to the closed state of the enzyme-DNA-Mg.dNTP complex (Kd = 3.7 mM) to facilitate catalysis. Weak binding of the catalytic Mg2+ contributes to fidelity by sampling the correctly aligned substrate without perturbing the equilibrium for nucleotide binding at physiological Mg2+ concentrations. An increase of the Mg2+ concentration from 0.25 to 10 mM increases nucleotide specificity (kcat/Km) 12-fold largely by increasing the rate of the chemistry relative to the rate of nucleotide release. Mg2+ binds very weakly (Kd ≤ 37 mM) to the open state of the enzyme. Analysis of published crystal structures showed that HIV reverse transcriptase binds only two metal ions prior to incorporation of a correct base pair. Molecular dynamics simulations support the two-metal ion mechanism and the kinetic data indicating weak binding of the catalytic Mg2+. Molecular dynamics simulations also revealed the importance of the divalent cation cloud surrounding exposed phosphates on the DNA. These results enlighten the roles of the two metal ions in the specificity of DNA polymerases.

Kinetic and Structural Analysis of Two Linkers in the Tautomerase Superfamily: Analysis and Implications.

The tautomerase superfamily (TSF) is a collection of enzymes and proteins that share a simple ß-α-ß structural scaffold. Most members are constructed from a single-core ß-α-ß motif or two consecutively fused ß-α-ß motifs in which the N-terminal proline (Pro-1) plays a key and unusual role as a catalytic residue. The cumulative evidence suggests that a gene fusion event took place in the evolution of the TSF followed by duplication (of the newly fused gene) to result in the diversification of activity that is seen today. Analysis of the sequence similarity network (SSN) for the TSF identified several linking proteins ("linkers") whose similarity links subgroups of these contemporary proteins that might hold clues about structure-function relationship changes accompanying the emergence of new activities. A previously uncharacterized pair of linkers (designated N1 and N2) was identified in the SSN that connected the 4-oxalocrotonate tautomerase (4-OT) and cis-3-chloroacrylic acid dehalogenase (cis-CaaD) subgroups. N1, in the cis-CaaD subgroup, has the full complement of active site residues for cis-CaaD activity, whereas N2, in the 4-OT subgroup, lacks a key arginine (Arg-39) for canonical 4-OT activity. Kinetic characterization and nuclear magnetic resonance analysis show that N1 has activities observed for other characterized members of the cis-CaaD subgroup with varying degrees of efficiencies. N2 is a modest 4-OT but shows enhanced hydratase activity using allene and acetylene compounds, which might be due to the presence of Arg-8 along with Arg-11. Crystallographic analysis provides a structural context for these observations.

Endoperoxide formation by an α-ketoglutarate-dependent mononuclear non-haem iron enzyme.

Many peroxy-containing secondary metabolites have been isolated and shown to provide beneficial effects to human health. Yet, the mechanisms of most endoperoxide biosyntheses are not well understood. Although endoperoxides have been suggested as key reaction intermediates in several cases, the only well-characterized endoperoxide biosynthetic enzyme is prostaglandin H synthase, a haem-containing enzyme. Fumitremorgin B endoperoxidase (FtmOx1) from Aspergillus fumigatus is the first reported α-ketoglutarate-dependent mononuclear non-haem iron enzyme that can catalyse an endoperoxide formation reaction. To elucidate the mechanistic details for this unique chemical transformation, we report the X-ray crystal structures of FtmOx1 and the binary complexes it forms with either the co-substrate (α-ketoglutarate) or the substrate (fumitremorgin B). Uniquely, after α-ketoglutarate has bound to the mononuclear iron centre in a bidentate fashion, the remaining open site for oxygen binding and activation is shielded from the substrate or the solvent by a tyrosine residue (Y224). Upon replacing Y224 with alanine or phenylalanine, the FtmOx1 catalysis diverts from endoperoxide formation to the more commonly observed hydroxylation. Subsequent characterizations by a combination of stopped-flow optical absorption spectroscopy and freeze-quench electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy support the presence of transient radical species in FtmOx1 catalysis. Our results help to unravel the novel mechanism for this endoperoxide formation reaction.

