Comparison of three different biomaterials used in in vitro molar apexification models.

OBJECTIVES: New biomaterials had some advantages such as mixing and easier application as compared to traditional MTA in single step apexification method. This study aimed to compare the three biomaterials used in the apexification treatment of immature molar teeth in terms of the time spent, the quality of the canal filling and the number of x-rays taken to complete the process. METHODS: The root canals of the extracted thirty molar teeth were shaped with rotary tools. To obtain the apexification model, ProTaper F3 was used retrograde. The teeth were randomly assigned into three groups based on the material used to seal the apex; Group 1: Pro Root MTA, Group 2: MTA Flow, Group 3: Biodentine. The amounts of the filling, the number of radiographs taken until treatment completion and the treatment duration were recorded. Then teeth were fixed for micro computed tomography imaging for quality evaluation of canal filling. RESULTS: Biodentine was superior to the other filling materials according to time. MTA Flow provided greater filling volume than the other filling materials in the rank comparison for the mesiobuccal canals. MTA Flow had greater filling volume than ProRoot MTA in the palatinal/distal canals(p = 0.039). Biodentine had greater filling volume more than MTA Flow in the mesiolingual/distobuccal canals (p = 0.049). CONCLUSIONS: MTA Flow was found as a suitable biomaterial according to the treatment time and quality of root canal fillings.

An Evaluation of the Cytocompatibility of Endodontic Bioceramics in Human Periodontal-Ligament-Derived Cells.

The present study evaluated the cytocompatibility of three endodontic bioceramics in human periodontal-ligament-derived cells (hPDLCs): MTA Repair HP (HP), MTA Flow White (F), and Nishika Canal Sealer BG multi (BG). In addition, we also evaluated the effect of the powder-liquid (paste) ratio of F and BG on cytocompatibility. Discs of endodontic bioceramics (diameter = 8 mm, thickness = 1 mm) were prepared with HP, F, and BG. hPDLCs obtained from extracted teeth and cultured for three to five passages were used in the experiment. The prepared discs were placed at the bottom of a 48-well plate, seeded with hPDLCs at 100,000 cells/well, cultured for 7 or 28 days, and subjected to a 3-[4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl]-2,5 diphenyl tetrazolium bromide assay. hPDLCs cultured without any discs were used as a negative control (NC) group. Discs made of F or BG mixed in three different consistencies were also used in this experiment. The absorbance values at days 7 and 28 were high in the order of HP > NC > BG > F. Furthermore, F or BG with higher consistency showed higher absorbance values. MTA Repair HP had the highest cytocompatibility among the three materials. Furthermore, it also showed that higher consistency improved cytocompatibility.

Role of phosphate-buffered saline on push-out bond strength of MTA Flow™ and Biodentine™ after acid challenge: An in vitro study.

Context: The physical and chemical properties of root repair materials are adversely affected when placed in areas of inflammation with acidic pH. Aim: To evaluate the role of phosphate-buffered saline (PBS- pH 7.4) on push-out bond strength (POBS) of MTA flow and Biodentine (BD) after acid challenge with butyric acid buffered solution (BABS- pH 5.4). Subjects and Methods: Eighty mid-root dentin slices (2 mm thick; 1.3 mm lumen diameter) were prepared and were divided into two groups (n = 40) based on the type of material used for filling lumen: Group 1-MTA Flow and Group 2-BD. Each group was again divided into four subgroups (n = 10) based on the duration of exposure to storage media: (a) 3 days in PBS, (b) 3 days in BABS, (c) 3 days in BABS followed by 30 days in PBS, and (d) 33 days in PBS. POBS was then measured using the universal strength testing machine. Statistical Analysis Used: Statistical analysis was performed with one-way analysis of variance and post hoc test using SPSS software version 23.0. Results: Group 1b and 2b showed significantly lower bond strength values. No significant difference was observed between Group 1b and Group 1c (P > 0.05), whereas highly significant POBS values were observed between Group 2b and Group 2c (P = 0.000). Among all the tested groups, Group 2d showed the highest POBS values. Conclusion: On storage in PBS after acid challenge, BD attained the highest POBS values while no significant difference was observed in MTA Flow.

The Effect of Ultrasonic Agitation on the Porosity Distribution in Apically Perforated Root Canals Filled with Different Bioceramic Materials and Techniques: A Micro-CT Assessment.

The present study evaluated the effect of ultrasonic agitation on the porosity distribution of BioRoot RCS/single gutta-percha cone (BR/SC) and MTA Flow (MF) root canals fillings used as apical plugs in moderately curved and apically perforated roots. Eighty mesial root canals of mandibular first molars were enlarged up to ProTaper NEXT X5 rotary instrument 2 mm beyond the apical foramen, simulating apical perforations. Specimens were randomly divided into four experimental groups (20 canals per group) according to the material and technique used for root canal obturation: BR/SC, BR/SC with ultrasonic agitation (BR/SC-UA), MF and MF with ultrasonic agitation (MF-UA). The ultrasonic tip was passively inserted into the root canal after the injection of flowable cement and activated for 10 s. The specimens were scanned before and after obturation with a high-resolution micro-computed tomography scanner, and the porosity of the apical plugs was assessed. The differences between groups were analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis and Mann-Whitney tests, with the significance level set at 5%. None of the obturation materials and techniques used in this study was able to provide a pore-free root canal filling in the apical 5 mm. Considerably higher percentages of open and closed pores were observed in the MF and MF-UA groups, with the highest porosity being in the MF-UA group (p < 0.05). No significant differences were observed between the BR/SC and BR/SC-UA groups, where the quantity of open and closed pores remained similar (p > 0.05).