Structural Basis for the Asymmetry of a 4-Oxalocrotonate Tautomerase Trimer.

Tautomerase superfamily (TSF) members are constructed from a single ß-α-ß unit or two consecutively joined ß-α-ß units. This pattern prevails throughout the superfamily consisting of more than 11000 members where homo- or heterohexamers are localized in the 4-oxalocrotonate tautomerase (4-OT) subgroup and trimers are found in the other four subgroups. One exception is a subset of sequences that are double the length of the short 4-OTs in the 4-OT subgroup, where the coded proteins form trimers. Characterization of two members revealed an interesting dichotomy. One is a symmetric trimer, whereas the other is an asymmetric trimer. One monomer is flipped 180° relative to the other two monomers so that three unique protein-protein interfaces are created that are composed of different residues. A bioinformatics analysis of the fused 4-OT subset shows a further division into two clusters with a total of 133 sequences. The analysis showed that members of one cluster (86 sequences) have more salt bridges if the asymmetric trimer forms, whereas the members of the other cluster (47 sequences) have more salt bridges if the symmetric trimer forms. This hypothesis was examined by the kinetic and structural characterization of two proteins within each cluster. As predicted, all four proteins function as 4-OTs, where two assemble into asymmetric trimers (designated R7 and F6) and two form symmetric trimers (designated W0 and Q0). These findings can be extended to the other sequences in the two clusters in the fused 4-OT subset, thereby annotating their oligomer properties and activities.

Visible Light Mediated Bidirectional Control over Carbonic Anhydrase Activity in Cells and in Vivo Using Azobenzenesulfonamides.

Two azobenzenesulfonamide molecules with thermally stable cis configurations resulting from fluorination of positions ortho to the azo group are reported that can differentially regulate the activity of carbonic anhydrase in the trans and cis configurations. These fluorinated probes each use two distinct visible wavelengths (520 and 410 or 460 nm) for isomerization with high photoconversion efficiency. Correspondingly, the cis isomer of these systems is highly stable and persistent (as evidenced by structural studies in solid and solution state), permitting regulation of metalloenzyme activity without continuous irradiation. Herein, we use these probes to demonstrate the visible light mediated bidirectional control over the activity of zinc-dependent carbonic anhydrase in solution as an isolated protein, in intact live cells and in vivo in zebrafish during embryo development.

Structural, Kinetic, and Mechanistic Analysis of an Asymmetric 4-Oxalocrotonate Tautomerase Trimer.

A 4-oxalocrotonate tautomerase (4-OT) trimer has been isolated from Burkholderia lata, and a kinetic, mechanistic, and structural analysis has been performed. The enzyme is the third described oligomer state for 4-OT along with a homo- and heterohexamer. The 4-OT trimer is part of a small subset of sequences (133 sequences) within the 4-OT subgroup of the tautomerase superfamily (TSF). The TSF has two distinct features: members are composed of a single ß-α-ß unit (homo- and heterohexamer) or two consecutively joined ß-α-ß units (trimer) and generally have a catalytic amino-terminal proline. The enzyme, designated as fused 4-OT, functions as a 4-OT where the active site groups (Pro-1, Arg-39, Arg-76, Phe-115, Arg-127) mirror those in the canonical 4-OT from Pseudomonas putida mt-2. Inactivation by 2-oxo-3-pentynoate suggests that Pro-1 of fused 4-OT has a low p Ka enabling the prolyl nitrogen to function as a general base. A remarkable feature of the fused 4-OT is the absence of P3 rotational symmetry in the structure (1.5 Å resolution). The asymmetric arrangement of the trimer is not due to the fusion of the two ß-α-ß building blocks because an engineered "unfused" variant that breaks the covalent bond between the two units (to generate a heterohexamer) assumes the same asymmetric oligomerization state. It remains unknown how the different active site configurations contribute to the observed overall activities and whether the asymmetry has a biological purpose or role in the evolution of TSF members.

A global view of structure-function relationships in the tautomerase superfamily.

The tautomerase superfamily (TSF) consists of more than 11,000 nonredundant sequences present throughout the biosphere. Characterized members have attracted much attention because of the unusual and key catalytic role of an N-terminal proline. These few characterized members catalyze a diverse range of chemical reactions, but the full scale of their chemical capabilities and biological functions remains unknown. To gain new insight into TSF structure-function relationships, we performed a global analysis of similarities across the entire superfamily and computed a sequence similarity network to guide classification into distinct subgroups. Our results indicate that TSF members are found in all domains of life, with most being present in bacteria. The eukaryotic members of the cis-3-chloroacrylic acid dehalogenase subgroup are limited to fungal species, whereas the macrophage migration inhibitory factor subgroup has wide eukaryotic representation (including mammals). Unexpectedly, we found that 346 TSF sequences lack Pro-1, of which 85% are present in the malonate semialdehyde decarboxylase subgroup. The computed network also enabled the identification of similarity paths, namely sequences that link functionally diverse subgroups and exhibit transitional structural features that may help explain reaction divergence. A structure-guided comparison of these linker proteins identified conserved transitions between them, and kinetic analysis paralleled these observations. Phylogenetic reconstruction of the linker set was consistent with these findings. Our results also suggest that contemporary TSF members may have evolved from a short 4-oxalocrotonate tautomerase-like ancestor followed by gene duplication and fusion. Our new linker-guided strategy can be used to enrich the discovery of sequence/structure/function transitions in other enzyme superfamilies.

Phosphatase activity of small C-terminal domain phosphatase 1 (SCP1) controls the stability of the key neuronal regulator RE1-silencing transcription factor (REST).

The RE1-silencing transcription factor (REST) is the major scaffold protein for assembly of neuronal gene silencing complexes that suppress gene transcription through regulating the surrounding chromatin structure. REST represses neuronal gene expression in stem cells and non-neuronal cells, but it is minimally expressed in neuronal cells to ensure proper neuronal development. Dysregulation of REST function has been implicated in several cancers and neurological diseases. Modulating REST gene silencing is challenging because cellular and developmental differences can affect its activity. We therefore considered the possibility of modulating REST activity through its regulatory proteins. The human small C-terminal domain phosphatase 1 (SCP1) regulates the phosphorylation state of REST at sites that function as REST degradation checkpoints. Using kinetic analysis and direct visualization with X-ray crystallography, we show that SCP1 dephosphorylates two degron phosphosites of REST with a clear preference for phosphoserine 861 (pSer-861). Furthermore, we show that SCP1 stabilizes REST protein levels, which sustains REST's gene silencing function in HEK293 cells. In summary, our findings strongly suggest that REST is a bona fide substrate for SCP1 in vivo and that SCP1 phosphatase activity protects REST against degradation. These observations indicate that targeting REST via its regulatory protein SCP1 can modulate its activity and alter signaling in this essential developmental pathway.

Death-associated protein kinase 1 phosphorylates Pin1 and inhibits its prolyl isomerase activity and cellular function.

Pin1 is a phospho-specific prolyl isomerase that regulates numerous key signaling molecules and whose deregulation contributes to disease notably cancer. However, since prolyl isomerases are often believed to be constitutively active, little is known whether and how Pin1 catalytic activity is regulated. Here, we identify death-associated protein kinase 1 (DAPK1), a known tumor suppressor, as a kinase responsible for phosphorylation of Pin1 on Ser71 in the catalytic active site. Such phosphorylation fully inactivates Pin1 catalytic activity and inhibits its nuclear location. Moreover, DAPK1 inhibits the ability of Pin1 to induce centrosome amplification and cell transformation. Finally, Pin1 pSer71 levels are positively correlated with DAPK1 levels and negatively with centrosome amplification in human breast cancer. Thus, phosphorylation of Pin1 Ser71 by DAPK1 inhibits its catalytic activity and cellular function, providing strong evidence for an essential role of the Pin1 enzymatic activity for its cellular function.

Inactivation of 4-Oxalocrotonate Tautomerase by 5-Halo-2-hydroxy-2,4-pentadienoates.