Porosity Distribution in Apically Perforated Curved Root Canals Filled with Two Different Calcium Silicate Based Materials and Techniques: A Micro-Computed Tomography Study.

The present study evaluated the porosity distribution of BioRoot RCS/single gutta-percha point (BR/SC) and MTA flow (MF) fillings, which were used as plugs for the apical perforation repair in curved canals of extracted mandibular molars using micro-computed tomography (µCT). Forty mesial root canals of mandibular first molars were shaped with ProTaper NEXT X1-X5 files 2 mm beyond the apex to simulate apical perforations that were randomly divided into two groups (n = 20) according to the material and technique used for the apical plug: BR/SC or MF. The specimens were scanned before and after canal filling at an isotropic resolution of 9.9 µm. The volumetric analysis of voids in the apical 5 mm of the fillings was performed. Data were analyzed using one-way ANOVA with Bonferroni correction (p < 0.05). Micro-computed tomography (µCT) evaluation revealed significant differences between the groups in terms of porosity: the total volume and percentage volume of voids was lower in the BR/SC group in comparison with the MF group (p < 0.05), with the predominance of open pores in both groups. Neither of the materials and/or application techniques were able to produce void-free root fillings in the apical region of artificially perforated curved roots of mandibular molars.

Ex Vivo Analysis of MTA FLOW® Biomineralization and Push-Out Strength: A Pilot Study / Análisis ex vivo del proceso de biomineralización y resistencia al desplazamiento del MTA FLOW®: Estudio piloto

Abstract: This study evaluated the biomineralization processes and push-out strength of MTA Flow® with radicular dentine in three different consistencies. The push-out test was performed on an ex vivo model, using 2mm thick dentin discs from the middle third of the root with standardized cavities of 1.5 mm. Samples were filled with MTA-Angelus (Angelus Dental, Brazil), Biodentine (Septodont, France), MTA Flow® Putty (Ultradent, USA), MTA Flow® Thick or MTA Flow® Thin. The samples were divided into 3 groups: subgroup 1 (n=5), analysis of the biomineralization process; 2 (n=20), evaluation of the bonding strength and push-out resistance; and 3 (n=5), evaluation of the cement/ dentin interface. The samples filled with Biodentine had a higher precipitation of carbonate apatite. However, there was no significant difference between MTA-Angelus, MTA Flow® Putty, or Thick (p=0.0536), but there was a significant difference in the Thin group (P<0.05). The samples with Biodentine displayed the greatest release of calcium ions. The formation of a partially carbonated intermediate apatite layer was observed in all groups. Zones of biomineralization were observed at the interface but were not continuous. After 72 hours, a significant difference was found between the Biodentine and MTA Flow® Thin groups (p=0.0090) in the push-out test. The samples submerged in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) for 15 days showed a significant difference between all groups and MTA Flow® Thin (p=0.0147). Putty or Thick consistencies presented a similar bonding strength to MTA-Angelus and Biodentine. MTA Flow® Putty and Thick consistencies show a good adaptation to dentin, similar to MTA-Angelus. However, the thickness of the interface was lower compared to that of Biodentine. MTA Flow® Thin, despite their tubular infiltration, results in gaps and a defective peripheral seal.Therefore, MTA Flow®, in Putty or Thick consistencies, presents a biomineralization process and push-out strength similar to MTA Angelus and Biodentine, however, both characteristics decreases considerably in Thin consistency.

Resumen: El objetivo de este estudio fue evaluar, en un modelo ex vivo, el proceso de biomineralización y fuerza de adhesión del MTA Flow® en sus tres diferentes consistencias por medio de la prueba de resistencia al desplazamiento (Push-out). Se utilizaron discos de dentina de 2mm de espesor del tercio medio radicular con cavidades estandarizadas de 1.5mm de diámetro, las cuales se obturaron con diferentes materiales entre ellos: MTA Angelus (Angelus Dental, Brasil), Biodentine (Septodont, Francia), MTA Flow® Consistencia Putty (Ultradent, E.E.U.U), MTA Flow® Consistencia Thick (Ultradent, E.E.U.U) y MTA Flow® Consistencia Thin (Ultradent, E.E.U.U). Las muestras se sometieron al proceso de biomineralización y a pruebas de Push-out. Las muestras obturadas con Biodentine promovieron una mayor precipitación de apatita carbonatada, sin embargo, no se presentó diferencia estadística significativa con respecto al MTA Angelus, MTA Flow® Putty ni Thick (p=0.0536). No obstante, si presentó una diferencia significativa con respecto al grupo de MTA Flow® consistencia Thin (P<0.05). Las muestras con Biodentine presentaron la mayor liberación de iones calcio. De acuerdo a las pruebas de resistencia al desplazamiento, a las 72 horas post-obturación, solamente se encontró diferencia significativa entre las muestras obturadas con Biodentine y las correspondientes al MTA Flow consistencia Thin (p=0.0090), sin embargo las muestras sumergidas 15 días en PBS presentaron diferencia significativa entre todos los grupos con respecto al MTA Flow Thin (p=0.0147). En general se observaron zonas de biomineralización en la interface, sin embargo, no fueron continuas. Se concluye que el MTA Flow en consistencia Putty o Thick presenta un proceso de biomineralización y una resistencia al desplazamiento similar al MTA Angelus y al Biodentine, sin embargo, esta última disminuye considerablemente en presentación Thin.