5-Halo-2-hydroxy-2,4-pentadienoates (5-halo-HPDs) are reportedly generated in the bacterial catabolism of halogenated aromatic hydrocarbons by the meta-fission pathway. The 5-halo-HPDs, where the halogen can be bromide, chloride, or fluoride, result in the irreversible inactivation of 4-oxalocrotonate tautomerase (4-OT), which precedes the enzyme that generates them. The loss of activity is due to the covalent modification of the nucleophilic amino-terminal proline. Mass spectral and crystallographic analysis of the modified enzymes indicates that inactivation of 4-OT by 5-chloro- and 5-bromo-2-hydroxy-2,4-pentadienoate follows a mechanism different from that for the inactivation of 4-OT by 5-fluoro-2-hydroxy-2,4-pentadienoate. The 5-chloro and 5-bromo derivatives undergo 4-OT-catalyzed tautomerization to their respective α,ß-unsaturated ketones followed by attack at C5 (by the prolyl nitrogen) with concomitant loss of the halide. For the 5-fluoro species, the presence of a small amount of the α,ß-unsaturated ketone could result in a Michael addition of the prolyl nitrogen to C4 followed by protonation at C3. The fluoride is not eliminated. These observations suggest that the inactivation of 4-OT by a downstream metabolite could hamper the efficacy of the pathway, which is the first time that such a bottleneck has been reported for the meta-fission pathway.

Structural Characterization of the Hydratase-Aldolases, NahE and PhdJ: Implications for the Specificity, Catalysis, and N-Acetylneuraminate Lyase Subgroup of the Aldolase Superfamily.

NahE and PhdJ are bifunctional hydratase-aldolases in bacterial catabolic pathways for naphthalene and phenanthrene, respectively. Bacterial species with these pathways can use polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) as sole sources of carbon and energy. Because of the harmful properties of PAHs and their widespread distribution and persistence in the environment, there is great interest in understanding these degradative pathways, including the mechanisms and specificities of the enzymes found in the pathways. This knowledge can be used to develop and optimize bioremediation techniques. Although hydratase-aldolases catalyze a major step in the PAH degradative pathways, their mechanisms are poorly understood. Sequence analysis identified NahE and PhdJ as members of the N-acetylneuraminate lyase (NAL) subgroup in the aldolase superfamily. Both have a conserved lysine and tyrosine (for Schiff base formation) as well as a GXXGE motif (to bind the pyruvoyl carboxylate group). Herein, we report the structures of NahE, PhdJ, and PhdJ covalently bound to substrate via a Schiff base. Structural analysis and dynamic light scattering experiments show that both enzymes are tetramers. A hydrophobic helix insert, present in the active sites of NahE and PhdJ, might differentiate them from other NAL subgroup members. The individual specificities of NahE and PhdJ are governed by Asn-281/Glu-285 and Ser-278/Asp-282, respectively. Finally, the PhdJ complex structure suggests a potential mechanism for hydration of substrate and subsequent retro-aldol fission. The combined findings fill a gap in our mechanistic understanding of these enzymes and their place in the NAL subgroup.

Structural Snapshots of an Engineered Cystathionine-γ-lyase Reveal the Critical Role of Electrostatic Interactions in the Active Site.

Enzyme therapeutics that can degrade l-methionine (l-Met) are of great interest as numerous malignancies are exquisitely sensitive to l-Met depletion. To exhaust the pool of methionine in human serum, we previously engineered an l-Met-degrading enzyme based on the human cystathionine-γ-lyase scaffold (hCGL-NLV) to circumvent immunogenicity and stability issues observed in the preclinical application of bacterially derived methionine-γ-lyases. To gain further insights into the structure-activity relationships governing the chemistry of the hCGL-NLV lead molecule, we undertook a biophysical characterization campaign that captured crystal structures (2.2 Å) of hCGL-NLV with distinct reaction intermediates, including internal aldimine, substrate-bound, gem-diamine, and external aldimine forms. Curiously, an alternate form of hCGL-NLV that crystallized under higher-salt conditions revealed a locally unfolded active site, correlating with inhibition of activity as a function of ionic strength. Subsequent mutational and kinetic experiments pinpointed that a salt bridge between the phosphate of the essential cofactor pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP) and residue R62 plays an important role in catalyzing ß- and γ-eliminations. Our study suggests that solvent ions such as NaCl disrupt electrostatic interactions between R62 and PLP, decreasing catalytic efficiency.